Skip to content

Roman imperial cult

Ch. 1 of 8
— CH. 1 · INTRODUCTION —

Contents

Roman imperial cult

8 sections
  • The Roman imperial cult bound the authority of the emperor to the will of the gods themselves. When Julius Caesar's heir Octavian completed the ceremony of apotheosis for his adoptive father in 42 BC, he was doing something that would have been unthinkable to his ancestors five centuries earlier: officially declaring a Roman man a god by vote of the Senate. That act opened a question that would trouble Rome for centuries. Where does a ruler end and a deity begin? The imperial cult, known formally as the cultus imperatorius, was Rome's answer to that question. But the answer kept changing. What began as a carefully managed fiction, a way for Augustus to claim divine approval without claiming godhood outright, grew into an institution so entangled with Roman identity that refusing to participate could be treated as treason. This is the story of how a republic that prided itself on rejecting kings learned to worship its rulers.

  • For five centuries, the Roman Republic refused to worship any living person. From 509 BC to the final decades of the Republic, Roman tradition held firm against the divine honors that surrounded Rome on almost every side. The aristocrats who filled the Senate acknowledged no man as their inherent superior. No citizen, living or dead, was officially regarded as divine. Yet the line between honor and worship was never as clear as Romans liked to pretend. The same crowns, garlands, statues, thrones, and processions that the state awarded to exceptional men were also suitable to the gods. When a general was acclaimed imperator by his troops, and the Senate voted him a triumph, he rode in a chariot bearing divine emblems, wearing the toga picta, in a costume thought to descend from the ancient kings of Rome. Some scholars have viewed the triumphal general as impersonating or even becoming a king or a god for that single day. Private life blurred the line further. Every head of household embodied the genius of his ancestors, a generative principle that family members and slaves would swear oaths by. A client could address his patron as "Jupiter on earth". After Gaius Marius defeated the Teutones, private citizens offered food and drink to him alongside their own household gods, calling him the third founder of Rome after Romulus and Camillus. In 86 BC, incense and wine were offered at crossroad shrines to statues of the still-living Marius Gratidianus, the popular nephew of the elder Marius, whose monetary reforms had eased a financial crisis during his praetorship. None of this was state cult. But it showed that the impulse was there, waiting for the right conditions.

  • Greek city-states had long since solved the problem of ruler worship, and their solution would prove decisive for Rome. When a Greek city wanted to declare allegiance to an outside power, it offered that power divine honors, committing the city to obey the ruler exactly as it obeyed Apollo or any of the other gods. Plutarch identified the cities of Ionia worshipping the Spartan general Lysander, after he dominated Greece following the Peloponnesian War, as the first instance of ruler cult in Greek history. Philip II of Macedon had his statue dressed as a god, set among the Twelve Olympians as their thirteenth member. But it was his son Alexander the Great who made the divinity of kings a standard expectation. The Egyptians accepted Alexander as Pharaoh, and therefore divine, after he drove the Persians from Egypt. In 324 BC he sent word to the Greek cities that they should make him a god; they did so, the source notes, with marked indifference. When the Athenians allied with Demetrius Poliorcetes, they lodged him in the Parthenon with Athena and sang a hymn calling him a present god who heard them as the other gods did not. When Roman magistrates began conquering the Greek world, they inherited this tradition. Games were set up in honor of Marcus Claudius Marcellus when he conquered Sicily at the end of the Second Punic War, as the Olympian games were for Zeus, and they were kept up for a century and a half. Titus Quinctius Flamininus had temples built for him; cities placed his portrait on their coinage. The Greeks also devised a goddess Roma, and her joint cult with Flamininus is attested in 195 BC. She would prove more durable than any individual general, becoming a continuing symbol of romanitas long after a Marcellus or Flamininus had lost power.

