Alternate history

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Alternate history asks a deceptively simple question: what if? What if Napoleon had conquered England? What if the Confederacy had won Gettysburg? What if Alexander the Great had turned his armies west? These are not idle daydreams. They form the backbone of a literary genre stretching back at least to the Roman historian Livy, who in his Ab Urbe Condita Libri speculated on whether Rome could have defeated Alexander in battle. Every story in this genre shares three structural bones: a point of divergence from the historical record, a change that reshapes subsequent events, and an exploration of the consequences that follow. How a genre born in Roman historiography became one of the most prolific corners of speculative fiction, spawning dedicated internet forums with over ten thousand active members, is itself a story worth tracing.

• 2. Ancient Roots, Medieval Branches

  ›

  Livy, writing in the Roman era, asked what would have happened if Rome had faced Alexander the Great in war, and concluded that Rome would have won. Even earlier, Herodotus included speculative material in his Histories. These were acts of counterfactual reasoning rather than fiction, tools historians used to illuminate why events unfolded as they did.

  Fiction with clear alternate-history elements arrived by the late 15th century. Joanot Martorell's 1490 epic romance Tirant lo Blanch depicts a Breton knight named Tirant who comes to the aid of the remnants of the Byzantine Empire and successfully repels the Ottoman forces of Mehmet II. Martorell was writing when the fall of Constantinople was still a raw wound for Christian Europe, which gives the novel a quality of wishful revision rather than pure entertainment. It is one of the earliest works of fiction to pivot on a single altered historical outcome.

  In the 11th century, the theologian Peter Damian explored a philosophical form of this thinking in De Divina Omnipotentia, asking whether God could alter the past, such as making it so that Rome had never been founded at all. That question sits at the intersection of theology and what later writers would call the point of divergence. The genre, from its earliest days, has been as much a tool for understanding the present as for imagining the past.

• 3. The 19th Century Takes Shape

  ›

  Louis Geoffroy published his novel imagining Napoleon victorious in Russia and England in 1836, and it reached a wide audience, making it one of the first alternate histories with genuine popular reach. The book pictures Bonaparte eventually unifying the world under his rule, carrying a nationalistic charge that later writers would recognize and argue against.

  Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story "P.'s Correspondence", published in 1845, holds the distinction of being the first known complete alternate history written in English. Its narrator is considered mad because he perceives a different 1845 in which long-dead figures, including poets Robert Burns, Lord Byron, Percy Bysshe Shelley, and John Keats, are still alive and active. The story uses the premise to examine the boundary between sanity and visionary perception.

  The first novel-length alternate history in English, Castello Holford's Aristopia from 1895, took a very different posture from Geoffroy's triumphalism. In it, the earliest settlers in Virginia discover a reef of solid gold and use that windfall to build a Utopian society in North America. The contrast with Geoffroy's conquest fantasy suggests the genre was never one thing: from its earliest long-form expressions, it contained both the nationalistic and the idealistic impulse.

• 4. Pulp, Propaganda, and the Science Fiction Turn

  ›

  H. G. Wells contributed one of the genre's foundational structural inventions in 1905 with A Modern Utopia. Wells explicitly stated that the book was a vehicle for his social and political ideas, but he introduced a device that became a genre staple: a person transported from our familiar world to a precise geographical equivalent in an alternate world where history had gone differently. The protagonists then return to the same geographical point in our world. That transit structure became the template for countless subsequent stories.

  In 1931, British historian Sir John Squire gathered leading scholars and writers for his anthology If It Had Happened Otherwise. The contributors included Hilaire Belloc, Andre Maurois, and Winston Churchill. Churchill's entry, "If Lee Had Not Won the Battle of Gettysburg", was narrated from the viewpoint of a historian in a world where the Confederacy won the Civil War, imagining what a Union victory might have looked like from that vantage point. This technique, a character in an alternate world imagining yet another world, is called recursive alternate history, or a double-blind what-if.

  The December 1933 issue of Astounding published Nat Schachner's "Ancestral Voices", and Murray Leinster followed in 1934 with "Sidewise in Time", a story in which pieces of Earth literally swap places with their counterparts from different timelines. "Sidewise in Time" has been described as the point at which alternate history first entered science fiction as a plot device, and it is the story for which the Sidewise Award for Alternate History is named. World War II then turned the genre toward direct political use, as both British and American authors wrote depictions of Nazi invasions as cautionary warnings.

• 5. Time Travel as a Plot Engine

  ›

  L. Sprague de Camp's Lest Darkness Fall introduced a different mechanism: an American academic who travels back to Italy during the Byzantine-Ostrogoth conflict and makes permanent changes, implicitly forming a new historical branch. The time traveler becomes the cause of the divergence rather than merely its witness.

