Mongol invasion of Kievan Rus'

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Mongol invasion of Kievan Rus' began, according to one chronicler, as a total mystery. "For our sins," he wrote, "unknown nations arrived. No one knew their origin or whence they came, or what religion they practiced. That is known only to God, and perhaps to wise men learned in books." Within a few years, those unknown nations had leveled some of the region's largest cities. Kiev alone held about 50,000 people, and Chernigov held about 30,000. Both were burned. The siege of Kiev in 1240 is generally treated as the moment Kievan Rus' ceased to exist, a state that was already splintering among rival princes well before that. Yet the destruction was strikingly uneven. Galicia-Volhynia, Pskov, Smolensk, Polotsk, and Vitebsk avoided serious damage almost entirely. Why did an army that could burn Kiev to ash leave other principalities standing? What made this campaign different from decades of smaller border raids that came before it? And how did a war meant to punish and plunder end up deciding which Russian city would one day rule all the others?

• 2. The Long Prelude

  ›

  In 1207, Genghis Khan sent his eldest son, Jochi, to bring the tribes north of the Selenga River and the Irtysh valley under Mongol control. Those lands became part of the Jochi Ulus, but Genghis Khan never lived to see his wider plan for Eastern Europe carried out. Between 1222 and 1224, the generals Subutai and Jebe led an army of about 30,000 men through Transcaucasia and into Southeastern Europe, a campaign later writers dismissed as mere reconnaissance. The Secret History of the Mongols and the historian Rashid ad-Din tell a fuller story. They say the campaign was meant to be joined by Jochi's own forces and aimed at Cumania, Alania, Hungary, and Rus', Kiev included. In May 1223, princes from Galicia-Volhynia and Chernigov beat the Mongols at the Battle of Oleshia. The same force, called "Tartars" in contemporary accounts, answered on the 31st of May 1223. At the Battle of the Kalka River, they crushed a combined Rus' army led by Mstislav the Bold and Mstislav Romanovich the Old, alongside Cuman fighters under Köten. The Mongols then withdrew, their reconnaissance apparently complete, and did not return for 13 years. The princes of Rus' went back to quarreling among themselves, unaware of what was still coming. A kurultai in 1235 revived the old target list. Ögedei ordered Batu, Büri, and Möngke, among other princes, to reinforce Subutai's campaign. Through 1235 and early 1236, the assembled army subjugated the Bashkir tribes, who were then forced to supply detachments of their own. By the autumn of 1236, the combined force had gathered on the Caspian steppes under Batu, Jochi's son, with Volga Bulgaria marked as the first target. Volga Bulgaria had spent years trading blows with the Vladimir-Suzdal and Murom-Ryazan principalities. The sight of Mongols on its border pushed the Bulgars to make peace with Rus' instead. They fortified their cities and reinforced their garrisons. None of it mattered. Volga Bulgaria fell completely by the spring of 1237. The Mongols then turned on the Cumans and Alans, fighting through to the autumn of 1237 before conquering the Burtas, Mokshas, and Erzyas as well. Near a crossing over the Sura River, the two sides fought what is remembered as the Zolotarevskoe battle. The historian Vadim Kargalov (1932-2009) argued that this entire 1237 campaign existed to build a springboard for the coming attack on Rus'. By year's end, Batu's army and its allied detachments had massed near Voronezh, on the very edge of Russian territory.

