Purgatory
The word purgatory entered English via Anglo-Norman and Old French, appearing as a noun perhaps only between 1160 and 1180. Before this specific term emerged, Latin adjectives like purgatorius described cleansing fire without naming a place. The concept predates the Catholic tradition itself, tracing back to early Jewish prayers for the dead that assumed an afterlife purification process. Christians adopted these practices from the beginning, presupposing assistance between death and final abode. The deuterocanonical book 2 Maccabees provided scriptural support for this belief within Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, and Oriental Orthodox canons. Protestants and major branches of Judaism regard this text as apocryphal, creating a foundational divide in interpretation.
Jacques Le Goff attributes the birth of Purgatory as a third other-world domain to Paris intellectuals and Cistercian monks around 1170 or 1180. This shift coincided with the composition of Tractatus de Purgatorio Sancti Patricii, an account by an English Cistercian about a knight visiting a cave on Station Island in Lough Derg, Ireland. A fresco in the Convent of San Francisco in Todi, Umbria, Italy, painted around 1345, depicts souls tormented by demons and fire within separate openings of a rocky hill. The Second Council of Lyon in 1274 defined the teaching for the first time, stating some saved souls need purification after death and benefit from prayers offered by the living. The Council of Florence (1431, 1449) repeated these points while excluding notions of fire and place that Eastern Orthodox representatives opposed. Pope John Paul II later clarified in 1999 that the term indicates a condition of existence rather than a physical location.
The Catholic Church teaches that all who die in God's grace but remain imperfectly purified undergo a process called Purgatory to achieve holiness necessary for heaven. Fire has never been included in the official doctrine, though speculation about it remains traditional based on New Testament passages like 1 Corinthians 3:12-15. Thomas Aquinas considered it probable that Purgatory was situated close to hell so the same fire tormenting the damned might cleanse the just souls. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, future Pope Benedict XVI, described it as an inwardly necessary transformation where a person becomes capable of Christ and unity with saints. Catherine of Genoa reframed the theology as voluntary, loving, and even joyful between 1447 and 1510. Indulgences open the treasury of merits of Christ and saints to obtain remission of temporal punishments due for sins.
Eastern Orthodox churches acknowledge an intermediate state after death before final judgment but reject the term Purgatory and the notion of purification by fire. They believe souls are judged immediately after death, entering either light and rest or a direful condition depending on their faith. John Calvin wrote that spirits return to God while resting in hope of blessed Resurrection, rejecting any external purgatorial punishment. The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion condemned the Romish Doctrine concerning Purgatory as vainly invented and repugnant to Scripture. Martin Luther stated that prayers for the dead do not justify ex opere operato, though he did not prohibit all prayer for the departed. C.S. Lewis found good reasons to doubt the popular picture of devils torturing souls, preferring Newman's vision of suffering as part of purification.
Dante Alighieri's Divine Comedy transformed theological concepts into enduring images of fire and suffering through his poem Purgatorio written in the fourteenth century. Dante pictured Purgatory as an island at the antipodes of Jerusalem pushed up by Satan's fall from the center of the globe. The cone-shaped island features seven terraces where souls ascend cleansed from the seven deadly sins toward the Garden of Eden at the summit. A 16th-century painting shows Dante gazing at this mountain structure with companions observing willing souls gathering round a sweet-smelling tree. Le Goff declared Dante's poetry made a decisive contribution to fixing this third place in public imagination after its recent birth. C.S. Lewis later used similar allegorical structures in works like The Great Divorce to explore opportunities for souls to choose salvation or remain lost.
Jewish tradition describes Gehenna as a place of purification where most sinners spend up to twelve months before release according to R. Akiba's opinion. Mandaean cosmology requires souls to pass through multiple ma tarta watch-stations before reaching the World of Light. Islam conceptualizes Jahannam as a temporary place for Muslim sinners that would cease to exist when the last repentant sinner is purified. Hinduism views naraka as a realm related to punishment for moral impure deeds functioning more like a prison than traditional Christian hell. Zoroastrian eschatology teaches the wicked will get purified in molten metal rather than eternal fire. These diverse traditions share concepts of postmortem purification short of everlasting damnation without adopting the specific Catholic doctrine of Purgatory.
Continue Browsing
Common questions
When did the word purgatory enter English language?
The word purgatory entered English between 1160 and 1180 via Anglo-Norman and Old French. Before this specific term emerged, Latin adjectives like purgatorius described cleansing fire without naming a place.
What defined the teaching of purgatory at the Second Council of Lyon in 1274?
The Second Council of Lyon in 1274 defined the teaching for the first time stating some saved souls need purification after death. The council stated these souls benefit from prayers offered by the living.
How does Catholic doctrine describe the nature of purgatory today?
Pope John Paul II clarified in 1999 that the term indicates a condition of existence rather than a physical location. The Catholic Church teaches that all who die in God's grace but remain imperfectly purified undergo a process called Purgatory to achieve holiness necessary for heaven.
Why do Eastern Orthodox churches reject the term purgatory?
Eastern Orthodox churches acknowledge an intermediate state after death before final judgment but reject the term Purgatory and the notion of purification by fire. They believe souls are judged immediately after death entering either light and rest or a direful condition depending on their faith.
When did Dante Alighieri write his poem Purgatorio?
Dante Alighieri wrote his poem Purgatorio during the fourteenth century. His work transformed theological concepts into enduring images of fire and suffering through this poem.