Battle of Kiev (1941)

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Battle of Kiev produced what historians have called the largest encirclement in the history of warfare by number of troops. In the summer and autumn of 1941, a vast ring of German steel closed around the Soviet Southwestern Front in eastern Ukraine, trapping 452,700 soldiers, 2,642 guns and mortars, and 64 tanks in a pocket covering roughly 20,000 square kilometers. Only 15,000 of those soldiers escaped before the encirclement was sealed by the 2nd of October.

  Adolf Hitler called it "the biggest battle in the history of the world." Joseph Goebbels described it as "the greatest battle of annihilation of all time." The historian Evan Mawdsley called it the German Ostheer's "greatest triumph of the war in the East and the Red Army's greatest single disaster." These were not casual claims. The Southwestern Front suffered 700,544 casualties in total, including 616,304 killed, captured, or missing. Five armies, the 5th, 21st, 26th, 37th, and 38th, along with 43 divisions, were nearly annihilated.

  Yet the battle that bears Kiev's name had only a peripheral role for the city itself. The fight played out across a vast stretch of eastern Ukraine, driven by German decisions at the highest levels, Soviet command paralysis, and one of the most consequential strategic arguments of the entire war. How did a battle originally intended to secure bridgeheads on the Dnieper River grow into a catastrophe of this scale? And what does the fate of General Mikhail Kirponos, commander of the Soviet forces who died trying to break out, tell us about the men caught inside the pocket?

• 2. The Opening Moves

  ›

  Operation Barbarossa began on the 22nd of June 1941, and Army Group South, commanded by Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt, drove into Ukraine immediately. The plan called for this force to penetrate 650 kilometers into Soviet territory, reaching the Dnieper River in an enveloping movement that would cut off and destroy Soviet forces west of that line.

  The Soviet Southwestern Front under General Kirponos was actually the most powerful front in the western border region. It held four field armies, three mechanized corps in the front line, one in reserve, and two more in strategic reserve. Despite that strength, the Red Army's response to the initial German advance went badly from the start. On the 26th of June, Kirponos launched a massive armored counterattack on a 70-kilometer front involving more than 2,000 tanks, one of the largest tank engagements seen to that point. The inexperience of Soviet officers in coordinating so many armored vehicles at once led to the attack's failure and the destruction of much of the front's armored reserve.

  German forces captured Lutsk the same day and Lvov on the 30th of June. The Stalin Line, the Soviet fortified belt near the 1939 Soviet-Polish border, was broken by the 7th of July when the 11th Panzer Division reached Berdichev. Critically, German forces seized Zhitomir on the 8th of July, and the 13th Panzer Division of III Motorized Corps then drove a corridor all the way to the Irpen River, just 15 kilometers west of Kiev, by the 10th of July. That corridor, known as the "Zhitomir Corridor," opened the road to the city. At this point, Soviet mechanized corps had been stripped nearly bare: only a handful of BT, T-26, KV-1, and T-34 tanks remained across three corps that had started the campaign with far greater numbers.

• 3. Hitler's Fateful Pivot

  ›

  By early August, the question of whether to take Kiev or bypass it had fractured the German command. At 1am on the 10th of July, Generaloberst Franz Halder, chief of the German army general staff, phoned Army Group South headquarters and banned the use of panzer forces toward Kiev except for reconnaissance, reflecting Hitler's view that assaulting the city would "unnecessarily sacrifice" armored units.

  The debate was never fully resolved before a larger strategic shift changed everything. In early July, Army Group Center's advance had stalled after the Battle of Smolensk, and the Soviet 5th Army's persistent pressure from the Pripyat Marshes was holding the German 6th Army in place and creating an open flank stretching more than 250 kilometers. Hitler's Directive No. 33 on the 19th of July ordered that the Soviet forces must not escape across the Dnieper into the Russian interior. The left wing of Army Group South was to cooperate with the right wing of Army Group Center to eliminate the Soviet 5th Army.

  Then, on the 21st of August, Hitler ordered the German 2nd Army and Panzer Group 2, under Generaloberst Heinz Guderian, to drive south into Ukraine. This was a momentous decision that Guderian himself resisted. He had wanted to continue east toward Moscow. On the 23rd of August, Guderian met Hitler at Wolfschanze and was assured his panzer group would remain united. The next day, he learned the promise had already been contradicted by an Army High Command order splitting his group, and his request to reverse the order was rejected by Field Marshal Fedor von Bock. The pivot south was final.

• 4. Guderian's Drive South

  ›

  Guderian's Panzer Group 2 was in poor condition before it turned south. Out of 953 tanks at the start of Barbarossa, only 263 remained serviceable as of the 25th of July. The unit had lost roughly 20,000 men out of 113,000 and received only 10,000 replacements. Fuel and spare parts were constant crises, with the 4th Panzer Division down to just 44 operational tanks by the 22nd of August and the 3rd Panzer Division reduced to 60 tanks that same day.

  The advance depended on capturing bridges before they could be destroyed. On the morning of the 26th of August, the 3rd Panzer Division seized an 800-meter bridge across the Desna River at Novgorod-Seversky intact. Guderian later called this news "surprising and the most pleasant." Soviet forces counterattacked to retake the eastern bank the next day, and the Germans were pushed back before eventually repelling the assault. A second crossing was captured near Korop, 50 kilometers to the southwest.