  • Julius Caesar was the first Roman to pursue godhood as part of a deliberate reach for monarchy. His claim began with lineage. As a member of the gens Julia, he could trace descent from Aeneas and his mother Venus. In his funeral eulogy for his aunt Julia in 69 BC, he implied descent also from Ancus Marcius and the kings of Rome, and therefore from Mars. As a teenager, the elder Marius had named him flamen Dialis, special priest of Jupiter; Sulla cancelled the appointment, but Caesar later became pontifex maximus, the chief priest who fulfilled most of the religious duties of the ancient kings. After defeating his rivals in 45 BC, the new Senate he had filled with his own partisans began offering him honors that crossed from exceptional to divine. His portrait appeared on Roman coinage, the first time a living man had done so. A house was built for him at public expense in the manner of a temple. His image was paraded with those of the gods. A special priest, a flamen, was ordained for him; the first was to be Mark Antony, then consul. That rank would have placed Caesar as an equal of Quirinus, Jupiter, and Mars. Cicero's account held that the living Caesar's honors were already and unambiguously those of a full-blown god. His name as a living divinity was Divus Julius. He was killed in the Senate on the 15th of March 44 BC before he could take another step. An angry crowd gathered in the Roman Forum to hear Antony's funeral oration. A comet was interpreted as Caesar's soul ascending to heaven and named the Julian star. In 42 BC, Octavian held ceremonial apotheosis for his adoptive father. With the full consent of the Senate and people of Rome, Julius Caesar became a god of the Roman state.

  • Octavian, now Augustus, understood the lesson of Caesar's death with perfect clarity. His predecessor had claimed too much, too openly, in Rome itself. Augustus would claim nothing, officially, while arranging for everything. When the koina of Asia and Bithynia in 30-29 BC requested permission to worship him as their deliverer, he imposed a careful structure. Cult honors could be jointly offered to the goddess Roma at centers to be built at Pergamum and Nicomedia. Roman citizens in those provinces were not to worship the living emperor but might worship Roma and the divus Julius at Ephesus and Nicaea. In 29 BC Augustus dedicated the temple of the divus Julius at the site of Caesar's cremation, presenting himself not as a god but as the dutiful son of one. He had, he claimed, come into being through the Julian star, and was therefore the divi filius, son of the divinity. His official achievements included the repair of 82 temples in 28 BC alone, the founding or repair of 14 others during his lifetime, and the construction of a new road, water supplies, Senate house, and theatres. His military successes brought what he called an enduring sacred peace, earning him the permanent title of imperator. His administrative genius was to make the office of emperor so central to every institution of Roman life that cult was simply the natural extension of that centrality. The emperor's image was everywhere, on coins, in temples, in the courts and offices of every level of administration. His name was used for oaths. His res gestae were public monuments. In Rome, Augustus was content to have the honors of his office, his munificence, his auctoritas, and his family line identified with every possible legal, religious, and social institution of the city. If foreigners wished to honor him as something more, that was their prerogative. In 27 BC, he accepted the elevated title of Augustus itself.

  • The imperial cult did not spread uniformly across the empire. In the Eastern provinces, where Greek and Hellenistic traditions had long normalized ruler worship, it found immediate and fertile ground. Greek cities of Roman Asia competed for the privilege of building high-status imperial cult centers called neocorates. Ephesus and Sardis, long rivals, each held two until the early 3rd century AD, when Ephesus was allowed an additional temple to the reigning emperor Caracalla. The Cypriot calendar honored the entire Augustan household by dedicating a month each to imperial family members, their ancestral deities, and major gods of the Romano-Greek pantheon. The Western provinces presented a different problem. Only recently Latinized following Caesar's Gallic campaigns, most of the West had no native tradition of monarchic divinity to absorb the imperial cult. The Western provincial concilia emerged as direct creations of the cult, recruiting existing local military, political, and religious traditions into a Roman model. The first known Western regional cult centers to Augustus, the arae sestianae, were established with his permission around 19 BC in north-western Spain, named after their military founder, L. Sestius Albanianus Quirinalis. Soon after, either in 12 BC or 10 BC, Drusus founded the first provincial cult center in the West at Lugdunum. The first priest of the altar there was Caius Julius Vercondaridubnus, a Gaul of the provincial elite who had been granted Roman citizenship. His priestly office gave him the right to participate in local government. Rejection of the cult carried real consequences. In 9 AD, Segimundus, the imperial cult priest at what would later become the city now known as Cologne, destroyed or cast off his priestly regalia to join the rebellion of his kinsman Arminius. In the province of Africa, local Berber deities were simply identified with the authority of Augustus, while two temples to Roma and the divus Augustus were attested in the senatorial province at Leptis Magna and Mactar.

