Sacrament

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  A sacrament, at its most stripped-back, is a Christian rite that has been judged to be particularly important and significant. Yet that tidy definition conceals a dispute running across nearly two thousand years of Christian life. How many such rites exist? Who gets to decide? And what exactly do they accomplish? Those questions have divided churches, shaped council decrees, and in at least one famous case sent the matter to a secular court.

  At stake is something fundamental: whether certain physical acts, water poured over a head, bread broken at a table, oil applied to a sick person, are merely reminders of spiritual truths or whether they actually deliver grace. Augustine of Hippo, the fifth-century bishop whose definition many denominations still cite, called a sacrament an outward sign of an inward grace, instituted by Jesus Christ. That formulation is shared by Catholics, Lutherans, Anglicans, Methodists, Moravians, and Baptists, among others. But the agreement ends there. The Catholic Church counts seven sacraments. Most Protestant denominations count two. Some communities observe none at all. The Assyrian Church of the East recognises the Holy Leaven and the sign of the cross as sacraments that no other tradition includes on its list. What follows is an account of how those differences arose and what they mean.

• 2. The Word Itself

  ›

  Tertullian, a third-century Christian writer, is the earliest known figure to link the Latin term sacramentum to Christian practice. In Ancient Rome the word meant a soldier's oath of allegiance. Tertullian observed that just as a soldier's oath marked the beginning of a new life of service, so initiation into the Christian community through baptism and the Eucharist marked a comparable threshold.

  The English word traces back through Ecclesiastical Latin sacramentum to the Latin sacrare, itself derived from sacer, meaning sacred or set apart. That etymological chain matters because it points to the underlying logic: a sacrament is not merely a ritual but something set apart from ordinary experience. Theologian Edward Schillebeeckx extended the term well beyond ritual, titling one of his books Christ, the Sacrament of the Encounter with God, treating Christ himself as the primordial sign. The Second Vatican Council followed similar logic when it described the whole Church as a sacrament. Pope Francis has described Jesus's love for humankind as itself a sacrament, writing that "his human emotions became the sacrament of that infinite and endless love". The word, in other words, has always been elastic, capable of describing a ritual, a person, or an institution.

• 3. Seven, Two, or None

  ›

  The Second Council of Lyon in 1274 was among the first major gatherings to formally specify seven sacraments for the Catholic Church. The Council of Florence in 1439 restated the list, and the Council of Trent, meeting between 1545 and 1563, went further, issuing a canon declaring that anyone who maintained there were more or fewer than seven sacraments should be anathema.

  That list comprises Baptism, Confirmation, the Eucharist, Penance, Extreme Unction, Holy Orders, and Matrimony. The Catholic Church later grouped them by function: the first three are Sacraments of Initiation, the next two are Healing Sacraments, and the final pair are Sacraments of Vocation. This structure gives the seven an internal coherence, covering the full arc of a Christian life from entry to vocation to final illness.

  John Calvin held an entirely different view. He accepted only baptism and the Lord's Supper as valid under the new covenant, and he rejected the Catholic doctrine of transubstantiation outright. The Westminster Confession of Faith, which codified the Reformed position, calls sacraments "signs and seals of the covenant of grace" and insists that Christ's presence in the Lord's Supper is real but spiritual, not bodily. The Lutheran tradition, by contrast, landed between those poles. Philip Melanchthon's Apology of the Augsburg Confession defined sacraments as rites with God's command and an attached divine promise of grace, a formulation that yielded three: Holy Baptism, the Eucharist, and Holy Absolution. Martin Luther himself, writing in the Large Catechism, named two sacraments but described Confession and Absolution as a third.

  At the far end of the spectrum sit communities that observe no sacraments at all. The Salvation Army does not practice formal sacraments, believing it is better to concentrate on the reality behind the symbols, though it does not forbid members from receiving sacraments elsewhere. The Quakers, formally the Religious Society of Friends, hold that all of life has the potential to be a means of God's grace; some Quakers use the words "Baptism" and "Communion" to describe the experience of Christ's presence in worship without performing any outward rite. The sixteenth-century Anabaptist group known as the Clancularii reasoned that because religion was seated in the heart, there was no need of outward expression through sacraments at all.

