Johann Joachim Winckelmann

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Johann Joachim Winckelmann was born on the 9th of December 1717 into poverty in Stendal, a town in the Margraviate of Brandenburg, the son of a cobbler and the grandson of a weaver. Half a century later, he would be murdered in a hotel room in Trieste, clutching medals given to him by the Empress Maria Theresa. Between those two moments lies one of the most unlikely intellectual careers in European history. A man who could barely afford to eat as a schoolteacher in rural Prussia would go on to write words that reshaped how the entire Western world looked at art. He would become what one admiring writer called "the prophet and founding hero of modern archaeology". He would be credited as the father of art history itself. And his obsession with ancient Greek beauty would sweep through painting, sculpture, literature, and philosophy like nothing before it. How did a cobbler's son from Stendal end up changing the way Europe thought about beauty? And what drove a man of such learning toward a fate so violent and so obscure?

• 2. The Making of a Scholar

  ›

  Stendal gave Winckelmann little beyond hardship. His father Martin worked leather; his mother Anna Maria was descended from weavers. Yet something in the boy's early years ignited a passion for Greek antiquity that no amount of poverty could extinguish. He attended the Köllnisches Gymnasium in Berlin and later the Altstädtisches Gymnasium at Salzwedel before enrolling, in 1738 at the age of twenty-one, as a theology student at the University of Halle. Theology proved a false start. The teachers at Halle could not satisfy his hunger for Greek classics, and he quietly shifted his attention, studying Greek privately and sitting in on lectures by Alexander Gottlieb Baumgarten, the philosopher who coined the very word "aesthetics". He also threw himself into translating Herodotus.

  From Halle he drifted through a series of positions that each fell short. In 1740 he took medical classes at Jena. From 1743 to 1748 he served as deputy headmaster of the gymnasium at Seehausen in the Altmark, a post he found suffocating and underpaid; his salary was so meager he depended on students' parents to feed him. A tutorship near Magdeburg followed, working for the powerful Lamprecht family. There he fell into one of a series of unrequited loves, this time for the handsome Lamprecht son. The experience, and others like it, sharpened his eye for the male form in ways that would eventually shape his entire theory of art. Years later, when he had become celebrated in Rome, he looked back on those lean years without bitterness: "One gets spoiled here; but God owed me this; in my youth I suffered too much."

• 3. The Library at Nöthnitz

  ›

  In 1748 Winckelmann wrote to Count Heinrich von Bünau lamenting that "little value is set on Greek literature, to which I have devoted myself so far as I could penetrate, when good books are so scarce and expensive". Von Bünau's response changed his life. That same year Winckelmann was appointed secretary of the count's library at Nöthnitz, near Dresden. The collection held some forty thousand volumes, and for a man who had scraped together his reading in provincial backwaters, it was a revelation. Alongside the Greek authors he already knew, he found the great Enlightenment writers, Voltaire and Montesquieu among them. After the spartan atmosphere of Prussia, the Dresden world felt like release.

  His official duties involved helping von Bünau compile a work on the Holy Roman Empire, but the real education happened on his visits to the antiquities collection in Dresden. The painter Adam Friedrich Oeser, born in 1717 and later a friend and influence on Goethe, steered Winckelmann toward serious aesthetic study. The encounter deepened what had been an intellectual interest into something closer to a vocation. By 1755 he was ready to publish. His Gedanken über die Nachahmung der griechischen Werke in der Malerei und Bildhauerkunst, which translates as "Thoughts on the Imitation of Greek Works in Painting and Sculpture", went out in a first edition of only fifty copies. It contained the phrase he would refine throughout his career: the ideal of "noble simplicity and quiet grandeur", or in the German, "edle Einfalt und stille Größe". Winckelmann then staged an unusual literary maneuver, publishing a feigned attack on the work and a defense of its principles, written as if by an impartial critic. The book won fame for both its ideas and its prose, was reprinted several times, and was soon translated into French. Henry Fuseli's English translation appeared in 1765 under the title Reflections on the Painting and Sculpture of the Greeks, with a corrected reprint following in 1767.

