Papinian

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Papinian died on the orders of an emperor he had served for decades, his body dragged through the streets of Rome after he refused to defend a fratricide. That moment, somewhere around 212 CE, crystallized who Aemilius Papinianus was: a man whose reputation for legal integrity outlasted the dynasty that killed him by more than two centuries. Who was this jurist so revered that third-year law students in ancient Rome were given the title "Papinianistae," meaning they were worthy simply to study him? How did a man of Syrian origin, born in Emesa around 142 CE, rise to become the praetorian prefect of the Roman Empire? And why do his written views still carry a formal legal weight codified by a law passed in 426 CE, more than two hundred years after his death?

• 2. Rise Through the Empire

  ›

  Papinian's path to the highest legal offices in Rome ran through a personal friendship with Emperor Septimius Severus. He was, by some accounts, a kinsman of Severus's second wife, Julia Domna, a member of the Emesene dynasty from the same Syrian city where Papinian was born. That family connection likely opened the first doors, but it was legal learning that kept them open. One ancient source describes Papinian as a follower of the casuistry of Quintus Cervidius Scaevola; another calls him Scaevola's pupil outright. A passage in the Augustan History, though considered dubious by later scholars, claims that Papinian and Severus studied law together under Scaevola.

  Severus eventually made Papinian master of petitions, a post known in Latin as magister libellorum, and at some point also named him attorney general, or advocatus fisci. He served as Treasurer and Captain of the Guard for the emperor as well. In 207 CE, Papinian accompanied Severus to Britain, where he served in what the sources call "the forum of York" during an uprising by Scottish Highlanders. When Gaius Fulvius Plautianus was killed in 205 CE, Papinian stepped into the most powerful administrative post below the emperor himself: praetorian prefect. Before Severus died, he placed his two sons, Caracalla and Geta, into Papinian's personal charge.

• 3. A Jurist Above All Others

  ›

  In his own lifetime, Papinian was called "the Asylum of Right and Treasurer of the Laws." That honorific was not empty flattery. His legal writings were considered so authoritative that the Law of Citations, passed in 426 CE, designated him as one of five jurists whose recorded opinions could serve as decisive sources in Roman courts. The other four were Gaius, Paulus, Modestinus, and Ulpian. When those jurists disagreed, the law specified a clear hierarchy: Papinian's view prevailed.

  His principal works included the Quaestiones, a collection in 37 books written before 198 CE, and the Responsa in 19 books, written sometime between 204 CE and his death. He also produced two books called the Definitiones and De adulteriis, along with shorter works. The briefest of these was a Greek-language manual on the duties of commissioners of streets and bridges, titled Αστυνόμικος, meaning City-Administration. Much of what he wrote has since been lost; what survives is small compared to the output of jurists like Ulpian or Paulus. The 16th-century French jurist Jacques Cujas, surveying that surviving material, wrote that "there was never such a great lawyer before, nor ever will be after him." The views Papinian committed to papyrus became primary sources for both the Codex Theodosianus and the Corpus Juris Civilis, two of the foundational texts of Western legal tradition.

• 4. The Brothers and the End

  ›

  Sharing power proved intolerable for Caracalla. After the death of Septimius Severus, Caracalla decided at some point to seize sole control by killing his brother Geta. Papinian had been given charge of both men by their dying father, and he tried to keep peace between them. That effort, far from earning Caracalla's gratitude, stoked his hatred. Following the fratricide of Geta in 212 CE, Caracalla ordered Papinian beheaded. The execution is recorded in the ancient source attributed to Spartianus, though the author of the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica article noted that the details of Papinian's death "are variously related, and have undergone legendary embellishment."

  Papinian's death came as part of a wider purge. One source estimates that around 20,000 persons associated with Geta were killed alongside him. The 17th-century German playwright Andreas Gryphius made Papinian's death the subject of a play in 1659, turning the jurist's refusal to bend into a study of conscience against power. That dramatization suggests the story carried moral weight long after the Roman world had dissolved.