Spice

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Spice is a seed, fruit, root, bark, or other plant substance used primarily to flavour or colour food. That simple definition hides a story stretching back more than four thousand years, across trade routes that shaped empires and sparked voyages to the ends of the known world. India today contributes roughly 75 percent of global spice production, a fact that echoes an ancient commercial reality. How did these small, dried plant parts become so powerful that they could topple a Venetian monopoly, fund a Portuguese navy, and draw Christopher Columbus across the Atlantic? And why, despite their reputation, were they never actually used to mask rotten meat? Those questions are worth following into the story of spice.

• 2. Ancient Origins

  ›

  By 2000 BCE, cinnamon and black pepper were already moving along trade routes across the Indian subcontinent and the Middle East. Cloves reached Mesopotamia by 1700 BCE. The Egyptians used herbs both in cooking and in mummification, and their appetite for exotic imports helped pull early world trade into motion.

  The Ebers Papyrus, an Egyptian document dating from 1550 BCE, describes around eight hundred different herbal medicinal remedies. Medical systems built on plants were established in China, Korea, and India by 1000 BCE. Early uses reached beyond flavour into magic, medicine, religion, tradition, and food preservation.

  Indonesian merchants sailed circuits connecting China, India, the Middle East, and the east coast of Africa. Arab traders managed the land corridors through the Middle East and into India. Their combined efforts made Alexandria, Egypt's great port city, the principal hub for spice commerce.

  The discovery that mattered most before Europe entered the trade was the monsoon wind system, understood by around 40 CE. Once sailors learned to ride those winds, direct sea routes from Eastern growing regions to Western buyers gradually displaced the Arab land caravans that had served for centuries.

  Spices reached deep enough into ancient culture to appear in the Old Testament. In Genesis, Joseph was sold into slavery by his brothers to spice merchants. In the Song of Solomon, the narrator compares his beloved to saffron, cinnamon, and other spices. Nutmeg, native to the Banda Islands in Southeast Asia, was reportedly introduced to Europe in the 6th century BCE. The Romans had cloves by the 1st century CE; the writer Pliny the Elder documented them.

• 3. The Medieval Spice Economy

  ›

  Black pepper, cinnamon, cassia, cumin, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves were the most coveted goods in medieval Europe, ranking among the most expensive products on the continent. Their desirability was not purely culinary. Medieval medicine operated on the theory of humorism, which held that bodily health depended on the balance of four fluids. Spices were considered essential daily tools for maintaining that balance, especially during the recurrent epidemics of the period.

  The European aristocracy layered a spiritual meaning on top of the medical one. Spices were believed to come from, and to connect their owners to, paradise. The King of Aragon in the 12th century invested heavily in importing spices to Spain, specifically seeking varieties to blend into wine. He was not unusual among European monarchs in that desire.

  From the 8th through the 15th century, the Republic of Venice held a monopoly on spice trade with the Middle East. That control let Venice dominate the surrounding Italian maritime republics and city-states, and the wealth it generated transformed the region. Historians estimate that around a thousand tons of pepper and a thousand tons of other common spices flowed into Western Europe every year during the Late Middle Ages. The value of those goods equalled a year's grain supply for one and a half million people.

  Saffron sat at the top of the hierarchy, prized as much for its vivid yellow-red colour as for its taste. Other spices that commanded enormous prices in that era have since faded from European cooking almost entirely: grains of paradise, a cardamom relative that largely replaced pepper in late medieval north French cuisine; long pepper; mace; spikenard; galangal; and cubeb.

  All of these goods arrived from plantations in Asia and Africa. None were grown in Europe. That dependence on distant sources, combined with their extraordinary value, made spices the central economic target of the age of exploration.

• 4. Voyages and the Spice Trade

  ›

  Vasco da Gama sailed to India in 1499 for a specific commercial reason: to find a sea route that would undercut Venice's grip on the pepper market. When he reached India and saw what pepper actually cost there, the price differential compared to what Venice charged made the journey's logic clear. At roughly the same moment, Christopher Columbus returned from the Americas and told investors about the new spices available there.