  • The Senate's power to vote a dead emperor divus, and thus raise him to official godhood in an act of apotheosis, became one of the most effective tools of political legitimacy and condemnation in the Roman world. An emperor voted worthy became a divus, a dweller in heaven, a lesser being than the Olympians but an official inhabitant of the divine order. Popular belief held that the divus Augustus would be personally welcomed by Jupiter. An emperor judged unworthy was denied apotheosis, and the Senate could go further, voting damnatio memoriae, the official erasure of a ruler's memory. Vespasian, founder of the Flavian dynasty, could not trace his lineage back to the divine ancestry of Julius Caesar and so could not legitimate his reign through that connection. He secured his position instead by renewing cult to the divus Julius and presenting himself as a restorer of Augustan modesty and senatorial Republican values. He was said to have approached his own impending divinity with dry humor. Suetonius records that his last words were "puto deus fio": I think I am turning into a god. Vespasian's use of apotheosis as legitimacy found a mirror in Septimius Severus, who entered Rome in 193 AD, gave apotheosis to his predecessor Pertinax, and then cancelled the Senate's damnatio memoriae of the much-hated Commodus, deifying him as a brother and thereby adopting Marcus Aurelius as his own ancestor. The mechanism could be wielded in the opposite direction too. Caracalla, who murdered his co-emperor and brother Geta in 212 AD, had Geta's memory officially damned. He is attributed with the phrase, describing his approach to divinity and its absence: "sit divus dum non sit vivus", let him be a divus as long as he is not alive.

  • By the 3rd century, the imperial cult had become inseparable from the question of what it meant to be Roman at all. The emperor Decius, who came to power in 249 AD after deposing Philip the Arab, decreed that all subjects of the empire must actively seek to benefit the state through witnessed and certified sacrifice to ancestral gods. Only Jews were exempt. Refusal was to be tried at proconsular level. Apostasy was the goal, not execution. A year after its deadline, the edict was allowed to expire, and Decius himself died. Valerian, reigning from 253 to 260, identified Christianity as the largest and most stubborn of non-Roman cults and outlawed Christian assembly. Aurelian, who ruled from 270 to 275, stabilized the empire and established an official, Hellenic form of unitary cult to Sol Invictus in Rome's Campus Martius. The Senate hailed him as restitutor orbis, restorer of the world, and deus et dominus natus, god and born ruler. He was murdered by his own Praetorians. Diocletian's response to religious dissent was the most severe in the Church's memory, the Diocletianic Persecution. According to Lactantius, it began with ominous results from haruspicy in Diocletian's own household and a subsequent decree of placatory sacrifice by the entire military. An unknown number of Christians suffered the extreme punishments traditionally reserved for rebels and traitors. But Diocletian's conservatism ultimately could not hold. His framework of divine imperial order passed to Constantine I, who in the ascendancy of Christianity turned the theological and political implications of the cult on their head. The emperor Julian tried and failed to reverse the declining support for Rome's official religious practices. Under Theodosius I, Christianity became the state religion of Rome. The traditional gods and the imperial cult were officially abandoned.

Continue browsing

Updated

Common questions

What was the Roman imperial cult and what did it involve?

The Roman imperial cult, known formally as the cultus imperatorius, was a framework that identified emperors and some members of their families with the divinely sanctioned authority of the Roman state. It was formulated during the early Principate of Augustus, building on Roman and Greek precedents, and involved official recognition of the emperor's rule as divinely approved through worship of his genius, posthumous deification by Senate vote, and the establishment of cult centers throughout the provinces.

How did Julius Caesar become involved in Roman emperor worship?

Julius Caesar was the first Roman to pursue godhood as part of an explicit reach for monarchy. By 44 BC, the Senate had placed his portrait on coinage, built him a house styled as a temple, paraded his image alongside the gods, and ordained a special priest (flamen) for him, with Mark Antony named as its first holder. He was killed in the Senate on the 15th of March 44 BC. Following his death, a comet was interpreted as his soul ascending to heaven, and in 42 BC, his heir Octavian held the formal ceremony of apotheosis, making him a divus of the Roman state.

How did Augustus manage the imperial cult without claiming to be a god?

Augustus allowed cult honors to be offered jointly to himself and the goddess Roma in Eastern provinces, particularly at Pergamum and Nicomedia, while directing Roman citizens in those provinces to worship only Roma and the divus Julius. In Rome, he presented himself as the dutiful son of the deified Julius Caesar, calling himself divi filius (son of the divinity), and arranged for cult to his own genius as a living emperor rather than claiming official divinity. He was voted the title Augustus in 27 BC.

What was apotheosis in the Roman imperial cult and who decided which emperors received it?

