Shakespearean tragedy

• 1. Defining The Tragic Form

  ›

  Sarah Siddons stood on the stage in 1784 as the Tragic Muse, her face painted with the gravity of centuries. Joshua Reynolds captured this moment in a famous portrait that still hangs today. This image represents how audiences viewed Shakespeare's work long after his death. The label "Shakespearean tragedy" applies to most plays written by William Shakespeare. Many history plays share these tragic qualities but were classified differently in the First Folio. Those works focused on real English figures and kept the title of histories instead. Roman tragedies like Julius Caesar and Antony and Cleopatra also used historical figures. Their sources came from foreign ancient lands so they received the tragedy classification. Shakespeare wrote romances late in his career which mixed elements of both genres. These plays featured high-status central characters yet ended happily like comedies. Frederick S. Boas coined the term problem play almost three centuries later. He created this category for plays that did not fit neatly into existing labels. Scholars continue to argue over how to categorize specific titles even today.

• 2. Chronology Of Composition

  ›

  The year 1591 marks the earliest possible date for Titus Andronicus according to scholarly estimates. This play appeared before Romeo and Juliet which dates between 1594 and 1595. Julius Caesar emerged around 1600 while Hamlet followed shortly after in 1601. Troilus and Cressida arrived in 1602 with Othello appearing two years later. King Lear and Macbeth both belong to the period spanning 1605 to 1606. Timon of Athens extends slightly further to 1608 alongside Antony and Cleopatra. Coriolanus rounds out the list ending its composition window at 1608 as well. The First Folio lists these plays under the tragedy heading without clear chronological order. Modern scholars have reconstructed these dates based on internal evidence and external records. James I ruled during the writing of most major tragedies including Hamlet and Macbeth. Elizabeth I had died by the time these darker works reached completion. The shift from Elizabethan to Jacobean rule coincided with a change in theatrical mood. Playwrights began exploring more violent themes under the new king's preferences.

• 3. Influences And Sources

  ›

  Christopher Marlowe wrote Doctor Faustus during this same Renaissance period when Shakespeare worked. English playwrights drew heavily from Roman and Greek classics throughout their careers. Italian, French, and Spanish literature also influenced the content of these tragic works. Most tragedies relied on historical figures except for Measure for Measure and Othello. Giraldi Cintio provided narrative fiction sources for those two specific exceptions. Plutarch supplied the historical basis for all Roman plays through his Lives of Noble Grecians and Romans. Holinshed's Chronicles served as the primary source for Britain-based stories like King Lear. The Danish Prince Amleth appeared in Holinshed's work as the foundation for Hamlet. Belleforest published The Hystorie of Hamblet in 1582 adding details about madness and murder. Geoffrey of Monmouth recorded the story of Lear in Historia regium Britanniae centuries earlier. John Higgins included the tale in his poem The Mirror for Magistrates in 1574. Philip Sidney's Arcadia inspired certain events within King Lear itself. Samuel Harsnett's book A Declaration of Egregious Popish Impostures influenced Edgar's poor Tom monologue. Elizabethan England had no copyright laws so characters and plots remained common property.

• 4. Contemporary Theatrical Context

  ›

  Senecan tragedy grounded its philosophical essence in nobles who committed grave errors leading to reversal. This concept of hamartia caused peripeteia which defined the tragic structure for many writers. Revenge tragedy became an increasingly popular genre during this age alongside classical influences. Thomas Kyd wrote The Spanish Tragedy while Christopher Marlowe produced Tamburlaine and The Jew of Malta. John Ford created 'Tis Pity She's a Whore and John Marston authored Antonio's Revenge. These plays featured violence and murder on stage unlike earlier religious morality plays. Elizabeth I outlawed those older religious forms before Shakespeare began writing tragedies. The English Renaissance marked a decisive shift toward secular theatrical content. Critics argue that pseudo-Aristotelian concepts of tragic flaw do not always apply to Shakespeare's figures. Violence and murder gained popularity as standard elements of English renaissance tragedy. Playwrights embraced these darker conventions to reflect the general mood following Elizabeth's death. James I held specific theatrical preferences that shaped the direction of Jacobean drama.

• 5. Scholarly Classification Debates

  ›

  Frederick S. Boas introduced the problem play category almost three centuries after Shakespeare died. He needed a label for works that defied simple classification into comedy or tragedy. Hamlet remains one of the most debated titles among modern academic circles. Troilus and Cressida presents another difficult case due to its mixed tone and ending. Roman histories like Julius Caesar occupy a gray area between tragedy and historical record. Scholars continue to disagree on how to categorize specific plays even today. Some argue that romances should be classified separately from pure tragedies despite shared elements. The First Folio grouped certain plays together while excluding others based on different criteria. Contemporary critics often question whether genre labels accurately describe the complexity of these texts. No single definition satisfies all scholars regarding what constitutes a true Shakespearean tragedy. The debate continues over whether historical accuracy or dramatic structure determines the final classification.