• 4. Ex Opere Operato

  ›

  One of the sharpest theological dividing lines concerns what actually makes a sacrament effective. The Catholic Church teaches that sacraments work ex opere operato, a Latin phrase meaning by the very fact of the act being performed. The personal holiness or wickedness of the minister administering the sacrament does not determine its validity. A sacrament performed by a corrupt priest is still a sacrament.

  Anglican theology echoes this in Article XXVI of the Thirty-Nine Articles, which states that the effect of Christ's ordinance is not taken away by the wickedness of the minister, since the sacraments have their effect "because of Christ's intention and promise, although they be ministered by evil men". But Anglican theology also insists on the worthiness of the recipient. Article XXV states that sacraments have a "wholesome effect and operation" only in those who receive them worthily, and that those who receive them unworthily "purchase for themselves damnation".

  This tension between objective validity and subjective disposition came to a head in the nineteenth century in the Gorham Case. The dispute centred on Baptismal Regeneration, the question of whether baptism itself produces spiritual rebirth. The Church of England decided in favour of Baptismal Regeneration, but a secular court overruled that decision. The episode illustrated how entangled questions of sacramental theology could become with civil authority. The Lutheran position adds yet another dimension: the sacraments are a Means of Grace that, together with the Word of God, empower the Church for its mission, suggesting that the sacraments are active instruments rather than merely valid rites.

• 5. Sacred Mysteries

  ›

  The Eastern Orthodox tradition approaches the counting problem differently. Rather than fixing a number, Orthodoxy holds that anything the Church does as Church is in some sense sacramental. Seven rites are nonetheless recognised as the major sacraments, with the Eucharist, also called the Synaxis, treated as the most profound of all. Orthodox thought does not claim to explain how the consecrated bread and wine become the body and blood of Christ; it accepts this as a mystery not fully penetrable by human reason.

  The preferred Orthodox term is not "sacrament" but "Sacred Mystery", reflecting the Greek word mysterion. Lists drawn from the Church Fathers include not only the seven principal rites but also the consecration of a church, monastic tonsure, and the burial of the dead. Oriental Orthodoxy, including the Coptic Orthodox Church, the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church, and the Armenian Orthodox Church, accepts the same seven major sacraments. The Eastern Catholic Churches maintain both the Eastern terminology of sacred mysteries and the Western listing of seven.

  The Latter-day Saint tradition offers yet another angle. Members more commonly use the word "ordinance" rather than "sacrament", but the underlying theology is explicitly sacramental: ordinances are understood to confer an invisible grace of a saving nature and are required for salvation and exaltation. The sacrament of the Lord's Supper is administered every Sunday as part of the sacrament meeting. Since the late 1800s, water has been substituted for wine in that rite. The Community of Christ, a separate branch of the Latter-day Saint movement, recognises eight sacraments, adding the Evangelist Blessing to the list.

• 6. Ordinance and Objection

  ›

  Several Protestant and post-Reformation communities deliberately avoid the word "sacrament" in favour of "ordinance". Plymouth Brethren and Pentecostals are among them. Their argument is that the word "ordinance" points to the ordaining authority of Christ, which lies behind the practice, rather than implying any priestly mediation.

  The Irvingian denominations, such as the New Apostolic Church, teach three sacraments: Baptism, Holy Communion, and Holy Sealing, the last of which corresponds to what other traditions call Confirmation or Chrismation. The Assyrian Church of the East takes an even more distinctive position, counting the Holy Leaven and the sign of the cross among its sacraments. Foot washing has been treated as a sacrament by Anabaptist groups, Schwarzenau Brethren groups, and the True Jesus Church. The Polish National Catholic Church of America has counted the hearing of the Gospel itself as a sacrament.

  The Baptist tradition has used both "sacrament" and "ordinance" for its two rites, Baptism and the Lord's Supper, without settling firmly on one term. Some denominations avoid sacerdotal language entirely because they do not regard clergy as having a priestly function. In those communities, the efficacy of the rite depends on the obedience and participation of the believer rather than on the authority of a minister, a position rooted in a developed theology of the priesthood of all believers. That view effectively transfers the sacramental role from an ordained minister to the individual worshipper.