The German scholar Theodor Mommsen proposed the term Principate in the 19th century to describe a constitutional system where imperial authority sat inside Republican institutions. He viewed this arrangement as an extension of the republic until its rupture in the third century when it became the Dominate. Historian Jochen Bleicken credits Mommsen with introducing these concepts as a framework for periodizing Roman imperial history. Mommsen also introduced the concept of diarchy to describe the early imperial system where power was formally shared between Augustus and the Senate from 27 BC. Since the early 20th century scholars have increasingly rejected this view calling the Principate a variant of monarchy instead. Ronald Syme led historians who now place more emphasis on the Augustan Principate over the Dominate. There has been a greater focus on how rulers interacted with communities during the 1960s to mid-1980s than on legal frameworks. In 21st-century scholarship the phrase Augustan Age is widely used to frame the period associated with the development of the Augustan Principate. However Bleicken considers the term unsuitable due to flawed legal basis and misunderstandings it creates such as viewing the earlier imperial period as having more freedom.
Augustus Political Settlements
On the 13th of January 27 BC Octavian made a show of returning full power to the Senate and relinquishing his control of the Roman provinces and their armies. The Senate proposed that he once again assume command of the provinces which served as a ratification of his extra-constitutional power. Feigning reluctance on the 16th of January 27 BC he accepted a ten-year responsibility of overseeing provinces considered chaotic. Command of these provinces provided Octavian with control over the majority of Rome's legions while maintaining a republican facade for the autocratic principate. On the 1st of July 23 BC Augustus gave up his consulship after dealing with a severe illness but retained consular imperium throughout the empire. This led to a second compromise between him and the Senate regarding what became known as the Marcus Primus affair. The Senate granted Augustus a form of general imperium proconsulare applicable throughout the empire not solely to his provinces. They augmented this into imperium proconsulare maius giving constitutional power superior to all other proconsuls. During the second settlement Augustus was also granted the power of tribune for life though not the official title of tribune. This power allowed him to convene the Senate at will veto actions preside over elections and speak first at any meeting.