Constructing The Lord of the Rings

• 1. Initial Conception And Development

  ›

  J. R. R. Tolkien began writing The Lord of the Rings in December 1937, shortly after his children's book The Hobbit became a success. He started with no clear idea of where the story would go or what characters would appear. By the 19th of December 1937, he had written a five-page draft which he called the first germ of the novel. In a letter to his publisher Stanley Unwin, Tolkien stated that he had written the first chapter about hobbits and an expected party. The original plan involved Bilbo using up his treasure and seeking another adventure. This early version lacked the One Ring as a central element. The story took an unpremeditated turn when Black Riders were introduced into the narrative by March 1938. Christopher Tolkien later identified this shift as the moment the true epic began to form.

  3

• 2. Hesitant Progress And Wartime Pauses

  ›

  Tolkien paused his work on the novel for nearly a year starting in August 1940 due to World War II and academic duties. He restarted writing in April 1941 and continued until making another break in 1942. During these pauses, he served as an examiner to earn extra income while holding a full-time academic position. The manuscript was effectively finished by 1946, but revision of earlier sections did not conclude until 1949. Between 1943 and 1944, Tolkien abandoned the project entirely before returning to rewrite the opening chapters. His son Christopher received chapters as they were written while serving with the Royal Air Force in South Africa. These interruptions created a fragmented development process spanning over ten years from start to publication.

  58

• 3. Structural Evolution And Plot Twists

  ›

  The narrative structure changed dramatically as Tolkien rewrote Book 3 and added major battles like Helm's Deep. Early drafts featured Gandalf fighting a Black Rider in Moria rather than a Balrog. By 1944, Tolkien introduced Saruman as a fallen wizard and expanded the Council of Elrond chapter significantly. The character Gollum evolved from a simple predator into a complex guide with split personality traits. Tolkien described this transformation as creating a good Smeagol angry with a bad Gollum. The final battle scenes involving Gondor's army entering Mordor were reworked extensively during 1946. Drafts of Mount Doom and the Tower of Kirith Ungol reached their final form only after multiple revisions between 1944 and 1947. Shippey notes that the wanderings of Frodo and Sam mirrored Tolkien's own frustrating writing process.

  17

• 4. Fluid Character Names And Identities

  ›

  Protagonist names shifted repeatedly throughout the writing process before settling on their final forms. By 1938, characters included Bingo who later became Frodo and Trotter who eventually transformed into Aragorn. Tolkien experimented with names like Angelica, Caramella, and Semolina for hobbit families while developing relationships. The name Trotter persisted even when the character had become fixed as the tall and long-legged Aragorn. Shippey criticizes how Tolkien defended an ill-sounding name in the final text by making it part of his royal line. Other early names included Odo, Vigo, and Marmaduke which appeared in poems from 1934. These fluid identities reflected Tolkien's delight in changing relations among hobbit-families without chopping them out completely.

  910

• 5. Linguistic Foundations And Map Making

  ›

  Tolkien drew maps to guide his storytelling rather than following a pre-existing outline or plot structure. His First Map underwent many modifications until Christopher redrew it as a large elaborate map in pencil and colored chalks during 1943. Shippey observes that inspiration followed substantial effort on practical materials like maps instead of appearing first. Invented languages such as Quenya and Black Speech formed the foundation of the narrative itself. Gandalf chants the Ring Verse in Black Speech creating a terrifying effect on listeners within the story. Tolkien believed untranslated elvish could do work that English language alone could not achieve. Placenames like Farthinghoe near Oxford inspired the concept of Shire's four farthings. Maps, names, and languages came before plot according to Tolkien's own explanation in letters.

  617

• 6. Artistic Drawings And Visual Design

  ›

  Tolkien updated drawings alongside text until descriptions felt correct for locations like Orthanc tower. The earliest versions showed the tower as round with multiple tiers and three small horns on top. Later drafts placed it on a cloven hill supported by a round arch before settling into four pyramidal horns made of bedrock. Drawing number five depicted the tower as composed entirely of four tall narrow almost pyramidal horns rising straight from level ground. These visual changes evolved considerably while writing chapters about Isengard and Saruman. Shippey notes that Tolkien elaborated character details through extensive rewriting rather than simple description. The final artwork shows black gleaming rock with sharp pinnacles resembling spear points or knives. This iterative process ensured both text and images matched perfectly before publication.

  4