Bar Kokhba revolt

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Bar Kokhba Revolt of 132 to 136 CE left behind silver coins that were struck over Roman ones. The old imperial designs were replaced with Jewish symbols. One first-year version shows a palm bundle called a lulav and a citron called an etrog, beside the words "Year One of the Redemption of Israel." Those coins belonged to a Jewish state that survived for more than three years inside the Roman Empire. Its leader was a man named Simon bar Kokhba. His rebellion was the last and most devastating of three major Jewish revolts against Rome. Even his name is still argued over.

  This documentary follows several questions. What pushed the province of Judaea into open war with Rome? What sort of man led the rebels, and what sort of state did he try to build? How did the rebels hold out as long as they did? And what did Rome do to the land and its people once the fighting was over?

  81444376

• 2. Fragments of Evidence

  ›

  Josephus, a contemporary historian, chronicled the First Jewish-Roman War from beginning to end. The revolt under Simon bar Kokhba had no such chronicler. Scholars instead assemble the story from a handful of sources, each with its own bias and its own uncertainties about dates.

  The fullest Roman account comes from Cassius Dio, a senator who wrote in the early 3rd century. His passages survive only through an 11th-century summary by John Xiphilinus, usually judged faithful. Dio concentrates on warfare. He describes the underground hideouts, notes that Jews around the world stood in solidarity with the rebels, and mentions some non-Jewish participants. The surviving text never calls the rebel leader Bar Kokhba.

  Eusebius, a 4th-century bishop in Caesarea Maritima, supplied several names that Dio lacks. He identified Tineius Rufus as the Roman governor, named Bar Kokhba as the leader, and named Betar as the site of the last siege. He also read the revolt as divine punishment for the crucifixion of Jesus. Even so, he had access to the library of Pamphilus, church archives in Aelia Capitolina, and earlier Christian writers such as Aristo of Pella and Julius Africanus. The Historia Augusta, a 4th-century set of imperial biographies, gives the revolt a single sentence in its Life of Hadrian.

  Rabbinic literature adds the Jewish experience. Most of it concerns law, but its narrative passages preserve stories about Betar in the Babylonian Talmud, the Jerusalem Talmud, and Lamentations Rabbah. These texts uniquely call Bar Kokhba a messianic figure. They judge him with both sympathy and criticism, and they record the Roman executions of leading sages.

  The largest change came from archaeology, beginning in the mid-20th century. Papyri found in refuge caves in the Judaean Desert include letters between Simon Bar Kokhba and his subordinates, plus legal documents. They reveal little about battles. They reveal a great deal about how the rebel state ran from day to day.

  814105754

• 3. Hadrian's New City

  ›

  Between 66 and 73 CE, Judaea was the center of the First Jewish Revolt. Vespasian, and then his son Titus, led the Roman campaign. In 70 CE it ended with the destruction of the Second Temple and the devastation of Jerusalem. Communal life slowly recovered, and Jews remained a relative majority in the population. Hopes for a divinely appointed messiah persisted. Works such as 4 Ezra and 2 Baruch voiced the expectation that God would soon overthrow Rome.

  Rome tightened its hold on the province. A governor of senatorial rank, called a legate, took charge. Legio X Fretensis, which had helped conquer Jerusalem, was stationed permanently among the city's ruins. Judea proper and Idumaea became a military zone run by legion officers, and former soldiers and other Roman citizens settled in the province.

  In 115-117, under Emperor Trajan, Jewish communities in Egypt, Cyrenaica, Cyprus, and Mesopotamia rose in what is called the Diaspora Revolt. Judaea may have seen a Roman campaign too, remembered in rabbinic tradition as the Kitos War. The name comes from Lusius Quietus, a Moorish general whom Trajan placed in charge of the province. The sources are scarce and mostly late, so these events were probably minor.

  After Hadrian took power in 117, Marcus Titius Lustricus Bruttianus replaced Quietus. A second legion, Legio II Traiana Fortis, arrived and raised the garrison to two. Judaea became a proconsular province. Milestones from around 120 record that these soldiers built a road from Acre to Sepphoris and Caparcotna. Settling loyal populations, including retired veterans, only deepened the alienation of the Jewish inhabitants.

  Hadrian toured the Roman East in 129-130, founding or refounding cities along the way. Judaea's non-Jewish residents honored him with new city names and festivals. During this tour he chose to rebuild the ruined Jerusalem as a Roman colony. He called it Aelia Capitolina, after his own family name and in honor of Capitoline Jupiter, chief god of Roman state religion. Scholars drawing on Jerome and the Talmud think the colony was formally founded during his visit, with the ritual of ploughing a furrow to mark the city's boundary.

