Thomas Cranmer

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Thomas Cranmer was born on the 2nd of July 1489 in the village of Aslockton in Nottinghamshire, England, a younger son from a modest gentry family with deep roots in Lincolnshire. Few could have predicted that this son of armigerous country squires would one day shape the language of an entire nation's worship, or that his final moments would become one of the most dramatic scenes in the history of English religion. On the 21st of March 1556, he stood at a pulpit in Oxford, reportedly about to read a prepared speech of submission. He deviated from the script entirely. He renounced his own recantations, declared the Pope to be "Christ's enemy, and Antichrist with all his false doctrine", and then thrust his right hand into the flames first, as punishment for having signed those recantations. His dying words echoed those of Saint Stephen, the first Christian martyr. What led a cautious Cambridge scholar, a reluctant diplomat, and an incremental reformer to that extraordinary end? The answers run through the corridors of royal power, the theological disputes of the Reformation, and the conscience of a man whose very human qualities of accommodation and principle were constantly in tension.

• 2. Cambridge and the King's Business

  ›

  At fourteen, two years after his father's death, Cranmer was sent to the newly created Jesus College, Cambridge. It took him eight years to earn his Bachelor of Arts degree, following a curriculum of logic, classical literature, and philosophy. Along the way he began collecting medieval scholastic books, a habit he maintained throughout his life. His marginal notes from this period reveal an early scepticism toward Martin Luther and a marked admiration for Erasmus. He received his Doctor of Divinity degree in 1526, and by 1520 had already been ordained a priest.

  A chance encounter during a plague outbreak in 1529 changed Cranmer's trajectory. Staying with relatives in Waltham Holy Cross to escape the sickness, he was joined by two Cambridge associates, Stephen Gardiner and Edward Foxe. Their conversations turned to the problem that consumed the English court: Henry VIII's desire to annul his marriage to Catherine of Aragon. Cranmer proposed a bold alternative to the legal impasse in Rome, suggesting that the question be put to university theologians across Europe. When Gardiner and Foxe brought the idea to Henry, the King was immediately interested.

  From that discussion, Cranmer was drawn into the royal machinery. A research team produced a document called the Collectanea satis copiosa, meaning "The Sufficiently Abundant Collections", marshalling historical and theological arguments that the King held supreme jurisdiction within his own realm. In January 1532, Cranmer was appointed resident ambassador at the court of Holy Roman Emperor Charles V. Travelling through the Lutheran city of Nuremberg, he witnessed the Reformation's effects firsthand. There he befriended the leading architect of the Nuremberg reforms, Andreas Osiander, and in July that year took the striking step of secretly marrying Osiander's wife's niece, Margarete. For a priest to take a wife rather than a mistress signalled a quiet but meaningful alignment with certain Lutheran principles.

• 3. The Archbishop and the Annulment

  ›

  While following Charles V through Italy, Cranmer received a royal letter dated the 1st of October 1532 informing him of his appointment as the new Archbishop of Canterbury, following the death of Archbishop William Warham. The news shocked London, where Cranmer had held only minor Church positions. The appointment had been secured by the Boleyn family, whose daughter Anne was being courted by Henry.

  Cranmer returned with urgency. Anne had already announced her pregnancy, and Henry had secretly married her on the 24th or the 25th of January 1533. The bulls authorising Cranmer's promotion arrived around the 26th of March, and he was consecrated as a bishop on the 30th of March in St Stephen's Chapel. On the 23rd of May, Cranmer pronounced Henry's marriage to Catherine contrary to the law of God. On the 28th of May he validated Henry and Anne's marriage. On the 1st of June he personally crowned Anne queen and placed in her hands the sceptre and rod. On the 7th of September Anne gave birth to Elizabeth, and Cranmer baptised the infant and acted as one of her godparents.

  His closeness to Anne did not shield him when political winds changed. On the 2nd of May 1536, Anne was sent to the Tower of London. The very next day Cranmer wrote to Henry expressing his doubts about the Queen's guilt. He visited Anne in the Tower on the 16th of May, heard her confession, and the following day pronounced the marriage null and void. Two days later Anne was executed, and Cranmer was among the few who publicly mourned her death.

