Theosophy

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Theosophy emerged from a single meeting in New York City on the 7th of September 1875, when a Russian emigre named Helena Blavatsky sat down with an American civil war veteran and a young lawyer and agreed to found a new organization. At that meeting, a man named Charles Sotheran proposed the name Theosophical Society, and it stuck. What followed was one of the most consequential new religious movements of the modern era, one that would carry Asian spiritual ideas into Western living rooms, inspire the pioneers of abstract art, shape the Indian independence movement, and seed dozens of later esoteric traditions. The questions that Theosophy raised are still live ones: Is there a hidden brotherhood of supernatural adepts guiding human evolution? Was there once a universal ancient religion that all faiths dimly remember? And what exactly do reincarnation and karma have to do with the suffering of the world?

• 2. The Masters

  ›

  At the center of Theosophy stands a claim that is either its most compelling feature or its most vulnerable one. Blavatsky insisted that a brotherhood of men, whom she called the Masters or Mahatmas, had cultivated extraordinary moral and intellectual development over many lifetimes and now possessed supernatural powers, including clairvoyance and the ability to project the soul instantly to any location. By the late 19th century, she said their chief residence was in Tibet. She also said they were the actual source of many of her published writings. The most prominent of these figures in Theosophical literature are Koot Hoomi and Morya, and in 1884 a painter named Hermann Schmiechen produced portraits of them that, according to scholar Massimo Introvigne, gained what he called a "semi-canonical status" in the community. Among those whom early Theosophists counted as Masters were biblical figures such as Abraham, Moses, Solomon, and Jesus, alongside Asian religious figures including Gautama Buddha, Confucius, and Laozi, as well as more recent individuals such as Alessandro Cagliostro and Franz Mesmer. The idea of a brotherhood of secret adepts was not new; it had roots in Rosicrucian thought and had been popularized in the fiction of Edward Bulwer-Lytton. Scholar Bruce F. Campbell observed that for outsiders, hypotheses about the Masters are among the weakest claims the movement makes, because they can be examined and potentially refuted. Tensions over the Masters would eventually fracture the Society itself, when William Quan Judge was accused of forging messages from them.

• 3. The Ancient Wisdom

  ›

  Blavatsky's teaching rested on the conviction that every major world religion draws from a single, forgotten source, a "secret doctrine" she said was known to Plato and to early Hindu sages. Ancient societies, she argued, had achieved a unity of science and religion that humanity has since lost, and a secret brotherhood had conserved that wisdom across the centuries. Theosophy presented an emanationist cosmology in which the universe is understood as an outward reflection of a single divine Absolute; the world as humans perceive it is illusory, or maya, a concept drawn from Asian religion. Blavatsky laid this out in her two major books, Isis Unveiled and The Secret Doctrine, which became the foundational texts of the movement. In The Secret Doctrine she described seven "Root Races", each subdivided into seven "Sub-Races". The first was formed from pure spirit; the fourth lived on the continent of Atlantis and possessed both psychic powers and advanced technology; some Atlanteans, she claimed, even built Stonehenge. The fifth Root Race, the Aryans, was the current one. Western scholars of Asian religion pushed back hard. Max Muller, among others, believed that Blavatsky was misrepresenting both Buddhism and Hinduism. Sociologist Christopher Partridge captured the tension precisely: he observed that "Theosophy is fundamentally Western. That is to say, Theosophy is not Eastern thought in the West, but Western thought with an Eastern flavour."

• 4. Reincarnation and Karma

  ›

  Theosophy presented a detailed and internally consistent account of what happens after death, and it shifted significantly between Blavatsky's earlier and later writings. In Isis Unveiled, published in the 1870s, she taught a doctrine called metempsychosis, in which the soul progresses through more spiritual planes at the moment of death. Around 1882 she replaced this with a doctrine of reincarnation that became central to Theosophical teaching. In The Secret Doctrine she stated that the spirit repeatedly incarnates into a new, mortal soul and body on Earth, always into a human form and never into another life form. After the physical body dies, she taught, the astral body survives for a time in a state she compared to limbo, called kama-loka, before also perishing. The soul then moves into a mental body in a realm called devachan, which she likened to paradise. Blavatsky taught that the soul remained in devachan for 1,000 to 1,500 years, though her colleague Charles Webster Leadbeater later shortened that figure to 200. Karma, she said, was "inextricably interwoven" with reincarnation, regulating the cycle so that actions in one life determine the circumstances of the next. She also believed that karma itself had a history: it came into being when humans first developed egos, and would one day no longer be required. Besant and Leadbeater went further, claiming they could read past lives through what they called the akashic record, an etheric store of all the universe's knowledge.