• 4. Rome and a New Science

  ›

  The papal nuncio Alberico Archinto visited Nöthnitz in 1751 and was struck by Winckelmann. Three years later, in 1754, Winckelmann converted to Roman Catholicism. Goethe would later conclude that Winckelmann was essentially a pagan; a contemporary named Gerhard Gietmann insisted he "died a devout and sincere Catholic". Whatever the spiritual truth, the conversion opened the papal library to him. On the strength of the Gedanken, Augustus III, king of Poland and elector of Saxony, granted him a pension of two hundred thalers so that he could pursue his studies in Rome.

  Winckelmann arrived in Rome in November 1755. His first task there was to describe the statues in the Cortile del Belvedere: the Apollo Belvedere, the Laocoön, the so-called Antinous, and the Belvedere Torso, which he regarded as the "utmost perfection of ancient sculpture". The Seven Years' War, which began in 1756, trapped him in Italy beyond his original two-year plan. He was named librarian successively to Cardinal Passionei, who admired his Greek handwriting, and then to Cardinal Archinto, the same nuncio who had noticed him at Nöthnitz. After both cardinals died, he entered the household of Alessandro Cardinal Albani, who was assembling a magnificent antiquities collection at his villa at Porta Salaria.

  The painter Anton Raphael Mengs, born in 1728, became a close collaborator and the first person Winckelmann lived with in Rome. Through Mengs, Winckelmann's ideas flowed into actual artistic practice and spread across Europe. Mengs was regarded by many as the greatest living painter of his day. Winckelmann's method, applying careful, systematic observation to works of art, allowed him to do something his contemporaries had not managed: to distinguish Roman copies from their Greek originals at a time when Roman culture was still treated as the pinnacle of antiquity. In 1758 and again in 1762, he visited Naples to observe the excavations at Pompeii and Herculaneum directly. His reports on those excavations, published in 1762 and 1764, gave European scholars their first reliable information about what was being uncovered there. While in Rome he also met the Scottish architect Robert Adam, whom he influenced toward neoclassicism in architecture. Winckelmann was appointed Prefect of Antiquities under Pope Clement XIII in 1763, a post he held while continuing in Albani's service.

• 5. The History of Ancient Art

  ›

  Winckelmann's Geschichte der Kunst des Alterthums, published in 1764, was the work that secured his place in intellectual history. Its full title in English is "The History of Art in Antiquity", and it was quickly recognized as a permanent contribution to European literature. No one before him had produced a thorough, comprehensive, and systematic chronological account of all antique art, reaching from the Egyptians and Etruscans through to the Greeks and Romans. He divided Greek art into distinct periods and applied the categories of style on a large, systematic basis; prior to this, such distinctions had not been articulated.

  The book's governing argument was that art follows the life cycle of an organism: it grows, matures, and declines. Embedded in that account was a richer claim. A civilization's art and artifacts, if examined closely, tell the story of the conditions that produced them: climate, political freedom, and craft traditions all leave traces. Winckelmann presented ancient Greece as the environment most favorable to creative flourishing, sketching what he believed were the political, social, and intellectual conditions that fostered it.

  His theory of beauty held that the goal of art is beauty, and that beauty is achieved when individual and characteristic features are subordinated to the artist's general scheme. The true artist selects from nature only the phenomena suited to his purpose, combines them through imagination, and produces an ideal type in which normal proportions are maintained. The work was translated into French in 1766 and later into English and Italian. Gotthold Ephraim Lessing built many of the ideas in his own Laocoön, published in 1766, directly on Winckelmann's views on harmony and expression. The book was read with intensity by Herder, Goethe, and Kant. Later, Winckelmann's influence on writers from Lessing through Friedrich Nietzsche and Oswald Spengler was described with the provocative phrase "the Tyranny of Greece over Germany".