• 4. Reforms, Rivals, and the Vicegerent

  ›

  Thomas Cromwell's appointment as vicegerent, the deputy supreme head of ecclesiastical affairs, effectively placed Cranmer in a junior position on matters of royal spiritual jurisdiction. Cranmer appeared to accept this arrangement without resentment, recognising that he lacked the political skill to outmanoeuvre even clerical opponents. Those confrontations were left to Cromwell.

  The result of this partnership was a carefully negotiated religious settlement embodied in the Ten Articles of 1536, the first attempt at defining the beliefs of the Henrician Church. The first five articles recognised only three of the former seven sacraments, showing reforming influence; the last five on images, saints, and purgatory placated traditionalists. Rival editorial corrections made by Cranmer and Cuthbert Tunstall, the conservative bishop of Durham, are still visible in two surviving early drafts.

  Also in 1536, the north of England erupted in the Pilgrimage of Grace, the most serious popular opposition to Henry's policies, with Cromwell and Cranmer as the primary targets of popular anger. Cranmer kept a low profile while the rebellion was quelled. The aftermath produced a new statement of belief, the Bishops' Book, first proposed in February 1537. Its influence on the King was limited, however; Henry was distracted by Jane Seymour's pregnancy and, after her death following the birth of the long-awaited male heir Edward, began annotating the Bishops' Book himself. Cranmer's responses to the King's amendments were far more confrontational than his colleagues', and his notes revealed unambiguous support for justification by faith alone and predestination. Henry was not persuaded, and a revised statement was not published until 1543 with the King's Book.

  By 1543, conservative clergymen in Kent had assembled a detailed dossier of Cranmer's alleged misdeeds dating back to 1541, the so-called Prebendaries' Plot. Henry, however, revealed the conspiracy to Cranmer himself, appointed him chief investigator, and as a personal gesture of trust gave the Archbishop his own ring. When the Privy Council arrested Cranmer at the end of November, the nobles found themselves blocked by that symbol of royal favour. The episode ended with two second-rank conspirators imprisoned and Stephen Gardiner's nephew, Germain Gardiner, executed.

• 5. The Book of Common Prayer

  ›

  When Edward VI came to the throne, the pace of reform accelerated. Initial meetings toward what would become the 1549 Book of Common Prayer were held at the former Chertsey Abbey and at Windsor Castle in September 1548. The membership of those meetings was balanced between conservatives and reformers, and the precise extent of Cranmer's personal composition within the book remains difficult for scholars to determine. Sources he drew on included the Sarum Rite, writings from Hermann of Wied, and several Lutheran sources including the work of Osiander and Justus Jonas.

  Cranmer had been rethinking eucharistic doctrine for years, influenced in part by a letter from Martin Bucer dated the 28th of November 1547, which denied the human real presence and condemned transubstantiation. He was also moved by an epistle brought from the Continent by the Italian reformer Peter Martyr, purportedly by John Chrysostom, which offered patristic support against the corporeal real presence. By the time Cranmer debated the Eucharist in the House of Lords between the 14th and the 19th of December 1548, he publicly declared that the Eucharistic presence was only spiritual.

  The Act of Uniformity 1549 backed the prayer book's publication and also legalised clerical marriage. Its use became compulsory on the 9th of June 1549. The response in Devon and Cornwall was immediate and violent. The region's population did not yet commonly speak English, and the rebels demanded the restoration of the Latin mass, the Six Articles, prayers for souls in purgatory, and the rebuilding of abbeys. Cranmer wrote a forceful rebuke to the King denouncing the rebellion, and on the 21st of July commandeered St Paul's Cathedral to publicly defend the new order. The only extant written sample of his preaching from his entire career survives in the form of a draft sermon from this episode, one he prepared in collaboration with Peter Martyr.

  The 1552 revision of the prayer book went further still. New words at the offering of bread and wine removed any sense of corporeal presence. Prayers for the dead were eliminated. Any remaining bread or wine was to be used by the curate afterward, again dissociating the elements from any notion of physical presence. A late intervention by John Knox, a Scots reformer who had impressed the regent John Dudley while preaching in Newcastle, nearly disrupted the final version. Knox objected to kneeling at communion. The Privy Council halted printing on the 27th of September 1552. On the 22nd of October the council decided to preserve the liturgy as written and append the so-called Black Rubric, clarifying that kneeling implied no adoration of the elements.

