Christian mysticism

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Christian mysticism sits at the heart of a tradition stretching back to the second century AD, and it begins with a surprisingly practical question: how does a human being actually encounter the living God? Not through argument or doctrine alone, but through direct, transformative presence. That is the core claim of Christian mysticism, as defined by scholar Bernard McGinn: "that part, or element, of Christian belief and practice that concerns the preparation for, the consciousness of, and the effect of a direct and transformative presence of God." The word mysticism itself carries ancient roots. It derives from the Greek word meaning "to close" or "shut" - as in closing the eyes or mouth - with a secondary meaning of something private, secret, or connected to the mysteries. In early Christianity, the term referred to three distinct dimensions: the hidden meanings within scripture, the liturgical mystery of the Eucharist, and the direct experiential knowledge of God. These three strands would weave together over centuries into one of the most complex and contested bodies of spiritual practice the world has known. What does genuine encounter with God feel like, and how do you prepare for it? Who has the authority to guide it? Can it be taught, or only received? And what separates authentic mystical experience from delusion? The traditions covered here stretch from desert hermits in Egypt to Spanish nuns, from Neoplatonic philosophers to Protestant reformers, all wrestling with those same questions.

• 2. Roots and Languages

  ›

  Before the word mysticism existed, Christians used a different term for what we now call that practice. According to William Johnston, until the sixth century, the tradition was referred to by the Greek word theoria and the Latin contemplatio, both of which meant simply "looking at" or "gazing at" God or the divine. The Greek theoria came from theorein, meaning "to consider or look at", and expressed the state of being a spectator. Several scholars, including Ian Rutherford and Gregory Grieve, have pointed to similarities between this Greek idea and the Indian concept of darshan, suggesting that the contemplative impulse runs across cultures and traditions. Plato, who lived from 428 to 348 BC, is considered by the source the most important of ancient philosophers in shaping later mystical thought. For Plato, the contemplative person gazes upon the Forms, the underlying realities behind individual appearances, gaining a perspective on ordinary life superior to that of ordinary people. Plotinus, writing around 204-270 CE as a founder of Neoplatonism, pushed this further: in his Enneads, he declared that everything is contemplation and everything is derived from contemplation. He articulated the famous principle that "The point of action is contemplation. Contemplation is therefore the end of action." These Greek foundations did not stay Greek for long. Jewish spiritual life before Jesus was highly communal and liturgical, centered on synagogue worship and the reading of scripture. From Jewish tradition, concepts like Shekhinah (the presence of God in daily life), Binah (understanding), and Chokmah (wisdom) passed into Christian mystical thought, where Shekhinah became mystery and Da'at became gnosis. The philosopher Philo of Alexandria, who lived from approximately 20 BCE to 50 CE, served as a crucial bridge, teaching that allegorical readings of Hebrew scripture unlock its real meanings and describing intellectual faith as a spiritual ecstasy in which the human mind is suspended and God's spirit takes its place. His influence reached Clement of Alexandria and Origen, and through them, Gregory of Nyssa.

• 3. The Desert and the Monastery

  ›

  Inspired by Christ's example, men and women withdrew to the deserts of Sketes and built something new. These early communities formed the basis of what would become Christian monasticism. The movement was called anchoritism, from the Greek word meaning "to withdraw", and it was understood not as an escape from the world but as a combat: fighting demons believed to inhabit the desert and achieving liberation from bodily passions in order to remain open to God. Anchorites could live in complete solitude, called hermits from the Greek word erēmitēs meaning "of the desert", or in loose communities called cenobites, meaning "common life". Their daily practice centered on continuous meditation on scripture, which they understood as a ladder of perfection - an image found throughout the Mediterranean world and anchored for Christians in the story of Jacob's ladder. One of the particular enemies they named was acedia, a boredom or spiritual apathy that prevents a practitioner from continuing in their training. The Eastern church contributed decisive figures to this tradition: Gregory of Nyssa, Evagrius Ponticus, and Pseudo-Dionysius all shaped contemplative theology as monasticism developed. Monasticism eventually moved west through the work of John Cassian and Benedict of Nursia, while Western spiritual writing was shaped by Jerome and Augustine of Hippo. Augustine described seven stages in the advance to contemplation: the first three correspond to the natural levels of vegetative, sensitive, and rational life; the fourth is virtue or purification; the fifth is tranquility gained by controlling the passions; the sixth is entrance into divine light; and the seventh is the unitive or truly mystical stage. Pseudo-Dionysius, writing in the late fifth to early sixth century, introduced what became known as apophatic or negative theology, the approach that defines God by what God is not. His work On Mystical Theology became especially influential when it reached wider circulation in the ninth century, shaping Eastern Orthodox Christian thought and forming a counter-current in Western Christianity to the dominant cataphatic or positive theology.

