The School of Athens

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The School of Athens is a fresco by the Italian Renaissance artist Raphael, painted between 1509 and 1511 on the walls of a room in the Apostolic Palace in Vatican City. Standing before it, a viewer faces an entire civilization packed into a single arched hall: ancient mathematicians, philosophers, and scientists gathered as if they had always known one another. Plato and Aristotle hold court at the center, but the crowd around them raises immediate questions. Who is the brooding figure slumped alone on the steps? Who is the turbaned scholar near the edge? And why does one of the ancient sages appear to have the face of Leonardo da Vinci?

  The fresco was not painted for public admiration. Pope Julius II commissioned it to decorate a suite of rooms, now called the Stanze di Raffaello, and the painting called The School of Athens was believed to be the third finished there, after works on theology and literature had already been completed on the same walls. Its overhead tondo-label reads "Causarum Cognitio" - knowledge of causes - echoing Aristotle's argument in his Metaphysics that true wisdom means knowing why things happen, not merely that they do. That philosophical note sets the agenda for everything Raphael placed beneath it.

• 2. A Room and Its Program

  ›

  The Stanza della Segnatura was the first of the suite's rooms to receive decoration, and its four main walls were each given over to a distinct branch of knowledge. Each theme was identified above by a separate tondo bearing a female figure seated in clouds, with putti holding phrases: "Seek Knowledge of Causes", "Divine Inspiration", "Knowledge of Things Divine", and "To Each What Is Due". The walls below illustrated philosophy, poetry, theology, and justice in kind.

  The traditional title, The School of Athens, was not given by Raphael himself. The fresco's actual subject is philosophy - specifically ancient Greek philosophy - and the overhead tondo signals as much. The architecture of the painted hall is built in the shape of a Greek cross, which some scholars have read as a deliberate harmony between pagan thought and Christian theology. Bramante, the architect who helped shape the real St. Peter's Basilica then under construction, reportedly assisted Raphael with the imagined building's design. The result bears a recognizable resemblance to the new basilica rising outside.

  Two sculptures stand in the background niches. On the left stands Apollo, god of light, archery, and music, holding a lyre. On the right stands Athena in her Roman form as Minerva, goddess of wisdom. The main arch framing the entire assembly is decorated with a meander pattern - continuous lines in rectangular bends, a design originating on pottery of the Greek Geometric period - which had long since traveled into ancient Greek architectural friezes.

• 3. Plato, Aristotle, and the Vanishing Point

  ›

  At the precise architectural center of the fresco, positioned at the composition's central vanishing point, stand two figures whose identities have never been disputed. Plato is on the left: old, grey, and barefoot. Aristotle is slightly ahead of him on the right: in mature manhood, wearing sandals and gold-trimmed robes, with the youths nearby oriented toward him.

  Both figures hold bound contemporary copies of their books in their left hands. Plato carries the Timaeus, which the source notes was a sophisticated treatment of space, time, and change that guided mathematical sciences for over a millennium. Aristotle carries the Nicomachean Ethics, a work he specifically argued could not be reduced to a mathematical science - a pointed contrast with his teacher's book. Their right hands gesture along different dimensions: Plato's hand points vertically upward toward the vault above, while Aristotle's extends horizontally toward the viewer, initiating a flow of space outward from the picture plane.

  Popular interpretation reads these gestures as philosophical declarations: Plato directing attention to his Theory of Forms in an ideal realm, Aristotle insisting on the concrete, visible world. Aristotle himself, with his four-elements theory, had held that all earthly change was owing to motions of the heavens - so his downward gesture does not simply mean "the earth" in a naive sense. The semi-circular setting placing both men at center may also allude, according to some commentators, to Pythagoras' concept of the monad.

• 4. Portraits Hidden in Plain Sight

  ›

  Raphael's fresco is also a gallery of disguised contemporaries. Leonardo da Vinci is believed to be the model for Plato himself - the old, grey, barefoot figure at the heart of the composition. Michelangelo is thought to appear as Heraclitus, the solitary figure slumped on the steps. Paolo Zamboni, a professor of vascular surgery at the University of Ferrara, made a medical study of the painting and noted that the depiction of Michelangelo as Heraclitus shows varicose veins in the legs.