• 6. Trial, Recantation, and the Flames

  ›

  Mary I's accession in mid-July 1553 transformed Cranmer's situation. He had signed his support for the succession of Lady Jane Grey, Edward's Protestant cousin, and he stayed in England even as he urged others, including Peter Martyr, to flee. He made a public declaration repudiating rumours that he had authorised the use of the mass in Canterbury Cathedral, stating that the doctrine established under Edward was "more pure and according to God's word than any that hath been used in England these thousand years". The government treated this as sedition. He was summoned to the Star Chamber on the 14th of September 1553 and sent to the Tower.

  On the 13th of November 1553, Cranmer and four others were tried for high treason, found guilty, and condemned to death. He was also charged with heresy based on witness testimony about his writings and conduct. On the 8th of March 1554, the Privy Council ordered his transfer to Bocardo prison in Oxford to await a second trial for heresy. He remained there for seventeen months before the trial opened on the 12th of September 1555. The trial operated under papal jurisdiction, with the final verdict to come from Rome. Latimer and Ridley were condemned almost immediately and burned at the stake on the 16th of October. Cranmer was taken to a tower to watch. On the 4th of December, Rome deprived him of the archbishopric and authorised the secular authorities to proceed.

  What followed was a collapse and then a reversal that defined his legacy. On the 11th of December, he was removed from prison and placed in the house of the Dean of Christ Church, treated as an academic guest rather than a condemned criminal. A Dominican friar named Juan de Villagarcía debated him on papal supremacy and purgatory. Between the end of January and mid-February 1556, Cranmer produced four recantations, submitting to the authority of the king and queen and recognising papal headship. On the 14th of February he was formally degraded from holy orders and returned to Bocardo. A fifth statement issued on the 26th of February went further, repudiating all Lutheran and Zwinglian theology and fully embracing Catholic doctrine including transubstantiation. He received sacramental absolution and participated in the mass. His last recantation, described in the source as a sign of a broken man, was issued on the 18th of March.

  Mary had decided, against canonical practice that would have absolved a recanting heretic, to proceed with execution on the treason charge established by parliament. At the pulpit on the 21st of March 1556, Cranmer opened with prayer and an exhortation to obey the king and queen, then abandoned his prepared text entirely. He renounced every recantation he had written or signed, stated that his hand would be punished by burning first, called the Pope "Christ's enemy, and Antichrist with all his false doctrine", and was dragged from the pulpit. As the flames rose, he thrust his right hand into the fire, calling it "that unworthy hand". His last words, "Lord Jesus, receive my spirit. I see the heavens open and Jesus standing at the right hand of God", were the same words attributed to Saint Stephen, the first Christian martyr.

• 7. Legacy in Language and Worship

  ›

  The Marian government circulated a pamphlet containing all six recantations alongside the prepared speech Cranmer never delivered. It did not mention his public withdrawal. What had actually happened became common knowledge quickly, undercutting the propaganda effort. Protestant exiles faced their own difficulty in publicising the story given how much ground Cranmer had conceded. John Foxe resolved the problem by putting Cranmer's story to effective use in 1559, and it appeared prominently in his Acts and Monuments when that work was first printed in 1563.

  When Elizabeth I came to power in 1558, the church she restored was essentially a snapshot of the Edwardine church as it had stood in September 1552. The Elizabethan prayer book was Cranmer's 1552 edition, minus only the Black Rubric. In the Convocation of 1563, the Forty-two Articles, which Cranmer had overseen but which were never formally adopted by the Church, were revised in their eucharistic sections to form the Thirty-nine Articles, an Anglican statement of faith that endures to this day.

  Cranmer's wife Margarete survived him. She escaped to Germany around the time of Mary's accession and eventually married Cranmer's favourite publisher, Edward Whitchurch. The couple returned to England after Mary's reign and settled in Surrey. Whitchurch died in 1562 and Margarete married a third time, to Bartholomew Scott, before her own death in the 1570s. Both of Cranmer's children died without issue and his direct line became extinct.

  The Church of England commemorates Cranmer as a Reformation Martyr on the 21st of March, the anniversary of his death, with an annual remembrance held by the Prayer Book Society at a paving cross in Broad Street, Oxford, marking the supposed site of the burning. His Book of Common Prayer has guided Anglican worship for four hundred years, and his prose is recognised as a shaping force in the development of the English language itself.