  Competition in the 15th and 16th centuries came from another unexpected corner: the Ragusans of Dubrovnik, the maritime republic on the southern Croatian coast. But it was Portugal that moved most decisively to take control.

  Afonso de Albuquerque, who lived from 1453 to 1515, used military force to seize the chokepoints of the sea-based spice routes. In 1506, he captured the island of Socotra at the mouth of the Red Sea. In 1507, he took Ormuz in the Persian Gulf. As viceroy of the Indies, he seized Goa on the Indian coast in 1510 and Malacca on the Malay Peninsula in 1511. Those four positions gave Portugal direct access to trade with Siam, China, and the Maluku Islands, bypassing every intermediary.

  The New World added entirely new items to the global spice catalogue: allspice, chili peppers, vanilla, and chocolate. That expansion kept the spice trade commercially vital well into the 19th century, with the Americas arriving late but contributing substantially.

  The myth that pepper and other spices were used to hide the taste of rotting meat in medieval Europe deserves direct correction. At 15th century Oxford, a whole pig cost roughly the same as a pound of pepper, the cheapest spice available. Cookbooks from the period make no such use of spices; they consistently instruct cooks to add spices late in preparation, a point at which no preservative effect is possible. Cristoforo di Messisbugo, writing in the 16th century, suggested that pepper might actually speed up spoilage rather than slow it.

• 5. How Spices Work

  ›

  A spice's flavour comes largely from volatile oils that oxidise or evaporate when exposed to air. Grinding dramatically increases the surface area of a spice, which accelerates both oxidation and evaporation. A whole dry spice keeps for roughly two years; a ground spice retains meaningful flavour for roughly six months, and the practical "flavour life" can be shorter still. Ground spices fare better when stored away from light.

  Fennel and mustard seeds sit at a practical midpoint: small enough to use whole but also available as powders, giving cooks a choice. Larger spices like ginger are usually more flavourful in fresh form than dried, but fresh versions are both more expensive and far more perishable. For spices rarely sold fresh, such as many bark and seed varieties, the dried or ground form is the practical default.

  Some flavour compounds in spices dissolve in water; many others dissolve in oil or fat. Because infusion takes time, spices are typically added early in cooking, unlike fresh herbs, which usually go in near the end.

  A mortar and pestle is the traditional instrument for grinding whole spices. Microplanes and fine graters handle small amounts. Coffee grinders work well for larger quantities. A heavily used spice like black pepper often earns its own dedicated hand mill at the table.

  A study by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration covering spice shipments during fiscal years 2007 to 2009 found that about 7 percent of those shipments carried Salmonella bacteria, including antibiotic-resistant strains. Pepper was among the spices of particular concern because it is often consumed raw. Shipments from Mexico and India were the most frequently contaminated. Food irradiation is identified as a way to reduce that risk.

• 6. Spice Blends and Global Reach

  ›

  Spice mixtures trace the cultural geography of flavour with unusual precision. Baharat comes from the Arab world and the broader Middle East. Berbere defines Ethiopian and Eritrean cooking. Bumbu is the Indonesian foundation. Garam masala and chaat masala belong to the Indian subcontinent. Harissa comes from North Africa; ras el hanout likewise. Jerk spice is Jamaican. Five-spice powder is Chinese. Za'atar is Middle Eastern. Pumpkin pie spice and cajun blends are American. Quatre épices is French. Khmeli suneli comes from Georgia. Shichimi togarashi is Japanese. Speculaas seasoning is Belgian and Dutch.

  That list spans nearly every inhabited region on earth, which reflects the degree to which spice cultivation, trade, and culinary adoption spread across cultures over millennia. India remains the dominant producer, supplying three quarters of the world's spices. A table of production data from 2010 and 2011 shows India generating well over a million metric tonnes in both years, with Bangladesh, Turkey, China, and Pakistan following at much lower volumes. World production across both years sat near two million metric tonnes.

  The International Organization for Standardization handles spices and condiments within its classification series 67.220, covering related food additives alongside them. That classification points to the degree to which spice is now a regulated global commodity as much as a culinary art. A 2019 review of claimed health benefits found that most lacked clinical support, though polyphenols found in spices were noted as potentially beneficial.