• 3. Envoys And Ultimatums

  ›

  Just before the Mongols crossed into Rus', a Hungarian friar named Julian traveled to the region's eastern border and learned that Batu's army was simply waiting for winter. Frozen rivers and swamps would let mounted archers cross ground that summer mud made impassable. Julian later described, in a letter to the Pope's legate in Hungary, meeting Mongol messengers who had been intercepted and held by Yuri II of Vladimir. Yuri handed their letter over to Julian himself. In November 1237, Batu sent envoys to Yuri's court demanding submission. According to the Laurentian Codex, the Mongols were genuinely asking for peace, but Yuri met them with contempt. "As they did before, the messengers came, those evil bloodsuckers, saying: 'Make peace with us'. He did not want that, as the prophet said: 'Glorious war is better than disgraceful peace'." Despite that defiance, Yuri avoided open conflict where he could. He sent the Mongol delegations away with gifts that were really tribute in disguise. The invasion itself came from several directions at once. One force struck Suzdal, one advanced along the Volga, and a third pushed south toward Ryazan. The historian Rashid al-Din Hamadani names the commanders at the siege of Ryazan as Batu, Orda, Güyük, Möngke, Kulkan, Kadan, and Büri. The city fell after just three days. Yuri sent his own sons to hold back the invaders, but they were routed and fled, and Yuri himself abandoned Vladimir for Yaroslavl. Before ever reaching Vladimir, the horde had already burned Kolomna and Moscow to the ground. A contemporary account of Ryazan's fall on the 21st of December is blunt: "They likewise killed the Prince and Knyaginya, and men, women and children, monks, nuns and priests, some by fire, some by the sword." Vladimir, the capital Yuri had just fled to reach, was still standing. Not for long.

• 4. Fire Across The North

  ›

  On the 4th of February 1238, the horde laid siege to Vladimir, capital of the Vladimir-Suzdal principality. Three days later the city fell and burned. The royal family died in the flames, while the grand prince had already retreated northward. Yuri crossed the Volga and raised a new army, but it was surrounded and wiped out at the Battle of the Sit River on the 4th of March. Batu then split his forces into smaller units that tore through fourteen cities of northeastern Rus', among them Rostov, Uglich, Yaroslavl, Kostroma, Tver, and Torzhok. Chinese siege engines, operated under the Mongol prince Tolui, breached the walls of many of these towns. Kozelsk held out the longest of all. Its boy-prince, Vasily, son of Titus Mstislavich, led the town's defense for seven weeks and killed 4,000 Mongol soldiers before it finally fell. Legend claims the nearby town of Kitezh sank beneath a lake rather than surrender, and that its outline can still be seen there. Novgorod avoided the same fate by choosing to surrender before the Mongols ever arrived. By mid-1238, Batu had turned south, devastating Crimea and pacifying Mordovia. In the winter of 1239, his forces sacked Chernigov and Pereyaslavl. Kiev, the city that still called itself first among equals, was next.

• 5. The Siege Of Kiev

  ›

  Kiev still held formal seniority among the principalities of Rus', but years of infighting between rival princes had hollowed out its defenses. By the time the Mongols arrived, the man commanding Kiev's defense answered to Prince Daniel of Galicia-Volhynia, not to Kiev's own ruler. Daniel had taken the city under his protection the previous year, in an arrangement with Prince Michael of Kiev, who had already fled after first resisting the Mongols and then losing his own stronghold at Chernigov. In November 1240, the Mongol approach reportedly terrified Kiev's defenders before a single arrow flew. One chronicler described "the squeaking of his carts, the bawling of his innumerable camels, and the neighing of his herds of horses," adding that "the Land of Rus' was full of enemies." After many days of siege, the horde stormed the city in December 1240 and pillaged it thoroughly, though the building of St. Sophia Cathedral somehow survived intact. From Kiev, Batu's forces pushed into Galicia-Volhynia, meeting fierce resistance from Daniel himself, and failed twice, unable to take either Kremenets or Kholm. The Mongols pressed on regardless, aiming, as the sources put it, to "reach the ultimate sea." Batu led the assault into Hungary while Baidar and Kaidu invaded Poland. Batu personally captured Pest, then took Esztergom on Christmas Day 1241. Rather than pushing further west, Batu folded the conquered principalities into his own Jochid appanage. He built a new capital, called Sarai, on the lower Volga, the seat of what would become known as the Golden Horde.