• 5. Founding and Fracture

  ›

  New York City in 1875 was an unlikely birthplace for a global spiritual movement, but the American religious landscape was fertile ground. Established Christianity was under pressure from rapid industrialization, mass immigration, and the spread of evolutionary theory. New movements such as Christian Science, New Thought, and Spiritualism were already attracting followers. Blavatsky and Henry Steel Olcott had met through Spiritualism, and they brought that restless religious energy into the new Society. By the early 1880s, Blavatsky and Olcott relocated to India, establishing the Society's headquarters at Adyar in Tamil Nadu. By 1895, there were 102 American branches with nearly 6,000 members. Blavatsky died in 1891, and the succession question exploded almost immediately. Three candidates, Olcott, Judge, and Annie Besant, met in London to negotiate. Judge claimed the Masters were sending him messages; Olcott suspected those messages were forged. Judge, in turn, told Besant that the Masters had revealed a plot by Olcott to kill her. A two-stage internal enquiry concluded that because the Society held no official position on whether the Masters existed, Judge could not technically be found guilty of forgery. The details of the trial were leaked to the journalist F. Edmund Garrett, who turned them into a critical book titled Isis Very Much Unveiled. In April 1895 the American section voted to secede. Judge remained its leader but died within a year, and control passed to Katherine Tingley, who in 1897 established a Theosophical community called Lomaland at Point Loma in San Diego.

• 6. Besant's Era

  ›

  Annie Besant had been nominated by Olcott before his death in 1907, and she was elected with a large majority in June of that year. In her first years leading the Society, she raised membership by 50%, bringing it to 23,000, and expanded the Adyar property from 27 to 253 acres. Besant was not simply an organizational administrator. She promoted women's rights in India through the Women's Indian Association, helped establish the Central Hindu College and a Hindu girls' school, and founded a group called the Home Rule League to campaign for Indian self-governance. She established the New India newspaper to further that cause. During the First World War, her continued advocacy in the paper's pages led to her internment for several months. That imprisonment raised her standing within the independence movement, and at the age of 70 she was appointed President of the Indian National Congress. Her partner in much of this was Charles Webster Leadbeater, whose readmission to the Society in December 1908 triggered a wave of resignations and the secession of the Sydney branch. It was Leadbeater who, in 1909, encountered a young boy named Jiddu Krishnamurti on a beach at Adyar and pronounced him the next World Teacher. Besant and Leadbeater established the Order of the Star in the East to promote this belief, and the Order eventually reached 30,000 members. Krishnamurti himself repudiated the role, resigned from the Society, and the organization lost a third of its membership in the years that followed. The Adyar Society's membership had peaked at 40,000 in the late 1920s; by the time Besant died in 1933 the long decline had begun, deepened by the Great Depression and then by World War II.

• 7. Arts, Culture, and Legacy

  ›

  Hilma af Klint's development of abstract painting was directly tied to her engagement with the Theosophical Society, aimed at rendering spiritual concepts visible. Wassily Kandinsky shared an interest in Theosophical ideas about color, and Piet Mondrian drew on Theosophical symbolism. These were not peripheral figures; they stand among the founders of abstract art as a tradition. William Butler Yeats was among the Irish literary figures drawn to the movement. The composer Alexander Scriabin became interested in Theosophy while living in Brussels from 1909 to 1910, and his engagement with mystical ideas shaped his tonal system and compositional output. Gustav Holst, Luigi Russolo, Cyril Scott, and Edmund Rubbra were among the other composers whose work was touched by Theosophical concerns. Prominent scientists who belonged to the Society included the inventor Thomas Edison, the biologist Alfred Russel Wallace, and the chemist William Crookes. Mark Frost has cited Theosophy as a direct influence on the television series Twin Peaks, which itself features a White Lodge. The movement's reach into later spirituality has been equally broad. Rudolf Steiner founded his Anthroposophical Society on the 28th of December 1912 and was expelled from the Theosophical Society on the 7th of March 1913, yet maintained a keen interest in Theosophy for the rest of his life. Alice Bailey established the Arcane School in 1923. The Völkisch movement absorbed Theosophical ideas and blended them into Ariosophy. The I AM group drew on Theosophy in the 1930s. Scholar Wouter Hanegraaff observed that Theosophy helped establish the "essential foundations for much of twentieth-century esotericism". The movement that began with a name suggestion at a New York meeting still has a global membership of roughly 26,606 people across 70 countries.