Fall of the Fascist regime in Italy

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  At two o'clock in the morning on the 25th of July 1943, Benito Mussolini stood in a room in Palazzo Venezia and watched 19 members of his own Grand Council vote to strip him of power. The man who had ruled Italy for almost 21 years called it a "not admissible and cowardly" document. Within hours, he would be riding in an ambulance through the streets of Rome to an army barracks, under arrest by order of the king he had once served.

  What unraveled that night was the product of two separate conspiracies that had been running in parallel for months: one led by a veteran Fascist politician named Dino Grandi, the other by King Victor Emmanuel III. Neither man fully trusted the other. Each was waiting for the other to move first. The story of how those two plots finally converged in a single vote raises a question that Italy has debated ever since: was the fall of Fascism a coup by enemies of the regime, or a rescue mission by men who had built it?

• 2. Italy on the Brink

  ›

  The collapse of the African front on the 4th of November 1942, followed by Allied landings in North Africa on the 8th through the 12th of November, exposed Italy to invasion in a way that had seemed unthinkable a year earlier. By early 1943, the Italian expeditionary force known as ARMIR had been destroyed on the Eastern Front. Heavy aerial bombing was striking Italian cities. Food and fuel were scarce.

  Mussolini was also physically failing. Diagnosed with gastritis and duodenitis of nervous origin, he was often confined to his home, leaving the country without effective day-to-day leadership. His illness fed uncertainty across all four of the main institutions capable of political action: the Royal Court, the anti-Fascist parties, the Fascist Party itself, and the military General Staff.

  On the 29th of April 1943, Mussolini met Adolf Hitler at Klessheim and proposed that Germany seek a separate peace with Russia and move the bulk of German forces south. Hitler rejected the proposal outright. The Wehrmacht refused Italy's request for reinforcements to hold Tunisia, having lost confidence in Italian resolve. When Tunis fell on the 13th of May 1943, the last Axis foothold in Africa was gone, and Italy found itself the next plausible target.

  On the 11th of June 1943, the Allies captured the island of Pantelleria, which Mussolini had fortified into what he considered a citadel. It surrendered after a week-long bombardment, with minimal resistance. The loss made clear that an invasion of Sicily, Sardinia, Corsica, or Greece was imminent.

• 3. Grandi's Gamble

  ›

  Dino Grandi had been a close colleague of Mussolini for over 20 years, but he was more of a right-wing conservative than a true Fascist. He had served as foreign minister and as ambassador to the United Kingdom, and he held the view that Fascism was an ephemeral phenomenon tied to Mussolini's personal lifespan rather than a durable ideology.

  On the 25th of March 1943, Victor Emmanuel awarded Grandi the collare dell'Annunziata, the highest royal honor, which gave him unrestricted access to the Royal House. During his final meeting with the King before the 25th of July, Grandi compared the monarch to the 18th-century Duke of Savoy, Victor Amadeus II, who had switched alliances to rescue his dynasty. Grandi proposed himself as the modern equivalent of Pietro Micca, the Savoyard soldier who sacrificed himself defending Turin in 1706. The King's response was careful: he would only move after a vote of parliament or the Grand Council.

  Grandi's plan was to use the Grand Council to pass a document, his Ordine del Giorno, that would formally invoke Article 5 of the kingdom's constitution, returning supreme civil and military power to the King. The document was written in deliberately vague language. Grandi could not tell most of his potential supporters what approval would actually mean: the dismissal of Mussolini, the end of the Fascist Party, and war against Germany. He estimated that of the 27 members he was counting, only 4 were firmly with him, 7 were against, and 16 were undecided.

  On the 22nd of July, he went to Palazzo Venezia under the cover of presenting a book about Italian involvement in the Spanish non-intervention committee. The meeting ran from 15 minutes to more than an hour and a quarter. Mussolini listened as Grandi explained why resigning was the only way to avoid catastrophe, then dismissed the argument, telling him that Germany was about to deploy a decisive secret weapon.

• 4. The King's Reluctance

  ›

  Victor Emmanuel III had retained his personal trust in Mussolini well into 1943, hoping the Duce could still salvage the situation. He described the pre-Fascist politicians who approached him as "revenants," an ironic term meaning ghosts or zombies, and was openly contemptuous of their attempts to sound him out. His inaction was partly a matter of character and partly constitutional scruple: he genuinely believed that a sudden move without legal justification would look like betrayal.

  General Vittorio Ambrosio, the new Chief of the General Staff, was devoted to the King and hostile to the Germans. He and his colleagues Giuseppe Castellano and Giacomo Carboni slowly placed officials loyal to the crown in key military positions, but Ambrosio would not act without the King's prior approval.

  In mid-May, Pietro d'Acquarone, Minister of the Royal House, began persuading the King to consider exiting the war, partly out of fear that the monarchy's own future was at risk. On the 2nd and the 8th of June, the King received Ivanoe Bonomi and Marcello Soleri, two senior pre-Fascist politicians who pressed for Mussolini's arrest and a military government. They left frustrated. On the 30th of June, Bonomi proposed three potential successors: General Ambrosio, Marshal Pietro Badoglio, and Enrico Caviglia. Badoglio had resigned as Chief of the General Staff after the disastrous invasion of Greece in 1941 and had become a bitter personal enemy of Mussolini.

  On the 4th of July, Badoglio was received by Crown Prince Umberto, who implied the Crown was no longer opposed to a change. The following day, Ambrosio proposed that the King appoint either Badoglio or Caviglia. Caviglia was considered too old for the task despite his anti-Fascist credentials. Badoglio, a personal friend of d'Acquarone, would be the choice, and on the 15th of July the King informed him directly.