  Gomel fell on the 21st of August after house-to-house fighting. About 50,000 Soviet soldiers were captured there. After Gomel, the Soviet 5th Army began retreating eastward from the Pripyat Marshes region, and the road deeper into Ukraine opened up. Guderian's supply columns were struggling to keep pace, moving at an average speed of only 12 kilometers per hour on poor roads. On the 19th of August, a fuel shortage forced General Leo Geyr von Schweppenburg, commander of the XXIV Motorized Corps, to inform Guderian that capturing Novozybkov was simply not feasible. The corps was resupplied by air on the 21st of August, and Starodub was taken the following day.

• 5. Stalin, Zhukov, and the Argument Over Kiev

  ›

  General Georgy Zhukov had foreseen the danger. On the 29th of July, he told Stalin plainly that the Gomel region was the Red Army's key strategic weakness, and that a German mechanized drive to the south could encircle the entire Southwestern Front. He recommended pulling back behind the Dnieper River and, when Stalin asked about Kiev, Zhukov said it could be abandoned.

  Stalin became upset and called Zhukov's words "worthless." Zhukov replied that if Stalin thought the Chief of the General Staff was talking nonsense, he should be dismissed and sent to the front. Stalin took him at his word, replacing Zhukov with Marshal Boris Shaposhnikov and sending Zhukov to command a reserve front. It was a costly exchange.

  By September, the strategic situation Zhukov had warned about was coming to pass. On the 11th of September, Marshal Semyon Budyonny, commander of the Soviet Southwestern direction, sent Stalin a telegram warning that only powerful reserves could prevent encirclement, reserves the front did not have. He requested permission to pull back 250 kilometers eastward to the Psyol River. Stalin refused, ordered Kirponos to hold Kiev, and forbade destruction of the bridges. On the 13th of September, Stalin replaced Budyonny with Marshal Semyon Timoshenko, but crucially did not authorize withdrawal. Timoshenko initially agreed to hold, believing reinforcements were coming, only to learn that the entire Bryansk Front had just 20 operational tanks across all its brigades.

• 6. Closing the Ring

  ›

  From the south, Panzer Group 1 crossed the Dnieper at a bridgehead near Kremenchuk, 280 kilometers southeast of Kiev, on the 31st of August. By the 11th of September, the 16th Panzer Division, under Major-General Hans-Valentin Hube as part of XLVIII Motorized Corps, began expanding southward. Rain, mud, and Soviet counterattacks slowed the advance, and Panzer Group 1's total strength had fallen to 331 tanks, representing 53 percent of its original force from the 22nd of June.

  The two German armored spearheads, one driving south from Guderian's group and one pushing north from Kleist's group, were converging on each other east of Kiev. The 14th Panzer Division reached Lubny, 30 kilometers north of Khorol, and seized 1,500 soldiers, 600 trucks, 70 cannons, and 3 aircraft from the Soviet 38th Army's supply lines. A small battle group from the 3rd Panzer Division, consisting of just three tanks, eight armored reconnaissance vehicles, six artillery pieces, and an anti-tank company, captured the city of Lokhvytsia and its bridge over the Sula River.

  At 18:00 on the 14th of September, a vanguard element of the 18th Panzer Division made contact with an engineer company of the 16th Panzer Division north of Lubny. On the 16th of September, the full connection between the 3rd and 16th Panzer Divisions was completed south of Lokhvytsia, 120 kilometers southeast of Kiev. All five Soviet armies of the Southwestern Front, the 5th, 21st, 26th, 37th, and 38th, were now inside the ring. Major General Vasily Tupikov, the Chief of Staff of the Southwestern Front, had sent a personal telegram to Shaposhnikov on the morning of the 14th of September that read: "The disaster has begun and will show itself to you in a few days." Shaposhnikov called him "panicky."

• 7. Death in the Pocket

  ›

  Inside the encirclement, Soviet forces made desperate attempts to break out. On the 18th of September, Red Army attacks from the east split the German defense and came within one kilometer of Romny, which was Guderian's own headquarters at that moment. Against two tank brigades, two rifle divisions, and cavalry, Guderian had only two battalions and anti-aircraft guns. He requested help from Panzer Group 1 and the SS Das Reich Division, whose arrival on the 19th of September and a counterattack by the 4th Panzer Division from the south prevented Romny from falling. Guderian moved his headquarters to Konotop regardless.

  Breakthroughs happened elsewhere along the ring, sometimes at devastating cost to the Germans. Forces east of Priyatin broke through the 35th Infantry Regiment of the German 25th Infantry Division entirely. On the morning of the 21st of September, attacks against the 239th Infantry Division's center surrounded the German 372nd Infantry Regiment. A German soldier described the confusion in his memoirs: "Often one does not understand who is surrounded; Bolsheviks or us!"

  Kirponos received a partial withdrawal authorization from Shaposhnikov on the night of the 17th of September, allowing him to leave Kiev but not to retreat to the Psel River. Before the order arrived, he had already on his own initiative ordered three of his armies to attack eastward to break out. He did not succeed. Trapped behind German lines, Kirponos was killed while trying to break out of the encirclement. Marshal Budyonny's forces, Marshal Timoshenko's forces, and Commissar Nikita Khrushchev managed to escape. The 5th, 37th, 26th, 21st, and 38th armies, comprising 43 divisions, were almost annihilated. The Southwestern Front would have to be rebuilt nearly from the ground up, just as the Western Front had been before it.