  Ray Bradbury's "A Sound of Thunder" from 1952 made that mechanism famous. Hunters travel to the Late Cretaceous to kill dinosaurs that are about to die naturally. One hunter stumbles off the designated antigravity path and crushes a butterfly. When they return to the present, history has shifted and a fascist is now President. The story's logic, that even a tiny prehistoric disturbance cascades into political catastrophe, became one of the most cited illustrations of what is now sometimes called the butterfly effect.

  Ward Moore's Bring the Jubilee, published in 1953, reversed the premise with unusual self-awareness. The protagonist lives in a world where the Confederacy won the American Civil War and travels backward through time, inadvertently bringing about a Union victory at Gettysburg, which erases his own timeline and creates ours. The novel was directly influenced by Churchill's 1931 essay. Stephen Fry's much later Making History took the mechanism to a grimmer conclusion: a time machine is used to prevent Adolf Hitler from ever being born, but the result is a more competent Nazi leader and a more durable Third Reich, suggesting that removing one person does not necessarily remove the conditions that produced them.

• 6. The Multiverse Question

  ›

  The quantum many-worlds interpretation offered alternate history writers a theoretical foundation in physics rather than just a plot device. If every quantum event spawns a new universe, then every possible outcome exists somewhere. The physicist David Deutsch articulated this with unusual moral weight, arguing that good choices "thicken the stack of universes" in which better outcomes occur. That framing treats individual decisions as having genuine consequence even in a multiverse where all outcomes are real.

  Few writers have handled this squarely. Terry Pratchett, in Night Watch, depicted a character who tells Vimes that while anything that can happen has happened, there is no history whatsoever in which Vimes has ever murdered his wife. That carve-out preserves moral identity even within an infinite multiverse. Larry Niven's All the Myriad Ways took the opposite stance: the reality of all possible universes leads to an epidemic of suicide and crime because people conclude their choices carry no moral import.

  Greg Egan's short story The Infinite Assassin put the dilemma into action. An agent works to contain reality-scrambling disruptions caused by a certain drug, constantly trying to keep his behavior consistent across his alternate selves, compensating for what he guesses are low-probability variations in his experience. The story examines what it would mean to act responsibly when you are not one person but a distribution of possible persons spread across many worlds.

• 7. Major Novelists and the Genre's Peak

  ›

  Philip K. Dick's The Man in the High Castle, published in 1962, placed Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan as the victors of World War II. The novel divided a conquered United States into zones of Japanese and German control, with a Neutral Zone between them. Inside the novel, one character has written a book in which the Allies won, though even that fictional victory differs from our actual history. The double-layering made the book a touchstone for recursive alternate history and later inspired a television adaptation on Amazon.

  Vladimir Nabokov's Ada or Ardor from 1969 took the form to a stranger extreme. His alternate North America is partly settled by Czarist Russia, and the characters call their world "Anti-Terra" while speculating about a real "Terra" that may be ours. Technology in Anti-Terra mirrors our world but runs entirely on water rather than electricity. Nabokov used the alternate world not for political commentary but to destabilize the reader's sense of which world is the original and which is the copy.

  Harry Turtledove, who has been called the "Master of Alternate History" by some in the field, dominated the genre's popular boom in the late 1980s and 1990s. His Timeline 191 series imagined a Confederacy that won the Civil War but then found itself allied with the Union against Imperial Germany in two subsequent world wars, with a Confederate government committing genocide against its Black population. Michael Chabon's The Yiddish Policemen's Union from 2007 placed the world's Jewish population in a semi-autonomous city-state called Sitka in Alaska, after the destruction of Israel in its infancy. Chabon also inverted a common trope: in his book, Germany loses the war more decisively than in reality, destroyed by a nuclear bomb rather than merely a ground defeat.

• 8. Online Communities and the Word Uchronia

  ›

  The internet gave alternate history fans a place to gather far earlier than it did most literary communities. The Usenet Alternate History List was first posted on the 11th of April 1991, to the newsgroup rec.arts.sf-lovers. In May 1995, a dedicated newsgroup, soc.history.what-if, was created for discussing and sharing alternate histories. When Usenet's prominence faded, the community migrated to moderated web forums, most prominently AlternateHistory.com, which describes itself as the largest gathering of alternate history fans on the internet, with over ten thousand active members.

  The archive Uchronia: The Alternate History List was created in 1997 as an online repository and now holds over 2,900 novels, stories, essays, and other printed materials across several languages. It was selected as the Sci Fi Channel's "Sci Fi Site of the Week" twice.

  The word uchronia itself has a history worth noting. In Spanish, French, German, Portuguese, Italian, Catalan, and Galician, native equivalents, uchronie, ucronia, ucronía, had been in use before the English borrowed the term. In English, uchronia started as a synonym for alternate history but has since broadened to cover an umbrella genre that includes parallel universes in fiction and fiction set in futuristic or non-temporal settings. The broadening of the word mirrors the broadening of the genre itself, which began as a historian's thought experiment and became one of the more elastic categories in all of speculative fiction.