• 5. Feltre and Its Failure

  ›

  On the 19th of July 1943, Mussolini, Bastianini, and Ambrosio met Hitler and the German high command at the villa of Senator Achille Gaggia in Feltre. Ambrosio had told Mussolini beforehand that his duty was to announce Italy's exit from the war within 15 days. The German delegation was focused on military realities: they had lost faith in the Italian army and wanted a German general, possibly Erwin Rommel, to take supreme command of Axis forces in the peninsula.

  Hitler began the meeting by blaming the Italians for their military failures. While he was speaking, an aide interrupted to tell Mussolini that Allied aircraft were bombing Rome for the first time. Ambrosio and Bastianini pressed the Duce to use the moment, to tell Hitler plainly that Italy needed a political solution. Mussolini could not overcome what he described as a sense of inferiority in Hitler's presence. He said later that he had been tormented for months by the dilemma of leaving or continuing the alliance.

  The meeting was scheduled to last three days. Mussolini cut it short, to Hitler's displeasure. On the return journey to Belluno by train, and then back to Rome in his personal aircraft, the Duce could see the eastern quarters of the capital still burning below him.

  That same evening, Grandi left Bologna with a first draft of his Ordine del Giorno. He reached Rome the following day, and by the morning of the 21st he learned that Mussolini had agreed to convoke the Grand Council. The meeting Grandi had been waiting for was finally set.

• 6. Night of the Grand Council

  ›

  At 17:00 on the 24th of July 1943, the 28 members of the Grand Council assembled in the parrot room, the anteroom of Mussolini's globe saloon in Palazzo Venezia. For the first time in the assembly's history, neither the Moschettieri del Duce nor the "M" battalion detachment was present in the palace, though armed blackshirts occupied the yard and antechamber. Mussolini ordered no stenographer, so no official minutes were kept.

  Grandi arrived carrying two hidden Breda hand grenades. He had revised his will and gone to confession beforehand, convinced he might not leave the palace alive. Mussolini opened by summarizing the history of the supreme command, then described the current military situation, saying he was prepared to move the government to the Po Valley. He posed what he called "il dilemma": war or peace.

  Farinacci spoke for the opposite position from Grandi, arguing that victory required purging the moderates from the Party, giving supreme command to the King, and tying Italy's war direction more firmly to Germany's. Bottai, the Fascist intellectual, delivered a purely political speech defending Grandi's document. Ciano summarized the history of the German alliance and declared that it was the Italians who had been betrayed, not the Germans.

  At 23:30, when Mussolini suggested postponing to the next day, Grandi called for an immediate vote, saying it was shameful to sleep while Italian soldiers were dying. Never before in 20 years had anyone in the Grand Council formally called for a vote. Fascism was anti-parliamentary by design; all previous meetings had ended with the Duce summarizing the discussion. Mussolini reluctantly agreed, the meeting was suspended for 10 minutes at midnight, and Grandi circulated the room collecting signatures.

  After further debate, Mussolini warned the assembly that approving Grandi's document would mean the end of Fascism, and hinted at dire consequences for those who voted against him. Grandi said openly that the Duce was blackmailing them all. At two o'clock in the morning, Mussolini called the vote. Scorza voted no first. Marshal de Bono voted yes and, according to witnesses, pulled the undecided with him. The final count was 19 for Grandi's Ordine del Giorno, 8 against. Mussolini asked who should bring the result to the King. Grandi answered: "You".

• 7. Arrest and Aftermath

  ›

  After the vote, Mussolini telephoned his mistress, Claretta Petacci, from Villa Torlonia. The call was intercepted. He told her: "We arrived to the epilogue, the greatest watershed in history"; "The star darkened"; "It's all over now". Grandi spent the night with Pietro d'Acquarone, handing over one of two copies of the Ordine del Giorno. At 07:00 on the 25th of July, d'Acquarone informed the King. The King called Badoglio and told him he would be the successor.

  At 17:00 on Sunday the 25th of July, Mussolini arrived at Villa Savoia carrying a copy of the Grand Council law, the Ordine del Giorno, and a withdrawal letter from Tullio Cianetti, who had already rescinded his vote. The Duce argued that the document had no legal force. The King told him the country was broken and that Marshal Badoglio would be the new President of the Council of Ministers. Mussolini's wife, Donna Rachele, had warned him not to go, saying "You won't be back." He told her the King was his best friend.

  When he left the meeting, Captain Paolo Vigneri of the Carabinieri directed him not to his car but to a nearby ambulance. Mussolini said there was no need for it but followed. The ambulance drove through Rome to the "Podgora" barracks in Trastevere, then to the "Legnano" barracks in Prati. Within days he was moved to Gaeta, then to the island of Ponza, then to La Maddalena, and finally to Campo Imperatore, where he remained until the 12th of September 1943, when a German commando unit led by Otto Skorzeny freed him.

  At 22:45, Radio EIAR announcer Titta Arista broadcast the news. The communique ended with: "La guerra continua. L'Italia tiene fede alla parola data" ("The war goes on. Italy will be true to its word"). Within hours, crowds in Rome were chiseling Fascist emblems off buildings. Writer Paolo Monelli described the streets erupting with songs and screams, people embracing strangers, tearing the Fascist pin from the jackets of party members and trampling it underfoot.

  The Germans received word of the arrest around 19:30 and moved immediately. Between the 26th of July and the 8th of August, eight German divisions and one brigade entered northern and central Italy without Italian consent, using the same passes and the same troops Hitler had refused Mussolini at Feltre two weeks earlier. The forty-six days between the arrest and the public announcement of the Armistice of Cassibile on the 8th of September would bring the meltdown of the armed forces, the flight of the royal family from Rome on the 9th of September, and the commencement of the Italian Civil War.