Apotheosis was the formal act by which a deceased emperor was declared a divus, an official state divinity, and elevated to a heavenly existence as a lesser being than the Olympian gods. The Senate voted on each case; emperors judged unworthy were denied the honor, and unpopular rulers could instead receive damnatio memoriae, the official erasure of their memory. Emperors like Vespasian and Septimius Severus used the granting of apotheosis to predecessors as a tool of political legitimacy for their own dynasties.

How did the Roman imperial cult spread to the western provinces?

The first known Western regional cult centers to Augustus were established around 19 BC in north-western Spain, named the arae sestianae after their founder L. Sestius Albanianus Quirinalis. The first provincial imperial cult center in the West was founded at Lugdunum by Drusus, either in 12 BC or 10 BC. Western concilia emerged as direct Roman creations recruiting local military, political, and religious traditions; the first priest of the Lugdunum altar was a Gaul, Caius Julius Vercondaridubnus, who received Roman citizenship and the right to participate in local government through his priestly office.

How did the rise of Christianity lead to the end of the Roman imperial cult?

As Christianity grew, the imperial cult became a flashpoint for theological and political conflict. Emperors including Decius and Diocletian legislated mandatory sacrifice to traditional gods and launched persecutions against Christians who refused. The emperor Julian failed to reverse the declining support for Rome's official religious practices. Theodosius I then adopted Christianity as the state religion, and Rome's traditional gods along with the imperial cult were officially abandoned.

