Nontrinitarianism

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Nontrinitarianism is the name given to a broad family of Christian belief that refuses one of mainstream Christianity's most defining claims: that God is three co-equal, co-eternal persons united in a single essence. The question at the heart of nontrinitarianism is deceptively simple. If the Trinity is the bedrock of Christian faith, why does the word "Trinity" never appear in the Bible? That puzzle has driven centuries of argument, exile, and occasionally execution. Michael Servetus was burned at the stake in Geneva in 1553, condemned by the Geneva City Council in accord with the Swiss cantons of Zurich, Bern, Basel, and Schaffhausen, for arguing that no scripture explicitly taught the doctrine. He was not the last. Edward Wightman was burned at the stake in England in 1612. Thomas Aikenhead was hanged in Britain in 1697, the last person in that country to face execution for blasphemy. Behind each of these deaths lay a single disputed question: what exactly is the relationship between God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit?

• 2. Before Nicaea

  ›

  Justin Martyr, Theophilus of Antioch, Hippolytus of Rome, and Tertullian all grappled with the nature of the Son in the 2nd and 3rd centuries, before any council had ruled on the matter. Their framework, drawn from Greek philosophical thought, held that God's internal divine reason was expressed outward as the Word, a personified being distinct from the Father and used as the instrument of creation. The Encyclopaedia Britannica Eleventh Edition, published in 1910-1911, described the tension plainly: some early Christians found the idea of a Trinity inconsistent with God's unity, and accepted Jesus not as incarnate God but as God's highest creature through whom everything else was made. That position, the encyclopedia noted, "long contended with the orthodox doctrine" in the early church. The philosopher Arius, a presbyter of Alexandria born around 250 AD, made this argument most systematically. He taught that the Son was the very first of God's creations, directly made by the Father before all ages, and that the Father then created the rest of the universe through the Son. The Third Council of Sirmium in 357 marked what historians regard as the high point of Arian influence. A confession issued there, later called the Blasphemy of Sirmium, declared that both "of one substance" and "of similar substance" were unbiblical terms, and that the Father is greater than the Son in all things. Arianism spread beyond theological debate into the political landscape of the Roman Empire, becoming dominant among the Visigoths until 589.

• 3. The Councils and Their Aftermath

  ›

  The First Council of Nicaea in 325 declared the full divinity of the Son. The First Council of Constantinople in 381 extended that declaration to the Holy Spirit. Together, those two councils are considered by churches that regard ecumenical councils as final authority to have settled the question definitively. Yet the settlement was messier than it appeared. Roman Emperor Constantine I, who convened Nicaea, issued an edict against the writings of Arius after the council and ordered systematic book burning. He then reversed course: he ordered Arius readmitted to the church, removed bishops who upheld Nicaea's teaching, including Athanasius, and was himself baptized on his deathbed by the Arian bishop Eusebius of Nicomedia. His successors promoted Arianism until Theodosius I came to the throne in 379 and threw imperial support behind Nicene Christianity. In 367, while the Eastern Empire was still governed by the Arian Emperor Valens, the bishop Athanasius issued an Easter letter from Alexandria specifying precisely which books belonged to the Old and New Testaments. The scholar Elaine Pagels writes that this letter demanded Egyptian monks destroy all writings Athanasius had not explicitly listed as acceptable, and that his approved list constitutes what became the present New Testament. Nontrinitarians have long pointed to this sequence as evidence that the doctrine was shaped by political pressure rather than scriptural clarity. The New Catholic Encyclopedia, for its part, acknowledges that the formulation "one God in three Persons" was not solidly established by any council prior to the end of the 4th century.

• 4. Views on God and Jesus

  ›

  Adoptionism, one of the oldest nontrinitarian positions, holds that Jesus became divine at his baptism or at his resurrection, rather than existing as God from eternity. Modalism, associated with Sabellius around 215 AD, took the opposite approach: God is not three distinct persons at all, but one person who has manifested in three different modes across history as Father in creation, Son in redemption, and Holy Spirit in regeneration. Tertullian, who was himself among the early formulators of proto-Trinitarian thought, coined the term "Patripassianism" for Sabellianism, derived from the Latin words for "father" and "to suffer", because it implied that the Father himself had been crucified. He introduced the term in his work Adversus Praxeas. The irony, noted by historians, is that the term homoousios, meaning "of the same substance", which the Nicene Council would later adopt for its anti-Arian creed, had already been used by the Sabellians. Socinianism, following Photinus, held a different position again: Jesus was the sinless Messiah and the only perfect human son of God, but had no pre-human existence whatsoever. Socinians interpreted the opening of John's Gospel to refer to God's plan, which existed in God's mind before Christ's birth, rather than to a pre-existing divine being. William Barclay, a minister of the Church of Scotland, summarized the scriptural situation: "The word Trinity is not itself a New Testament word. It is even true in at least one sense to say that the doctrine of the Trinity is not directly New Testament doctrine. It is rather a deduction from and an interpretation of the thought and the language of the New Testament."