  Raphael placed himself in the fresco beside Ptolemy, offering a self-portrait among the ancients. The art historian Giorgio Vasari recorded that the scene also includes accurate portraits of the Duke of Mantua, Zoroaster, and some Evangelists. Vasari specifically mentioned the young Duke of Mantua leaning over Bramante with his hands raised near the bottom right.

  Ibn Rushd, known in the West as Averroes, appears among the identifiable figures - a notable inclusion, since he was a medieval Islamic philosopher rather than an ancient Greek. Hypatia, the ancient mathematician and philosopher, is the one significant figure who looks directly at the viewer. Her gaze out of the picture plane is unique among the assembled crowd. The identities of most other figures remain ambiguous or readable only through subtle iconographic clues; Raphael had to invent a system of visual allusions for many subjects who had no established portrait tradition.

• 5. What the Drawings Reveal

  ›

  A number of preparatory drawings made by Raphael as studies for the fresco survive. A study for the figure of Diogenes is held at the Stadel in Frankfurt. A study for the group around Pythagoras, positioned in the lower left of the painting, is preserved at the Albertina Museum in Vienna. Several other drawings are in the Ashmolean Museum of Art and Archaeology at the University of Oxford, including studies of two men talking while walking up steps, the Medusa on Athena's shield, the statue of Athena as Minerva, three other statues, a study for the combat scene in the relief below Apollo, and a depiction of Euclid teaching his pupils.

  The full cartoon for the painting is held at the Pinacoteca Ambrosiana in Milan. Notably absent from it are the architectural background and the figures of Heraclitus, Raphael himself, and Protogenes - suggesting those elements were added or resolved after the primary figure compositions were settled. The group of philosophers in the left foreground of the final fresco strongly recalls figures from Leonardo's Adoration of the Magi, a connection that fits the broader picture of Leonardo's influence on the work. Marcantonio Raimondi produced engravings of the scene's sculptures; scholars believe these may derive from lost drawings by Raphael, since they do not match the fresco exactly.

• 6. Copies Across Centuries

  ›

  The Victoria and Albert Museum in London holds a rectangular copy of the fresco, painted on canvas and measuring over 4 metres by 8 metres, dated 1755 and attributed to Anton Raphael Mengs. It is displayed in the museum's eastern Cast Court.

  A full-size reproduction can be found in the auditorium of Old Cabell Hall at the University of Virginia. George W. Breck produced it in 1902 to replace an earlier reproduction destroyed in a fire in 1895. The Vatican declined to permit identical reproductions of its works, so Breck's version is four inches off scale from the original.

  A 1689 tapestry reproduction made by the Gobelins Manufactory and commissioned by Louis XIV hangs above the presiding officer's platform in the chamber of the French National Assembly. It was removed in 2017 for a three-year restoration undertaken by the Mobilier National, which manages the Gobelins Manufactory. Other copies exist in Konigsberg Cathedral in Kaliningrad, in the University of North Carolina at Asheville's Highsmith University Student Union, in a seminar room at Baylor University's Brooks College, and on the wall of the ceremonial stairwell leading to the main-floor reading room of the Sainte-Genevieve Library in Paris. Two figures from the fresco - those to the left of Plotinus - appeared on the cover art of both Use Your Illusion I and Use Your Illusion II by Guns N' Roses.

• 7. Ancient Precedents

  ›

  The idea of gathering ancient thinkers into a single monumental composition was not Raphael's invention. A similar subject appears in antiquity in the Plato's Academy mosaic. It may also have surfaced in two groups of statues from Roman Egypt. The 19th century French consul Jean-Francois Mimaut documented nine statues at the Serapeum of Alexandria holding scrolls. Separately, eleven statues were found at Memphis Saqqara.

  A review of "Les Statues Ptolemaiques du Sarapieion de Memphis" placed those figures in the 3rd century, sculpted of limestone and stucco, some standing and some seated. Rowe and Rees, writing in 1956, proposed that both statue groups share a common subject with the Plato's Academy mosaic, and offered identifications for the Saqqara figures: Pindar, Demetrius of Phalerum, Orpheus, Hesiod, Homer, Protagoras, Thales, Heraclitus, Plato, and Aristotle among them. Plato and Thales are commonly identified as the central figures in that ancient grouping. The tradition of assembling the great minds of the past into a single visual gathering thus stretches back more than fifteen hundred years before Raphael reached for his brush in the Vatican, and the Saqqara limestone figures still await a settled scholarly consensus on exactly who they represent.