Germanic paganism

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Germanic paganism shaped the spiritual lives of people across Scandinavia, the British Isles, and modern Germany for at least a thousand years. What did they believe happened after death? Who did they pray to, and in what kinds of places? Why do Thursday and Friday still carry traces of their gods? Those are the questions at the heart of this documentary. The answers are harder to recover than you might expect, because almost no pagan left a written record. What survives comes mostly from outsiders: Roman generals, Christian monks, and Arab travelers who were, each in their own way, trying to understand a world foreign to them. And yet, through bog deposits, runic inscriptions, burial mounds, and the surviving Norse texts, scholars have managed to reconstruct something vivid and surprising about a religion that resisted any single creed, varied from region to region, and outlasted the Roman Empire by centuries.

• 2. The Problem of Sources

  ›

  Gaius Cornelius Tacitus wrote his Germania around the turn of the 2nd century CE, and it remains the single most important written source for Germanic religion in the Roman period. That fact should give listeners pause, because Tacitus had an agenda. One purpose of the work was to hold up the supposedly virtuous Germani as a mirror to what he saw as Rome's moral decline. He also drew on long-standing topoi from Herodotus and others who had written about barbarian peoples, meaning some of what he describes may be literary convention rather than observed reality.

  Julius Caesar, writing somewhat earlier, claimed the Germani worshipped no individual gods at all, only natural phenomena like the sun, moon, and fire. Tacitus contradicts this directly by naming Mercury, Hercules, and Mars as the most venerated gods, though he uses Roman names throughout. Later scholars interpret Mercury as Odin, Hercules as Thor, and Mars as Tyr, but those identifications are educated guesses.

  For the post-Roman period, Christian authors become the primary narrators. Gregory of Tours wrote about the Franks in the late 6th century. Bede produced his Ecclesiastical History of the English People around 731 CE. The Prose Edda, attributed to the Icelander Snorri Sturluson, dates to the 13th century and is by far the richest source for Norse mythology, but it was composed centuries after Christianity had transformed Scandinavia. Scholars debate how much Snorri imposed a Christian, systematized worldview onto material that was originally far more fragmentary and contradictory.

  The Arab traveler Ahmad ibn Fadlan, writing in the 10th century about the Rus', provides one of the few eyewitness accounts of a ship burial. His report gives details no Norse source bothers to record, precisely because he was encountering these practices for the first time. Standing alongside that account are the poems of the Poetic Edda, runic inscriptions, bracteates, and the physical remains of sacrificial bogs, each speaking a different language and requiring a different kind of translation.

• 3. A World of Gods and Beings

  ›

  The four gods most securely attested across the Germanic world from the early Middle Ages onward are Tiwaz (Tyr), Thunraz (Thor), Wodanaz (Odin), and Frijjo (Frigg). Their names survive in the days of the week. Dies Martis became Tuesday, after Tyr; dies Jovis became Thursday, after Thor; dies Mercurii became Wednesday, after Odin; dies Veneris became Friday, after Frigg. Scholars date this translation to roughly the 3rd or 4th century CE, making it one of the earliest traceable acts of Germanic religious self-definition.

  Tyr is probably the oldest of the four. His name is etymologically related to the Vedic Dyaus and the Greek Zeus, pointing to an origin in the reconstructed Indo-European sky deity *Dyeus. A possible attestation appears as early as 450-350 BCE on the Negau helmet. By the Viking Age, though, his importance had faded considerably, and he plays a major role in only one surviving myth: the binding of the monstrous wolf Fenrir, during which Tyr loses his hand.

  Thor, by contrast, was the most widely known and probably the most widely worshipped god in Viking Age Scandinavia. His name means thunder. The Oak of Jupiter reportedly felled by Saint Boniface among the Chatti in 723 CE is generally presumed to have been dedicated to Thor. The most common archaeological evidence for his cult takes the form of small hammer pendants found in Viking Age contexts. Textual sources such as Adam of Bremen and the association with Jupiter in the interpretatio Germanica both suggest he may have been considered the head of the pantheon in at least some times and places.

  Odin is more complex and harder to pin down. He is connected to arcane knowledge, the dead, and magic, which may explain the interpretatio Romana equation with Mercury. The earliest clear reference to Odin by name comes from a C-bracteate discovered in Denmark in 2020, dated to as early as the 400s CE, with a Proto-Norse Elder Futhark inscription reading 'He is Odin's man'. In Germany, he appears in the Second Merseburg Charm, healing a horse belonging to Balder. In England, he appears as a healing magician in the Nine Herbs Charm and as an ancestor in Anglo-Saxon royal genealogies.

  Frigg, Odin's wife, is the only major Norse goddess also clearly attested before the Viking period. The Merseburg Charms show her exercising magical abilities. She plays a central role in the stories of how the Lombards got their name, tricking Odin into granting them victory.