• 4. Three Stages, Countless Paths

  ›

  Evagrius Ponticus, who lived from 345 to 399 AD, and Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite formalized the standard three-stage structure that Christian mystical practice would follow for centuries: first, catharsis or purification; second, theoria or illumination; and third, theosis or union with God. In the Western churches these became the purgative, illuminative, and unitive ways. In the Eastern churches they became prayer of the lips, prayer of the mind, and prayer of the heart. Purification is not merely ethical. In the Orthodox tradition, purification specifically refers to the cleansing of the nous, the faculty of inner perception or the "eye of the soul" as Matthew 6:22-34 calls it. With a purified nous, clear vision becomes possible; without it, one remains trapped in what Orthodox writers called prelest in Russian and plani in Greek, a state of spiritual delusion, or even somnolence, described as "awake sleep". Illumination leads to theoria proper: the vision of God, described as an uncreated light, a grace that the practitioner does not produce but receives. John Climacus, writing in the sixth to seventh century, laid out stages of hesychast practice in his influential Ladder of Divine Ascent, culminating in agape. Symeon the New Theologian, who lived from 949 to 1022, went further, claiming that direct experience of God gave monks the authority to preach and absolve sins without formal ordination. He met strong resistance from Church authorities for that claim. Union, the third stage, is described in the Eastern tradition as theosis or deification. A phrase attributed to Athanasius of Alexandria captures the logic: "God became human so that man might become god." According to John Romanides, this conviction that God can be directly experienced in this life is the very heart of the theological conflict between Eastern Orthodoxy and Western Christianity, where a greater emphasis on divine transcendence is seen to have produced the conclusion that God cannot be encountered before death.

• 5. The Spanish Mystics

  ›

  Teresa of Avila organized the mystical life with unusual precision. Jordan Aumann identifies nine grades of prayer in her writings, from vocal prayer through meditation and affective prayer to infused contemplation, the prayer of union, and finally the prayer of transforming union. The first four belong to what Aumann calls the predominantly ascetical stage; the remaining five belong to the mystical phase, in which prayer is infused rather than generated by human effort. One of her most discussed contributions is what she called the Prayer of Quiet, a form of contemplative prayer in which the soul experiences an extraordinary peace and rest while contemplating God as present. Teresa explained it through the image of four ways of watering a garden: the laborious drawing of water from a well represents discursive meditation, while a water-wheel and buckets represents the Prayer of Quiet as a more passive and grace-filled mode. The Prayer of Quiet belongs chiefly to what she called the Fourth Mansions in her work Interior Castle, the point where the soul begins to pass from active prayer to forms marked by divine initiative. Teresa warned strongly against abandoning the humanity of Christ in favor of abstract or purely imageless contemplation, a position that distinguished her from more purely apophatic approaches. Ignatius of Loyola's Spiritual Exercises, a 30-day retreat, pursued a different emphasis: using careful spiritual direction to open people to a receptive consciousness in which they experience God by understanding how the mind connects to the will. John of the Cross used the language of bridal mysticism and the two dark nights - the dark night of the senses and the dark night of the soul - to describe a process of renunciation in which the soul first abandons everything that blocks God, then endures the pain of feeling entirely separated from God, before ascending what he described as a 10-step ladder toward union. A more controversial figure was Miguel de Molinos, the leading apostle of Quietism. No suspicion arose against him until 1681, when the Jesuit preacher Paolo Segneri attacked his views in a publication called Concordia tra la fatica e la quiete nell' orazione. The matter was referred to the Inquisition. On the 3rd of September 1687, Molinos made public profession of his errors and was sentenced to life imprisonment. He died in prison in 1696 or 1697.