  Historians read the project as a deliberate blow. Mary E. Smallwood called it "an attempt to combat resurgent Jewish nationalism." Martin Goodman noted that Hadrian founded cities elsewhere to flatter local people. Here the purpose was "not to flatter but to suppress the natives." A story in Genesis Rabbah says Rome first allowed the Temple to be rebuilt, then withdrew the offer after a Samaritan warned that a restored city would breed rebellion. Its historicity is questioned.

  Historians long debated whether the new city caused the war or was imposed afterward as punishment. Cassius Dio said it provoked "a long and serious war, since the Jews objected to having gentiles settled in their city and foreign cults established." Eusebius described a colony planted only after the Jewish population had been removed. In 1998, a coin hoard hidden before 135 in the el-Jai cave in the northern Judaean Desert largely settled the matter. It held Aelia Capitolina coins alongside Bar Kokhba coins, so the colony was already minting money before the revolt ended.

  Another cause named by an ancient writer has not been settled so neatly.

  4039366654

• 4. Contested Triggers

  ›

  The Historia Augusta says the Jews "began a war because they were forbidden to mutilate their genitals." Scholars read this as a ban on circumcision. The text was written centuries later and admits its own errors. Rabbinic sources describe such a ban as a punishment enacted after the revolt, so experts disagree about whether it caused the war or followed it.

  Mary E. Smallwood argued for a universal ban before the revolt, later lifted. Domitian, who ruled 81-96, and Nerva, who ruled 96-98, had already restricted castration. Antoninus Pius, who ruled 138-161, is known to have let Jews circumcise their own sons, though not proselytes. That permission implies an earlier prohibition. Smallwood also cited a Talmudic account in which Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus allowed circumcision knives to be hidden in times of danger. She read the discussions of mesukhim, men who underwent a procedure to reverse circumcision, as attempts to dodge the ban.

  Aharon Oppenheimer rejected this. He called the Historia Augusta highly unreliable, possibly tinged with anti-Jewish stereotypes, and read the Talmudic passages as describing the repression after the war. For him the colony was the sole cause. Peter Schäfer added that Hadrian was a political pragmatist who would likely have avoided a measure so obviously certain to enrage his Jewish subjects.

  Deeper pressures may also have mattered. The exile after the destruction of Solomon's Temple in 587/586 BCE had lasted seventy years, a span read as the fulfillment of a prophecy in the Book of Jeremiah. By 130 CE about sixty years had passed since the Second Temple fell, so a renewed divine intervention may have seemed near. Many Jews had lost land to Roman veterans and collaborators after the First Jewish Revolt. That dispossessed class probably became a base of support for the rebel leader. Historian Menahem Mor judged that his personal charisma was itself a major catalyst.

  4039456675

• 5. Prince of Israel

  ›

  Letters from the Judaean Desert are signed Shimʻon ben Kosibah. Rabbinic texts call the leader Ben Kosiba, while the name Bar Kokhba appears only in Christian sources, which render it in Greek as Barkhokhebas. Some historians once thought Bar Kokhba, "son of the star," was his true name and Bar Kosiba, "son of disappointment" or "son of lies," a later insult. His own signed letters showed that Ben Kosibah was part of his authentic name. It probably points to his place of origin, a place called Kosiba. The star title was probably a messianic honorific from Rabbi Akiva, alluding to the line in Numbers 24:17, "A star shall come out of Jacob."

  The sages were divided over him. According to tradition, Akiva endorsed him as the messiah. Yohanan ben Torta replied, according to the Jerusalem Talmud, "Grass will grow on your cheeks, and the Messiah will not yet have come!" On his coins the leader is called Nasi, usually translated as prince, patriarch, or president.

  His letters show a hands-on commander. He personally managed discipline and supplies and rebuked subordinates sharply. He scolded officers at Ein Gedi for sheltering men from Tekoa, apparently to help them avoid conscription. He warned a commander named Jeshua ben Galgula, "I shall put your feet in fetters as I did to Ben Aphlul!" Yet the same letters show a man who kept the Sabbath, observed the laws of tithes, and ordered lulavs and etrogs for the festival of Sukkot. His army had ranks such as "head of a camp," and the letters name commanders including Judah bar Manasse at Kiryath Arabaya and Masabala bar Simeon at Ein Gedi.

  The state announced its independence in money. Silver coins came as the sela and the zuz, with four zuzim to a sela, and a rare half-sela is known. Scholars disagree whether the bronze coinage had three denominations or four. Inscriptions use the archaic Paleo-Hebrew alphabet instead of the square script of the day, as earlier Jewish revolts had also revived Hebrew as a symbol of nationhood. The first-year silver tetradrachm shows a Temple facade, apparently holding the Ark of the Covenant, with the word "Jerusalem." Later coins carry slogans such as "For the Freedom of Israel" and "For the Freedom of Jerusalem." Grapevines, palm trees, harps, trumpets, and Temple vessels also appear.