  Beyond these four, the Germanic world was populated by beings of every scale. Giants, known in Old Norse as jötnar, were just as important as the gods in myths about creation and the end of the world. Their name may derive from a verb meaning to eat, possibly referencing cannibalism as a trait. Elves and dwarfs belonged to what scholars call lower mythology. Snorri divided elves into light and dark varieties, but this division appears nowhere else. In Anglo-Saxon England, elves were understood as potentially dangerous beings associated with woods, fields, hills, and water; dwarfs were connected there with madness, fever, and dementia rather than mountains and smithcraft. Dragons, meanwhile, were probably originally imagined as large, snake-like, poison-spitting creatures that lived underground; the idea of flying dragons is thought to have entered from Greco-Roman culture.

• 4. Creation, Cosmos, and Fate

  ›

  Gylfaginning, a section of Snorri Sturluson's Prose Edda, provides the only comprehensive Old Norse origin myth that survives. In it, the first being is the giant Ymir, who is followed by the cow Auðumbla. Eventually Odin and his two brothers are born, kill Ymir, and make the world from his body. The first man and woman, Ask and Embla, are made from trees. Some scholars suspect that Snorri compiled this narrative from contradictory sources, smoothing over gaps and inconsistencies.

  Tacitus offers a different kind of creation story from the Roman period. In chapter 2 of Germania, he records that the Germanic tribes traced their descent from the gods Tuisto, who was born from the earth, and his son Mannus, whose offspring divided into three or five Germanic subgroups. Tuisto's name appears to mean 'twin' or 'double-being', suggesting a hermaphroditic figure. Scholars have noted that both Tuisto and Ymir have names with similar meanings and that both myths include a genealogy of grandfather, father, and then three sons, pointing to possible continuity between them.

  The cosmology that filled the space between creation and destruction placed the inhabited world, Midgard or 'dwelling place in the middle', at the center. The term is first attested in Gothic in Wulfila's translation of the Bible around 370 CE, with cognates across Old English, Old High German, and Saxon. The world tree Yggdrasill stood at the center of all things, propping up the heavens, with the realm of the giants beyond Midgard and the underground realm of Hel below. A world-surrounding serpent or dragon, Jörmungandr, encircled the inhabited world; allusions to this creature from southern Germany and England suggest the concept was not exclusively Scandinavian.

  At the end of all this stood Ragnarök, a war between the gods and the forces of chaos ending in fire and the destruction of almost all gods, giants, and living things, followed by a rebirth of the world. An Old High German word, Muspilli, probably meaning 'world conflagration', suggests that some version of the end-of-the-world myth existed in southern Germany as well, though scholars debate how much Christian eschatology shaped the surviving accounts.

  Fate was woven through everything. Old English, Old High German, and Old Saxon all attest a word for fate, wyrd, referring to an inescapable, impersonal force. Norse texts describe fate as created by the Norns, supernatural female beings who appear at birth and are somehow involved in deaths. The disir and valkyries were also bound up with fate. Christian authors like Bede, writing around 700, and Thietmar of Merseburg, writing around 1000, both described Germanic peoples as strongly fatalistic, but scholars since 1969 have noted that this characterization may reflect Christian interpretations of fortuna fatalis more than actual Germanic belief.

• 5. Sacred Places and Ritual Practice

  ›

  Caesar and Tacitus both claimed the Germani had no temples and worshipped only in sacred groves. Archaeology has shown this to be wrong, or at least incomplete. At Uppåkra in modern Sweden, archaeologists have identified an early Scandinavian temple: a very large hall with two entrances that was rebuilt on exactly the same site seven times between 200 and 950 CE. Architecturally it resembles later stave churches. The site was surrounded by animal bones and a few human bones.

  Adam of Bremen, writing in the 11th century, described the Temple of Uppsala as containing idols of Borr, Thor, Odin, and Frey, with a large tree and a well nearby where sacrifices were made. Archaeology has confirmed that Uppsala became an important cult center around 500 CE, with a main royal hall dating from 600 to 800 CE featuring large doors with iron spirals. Four large grave mounds stood southwest of the main hall, and ritual roads lined with large wooden posts and rows of fireplaces indicate that processions and ceremonies took place both inside and around the site. Animal remains found there suggest the sacrificial deposits were made in March, which aligns with written sources on the Dísablót festival.

  Bogs served as an equally important kind of sacred space. Roughly carved wooden male and female figures, generally following the natural form of a branch, have been found throughout northern Europe and may depict gods, though whether they were the objects of sacrifice or the recipients is unclear. Rich sacrificial deposits, including objects, animals, and human remains, have been recovered from bogs, springs, and under the foundations of new structures. About 160 lots used for divination have been found in Roman-era and migration-period sites as of 2002.

  Tacitus provides the most detailed description of lot casting in Germania chapter 10: the Germani cut lots from fruit-bearing wood, marked them with signs, scattered them on a white sheet, and drew three at a time, either by the head of the family or a priest. The signs have sometimes been interpreted as runes, but most scholars believe they were simpler marks. Horse divination was another practice Tacitus reports: the Germani read the future in a horse's whinnying. Bird interpretation was more widespread and better corroborated. The seeress prophesying from a raised platform is mentioned both by Tacitus and by the Saga of Erik the Red, separated by roughly a thousand years, with the later source adding the detail of a wand.

