Christian Church

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Christian Church is not one thing. It never has been. From its earliest days in Roman Judea in the first century AD, it has been a subject of argument, definition, and redefinition. Who belongs? What makes a church real? Which institution can claim to be the original? These questions have split communities, driven reformations, and shaped empires. And they remain unanswered, in the sense that no single answer commands universal agreement. What we do have is a remarkable tangle of competing claims, each backed by centuries of theology, councils, confessions, and history. The word at the center of it all began as a simple Greek term for an assembly. How it became one of the most contested concepts in human civilization is a story worth telling.

• 2. The Word Itself

  ›

  The Ancient Greek word ἐκκλησία, pronounced ekklesia, literally meant something like "called out" or "called forth." In the ordinary Greek world, it referred to an assembly of citizens gathered to conduct civic business. Only those with full citizenship could participate. Greek-speaking Jews had already repurposed the word before Christianity existed. In the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew scriptures, ἐκκλησία rendered the Hebrew word קהל, meaning "qahal," the gathered people of God.

  When early Christians adopted the word, they were drawing on both of those traditions at once. They were a community set apart, like the Greek city assembly, but also the new Israel, like the qahal. The tension between those two inheritances never fully resolved. The word ἐκκλησία appears 114 times in the New Testament, though not every instance is a technical reference to the church as an institution. It shows up across the Gospels, the Acts of the Apostles, the letters attributed to Paul, and the Book of Revelation, shifting in meaning depending on context.

  The English word "church" traveled a different route entirely. It comes from the Old English "cirice," itself derived from West Germanic "kirika," which came from the Greek "kuriake," meaning "of the Lord." That Greek root, "kurios," meant ruler or lord. So English speakers ended up with a word rooted in ownership and lordship, while most Romance and Celtic languages kept a form of "ecclesia." Even the Slavic words for church, including the Russian "cerkov" and Bulgarian "carkva," trace back through Old High German. Christianity carried its vocabulary across the continent, each language borrowing and reshaping.

• 3. Birth and Expansion

  ›

  Roman Judea in the first century was the starting point. Jesus of Nazareth gathered disciples, and those disciples, after his death and what they understood as his resurrection and ascension, became the nucleus of a new community. For most Christians, the holiday of Pentecost marks the church's birthday. The event, described as the descent of the Holy Spirit on gathered disciples after the ascension, gave the early community its defining sense of purpose.

  From the start, a critical decision shaped the church's future: non-Jews, called Gentiles, were welcomed without requiring full adoption of Jewish customs such as circumcision. The church was springing out of Second Temple Judaism but deliberately choosing a wider path. Some scholars think early conflict with Jewish religious authorities led to the expulsion of Christians from synagogues in Jerusalem, forcing the community to define itself separately.

  The church spread through the cities of the Roman Empire. Jerusalem, Antioch, and Edessa became major centers. Roman authorities treated the new religion with suspicion, partly because Christians refused to sacrifice to the Roman gods and challenged the imperial cult. Persecution followed. Then, in the 4th century, the situation reversed entirely. Emperor Constantine I moved toward legitimizing Christianity, and his successor Theodosius I went further. On the 27th of February 380, the Roman Empire officially adopted the Nicene version of Christianity as its state religion. It was a transformation that would reshape the church's relationship to power for centuries.

  Ignatius of Antioch, writing in around 100 AD, left what is considered the earliest recorded use of the term "Christianity" itself. A few years later, around 107, he also wrote the first recorded application of the word "catholic," meaning universal, to the church, in his Epistle to the Smyrnaeans.

• 4. State Religion and Its Costs

  ›

  Theodosius I's decree on the 27th of February 380 did more than recognize Christianity. It defined which Christianity was legitimate. Only followers of Trinitarian Christianity, as laid out in the Nicene Creed from the First Council of Nicaea, were entitled to be called Catholic Christians. Everyone else was classified as a heretic, and heresy was now illegal. The consequences arrived quickly. In 385, Priscillian became the first heretic in recorded history to be executed under this new legal order, condemned to death along with several followers by a civil tribunal for the crime of magic.

  The church within the Roman Empire organized itself under metropolitan sees. Five of these rose to particular prominence, forming the basis for what Emperor Justinian I later proposed as the Pentarchy: Rome in the West, and Constantinople, Jerusalem, Antioch, and Alexandria in the East. When the Western Roman Empire fell to Germanic incursions in the 5th century, the church in the West became for several centuries the primary surviving link to Roman civilization. It was an unexpected consequence of collapse: the institution outlasted the empire that had adopted it.

  Starting in the 7th century, the Islamic Caliphates expanded across territories that had once been Christian heartlands. North Africa and most of Spain were absorbed. Northern and western Europe largely escaped, partly because Constantinople, still wealthy and powerful, drew the primary force of that expansion. Even in the Muslim world, Christian communities survived, including the groups that became the modern Copts and Maronites, though often under significant pressure.

• 5. The Great Schism

  ›

  The break that divided the Christian world into Eastern and Western halves did not happen overnight. Frictions between Rome and the eastern patriarchs had been building for a long time. A turning point came when Rome shifted its political allegiance away from Constantinople toward the Frankish king Charlemagne. The theological and political distance widened until, in the 11th century, Rome and the East excommunicated each other. That rupture is known as the Great Schism of 1054.