  First-year coins also name "Eleazar the Priest," whose identity is unknown. Some scholars think he was Bar Kokhba's uncle, whom rabbinic tradition says the leader killed for seeking talks with Rome. Pairing a priest with the prince suggests preparation for rebuilding the Temple and restoring the High Priesthood. Seven official lead weights survive as well. One names "Shimon Dasoi" as parnas, an official who oversaw weights and measures in the marketplace.

  5881574643

• 6. Borders of the Rebel State

  ›

  The rebel state covered roughly 40 kilometers from east to west and 80 kilometers from south to north. The spread of its coins puts the southern edge near Arad and Beersheba and the northern edge beyond modern Ramallah. In the east it reached the Dead Sea shore and the southern Jordan Valley, and in the west the lowlands near Kiryat Gat. Scholars agree it held Judea proper. "Maximalists" argue it reached Galilee and the Golan Heights, while "minimalists" do not.

  Jerusalem is the sharpest puzzle. Ancient sources mention fighting there, and coin slogans invoke the city. Yet as of 2020, only four Bar Kokhba coins had turned up within Jerusalem, out of more than 22,000 found across the region. On that evidence the Israel Antiquities Authority holds that the rebels never captured it. Archaeologists Moran Hagbi and Joe Uziel suggest Roman soldiers may have carried the few coins in as souvenirs. The lasting camp of Legio X Fretensis also points to a Roman hold that would have been hard to break.

  Galilee presents the opposite problem. Most scholars think this Jewish-majority district stayed out of the revolt. Twenty underground hideout systems like those in Judea have been found there, but no revolt coins. Haggai Olshanetsky proposed that Galilee joined early and withdrew around 132-133. Werner Eck read a Roman arch at Tel Shalem as a victory monument over rebels in Galilee, while Menahem Mor said it marked Hadrian's visit in 130. Perea, the Jewish part of Transjordan, probably did take part. Abandoned sites such as Tel Abu al-Sarbut, al-Mukhayyat, and Callirrhoe may reflect the conflict, and a 151 papyrus naming a Roman veteran from Meason suggests confiscated land.

  Not everyone in the region backed the rebel leader. Justin Martyr wrote that Christians who refused to acknowledge Bar Kokhba suffered "dreadful torments." Shaye J. Cohen suggested the leader "could not abide the messianic claims of another." Dio says many outside nations helped the Jews out of greed. Mor suggested poorer residents of Hellenistic cities joined to undermine the Roman-backed elite. The Samaritans, whose homeland bordered the revolt's core, appear to have stayed out. Glen Bowersock pointed to erased inscriptions of the governor Haterius Nepos at Gerasa and a Safaitic graffito about a tribesman who "rebelled" against "Nepos the tyrant." He admitted these readings remain open to interpretation.

  4357515447

• 7. Tunnels and Legions

  ›

  Cassius Dio wrote that the rebels avoided meeting the Romans in the open field. They fortified high ground with mines and walls, and dug passages that let them gather unseen and let in air and light. Hundreds of such complexes have been found, built mostly by adapting cisterns, ritual baths, and silos and linking them with narrow tunnels and shafts. As of 2022, 439 complexes were documented at 252 sites in Judea. In 139 of them the securely dated artifacts fall between 70 and 136. Builders sealed the original entrances and cut hidden ones into house floors. Sharp 90-degree turns and internal locking mechanisms were meant to disorient and trap Roman soldiers. Civilians sheltered there too. Dio also claimed the rebels deliberately made poor weapons so that Rome would reject them, but recovered weapons match standard Roman types.

  Betar, on a ridge in the Judaean Mountains, became the headquarters because it sat near Jerusalem, had abundant springs, and was easy to defend. The rebels also used the palace-fortress of Herodium as a regional headquarters and wheat depot. Its tunnels hold arrowheads, slingstones, and fire-blackened surfaces, and beams from the Herodian palace were reused to reinforce their roofs.

  The revolt probably erupted in the summer of 132. Documents record people fleeing from Zoar to Ein Gedi soon after. Governor Quintus Tineius Rufus tried to put down the uprising and apparently suffered a humiliating defeat. The legate of Syria, Gaius Poblicius Marcellus, was sent to stabilize the region until a larger force could be gathered.

  Hadrian then called on Sextus Julius Severus, transferred from his post as governor of Britannia. He appears to have arrived in the first half of 133. Moving a commander from Britain to a minor province suggests a state of emergency. Hadrian took part in the campaign for a time. At least nine legions sent whole formations or detachments, including Legio III Cyrenaica from Bostra and Legio V Gallica from Syria. Marines from the fleet at Misenum were moved into Legio X Fretensis and given Roman citizenship, and recruits were drafted in Italy and the Alpine provinces. Roman forces used ballista at Herodium and Betar, among other sites.

