High Renaissance

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The High Renaissance lasted, by most reckonings, no more than three decades. Within that compressed window, Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo, Raphael, and Bramante were all working at the same time, in the same peninsula, often for the same patrons. Art historians have called the paintings produced in those years the absolute zenith of western painting. That is a striking claim. How did so much converge so fast? And when did it actually begin and end? Those questions turn out to be far thornier than any textbook lets on.

• 2. A Term With a History

  ›

  Jacob Burckhardt coined the German word Hochrenaissance in 1855, though the concept it described had roots going back further. Art historian Jill Burke was the first to trace those origins, finding them in Johann Joachim Winckelmann's 1764 description of a "High Style" in painting and sculpture from the early sixteenth century. The label arrived long after the works it names, which means it carries all the distortions of hindsight. By the twenty-first century, some academic art historians were criticizing the term outright. Their objections: it oversimplifies artistic developments, ignores historical context, and fixates on a handful of iconic works at the expense of everything else happening around them. More recently, scholars have moved toward calling the High Renaissance a movement rather than a period. On that reading, it was one experimental attitude among several that competed in the late fifteenth and early sixteenth century, variously described as conservative, as reflecting new ideas about beauty, and as a deliberate synthesis of eclectic models linked to literary fashion.

• 3. The Problem of Dates

  ›

  Frederick Hartt pointed to Leonardo's The Last Supper as the decisive break with the Early Renaissance. That painting began in 1495 and concluded in 1498, and Hartt argued it created the world in which Michelangelo and Raphael would work. Christoph Luitpold Frommel agreed that The Last Supper was the first High Renaissance work but placed the peak of the period between 1505 and 1513. David Piper, writing in 1991, called The Last Supper one of the most influential paintings of the entire era, yet still placed the start of the High Renaissance just after 1500. Manfred Wundram pushed the origin further back still, to Leonardo's Adoration of the Magi of 1481. Only the underpainting of that work was ever completed, which makes it an unusual foundation stone. Michelangelo's Pietà, housed in St. Peter's Basilica in Vatican City and executed in 1498-99, falls into the contested zone claimed by multiple historians as the opening of a new era. On the question of endings, scholars fracture just as sharply. Hartt, Frommel, Piper, Wundram, and Winckelmann all settled on 1520, the year Raphael died. Hugh Honour and John Fleming defined the High Renaissance as the first quarter of the sixteenth century, which points toward 1525. Luigi Lanzi, writing in 1809, tied the end to the Sack of Rome in 1527, when the mutinous army of Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor, killed several artists and scattered many more. Alexander Raunch proposed 1530. In Florence specifically, tradition marks the end with the fall of the Republic of Florence and the founding of the Duchy of Florence in 1532.

• 4. What Made Painting New

  ›

  High Renaissance painting assembled techniques that had been developing separately and fused them into a single style. Linear perspective, the realistic depiction of physical and psychological features, and the manipulation of light and darkness all came together. Sfumato, the softening of transitions between colours, and chiaroscuro, the contrast between light and dark areas, were particular tools of this synthesis. The result was what scholars describe as total compositional order, balance, and harmony, where the individual parts of a painting maintained a complex but balanced relationship to the whole. Giorgio Vasari, the Florentine who first proposed the dominant model of art history used for centuries afterward, saw this as a great explosion of creative genius. Scholars such as Stephen Freedberg pointed to the Vatican paintings by Michelangelo and Raphael as the culmination of this style. Their scale was ambitious, their compositions complex, and their references to classical antiquity pointed and deliberate. Even painters working at a less elevated register produced work that later generations valued. Fra Bartolomeo and Mariotto Albertinelli are described as relatively minor painters of the period, yet their compositions are still praised for harmony of design and technique. In Venice, Giorgione and the early Titian demonstrated a different inflection of the same style, one defined by serene mood and luminous colour. Raphael's The School of Athens stands as a specific landmark: a fresco set beneath an arch, described as a virtuoso work of perspective, composition, and disegno. Leonardo's Mona Lisa belongs to the same moment. In the late work of Michelangelo, Andrea del Sarto, and Correggio, elongated proportions and exaggerated poses began to signal the next direction, the style that would be called Mannerism.

• 5. Architecture and Patronage

  ›

  Donato Bramante's Tempietto at S. Pietro in Montorio in Rome, begun in 1510, is where historians conventionally place the start of High Renaissance architecture. David Watkin wrote that the Tempietto, like Raphael's Vatican works of 1509-1511, represents an attempt at reconciling Christian and humanist ideals. The building signifies a full-scale revival of ancient Roman commemorative architecture, and its compact, centralized form set a template that later architects would return to repeatedly. Sculpture in this period answered to a different set of patrons. High Renaissance sculpture was predominantly commissioned by public bodies and the state, partly because sculpture, as an expensive medium, demanded institutional resources. Wealthy cardinals, rulers, bankers, and prominent families also commissioned work, as did Pope Julius II, who supported many of the era's artists. The period saw the development of small-scale statuettes made for private collectors, alongside the creation of busts and tomb sculpture. Subject matter was largely religious, but tomb sculpture and painted ceilings also drew on classical individuals. Sculpture was frequently installed in courtyards, places where others could study and engage with it over time. Michelangelo's Pietà and his David together exemplify the defining quality scholars ascribe to High Renaissance sculpture: an ideal balance between stillness and movement. The term "ideal" here is not casual. It points toward the broader ambition of the period to reconcile contradictions, real versus ideal, movement versus rest, freedom versus law, space versus plane, line versus colour, and hold them in stable tension.