All sources

249 references cited across the entry

  1. 1It is unclear whether the worship of Aeneas as Jupiter Indiges was an official (and thus, state sponsored) cult.
  2. 2As opposed to offices
  3. 3Gradel, pp. 32–52, as is much of this section.
  4. 5Beard, 272–275: the very few accounts of a public slave (or other figure) who stands behind or near the triumphator to remind him that he "is but mortal" or prompts him to "look behind" are open to a
  5. 6Taylor, p.67
  6. 7Gradel, p.46, citing Plautus – this is Plautus' addition to the Greek originals; Gradel also suggests that the corona civica began as an acknowledgement by A.A. that N.N. had saved his life – as a god
  7. 8Taylor, p. 55
  8. 10most likely an aide-de-camp of Metellus, and not a provincial official.
  9. 11Taylor, p.48; she cites Macrobius, Saturnalia, 3.13.9, which is largely an otherwise unknown quotation from Sallust; quasi deo supplicabatur is from Sallust. The year is uncertain, possibly 77 BC, aft
  10. 12This incident is also mentioned by Valerius Maximus, Facta et dicta memorabilia 9.1.5
  11. 14Taylor, p.48, citing Plutarch's Marius, 27
  12. 16When the messengers of Thasos announced to him that the city had declared him a god, he told them that if they could make men into gods, they should make themselves into gods; he would then believe th
  13. 17Taylor, pp. 12–13
  14. 18The Spartan decree was "Since Alexander wishes to be a god, let him be a god"; at Athens, Demades argued against provoking Alexander over this: don't protect Heaven and lose the earth; Demosthenes sai
  15. 20Taylor, pp. 40–41, citing Polybius 30.16, Livy, 45.44; also, as a parallel case, CIL VI 374, from the Laodiceans to the Roman people.
  16. 22Taylor, p. 8
  17. 23Taylor, Appendix II, citing Athenaeus, Book 10, passim.
  18. 24Taylor, pp. 9–10, citing Diodorus, 16.20; Cornelius Nepos, Timoleon 5, Plutarch, Moralia 542 E, Dion 46 and Timoleon 36,39; Timoleon is the first Greek whose birthday is recorded.
  19. 25Mark H. Munn, The School of History: Athens in the Age of Socrates, pp. 11,172
  20. 26Chiefly Zeus, as identified with Ammon, and his ancestors Achilles and Hercules.
  21. 27Taylor, Appendix 2; this was the ritual in which Callisthenes declined to take part, one of the offenses for which Alexander killed him.
  22. 28Taylor, 31–32. A papyrus survives which has a man swearing by the daimones of Ptolemy II and his queen.
  23. 29Taylor, p. 33
  24. 30Taylor, p. 57
  25. 31Taylor, p.57, citing Cicero, To Atticus, 1.18.6; Velleius Paterculus, 2.40.4. He only exercised the privilege once, and was attacked for it.
  26. 32BookThe CaesarsSuetonius et al. — Hackett Publishing — 2011
  27. 33Taylor, 58–60
  28. 34And Nicomedes IV of Bithynia was intimately familiar with Caesar, or so rumor sang about the streets of Rome. Suetonius, Divus Julius 49
  29. 36This statue showed him standing on the globe: the dedication is offered by Cassius Dio in Greek: hēmitheos (demigod), Dio 43.14.6 & 21.2. This may be Dio's late, anachronistic and approximate equivale
  30. 37Taylor, p.65; this was in the temple of Quirinus.
  31. 38For instance, at the pompa circensis, the procession held before games presented at the circus.
  32. 39An honorific also granted Cicero during his consulship and comparable to Romulus' title as parens urbis Romanae (parent of the Roman city)
  33. 40Price, in Cannadine and Price, 71, 85: in particular Cicero's speech to the Senate some months after Caesar's death: "...couch, image, pediment, priest" refer to Caesar's divine honours while living.
  34. 42Fishwick, Vol. 1, 1, 65, 73.
  35. 43Fishwick, Vol I, 108.
  36. 44The imperial cult in Roman Britain-Google docs
  37. 45Fishwick, Vol 3, part 1, 3: citing Cassius Dio, 51, 20, 6–7.
  38. 46Suetonius, Lives, Augustus, 52: Tacitus, Annals, 4, 37.
  39. 47Fishwick, Vol 1, book 1, 77 & 126–30.
  40. 49That is, through the manifest numen of his adoptive father the divus Julius.
  41. 50Rosenstein, 57–58.
  42. 52Fishwick, vol 1, 1, 51: .
  43. 54Howgego, in Howgego et al., 4–6: coinage celebrating state deities conspicuously features the restorer of their temples. Ibid 53: Imperial themes, including the Imperial family, dominate Roman coin is
  44. 55See Ando, 46 ff, for discussion of Augustan ideology.
  45. 56Beard et al, Vol. 1, 196–7.
  46. 58The caesareum at Najaran (in what is now south-west Saudi Arabia) was possibly later known as the "Kaaba of Najran": جواد علي, المفصل في تاريخ العرب قبل الإسلام (Jawad Ali, Al-Mufassal fi Tarikh Al-'A
