A Tolkien Compass

• 1. The First Fan-Organized Scholarship

  ›

  Open Court published A Tolkien Compass in 1975. This book stands as one of the earliest collections of academic essays dedicated to J.R.R. Tolkien's work. The editor Jared Lobdell assembled papers that originated from fan-organized conferences rather than university departments. Most contributors were academics who had been invited by fans to speak at these gatherings. The collection included a text called Guide to the Names in The Lord of the Rings for the first time. This document became widely available only through this specific publication. Before 1975, no other book had made these names accessible to the general public. The essays avoided Quellenforschung, which is the search for Tolkien's sources. Lobdell noted that this method was worthy of study but chose not to pursue it himself. The book contained eleven distinct essays covering various aspects of Middle-earth.

  9

• 2. An Age Of Innocence In Criticism

  ›

  Tom Shippey later described the era of these essays as an innocent time before professionalized Tolkien studies emerged. He argued that the writing possessed freshness and candor that could never be repeated today. The scholar noted that many predictions made before 1977 proved incorrect because they lacked knowledge of The Silmarillion. Shippey pointed out that some early scholars did not know Tolkien wrote much of The Lord of the Rings before the Second World War. Despite these errors, he stated that the collection offered historical depth unavailable in modern scholarship. David Bratman identified the volume as the first commercially published collection from the fan community. Jean MacIntyre regretted that scholars often ignored The Hobbit compared to his other novels. She praised A Tolkien Compass for taking the children's book seriously with two frequently consulted essays. These works by Bonniejean Christensen and Dorothy Matthews remain central to the field.

  41213

• 3. Jungian Archetypes And Character Shifts

  ›

  Dorothy Matthews applied a Jungian approach to analyze Bilbo Baggins in her essay titled The Psychological Journey of Bilbo Baggins. She suggested that Gandalf fits the Wise Old Man archetype while Gollum represents the Devouring Mother. Matthews observed that Bilbo sets out on his quest out of balance and far from integrated. Bonniejean Christensen focused on the fallen hobbit named Gollum who became fascinating after changes to the second edition. Her analysis highlighted chapter five called Riddles in the Dark where the riddle competition turned deadly serious. Christensen noted that Gollum becomes a far darker character when the story was updated to fit The Lord of the Rings. She found the immediate interest in this figure even apart from those specific revisions. The key changes made the encounter between Bilbo and Gollum much more dangerous than the original version.

  37

• 4. Fairy Tale Morality And Power Corrupts

  ›

  Walter Scheps argued that Tolkien's morality is radically different from our own and resembles fairy-tale traditions. He stated that nobility is inherited rather than acquired within Middle-earth. Scheps dismissed concerns about orcs being black or trolls working class as irrelevant to the moral framework. Agnes Perkins and Helen Hill examined what power does to those who possess it, specifically the One Ring. They concluded that the desire for power corrupts unequivocally. Their essay showed that Gandalf and Galadriel see the temptation but reject it while Saruman succumbs to it. Boromir tried to seize the Ring whereas Faramir understood the danger. Deborah Rogers argued that both Hobbits and Aragorn represent Man in her piece Everyclod and Everyhero. She noted that Tolkien wrote a letter in 1958 confessing he was in fact a hobbit himself. Rogers described Hobbits as small provincial and comfort-loving yet not John Bull English.

  56

• 5. Medieval Interlacing And Narrative Cycles

  ›

  Richard C. West demonstrated that The Lord of the Rings uses complex medieval organization where story threads are interwoven. He claimed this technique mirrors the perception of flux events happening at once around us. West noted that modern writers like James Joyce and Marcel Proust began experimenting with this same medieval structure again. David Miller analyzed the journey in the first volume as a sequence of nine cycles involving conference in tranquillity and blundering journeys. He identified specific dangers such as when the party ventured into the Old Forest. The group became entrapped by Old Man Willow only to be rescued by Tom Bombadil. Miller classified these events as unexpected aid following periods of entrapment. This picaresque structure includes there and back again novels like The Hobbit itself. The narrative pattern relies on these repeated cycles of danger and rescue throughout the text.

  711

• 6. The Scouring Of The Shire Without Magic

  ›

  Robert Plank examined Book six Chapter eight titled The Scouring of the Shire as a view of fascism. He stated that the outstanding characteristic of this chapter is that miracles do not happen. Laws of nature remain in full and undisputed force while actors in the drama are all human mortals. Plank found it surprising that Tolkien viewed the overthrow of a tyrannical government as quick and easy work. The chapter depicts Hobbits returning home victorious from their adventures like Odysseus to Ithaca. They must then scour their home of enemies without any fantasy intervention. Charles A. Huttar described Isengard as an industrial hell using quotes about tunneled dark deep places. He noted that the chapter stands apart from the rest of the novel because it lacks magic. The struggle here involves real people facing real consequences rather than mythical battles.

  68