Skip to content
— CH. 1 · DEFINING THE CRIME —

War crime

~5 min read · Ch. 1 of 6
6 sections
  • A U.S. soldier observed victims of the Malmedy massacre on the 17th of December 1944 in Belgium, where 84 American prisoners of war were murdered by Waffen-SS troops. This event illustrates a core category of war crimes: intentionally killing civilians or combatants who have surrendered. International humanitarian law defines these acts as serious violations that create individual criminal responsibility under international law. Examples include torture, taking hostages, and unnecessary destruction of civilian property. Deception through perfidy is also prohibited when it involves wearing enemy uniforms to infiltrate lines for assassination. Protocol I of the Geneva Conventions explicitly forbids attacking parachutists who eject from disabled aircraft after they surrender. Chemical and biological weapons remain banned under multiple arms control agreements. The rules distinguish between legitimate military objectives and attacks on non-combatants. When no justification exists for targeting civilians, proportionality analysis becomes irrelevant because the act itself is unlawful.

  • The Lieber Code appeared as General Order 100 on the 24th of April 1863 during the American Civil War. Franz Lieber wrote this document to define command responsibility for war crimes committed by Union Army soldiers fighting Confederate forces. The Hague Conventions followed in 1899 and 1907, establishing early formal statements about laws of war. These treaties created a framework for how sovereign states should conduct warfare against one another. The Geneva Conventions expanded over time with four related treaties adopted between 1864 and 1949. Every United Nations member state has ratified these conventions, making them universally accepted customary international law. Additional Protocols added in 1977 provided more detailed protections for persons and objects in modern conflicts. Some nations including the United States, Israel, India, Pakistan, Iraq, and Iran have not ratified all protocols. The fourth convention adopted in 1949 protected civilian persons during wartime based partly on earlier Hague provisions. This evolution shows how legal definitions grew from specific national codes into global standards.

  • Peter von Hagenbach became the first person tried for a war crime in 1474 before an ad hoc tribunal of the Holy Roman Empire. He was convicted and beheaded despite claiming he had obeyed superior orders because he failed to prevent criminal behavior by his soldiers. Modern concepts developed further under the Nuremberg trials which began after World War II ended. The London Charter published on the 8th of August 1945 defined crimes against peace alongside war crimes and crimes against humanity. The International Military Tribunal for the Far East convened on the 3rd of May 1946 to try Japanese leaders for Class A, B, and C crimes. Hermann Göring served as Commander-in-Chief of the Luftwaffe while facing prosecution at Nuremberg. William Calley later faced murder charges for his role in the My Lai massacre involving hundreds of Vietnamese villagers killed by U.S. soldiers. These tribunals established that individuals could be held criminally responsible regardless of their rank or position. The Tokyo Trial specifically addressed atrocities committed during the Second World War including the Nanjing Massacre.

  • The International Criminal Court came into being on the 1st of July 2002 located in The Hague for prosecuting war crimes committed from that date forward. Article 12 of the Rome Statute provides jurisdiction over citizens of non-contracting states if they commit crimes within territory belonging to state parties. Several nations including China, Russia, Israel, and the United States have criticized the court's authority. The United States participates only as an observer despite not ratifying the treaty. The ICC exercises jurisdiction when crimes form part of a plan or policy or occur as large-scale commissions. NATO pilots once hit the Chinese embassy in Belgrade without knowing it was civilian property according to information supplied by headquarters. The committee ruled aircrew involved should bear no responsibility since they received wrong target data from other agencies. States apply a clearly excessive standard to determine whether criminal violations occurred regarding collateral damage. This approach acknowledges that commanders must judge military necessity based on available information at the time rather than hindsight.

  • Russian President Vladimir Putin faces charges for illegal abduction of children from Ukraine during the invasion beginning in February 2022. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been accused of using starvation as warfare method during the Gaza conflict starting the 7th of October 2023. Former Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir carries three counts of genocide and war crimes related to fighting in Darfur region. Ratko Mladić was captured in Serbia in May 2011 and extradited to face trial in The Hague where he received life imprisonment. Radovan Karadžić arrested in Belgrade on the 18th of July 2008, was found guilty of genocide in Srebrenica with 40 years initially before life sentence on appeal. Charles Taylor served as Liberian President until his conviction in April 2012 for aiding crimes against humanity stretching from 2007 through March 2011. Joseph Kony leads the Lord's Resistance Army guerrilla group operating in Uganda who used child soldiers extensively. These cases demonstrate how international courts pursue leaders regardless of their official positions or national status.

Common questions

What happened during the Malmedy massacre on the 17th of December 1944 in Belgium?

84 American prisoners of war were murdered by Waffen-SS troops. This event illustrates a core category of war crimes involving intentionally killing civilians or combatants who have surrendered.

When did Peter von Hagenbach become the first person tried for a war crime?

Peter von Hagenbach became the first person tried for a war crime in 1474 before an ad hoc tribunal of the Holy Roman Empire. He was convicted and beheaded despite claiming he had obeyed superior orders because he failed to prevent criminal behavior by his soldiers.

Who wrote the Lieber Code that appeared as General Order 100 on the 24th of April 1863?

Franz Lieber wrote this document to define command responsibility for war crimes committed by Union Army soldiers fighting Confederate forces. The Lieber Code appeared as General Order 100 on the 24th of April 1863 during the American Civil War.

Where is the International Criminal Court located and when did it come into being?

The International Criminal Court came into being on the 1st of July 2002 located in The Hague for prosecuting war crimes committed from that date forward. Article 12 of the Rome Statute provides jurisdiction over citizens of non-contracting states if they commit crimes within territory belonging to state parties.

What charges does Russian President Vladimir Putin face regarding Ukraine?

Russian President Vladimir Putin faces charges for illegal abduction of children from Ukraine during the invasion beginning in February 2022. These actions constitute violations under international humanitarian law definitions of war crimes.