  47. 59Harland, 2003, 91–103, finds among these examples a privately funded local, traditional Graeco-Asian civil association offering cult to Demeter and the emperor as a form of mystery cult: contra Price,
  48. 60See also Harland, 1996.
  49. 65Taylor, 56: See Macrobius 3.13.6–9 – "".
  50. 67Fishwick, vol 3, 1, pp. 7 & 230.
  51. 68Fishwick, vol 3, 1, 7: see also Pliny the Elder, Historia Naturalis, 4.111; Ptolemy, Geographia, 2.6.3; Pomponeus Mela, 3.13.
  52. 69Fishwick, vol 1,1, 97–149.)
  53. 70Fishwick vol 1, 1, 101 & vol 3, 1, 12–13: Fishwick determines the lower age limit at 25 years for these priesthoods. With minor exceptions, provincial priesthoods – whether described as sacerdos or fl
  54. 71Tacitus, Annals, 1.57.
  55. 72Potter, 26–7.
  56. 73Mellor, 1003.
  57. 74Mohamed Yacoub, Le musée du Bardo : Départements antiques, Tunis, Agence nationale du patrimoine, 1993, p.111
  58. 75Ando, 31–33, provides the constitutional and personal background to this dilemma.
  59. 76Price, in Cannadine and Price, 70.
  60. 77Beard et al, 360–363
  61. 78Potter, 6–7.
  62. 79See also Tacitus, Annals, 1.9–10 for appraisals of compuAugustus' motives in his rise to power, his opaque complexity of character, evaluation of his success and the exchange of constitutional freedom
  63. 81Tacitus interprets Tiberius' repeated refusal of provincial cult as a shirking of his moral responsibilities to empire, and therefore a dishonour to his high office and Rome.
  64. 82Gradel, 15: the collective genius of the Senate was usually personified as a bearded, elderly man – this is an exceptional genius type. Most individual genii are portrayed as youthful.
  65. 83Klose, in Howgego et al, 127.
  66. 84Ando, 170–171: see also 170, note 187.
  67. 85cf Caesar's "kingly" regalia, though as princeps Caligula was also "permanent ".
  68. 86Suetonius, Life of Caligula
  69. 87Neither Josephus nor Philo imply Caligula's elevation as a state deity in Jerusalem.
  70. 88Gradel, 142–158.
  71. 89Cassius Dio, (in John Xiphilinus' epitome), 59, 26, 3. Both Suetonius and Philo offer Caligula as a suspiciously perfect example of how not to be emperor. The Senate remains a vague figure of superior
  72. 91A cult dedication to Livia as diva Augusta appears in Lusitania, dated to 48 AD.
  73. 92Gradel proposes that had Claudius employed those of higher rank within his domus, it would have imputed their clientage as his servants. He may have underestimated the complexity of the problems inher
  74. 93This surmise is based on a combination of Seneca's satirical Apocolocyntosis, Suetonius' sneering "Life" and Tacitus's sharp observations of Julio-Claudian failings.
  75. 94Tacitus, Annals, 13, 3.
  76. 95Fishwick, Vol. 3, 1, 75–6: cf the Lyons Tablet and Claudius' modesty (or fear of seeming arrogant).
  77. 96Fishwick, 81–89.
  78. 97Fishwick, Vol. 3, 1, 54–9.
  79. 98Mons Caelus had "ambiguous Etruscan connections" (Claudius had a historian's interest in Etruscan culture and language). It was also notorious for its brothels and meat-market. Claudius had a reputed
  80. 99Fishwick, Vol. 3, 1, 88–9.
  81. 100Claudius' Caelian temple was later rebuilt and some of it survives through incorporation in later building. Nero's cult may have been justified as a "revival" of Claudius' entitlement to genius cult a
  82. 101Tacitus, Annals, XV.74.
  83. 102Potter, 68.
  84. 103Kenneth Scott, The Imperial Cult Under the Flavians, New York 1975
  85. 104Chabrečková, Barbora. The Imperial Cult During the Reign of Domitian. Masaryk University, Department of Archaeology and Museology. 2017.
  86. 105Tacitus, Histories, 4.40.2
  87. 106Some still thought the head resembled Nero's. Others were reminded of Titus, Vespasian's son: see also Cassius Dio, 65.15.1.
  88. 107A dedication of the Colossus to the sun god is consistent with Neronian iconography – any resemblance to Nero would be appropriate to his imperial representation as the "second sun" of the pax Romana
  89. 108Marlowe, E. (2006), "Framing the sun: the Arch of Constantine and the Roman cityscape". The Art Bulletin
  90. 109Smallwood, 345.
  91. 110The practice of a genius cult towards Domitian is shown in the Arval Acts.
  92. 111Gradel, 159–161: Suetonius' claims for Domitian's personal use of the title – or its use by his procurators at his behest – are unverified. He is clear that Domitian's freedmen were the first to use i
  93. 112Gradel, 159–161.
  94. 113Ando, 167: Pliny panegyric 75.1–3: Pliny refers to the publication of the senatorial voice in proceedings: Trajan's respect for the Senate can only be good for the "dignity" of the state.
  95. 114Gradel, 190–192.