• 6. Desire and the Aesthetic Eye

  ›

  Winckelmann was homosexual, and the fact was not concealed from his contemporaries. Goethe recognized it openly. In 1752 Winckelmann himself wrote, in terms that mixed the erotic and the political, of the "lust" available in Potsdam with Frederick the Great in a manner he compared to Athens and Sparta, adding that he could enjoy it so immensely that he would never again be allowed to. His homoerotic sensibility was not incidental to his intellectual work; it saturated his writing on aesthetics. The series of unrequited loves he pursued throughout his life, beginning with the Lamprecht son and continuing in Rome, channeled a personal hunger into the rhetorical intensity of his descriptions of ancient sculpture.

  His Monumenti antichi inediti, published in 1767 and 1768, exemplified the method: the plates documented objects that had either been falsely explained or left without explanation, and Winckelmann's observational approach showed that many works long associated with Roman history actually drew their inspiration from Homer. The fervid descriptive enthusiasm of his prose, its strong yet graceful style, gave his scholarship an immediate appeal that purely technical writing would never have achieved. What made his work revolutionary in tone, even when judged cautiously in method, was this fusion of desire and analysis. When he wrote that "the one way for us to become great, perhaps inimitable, is by imitating the ancients", the word imitation did not mean copying: "what is imitated, if handled with reason, may assume another nature, as it were, and become one's own".

• 7. Murder in Trieste

  ›

  In 1768, Winckelmann journeyed north over the Alps for the first time in years. Tyrol depressed him and he turned back toward Italy, but his friend Bartolomeo Cavaceppi, a sculptor and restorer, persuaded him to continue on to Munich and then Vienna. There, Maria Theresa received him with honor and gave him medals as a mark of distinction. On the 8th of June 1768, on his way back south, Winckelmann was murdered in a hotel room in Trieste by a fellow traveler named Francesco Arcangeli. He was fifty years old.

  The true motive has never been established. One hypothesis holds that Arcangeli killed him for the medals from the empress, but the medals were not taken after the crime. Another suggests Arcangeli acted in response to a homosexual advance, though Winckelmann had privately written Arcangeli off as "un uomo di poco conto", meaning "a man of little account". Arcangeli was executed a month after the murder, by breaking on the wheel, in front of the hotel where both men had stayed. Winckelmann was buried in the churchyard of Trieste Cathedral. A document known as the "Mordakte Winckelmann" recorded the last week of his life; Heinrich Alexander Stoll later translated it from Italian into German.

  The speed and obscurity of the killing stands in sharp contrast to the scope of his influence. Winckelmann had steered clear of the art trade even during years of financial strain, wary of the "shady world of art dealing" that had compromised other antiquarians. He held the post of Pope Clement XIII's Prefect of Antiquities at the time of his death. His Briefe an Bianconi, letters written for the electoral prince and princess of Saxony, were published eleven years after the murder in the Antologia romana, one final posthumous thread connecting the scholar to the Italian world he had made his own.

• 8. Legacy

  ›

  Lessing found in the earliest of Winckelmann's works the starting point for his Laocoön; Kant read the Geschichte with intensity; Goethe was shaped by him so thoroughly that Goethe himself acknowledged the debt explicitly. The path of influence runs forward from there through Herder, Hölderlin, Heine, Nietzsche, Stefan George, and Spengler. Winckelmann's writings are now understood as foundational to the modern European discovery of ancient Greece, to the neoclassical movement, and to the doctrine of art as imitation.

  Neoclassical artists took from Winckelmann not just a set of forms but a spirit: the attempt to revive the feeling of ancient Greece and Rome rather than merely to copy their surface. The French painter Jacques-Louis David met Mengs in Rome between 1775 and 1780 and was introduced through him to Winckelmann's theories. Josiah Wedgwood's "Etruria" factory, operating from 1782, popularized Winckelmann's ideals in England through its reproductions. A medal struck in a French series for illustrious men in 1819 gave him a formal place in the European pantheon.

  Many of Winckelmann's specific conclusions were later modified or reversed as scholarship advanced; he had, after all, worked largely from Roman copies when direct evidence of Greek originals was scarce. But the framework he built, a systematic, period-based, culturally grounded history of art, endured. Today the Winckelmann Institute at Humboldt University of Berlin is dedicated to the study of classical archaeology, carrying forward a discipline that, before a cobbler's son from Stendal sat down to write, had no name.