  Betar came under siege in the summer of 135. The defenders threw up a wall of earth fill and reused structures. The Romans built a siege wall and two camps to the south, likely cutting off the spring. Twenty-two slingstones lay on a tower roof, hewn in haste and left unused. A Latin inscription at a nearby spring names detachments of Legio V Macedonica and Legio XI Claudia. Jewish tradition says Betar fell on Tisha B'Av, the day mourning the Temple. The Jerusalem Talmud says the Romans killed until a horse sank in blood to its nostrils. Betar was destroyed and never rebuilt.

  The war did not stop there. Hadrian reportedly set guard posts at Hammat, Bethlehem, and Kefar Lekitaya to catch fleeing rebels. He sent heralds promising a reward to those in hiding, but those who came out were surrounded and killed in the Valley of Beit Rimmon. Other refugees fled to high desert caves above the Dead Sea. Rome besieged roughly half of them, building camps overhead to starve the occupants. Skeletons and arrowheads show that some died of hunger and thirst and others in assaults.

  Scholars disagree about when it ended. Boaz Zissu says fighting lasted at least until January 136. Werner Eck notes that Hadrian's second acclamation as imperator is absent from 135 records but appears from 136, which suggests the war still raged at the end of 135.

  Roman losses were heavy. Dio admits that many Romans died. Hadrian's report to the Senate left out the customary line "I and the army are in health." A letter of 162 from the orator Fronto to Marcus Aurelius recalls how many soldiers the Jews killed under Hadrian. Legio X Fretensis took heavy casualties. Legio XXII Deiotariana vanishes from the records after 119, and some scholars blame the revolt, while Mor suggests an earlier disbanding after unrest in Alexandria in 121-122.

  5784546251

• 8. After Judea

  ›

  Dio wrote that 50 outposts and 985 villages were razed, and that 580,000 men died in raids and battles. He added that those who perished from famine, disease, and fire could not be counted. Peter Schäfer suspected inflation, but allowed that the losses would still have been considerable. Hannah Cotton found the figures plausible against Roman census declarations. In 2021, Dvir Raviv and Chaim Ben David compared settlement patterns with Ottoman-period demographic data and judged Dio's account reliable. Shimon Applebaum estimated that about two-thirds of Judaea's Jews died. No site in Judea shows continuous occupation through the 2nd century. At Horvat 'Ethri, a mass grave lay inside a ritual bath, and one skeleton bore cut marks consistent with beheading.

  Survivors faced expulsion and slavery. Jews were barred from Jerusalem and its surrounding district. Jerome wrote that they could enter only once a year, on Tisha B'Av, and only by paying. William V. Harris estimated that more than 100,000 Jews were enslaved. The Chronicon Paschale says Hadrian sold captives for the price of a day's food for a horse. Jerome reports that countless people were sold at the market of Terebinthus, and that others were taken to Gaza or moved to Egypt. Many refugees went to Babylonia, strengthening its Jewish community.

  Hadrian then banned Torah study and the Hebrew calendar. Sages were executed and sacred texts burned, and he set statues of Jupiter and himself on the Temple's ruins. These decrees stood until his death in 138. Rabbinic memory calls the era shemad, and texts add the curse "may his bones rot" to Hadrian's name. The Babylonian Talmud tells how Rabbi Akiva was flayed with iron combs and died reciting the Shema. Shimon bar Yochai and his son hid in a cave for twelve years. These stories fed the tradition of the Ten Martyrs.

  The province also lost its name. Judaea became Syria Palaestina, after the long-vanished Philistines. Werner Eck stressed that no other province was renamed in response to a rebellion, not even Britannia or Germania. Hannah Cotton said Judaea was "air-brushed out of the map of Roman provinces." David Jacobson dissents, seeing a tidying of provincial naming. Hebrew also largely stopped being spoken in daily life.

  Land changed hands. Roman veterans, and migrants from Syria, Phoenicia, and Arabia, settled the countryside around Jerusalem, as shown by a legionary tomb at Manahat and Roman villas at Ein Yael and Ramat Rachel. Rabbi Abbahu said Samaritans settled thirteen towns. Rabbis created sikarikon laws so Jews could buy back confiscated land.

  Jewish life moved north. Galilee, less harmed by the war, became the center. Usha housed the Sanhedrin before it moved on to Tiberias. Around 200, Rabbi Judah ha-Nasi redacted the Mishnah in Galilee. Within a few generations, Babylonian scholars built on that text to compose the Babylonian Talmud, which became the central authority for Jewish religious law.

  5447717043