Pro Bowl

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Pro Bowl began on the 15th of January 1939 at Wrigley Field in Los Angeles, where the New York Giants beat a squad of all-stars by a score of 13-10. Only about 15,000 people showed up. From that modest afternoon, the NFL's all-star event grew into something the league couldn't quite figure out what to do with: a game that players dreaded playing hard, fans struggled to take seriously, and commissioners threatened to cancel. The Associated Press once wrote that players in the 2012 game were "hitting each other as though they were having a pillow fight". Yet somehow, being named to the Pro Bowl remained one of the highest honors in professional football. This is the story of an event caught between celebration and competition, between honoring the game's best players and actually watching them play.

• 2. A Game Interrupted

  ›

  The first all-star series ran for just five games before World War II killed it. Travel restrictions imposed during the war forced the NFL to abandon the experiment after December 1942. The league champion had won the first four of those matchups, with the all-stars finally breaking through in that final wartime game at Shibe Park in Philadelphia, where the NFL All-Stars beat the Washington Redskins 17-14.

  The concept sat dormant for nearly eight years. When it returned in June 1950, the NFL had a new name for it: the Pro Bowl. The Los Angeles Publishers Association sponsored the relaunch, and the format was deliberately changed. Rather than pitting the league champion against an all-star team, which risked confusion with the Chicago College All-Star Game already using that concept, the new Pro Bowl would match the best players from each conference. The first game under this structure, played on the 14th of January 1951 at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, drew 53,676 fans to watch Otto Graham of the Cleveland Browns lead the American Conference to a 28-27 win over the National Conference.

• 3. Hawaii and Its Hold

  ›

  The first 21 games in the new Pro Bowl format were all played in Los Angeles. After a seven-year period when the location changed each year, Aloha Stadium in Halawa, Hawaii became the game's permanent home for three decades, hosting it from 1980 through 2009 without interruption, then again in 2011 through 2014, and once more in 2016.

  Hawaii gave the game something a cold-weather city never could: a reward. Players came for the location as much as the honor. Broadcasters and fans understood that dimension too. The game's highest television viewership in the modern era came from the 2011 Pro Bowl, held at Aloha Stadium, which drew 13.4 million viewers. That figure held as the record for at least the next decade of available data. John Madden, whose broadcasting career spanned multiple networks that aired the Pro Bowl, declined every time to join the announcing crew in Hawaii. He feared flying. According to a joke written into the Madden NFL '97 video game, Madden quipped that he drove his "Madden Bus" to Hawaii rather than flying. He only appeared twice when his network held the rights: Dan Fouts took his place on ABC in 2003, and Cris Collinsworth filled in on NBC in 2009, a year before Collinsworth replaced Madden permanently after Madden's retirement.

• 4. The Problem of Playing Hard

  ›

  Player injury is a more existential threat in professional football than in any other major American sport. A torn knee ligament can end a season; a broken hand can cost a team its playoff chances. That fear shaped how the Pro Bowl was played and when it was scheduled.

  For decades, the NFL held its all-star game after the season ended, unlike the NBA, NHL, and MLB, which hold theirs midseason. The logic was that a player injured in the Pro Bowl would have at least six months to recover before the following season. But that scheduling choice placed the game immediately after the Super Bowl, making it feel like an afterthought. When the NFL moved the game to the Sunday before the Super Bowl in 2010, a new problem emerged: the teams playing in the Super Bowl could no longer participate, removing many of the very players fans wanted to see. The 2012 game produced a combined score of 100 points. NFL player Brett Keisel, watching the game, said: "They probably should have just put flags on them." On the 24th of October 2012, Commissioner Roger Goodell told a Sirius XM show that if players did not compete more seriously in the 2013 game, he was "not inclined to play it anymore".

  The gentlemen's agreement not to tackle became the defining feature of the game. On most plays, ball carriers either went out of bounds on their own or surrendered as soon as a defender touched them. The game functioned essentially as two-hand touch football, a reality that made the stakes feel hollow despite the talent on the field.

• 5. Votes, Politics, and Snubs

  ›

  Fan votes account for one-third of Pro Bowl selections, with coaches and players each contributing the remaining thirds. That structure introduced its own distortions. In the 2008 Pro Bowl, the Dallas Cowboys placed thirteen players on the NFC roster, an NFL record, a figure that reflected the Cowboys' national fan base as much as the performance of their players that year.

  Minnesota Vikings cornerback Antoine Winfield spoke directly to the market-size problem. "If you're in a small market, no one really gets to see you play," he said. "If you're a quiet guy, it's hard to get the attention. You just have to work hard and play." Winfield had gone ten seasons without a Pro Bowl selection before finally being named in 2008.

  Player voting carried its own complications. Former offensive lineman Ross Tucker identified politics, incumbency, personal vendettas, and compensation for past injuries as drivers of how players voted. In 2010, Baltimore Ravens linebacker Terrell Suggs admitted he voted for Ryan Fitzpatrick, then the backup quarterback of the Buffalo Bills, over the eventual league MVP Tom Brady. His reason had nothing to do with on-field performance. He voted against Brady as a gesture of disrespect toward the New England Patriots.

  The snubs accumulated over generations. Hall of Fame fullback John Riggins made the Pro Bowl just once across a career stretching from 1971 to 1985. He was not selected in the year his team reached the Super Bowl after he set the record for rushing touchdowns in a season. Defensive back Ken Riley recorded 65 interceptions across 15 seasons, the fourth-highest total in NFL history at the time of his retirement, and was never invited. Fred Taylor, 15th on the all-time rushing yards list with a career average of 4.6 yards per carry, was named to his only Pro Bowl in 2007.

• 6. Reinvention

  ›

  In September 2022, Commissioner Roger Goodell acknowledged publicly that the traditional Pro Bowl game "doesn't work". On the 26th of September 2022, the NFL announced a partnership with Peyton Manning's Omaha Productions to rebuild the event as "The Pro Bowl Games", replacing the contact football game with flag football and a series of skills challenges.

  The new format launched in 2023 with Manning and his brother Eli serving as honorary coaches for the AFC and NFC, respectively. Peyton had spent his entire playing career in the AFC with the Indianapolis Colts and Denver Broncos. Eli had played his whole career with the New York Giants in the NFC. The 2023 event itself was structured so that points earned in skills competitions during the week carried into the final flag football game, with the NFC winning 35-33 in a game played at Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas.

  The flag football games run on a 50-by-28-yard field with seven players per side, two 10-minute halves, and a 15-minute halftime. Teams can attempt a one-point conversion from the five-yard line or a two-point conversion from the ten. That structure replaced a century-old format, and the 2026 edition went further still, integrating the Pro Bowl Games into Super Bowl week itself as a smaller-scale event held at Moscone Center, with the NFL explicitly describing the goal as making it a television-oriented event rather than a standalone spectacle.

  With his selection to the 2022 Pro Bowl, quarterback Tom Brady set the all-time record with 15 invitations, a mark that stands as the most in the event's history. Travis Kelce, still active as of the most recent records, has accumulated 11 selections, all with the Kansas City Chiefs.