  In 1448, not long before the Byzantine Empire itself collapsed, the Russian Orthodox Church gained independence from the Patriarch of Constantinople. Then in 1453, Constantinople fell. Eastern scholars fled to the West carrying ancient manuscripts, and historians have pointed to this event as one factor in the beginning of the Western Renaissance. Some Eastern churches, faced with the collapse of the Byzantine world, chose to enter into communion with Rome. These became known as the "Uniate" Eastern Catholic Churches.

  The Reformed tradition would later describe the church as both invisible and visible. John Calvin called the visible church "our mother," the institution God provides for saving and sustaining activity. The Reformed confessions of faith identified two marks of the true visible church: pure teaching of the gospel and the right administration of the sacraments. These categories were themselves products of the fractures that had been accumulating since the 11th century and would intensify further in the 16th.

• 6. Reformation and Multiplicity

  ›

  The Protestant Reformation brought an entirely new set of claims about what the true church looked like. Lutheran followers, Reformed followers of Calvin, Hus, Zwingli, Melancthon, Knox, and others each broke from the Catholic Church while insisting they were recovering something the church had lost. The Lutherans, when they presented the Augsburg Confession to Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor, in 1530, argued they were not proposing anything new. They believed they had shown that their faith was consistent first with scripture and then with the church fathers and the councils.

  At the same time, a separate dispute in England, partly non-theological in origin, led to the English Reformation and the independence of the Church of England. Anglicans came to understand their tradition as a via media, a middle way, often positioned between Lutheranism and Reformed Christianity, or between Roman Catholicism and Reformed Christianity.

  Methodism emerged later with its own self-understanding. John Wesley, the founder of the movement, held that what God had achieved through Methodism was no mere human endeavor. He taught that the propagation of entire sanctification was the specific reason God had raised up the Methodists, calling it "the grand depositum" of the Methodist faith.

  Baptists developed yet another position. Many who upheld the doctrine known as Landmarkism, or Baptist successionism, argued that only Baptist churches could trace their lineage in uninterrupted fashion back to the New Testament. Walter B. Shurden, the founding executive director of the Center for Baptist Studies at Mercer University, identified this theology as integral to the history of the Southern Baptist Convention. In this view, ordinances like baptism and the Lord's Supper, when practiced by non-Baptists, are simply invalid.

• 7. Competing Claims of Legitimacy

  ›

  The Catholic Church teaches that it is the original institution founded by Christ on the Apostles in the 1st century AD. The encyclical of Pope Pius IX, Singulari Quidem, states: "There is only one true, holy, Catholic Church, which is the Apostolic Roman Church. There is only one See founded on Peter by the word of the Lord … Outside of the Church, no one can hope for life or salvation unless he is excused through ignorance beyond his control." The Second Vatican Council's dogmatic constitution Lumen gentium, issued in 1964, declared that the one Church of Christ "subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the Bishops in communion with him."

  A 2007 declaration of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith clarified that "subsistence" in this context means the perduring historical continuity of all elements instituted by Christ, found concretely in the Catholic Church on this earth. The declaration also acknowledged that grace can be operative in separated communities through "elements of sanctification and truth" within them, while maintaining that the word "subsists" can only be attributed to the Catholic Church alone.

  The Eastern Orthodox Church bases its competing claim on its assertion that it holds to traditions and beliefs of the original Christian Church. It also points out that four of the five sees of the Pentarchy, all except Rome, remain part of it. The Oriental Orthodox Churches make a parallel claim, adding that they never adopted the theory of the nature of God formulated after the Council of Chalcedon. Lutheran churches take a different approach: they acknowledge true Christians in other churches and accept the word "Church" for other denominations, since the proclamation of the Word of God bears fruit wherever it is genuinely proclaimed. The Four Marks of the Church, first expressed in the Nicene Creed in 381, remain the shared reference point: one, holy, catholic, and apostolic. Each tradition interprets those four words differently.

• 8. World Christianity

  ›

  A number of historians have noted a twentieth-century shift in where Christianity lives. What had been concentrated largely in Europe and the Americas moved steadily toward what researchers call the global south, encompassing Asia, Africa, and Latin America. The term "World Christianity" or "Global Christianity" was coined to capture this shift, though scholars have noted that the term often emphasizes the non-Western instances of the faith, the "exotic" expressions in the global south, while also encompassing indigenous and diasporic forms in Western Europe and North America.

  This demographic transformation did not resolve the old ecclesiological arguments. It extended them into new contexts. Communities in Nigeria, South Korea, Brazil, and elsewhere brought their own interpretive traditions to the question of what makes a church genuine. The spread of Christianity to these regions was itself a product of the earlier divisions. During the Age of Exploration and the Age of Imperialism, Western Europe carried both the Catholic Church and the Protestant churches outward, especially into the Americas. Those two competing streams followed colonialism around the world and then, in many places, grew beyond the control or expectation of their European originators. The Christian Church, still contested, still plural, became the largest religion in the world as a result of that expansion.