Skip to content

A listener's guide to Middle-earth

·The HearLore team·rabbit-holes

Middle-earth began with an Oxford professor marking exams. One candidate had left a page blank, and Tolkien wrote a sentence on it without knowing why. "In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit." Then he had to work out what a hobbit was.

Middle-earth feels finished. It was built by hand, one name and one map at a time, by a man who kept changing his mind. Whether you know every appendix or only the films, hearing how it was made gives the books more room.

These twenty-seven stories start with how it was built and end with the people who fell for it.

The man and the first book

J. R. R. Tolkien, about eleven minutes. On his twenty-first birthday he proposed by letter to a woman who was already engaged to someone else. Three years later he was on the Somme, sending her a code of dots so she could follow his movements on a map.

The Hobbit, about eleven minutes. How that one sentence became a children's book. The publisher let his ten-year-old son decide whether to print it.

The Lord of the Rings, about twelve minutes. The overview. An editor at a rival publisher told Tolkien it "urgently wanted cutting." He refused. He wanted one book, and the three volumes were a financial precaution.

Constructing The Lord of the Rings, about nine minutes. The drafts, in which the hero was a hobbit called Bingo. After this one the finished book starts to look like a series of decisions.

The world under the story

Middle-earth, about ten minutes. Tolkien meant it as our own planet in an imagined past. He placed Hobbiton at the same latitude as Oxford.

Tolkien's maps, about ten minutes. Tolkien said he started with a map and made the story fit. This is one of the best entries here.

The Silmarillion, about fifteen minutes. The deep history behind everything else. It opens with a song that one rebel spirit tries to ruin, and the world grows out of that broken music.

Christopher Tolkien, about eight minutes. The son who edited his father's unfinished papers into a book in 1977. He later admitted he had to invent some passages himself. Hear this one straight after The Silmarillion.

Characters you already know

These work whether you met the characters on the page or on screen. There are more in the Lord of the Rings characters collection if you want to keep going.

Frodo Baggins, about nine minutes, and Samwise Gamgee, about ten. Do them as a pair. Tolkien called Sam, not Frodo, "the chief hero," and said Sam reflected the ordinary English soldiers he had served with in the First World War.

Gollum, about thirteen minutes. He starts as Sméagol, who kills a relative for a ring on his birthday. The rest of the entry is about what pity costs and what it saves.

Aragorn, about fifteen minutes. He began as a hobbit in wooden shoes, nicknamed Trotter. Few characters changed more on the way to the page.

The old stories underneath

Tolkien was a professor of Anglo-Saxon before he was a novelist. These entries show what he was reading.

Beowulf, about eighteen minutes. Tolkien translated the poem himself, and in a 1938 letter about The Hobbit he named it among his most valued sources.

Völsunga saga, about twelve minutes. A cursed ring kills every owner who holds it. Scholars see echoes of it in the One Ring, though Tolkien brushed off comparisons between his ring and older ones.

Kalevala, about twelve minutes. Finnish folk poetry, gathered by a country doctor on eleven trips through Karelia. Tolkien built one of his darkest tales on its story of Kullervo.

Elves in Middle-earth, about ten minutes. Old English medicine blamed elves for shooting sick horses. This story suggests Tolkien read that as a clue when he made his Elves archers.

Tengwar, about ten minutes. The Elvish script, designed so that the shapes show how each sound is made.

C. S. Lewis, about fifteen minutes. Tolkien's friend and Oxford colleague. This is where you meet the Inklings, the informal circle of friends that grew up around them.

Reading it closely

Themes of The Lord of the Rings, about twenty minutes. The longest entry in the guide. Most quests are about winning a treasure. Frodo carries his toward its destruction, and critics still argue over what that reversal means.

Poetry in The Lord of the Rings, about eleven minutes. The book has sixty-one poems. This entry makes the case for them, starting with a walking song that changes one word when Frodo sings it.

Women in The Lord of the Rings, about seventeen minutes. Eleven women appear in the book. Scholars still argue over Galadriel, Éowyn and Arwen, and this story lays out both sides fairly.

On screen

Adaptations of The Lord of the Rings, about nine minutes. The history before the famous one, from a 1950s BBC radio version Tolkien disliked to Ralph Bakshi's animated film in 1978.

Peter Jackson, about fifteen minutes. He saw King Kong on television at about nine and tried his own version a few years later, with a wire-and-rubber model. He first came to Tolkien through that Bakshi film.

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, about eleven minutes. Jackson pitched two films. New Line's chief, Robert Shaye, asked for three, and all of them were shot at once in New Zealand. Sean Connery was offered Gandalf and reportedly said he did not understand the plot.

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, about thirteen minutes. The ending. It won all eleven Oscars it was nominated for, including Best Picture.

The fans

Tolkien fandom, about fourteen minutes. Tolkien once called his fans a "deplorable cultus." They kept going anyway, from the cheap paperbacks of the 1960s counterculture to the early hacker culture of computing.

The Tolkien Society, about eight minutes. It began in 1969 with a small notice in a magazine, signed with a hobbit name.

Pacing it

Twenty-seven entries, roughly five and a half hours. A few weeks of walks, or one long weekend of chores.

Keep the order for the first two parts. The drafts and the maps change how you hear everything after them. After that, wander. The characters, the old sources and the films work in any order.

Tolkien never finished Middle-earth. He was still revising it when he died in 1973. Twenty-seven stories will not finish it for you either, and that is most of the pleasure.

Queue