• 6. A Disputed Eyewitness

  ›

  In 1246, the Italian diplomat Giovanni da Pian del Carpine passed through Kiev and later wrote about it in Latin, in a text called the Ystoria Mongalorum. His account of the siege, composed years after the fact, has since become one of history's most argued-over sources. Carpine's manuscript survives in two versions, and the second redaction expanded a short passage from the first in ways that actually contradict it. The first redaction says the Mongols "put the inhabitants to death," implying no one survived the siege at all. The second redaction adds that "the inhabitants are kept in complete servitude," which only makes sense if some of Kiev's people had, in fact, lived. That same expanded passage claims Kiev had shrunk to "scarce two hundred houses" and that its people came across "countless skulls and bones of dead men lying about on the ground." Historians consider that added material a likely later interpolation rather than Carpine's original words. Doubts run deeper still. Carpine never mentions the Cathedral of St. Sophia. That silence matters. It is the one landmark that would confirm he was truly describing Kiev, not some other ruined town he was merely told was Kiev.

• 7. Ashes And Absence

  ›

  The demographer Colin McEvedy estimates that the region's population fell from about 7.5 million before the invasion to about 7 million afterward. Kiev needed centuries to rebuild from the devastation of that first attack, while the Novgorod Republic, spared by its early surrender, kept growing. A new power, the Principality of Moscow, began to flourish instead under Mongol rule. Stone construction across Russian cities halted for decades after the invasion. Skilled crafts, including glass jewelry, cloisonné enamel, niello work, granulation, and polychrome glazed ceramics, disappeared from production entirely. Russian handicraft fell centuries behind, even as guild industry in the West kept advancing toward what would become the era of primitive accumulation. Trade between cities and their surrounding villages broke down. It took more than 100 years for Russian cities to recover. Ordinary residents of Vladimir-Suzdal and Ryazan fled north beyond the Volga, while others hid in dense forest. Most eventually went home once the Mongols withdrew. Just a year after Vladimir-Suzdal fell, so many people had returned that Prince Yaroslav Yaroslavich raised a large army from among them for a campaign against the Lithuanians. People from Kiev, Pereyaslav, and Chernigov in the south fled north instead, resettling in northeastern Russia. Later Mongol-Tatar campaigns through the second half of the 13th century kept displacing people from Vladimir and Suzdal, pushing many further still, some toward Moscow and Tver, others as far north as Yaroslavl and Veliky Ustyug.

• 8. Moscow's Mongol Inheritance

  ›

  In 1327, the prince of Tver led an uprising against Mongol rule, and Ivan I of Moscow chose to join the Mongols in crushing it. By devastating Tver, Ivan eliminated his chief rival, secured the Russian Orthodox Church's move to Moscow, and was rewarded with the title of Grand Prince. That made the Muscovite prince the middleman between the Mongol overlords and every other Russian prince, a position Moscow's rulers kept exploiting through the 14th century while "gathering Russian lands." Under Mongol rule, Muscovy built its mestnichestvo hierarchy of noble precedence. It also adopted a postal road network based on the Mongolian ortoo system, known in Russian as the yam. By 1450, the Tatar language had become so fashionable at the Moscow court that Grand Prince Vasily II was accused of loving Tatar speech excessively. Russian noblemen took Tatar names too. A member of the Veliaminov family adopted the Turkic name Aksak, and his descendants became the Aksakovs. A 17th-century survey of Russian noble families found that more than 15% traced their descent to Tatar or Oriental origins, among them the Godunov, Arseniev, Bulgakov, and Chaadaev families, the last tracing itself to Genghis Khan's own son Chagatai. Mongol influence also reshaped Russian law. Capital punishment, once reserved for slaves under Kievan Rus', became widespread, and torture entered criminal procedure as routine practice. Moscow introduced specific punishments of its own, including beheading for accused traitors and branding for thieves, with execution reserved for a third offense. The historian Donald Ostrowski argues that adopting these Mongol institutions reflected Muscovite pragmatism, the very trait that let its leaders "triumph over their competitors in northeastern Rus'." The debate over that inheritance never fully settled. Writing in 2011, the historian Charles J. Halperin traced Russia's pseudohistorical "New Chronology" movement of the 1980s back to old discomfort with the idea that Russia had absorbed its institutions from the very nomads it once called Tartars.