• 5. Greek Philosophy and the Trinity's Shape

  ›

  Stuart G. Hall, formerly Professor of Ecclesiastical History at King's College London, traced the process by which early Christian apologists drew on Greek culture to argue that it pointed toward and was fulfilled in the Christian message. Hall described this synthesis as most thoroughly accomplished by Clement of Alexandria, and noted several methods: mining Greek literature for references compatible with monotheism, constructing a shared chronology between Greek legend and biblical history, and claiming that Plato and other Greek philosophers had indirectly borrowed their best ideas from Moses. The neo-Platonic trinity, a structure of the One, the Nous, and the Soul, was not a trinity of co-equal consubstantial beings in the Christian sense, but it carried the concept of emanation, an eternal derivation from a single source. Origen and later Athanasius applied this logic to the generation of the Son from the Father, arguing that because the Father is immutable, he always had been a Father, and therefore the generation of the Son is eternal and timeless. Plato himself, in Phaedo, introduced the Greek word for "triad", which Latin renders as "trinity". By the 3rd and 4th centuries, some Christian writers were applying this framework to Father, Word, and Spirit. The Anglican priest Maxwell Staniforth, writing in 1964, also pointed to Stoic influence, quoting Seneca's description of supreme power as sometimes called "God", sometimes "incorporeal Wisdom", sometimes "the holy Spirit", sometimes "Destiny". Staniforth noted that the church had only to drop the last of Seneca's terms to arrive at its own formulation. Trinitarian scholars have pushed back on parts of this argument, noting that some passages attributed to Aristotle in support of a pagan trinity are not found in scholarly translations of his original Greek text.

• 6. Reformation and Renewal

  ›

  By 1530, following the Protestant Reformation and the German Peasants' War of 1524-1525, large sections of Northern Europe had turned Protestant, and nontrinitarian ideas surfaced again among groups the historian labels the Radical Reformation. The first recorded English antitrinitarian was John Assheton in 1548, an Anglican priest. The Italian Anabaptist Council of Venice in 1550 and the trial of Michael Servetus in 1553 marked a visible emergence of organized antitrinitarian Protestantism. The only formally organized nontrinitarian churches at that point were the Polish Brethren, who separated from the Calvinists in 1565 and were expelled from Poland in 1658, and the Unitarian Church of Transylvania, founded in 1568 and still considered the oldest Unitarian organization in the world. In 1733, Voltaire's Letters on the English placed Isaac Newton among the antitrinitarians. Newton, born in 1642, was joined on later lists by figures including John Locke, who died in 1704, and several American presidents: John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, John Quincy Adams, Millard Fillmore, and William Howard Taft. The Doctrine of the Trinity Act 1813 formally permitted nontrinitarian worship in Britain. In the 18th century, a Church of England theologian named Thomas Firmin had already been described as Unitarian in practice, followed in the 19th century by Bishop John Colenso and the scholar G.W.H. Lampe.

• 7. Modern Denominations

  ›

  The largest nontrinitarian groups in contemporary Christianity include the Oneness Pentecostal movement, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Jehovah's Witnesses, La Luz del Mundo, and Iglesia ni Cristo. Jehovah's Witnesses teach that God the Father is uniquely Almighty God and that Jesus is his first and only direct creation, identifying Jesus with Michael the archangel. They regard the Holy Spirit not as a person but as God's active force. The LDS Church, founded by Joseph Smith in 1805, teaches that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are three distinct beings united in will and purpose but not in substance, a position sometimes compared to social trinitarianism. Latter-day Saints hold that both God and the resurrected Christ have perfected physical bodies. Oneness Pentecostalism treats the Trinity as pagan and unscriptural, teaching instead that God is one person who manifests as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in different circumstances; the Son is understood as the Incarnation specifically, not a distinct eternal person. Iglesia ni Cristo, whose name is Tagalog for Church of Christ, views Jesus as human but endowed with qualities beyond ordinary human capacity. It rejects the Trinity explicitly as heresy. The Unitarian Universalist Association in the United States was formed in 1961 from the merger of the American Unitarian Association with the Universalist Church of America; while both predecessor bodies were originally Christian, the UUA does not hold a shared creed and does not identify as a Christian Unitarian organization.

• 8. Heresy, Ecumenism, and Dispute

  ›

  The Catholic Church has formally designated multiple varieties of nontrinitarianism as heresies, including Arianism, Modalism, and Tritheism, and has named Mormonism and Jehovah's Witnesses specifically in that category. Ecumenical dialogue across Christian traditions is typically grounded in a shared acceptance of trinitarian baptism, which by definition excludes nontrinitarian groups from most formal ecumenical structures. The Community of Christ, Mormonism's second-largest denomination, differs from the LDS Church on this point: it follows traditional Protestant trinitarian theology and participates in the National Council of Churches of Christ. Nontrinitarians often invert the heresy charge, arguing that mainstream Christianity itself departed from original teaching in what they describe as a Great Apostasy, a departure Paul foretold. The author H.G. Wells, writing in The Outline of History, put it plainly: "There is no evidence that the apostles of Jesus ever heard of the Trinity, at any rate from him." Montefiore, writing in the Jewish Quarterly Review in 1897, described Unitarianism as a bridge between Judaism and Christianity, calling it simultaneously a "phase of Judaism" and a "phase of Christianity". In Islam, the concept of a co-equal trinity is rejected in the Quran itself, with verses the tradition describes as calling the doctrine blasphemous. Early Islam was seen by the Byzantine emperor in the 600s as a variant of Arianism, and in Spain in the 700s many Arians considered Muhammad a prophet. The scholar William Whiston, who translated the works of Josephus and was expelled from the University of Cambridge in 1710 for holding Arian views, represents one thread of a long tradition in which nontrinitarian conviction carried personal and professional costs that mainstream theology did not.