  96. 116Gradel, 194–195.
  97. 117Howgego, in Howgego et al, 6, 10.
  98. 118Hadrian's "Hellenic" emotionalism finds a culturally sympathetic echo in the Homeric Achilles' mourning for his friend Patroclus: see Vout, 52–135.
  99. 119Dio – or his epitomist – insists that Antinous died not through drowning, as Hadrian claimed, but as the emperor's willing sacrificial victim as part of a bid for immortality – though whose is not cle
  100. 120Vout, 118–119, contra Price, 68, who does not regard Antinous as receiving full cult honours of apotheosis in Rome itself. Both agree that Antinous was unlikely to have had official parity with other
  101. 122Vout, 111. His piety lay in his unrelenting yet personally modest plea to the Senate for the deification of his predecessor Hadrian: morally comparable with the filial devotion of Metellus Pius during
  102. 123Gradel, 200, citing Fronto, Epistulae ad M. Caesar (letters to M. Aurelius), 4, 12, 6.
  103. 124Gradel, 199: see also The context and precedents for Imperial Cult. Relative to the living emperor, the divi probably have little or no personal power, unless of divine intercession.
  104. 125Potter, 78–79.
  105. 127On 1 January 193 AD, the legions unwittingly renewed their annual vows of loyalty to a dead Emperor: Potter, 92–96. see also Dio ibid.
  106. 128This is based on a statement in the Historia Augusta, which claims he planned to have his own flamen while still living. Cassius Dio, in an otherwise detailed account, makes no mention of this. See Gr
  107. 129Potter, 93–96.
  108. 130Potter, 75–79.
  109. 131Potter, 96–99.
  110. 132Potter, 103.
  111. 134Dio, Ibid. 77.9.4: (Loeb) – "When the emperor was enrolled in the family of Marcus, Auspex said: 'I congratulate you, Caesar, upon finding a father', implying that up to that time he had been fatherle
  112. 135Gradel, 194.
  113. 136Potter, 107–112: for coinage of Antonine dynasts, see 111.
  114. 137Potter, 110.
  115. 138Another name for the Imperial divi, which indicates their elevation to "August" status. "Caesar Augustus" is reserved for living emperors: See Gradel, 88.
  116. 139Fishwick, vol. 3, 1, 199.
  117. 140Potter, 113–120.
  118. 142Potter, 133–135: dediticii (those who had surrendered to Rome in war) and a specific class of freedmen were excluded.
  119. 143Potter, 138–139: slaves formally adopted the name of the master who freed them.
  120. 144Like Commodus, he participated in chariot races and beast-fights, with minimal risk to himself.
  121. 145Potter, 142–146: citing Philostratus, V. Soph, 626.
  122. 146Days of careful negotiation had preceded his "spontaneous" acclamation as imperator by the military
  123. 147Dio disapproves of Macrinus' equestrian status, but not his integrity or manner of government.
  124. 148Potter, 146–148: Avitus took the Imperial name Marcus Aurelius Antoninus.
  125. 149Potter, 148–149:
  126. 150Potter, 152–157.
  127. 152Gradel, 356–362: citing Herodian for the removal of temple wealth and reactions to it.
  128. 153Potter, 237–238, citing Zosimus, 1.19.1–2.
  129. 154Howgego, in Howgego et al., 5.
  130. 155Potter, 244–248.
  131. 156Ando, 209.
  132. 157Beard et al, Vol. 1, 241.
  133. 158Potter, 241–243: see 242 for Decian "libellus" (certificate) of oath and sacrifice on papyrus, dated to 250 AD.
  134. 161Rees, 60.
  135. 162Beard et al, 241.
  136. 164Cascio, in Bowman et al. (eds), 171: citing .
  137. 165See also (with due caveat) Historia Augusta, Vita Taciti, XIII 1–2.
  138. 166Vout, 118–119.
  139. 167Lactantius, II.6.10.1–4
  140. 168Eusebius, II.8.1.8.
  141. 169Bowman et al, 170–173.
  142. 170Rees, 46–56.
  143. 171Rees, 51–56 (ideology) & 73–74 (coin image interpretation).
  144. 172MacCormack, 722, & note 8.
  145. 173Brent, 49–51. See also Augustus, Res Gestae, c.4.2.
  146. 174Fishwick, Vol. 3, 1, 5.
  147. 175Gradel, 263–268: citing Tertullian.
  148. 176Gradel, 7: numen "can also be synonymous with deus".
  149. 177Fishwick, Vol 3, 1, 42: see also Plutarch (based on Varro, Quaestionaes Romanae, 14).
  150. 178The apotheosed ("deified") Julius Caesar was "translated by the senate and people of Rome into the company of the gods (dei)" and became the divus Julius: Price, in Cannadine and Price, 1992, 77–8: th
  151. 179Price, in Cannadine and Price, 82–102, for the changing roles of senate and emperors in the granting of apotheosis.
  152. 180Javier Arce, in Theuws and Nelson, pp.116 – 117.
  153. 181Price, 115.
  154. 184Beard et al, 207: see above for Augustus' permission for cult to his own numen only very late in his reign. Whether it was official cult is uncertain, but it would have been offered and permitted, not