• 6. Protestant and Northern Traditions

  ›

  Martin Luther was a monk before he became a reformer, and his mystical formation left lasting marks. He was influenced by the German Dominican tradition of Eckhart and Tauler and by the Dionysian-influenced tradition known as Wesenmystik, or essence mysticism. He also published the Theologia Germanica, which he called the most important book after the Bible and Augustine for teaching him about God, Christ, and humanity. John Calvin took a sharply different posture, rejecting many medieval ascetic practices and favoring doctrinal knowledge over affective experience, but he too carried medieval influences through Jean Gerson and the Devotio Moderna. His notion that believers can begin to enjoy eternal salvation through earthly successes eventually generated what the source describes as "a mysticism of consolation" in later generations. The English tradition encompassed a striking range. Julian of Norwich, described as the first woman whose English writings survive, appears alongside Anglicans William Law, John Donne, and Lancelot Andrewes; Puritans Richard Baxter and John Bunyan, author of The Pilgrim's Progress; George Fox, the first Quaker; and John Wesley, cofounder of the Methodist movement. Sir Thomas Browne, a Norwich physician and scientist, exemplifies what the source calls "scientific reason lit up by mysticism." His Religio Medici is a self-portrait structured around the Christian virtues of Faith, Hope, and Charity, and his work The Garden of Cyrus carries the full title The Quincuncial Lozenge, or Network Plantations of the ancients, Naturally, Artificially, Mystically considered. In Germany, Johann Arndt's book True Christianity was popular among Protestants, Catholics, and Anglicans alike. Arndt influenced Philipp Jakob Spener, who formed a group called the collegia pietatis, or college of piety, which stressed spiritual direction among lay people. Spener's Pietism rejected both intellectualism and organized religion in favor of a personalized spirituality. A more rigorous strain ran through John Wesley, influenced by Zinzendorf, and through American preacher Jonathan Edwards, who restored to pietism Gerson's focus on obedience and drew from Origen and Gregory of Nyssa the idea that humans naturally yearn for God.

• 7. Practice and Its Boundaries

  ›

  Across traditions, the practical question has always been the same: what does a person actually do to prepare for or cultivate the presence of God? Saint John Cassian recommended the phrase "O God, make speed to save me: O Lord, make haste to help me" as a focus for continuous repetition. The Jesus Prayer - "Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner" - developed from an early training exercise for repose into the central practice of hesychasm, acquiring technical requirements and theological controversies in the Byzantine period. The author of The Cloud of Unknowing recommended a single monosyllabic word, such as "God" or "Love". In modern times, Thomas Keating popularized centering prayer, drawing on hesychasm and The Cloud of Unknowing. The distinction between meditation and contemplation is described by John of the Cross through an economic image: the difference between working and enjoying the fruit of work, between receiving a gift and profiting by it, between the toil of travelling and the rest at journey's end. The Oriental Orthodox monk Matta al-Miskin put it differently: meditation is an activity of the spirit, while contemplation is a spontaneous activity that follows to relieve the practitioner of all effort. Scholar Bernard McGinn argues that the authentic test Christianity has used to judge a mystic is not visions or phenomena but personal transformation - both in the mystic and, especially, in those the mystic has affected. Richard King raises a different concern: that locating mysticism in the psychological realm of personal experience excludes it from political questions such as social justice, making it a tool for accommodating individuals to the status quo rather than changing the world. Caroline Bynum's research shows that in the late Middle Ages, miracles attending the Eucharist served not merely as spiritual events but as proof of theological orthodoxy, demonstrating that a mystic had not fallen into heresy such as the Cathar rejection of matter. Mystical experience, in other words, has always been shaped by the cultural and theological pressures of its moment - never a purely interior affair between one soul and God.