  Festivals punctuated the year. Tacitus mentions an autumn sacrifice to the goddess Tamfana. Bede records the festival of Mōdraniht in early February. Adam of Bremen describes a Swedish sacrificial feast held every nine years at Uppsala. Thietmar of Merseburg mentions a similar festival each January at Lejre in Zealand. Yule around Christmas is the only festival with anything approaching universal Germanic attestation.

• 6. Burial and the Afterlife

  ›

  Germanic beliefs about the afterlife were not uniform. Sources describe a range of destinations for the dead: an underworld, continued existence in the grave, a world of the dead in the sky, and reincarnation. Hel, described as cold, dark, and located in the north, functioned as a general abode of the dead. Its connection to the West Germanic verb helan, meaning to hide, suggests it may originally have referred to the grave itself. It was not conceived of as a place of punishment until the high Middle Ages.

  Valhalla was reserved for the illustrious dead, a hall in Asgard where chosen warriors feasted and fought in Odin's company. Old Norse sources also frequently describe the dead as living on in their graves, sometimes returning as revenants. Elder Futhark inscriptions on grave-marking stones appear intended to prevent exactly this. The concept of the Wild Hunt, attested from the 11th century onward, is found across the Germanic-speaking world and is bound up with the dead moving through the landscape.

  Burial customs shifted dramatically over the thousand-year span covered by Germanic paganism. Cremation was the dominant practice until the first century BCE, when inhumation burials began appearing. By the Merovingian period, most male burials on the continent included weapons. Some graves also contained horses, possibly meant as conveyances to the next life; dogs appear across a wide area through the migration period and may have been intended to protect the deceased or prevent revenants.

  Ship burial represents one of the most striking practices. The earliest example comes from Jutland in the late Roman Imperial period. Another early burial, outside Scandinavia, was found near Wremen on the Weser river in northern Germany, dating to the 4th or 5th century CE. Ahmad ibn Fadlan's 10th-century account of a Rus' ship burial describes the deceased being cremated in the ship before a mound was raised over it, giving a level of detail that no Norse text provides. The Reihengräber tradition, beginning in the 400s CE among continental Germanic peoples, saw graves arranged in rows packed with gold, jewelry, and luxury goods, with only a few hundred individuals per cemetery.

  At the elite end, chamber graves in 9th and 10th-century Scandinavia sometimes buried the deceased seated, with objects placed in the hands or on the lap. The bracteates and gold foil figures deposited in graves often depict what appear to be divine figures, originally based on Roman gold medallions from the era of Constantine the Great but highly stylized by the time they entered Germanic use.

• 7. Outside Influence and Long Continuity

  ›

  Celtic and Germanic peoples were in close contact during the first millennium BCE, and the fingerprints of that contact appear in religious vocabulary. The name of the deity Thunraz (Thor) is identical to the Celtic Toranos (Taranis). The Germanic name for runes derives from the Celtic runa, meaning secret or magic. The word for sacred groves, nemetaz, matches the Celtic nemeton. The Roman-era Rhineland goddesses known as matronae display both Celtic and Germanic names, and during the Viking Age there is evidence for continued Irish mythological influence on Norse religion.

  The process of Interpretatio Romana moved in both directions. Germanic gods were given Roman names and worshipped at Roman-style altars in contact zones. Later, Roman gods received Germanic names, most durably in the days of the week. In time, various aspects of Roman worship and iconography were adopted, including bronze and silver statues of Roman gods found throughout the Germanic world; Heiko Steuer argues that these were likely reinterpreted as local gods and used on home altars. A find from Odense dating to roughly 100-300 CE includes statues of Mercury, Mars, Jupiter, and Apollo together.

  Christianization was a long, uneven process. Gold bracteates show evidence of Christian symbolism being appropriated and reinterpreted. The Christianization of the Franks, Lombards, Saxons, and Anglo-Saxons all proceeded differently, and Christian sources from these periods document the co-existence and sometimes blending of pagan and Christian practice. The Lex Frisionum, the post-conversion Frisian Law, still included punishments for those who broke into or desecrated temples, suggesting pagan sites remained active long after official conversion.

  Whether any of this survived into modern times is a question scholars approach with considerable caution. Jacob Grimm argued in the 19th century that modern folklore preserved ancient Germanic religion essentially intact. That idea later became entangled with völkisch ideology and Otto Höfler's Germanic continuity theory, which stressed an organic national spirit expressed in folk practice. After World War II, especially in Germany, the use of folklore as a direct source for ancient religion fell sharply out of fashion. Since the 1990s, Nordic scholarship has revived cautious engagement with folkloric material, focusing on areas where continuity is most defensible: agrarian rites, magical ideas, and the root elements of certain folktales. The Anglo-Saxon festival of modranicht, mentioned by Bede and possibly connected to the matronae, is one thread scholars continue to follow.