  155. 185Fishwick, Vol.3, 1, 198, referring to the Severan emperor Caracalla.
  156. 186Beard et al, vol 1, 140–9.
  157. 187Gradel, 3, 15.
  158. 188Livy, 25.16.1–4 & 6.1.12: Livy wrote at a time of extreme civil strife, during the era of Rome's transformation from Republic to Principate. See also Rosenstein, 58–60
  159. 189Beard et al, Vol 1, 32–6.
  160. 190Gradel, 21.
  161. 191Gradel, 78, 93
  162. 192Price, 209, 221.
  163. 193Beard et al, Vol 1, 12–20: haruspicy was also used. The haruspex read the divine will in the sacrificial entrails. This was regarded as an ethnically Etruscan "outsider" practise, whose priesthood was
  164. 194Brent, 17–20: citing Cicero, De Natura Deorum, 2.4.
  165. 195Beard et al, Vol 1, 17–21: most magistracies ran for only a year. Priesthoods were for life, which offered evident advantages in maintaining a high public and political profile.
  166. 196Brent, 21–25.
  167. 197Brent, 59: citing Suetonius, Augustus 31.1–2. cf official reactions to "foreign cult" during the Punic crises, above.
  168. 198Gradel, 36–38: the paterfamilias held – in theory at least, and through ancient right – powers of life and death over every member of his extended familia, including children, slaves and freedmen. In
  169. 199See also Severy, 9–10 for interpretation of the social, economic and religious role of the paterfamilias within the immediate and extended family and the broader community.
  170. 200Beard et al, vol 1, 67–8.
  171. 201Gradel, 5, 8.
  172. 202Brent, 61: Dio Cassius, 51.19.7.
  173. 203Brent, 62–63.
  174. 204Beard et al, Vol. 1, 193–4: under Augustus' programme of "renewal" the Vestals had high status seating at games and theatres, and became priestesses to the cult of the deified Livia (wife of Augustus)
  175. 205Gradel, 38.
  176. 206Brent, 61.
  177. 208Lott, 14–15, 115 & 230 (note 127).
  178. 209Brent, 268–269.
  179. 212Gradel, 364.
  180. 213Gradel, 78–98.
  181. 214Lott, 81 – 106; for discussion of Lares Augusti see 107 – 117. Lott rejects the replacement of neighbourhood Lares with Augustus' own as politically indelicate. The Lares Augusti can be understood as
  182. 215Rehak & Younger, 93.
  183. 216Brent, 17–18, 53–54.
  184. 218Smallwood's application of religio licita (licensed religion) to Judaism in this and possibly any period is disputed by Rajack in: Tessa Rajack, "Was there a Roman Charter for the Jews?" Journal of Ro
  185. 219Potter, 36.
  186. 220Fishwick, vol. 1, 1, 36.
  187. 222Brent, 221.
  188. 223Price, 10–11.
  189. 224Potter, 37.
  190. 225Collins, 125: citing Revelation, 13, 7–8 & 16–17; 14, 9–11; 16, 2.
  191. 228cited in Beard et al, Vol 1, 370.
  192. 229Momigliano, 104.
  193. 233Nixon & Rodgers, 437–448: Full text of Latinus Pacata Drepanius, Panegyric of Theodosius (389) with commentary and context.
  194. 234MacCormack, 721–752.
  195. 236Price, 204–205, and footnote 171, citing Basil, Homily 24: "on seeing an image of the king in the square, one does not allege that there are two kings" (therefore veneration of the image venerates the
  196. 237Price, 13–17, includes historians of opposing political views among those who interpret the imperial cult as the domination of "a servile world" through politically driven "charade". Eduard Meyer, "Al
  197. 238See also Harland, P. A., "Honours and Worship: Emperors, Imperial Cults and Associations at Ephesus (First to Third Centuries C.E.)", Studies in Religion/Sciences religieuses 25 (1996) 319–334.
  198. 239Tacitus' reference to the graeca adulatio (greek adulation or flattery) of benefactor-cult was set within the Graeco-Eastern context of the Roman civil war and referred to Theophanes of Mytilene, whos
  199. 240Roman (and Greek) justifications of Rome's hegemony insisted on Rome's moral superiority over its allies and subject peoples. The same commentators deplored Empire for the demoralising effects of its
  200. 241Price, 10–20: citing evaluations of the imperial cult as insincere or "mechanical" in Gibbon, Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Bury edn, 1, 75–77; Ferguson, CAH, VII (1928), 17; Eduard Meyer, "Al
  201. 242Harland, 85, cites among others M. P. Nilsson, Greek Piety (Oxford 1948) 177–178, and early work by D. Fishwick, The Development of Provincial Ruler Worship in the Western Roman Empire, ANRW II.16.2 (
  202. 243Brent, 17.
  203. 244Beard, North, Price, (1998), 318: see also 208–210, 252–253, 359–361.
  204. 245Price, 6–20, 116.
  205. 246Gradel, 3–8.
  206. 247Price, 11.
  207. 248Gradel, 23.
  208. 249Price, 20.

Queue