Martin Bucer

• 1. From Monk To Reformer

  ›

  Martin Bucer was born on the 11th of November 1491 in Sélestat, a free imperial city within the Holy Roman Empire. His father and grandfather worked as coopers who crafted barrels for trade. He entered the Dominican Order as a novice after completing his studies at a prestigious Latin school in the summer of 1507. A year later he became an acolyte in the Strasbourg church of the Williamites before taking full vows as a friar. By 1510 he had been ordained as a deacon and by 1515 he studied theology in Heidelberg. The course changed everything when Johannes von Staupitz invited Martin Luther to argue his theology at the Heidelberg Disputation in April 1518. Bucer met Luther for the first time during this event and wrote a long letter to his mentor Beatus Rhenanus about what he learned. He largely agreed with Luther's Ninety-five Theses and saw concord between Luther and Erasmus. This meeting posed risks so he asked Rhenanus to ensure his letter did not fall into wrong hands. He even wrote his will which contained an inventory of his books including major works by Thomas Aquinas. In early 1519 he received his baccalaureus degree and stated his theological views in a disputation revealing his break from scholasticism. A fellow Dominican named Jacob van Hoogstraaten tried to prosecute humanist scholar Johann Reuchlin and planned to target Bucer next. On the 11th of November 1520 Bucer told Wolfgang Capito that Hoogstraaten threatened to make an example of him. To escape jurisdiction Capito helped annul his monastic vows on the 29th of April 1521. For two years Franz von Sickingen protected him while he worked as chaplain to Frederick brother of Elector Ludwig V. He lived in Nuremberg where he met Willibald Pirckheimer and Andreas Osiander. In September 1521 he accepted Sickingen's offer to become pastor at Landstuhl moving there in May 1522. That summer he married Elisabeth Silbereisen who was a former nun.

• 2. Strasbourg Liturgical Changes

  ›

  Bucer arrived in Strasbourg on the 13th of May 1523 after fleeing Wissembourg where he had been excommunicated for attacking traditional church practices. The city council under Matthew Zell allowed him to work as an unofficial chaplain before appointing him pastor of St Aurelia's Church on the 24th of August 1523. A month later the council granted him citizenship joining a team including Wolfgang Capito and Caspar Hedio. Hostility reached a boiling point when Conrad Treger denounced reformist preachers as heretics on the 5th of September 1524. Angry mobs broke into monasteries looting religious images and arresting opponents like Treger. Bucer drafted twelve articles summarizing Reformation teachings including justification by faith while rejecting the Mass and Catholic concepts such as purgatory. His book Grund und Ursach published in December 1524 attacked the idea of the Mass as sacrifice and rejected liturgical garments. It also acknowledged the introduction of congregational German hymn singing in the city. By May 1525 liturgical reforms were implemented in parish churches though the council allowed masses to continue in the cathedral and collegiate churches. On the 20th of February 1529 Strasbourg officially joined the Reformation suspending all mass practice. Two preaching services per Sunday replaced it in all parish churches. On the 5th of January 1530 the council systematically removed images and side altars from churches after joining the Christian Confederation. Special wardens chosen from laity supervised doctrine and practice to instill moral discipline amid rising refugee populations. The synod convened on the 3rd of June 1533 at the Church of the Penitent Magdalens debating sixteen articles on church doctrine which they accepted fully. Sectarian leaders faced questioning with Caspar Schwenckfeld leaving voluntarily while Melchior Hoffman's followers seized power in Münster causing fear. On the 4th of March 1534 the council made Bucer's Tetrapolitan Confession official church statements requiring Anabaptists to subscribe or leave.

• 3. Mediating Doctrinal Divides

  ›

  Beginning in 1524 Bucer concentrated on the eucharist dispute dividing Luther and Zwingli over whether Christ's body was physically present in bread and wine. By late 1524 he abandoned corporeal real presence accepting Zwingli's interpretation that Christ's blood was made present by the Holy Spirit. He proposed a formula in his Apologia published in March 1526 hoping different scriptural understandings could coexist if both sides held child-like faith. This outraged Wittenberg theologians who rejected his interpolations into translations of Luther and Bugenhagen. In 1528 Luther published a treatise detailing sacramental union prompting Bucer to respond with a dialogue between two merchants where the Strasbourg supporter won. Luther harshly rejected this interpretation claiming no agreement existed despite Bucer noting both believed in spiritual presence. The Marburg Colloquy of October 1529 ended in failure when Luther refused compromise on real presence stating they did not share one spirit. Bucer wrote of disappointment at doctrinal inflexibility the following year. At the Diet of Augsburg in 1530 Philipp Melanchthon prepared the Augsburg Confession which Wittenberg theologians rejected without an article on the Lord's Supper. Bucer countered with the Tetrapolitan Confession adopted by four southern German cities including Strasbourg. It used ambiguous wording stating true body and blood were truly given as food for souls remaining in them. Charles V decreed all reformers must reconcile or face military force prompting meetings in Coburg and Ulm. By February 1531 the Protestant Schmalkaldic League formed with Strasbourg joining based on the Tetrapolitan Confession. Zwingli ended their friendship on the 21st of February 1531 due to political ties with Saxony and partial support for Luther. In December 1534 Bucer and Melanchthon held talks in Kassel drafting ten theses accepted by Wittenberg. A meeting moved to Wittenberg began on the 21st of May 1536 where Luther demanded recantation before Johannes Bugenhagen formulated a compromise distinguishing unworthy from unbelievers receiving Christ. The Wittenberg Concord signed on the 28th of May 1536 allowed south Germans to accept that unworthy receive Christ while leaving unanswered what unbelievers receive.

• 4. The Augsburg Compromise

  ›

  With the onset of the Schmalkaldic War in 1546 Protestants gradually retreated within the Empire. On the 21st of March 1547 Strasbourg surrendered to imperial forces ending most resistance after the Battle of Mühlberg. Charles V overruled reform efforts at the Diet of Augsburg which sat from September 1547 to May 1548 producing the provisional Augsburg Interim imposing Catholic rites throughout the Empire. To make it acceptable Charles needed a leading reformer to endorse it selecting Bucer. He arrived in Augsburg on his own volition on the 30th of March 1548 announcing willingness to ratify changes but negotiations had passed. When he refused house arrest followed on the 13th of April and close confinement shortly after. On the 20th of April he signed the Interim and was immediately freed despite continuing attacks on Catholic rites upon returning to Strasbourg. On the 2nd of July he published a confessional statement calling for repentance defending reformed principles outlined in twenty-nine articles though Charles ordered all copies destroyed. Tension grew as merchants left fearing clashes with imperial forces. On the 30th of August guild officials voted overwhelmingly to begin introducing the Interim. Even after Konstanz accepted it Bucer called for unconditional rejection. Plans for implementation began in January 1549 when Bucer produced memoranda preserving Protestant faith under directives. With no support remaining he and Fagius were dismissed on the 1st of March 1549 leaving Strasbourg as a refugee on the 5th of April.

• 5. Exile And English Reforms

  ›

  Bucer received offers from Melanchthon and Calvin but accepted Thomas Cranmer's invitation arriving in London on the 25th of April 1549 with Fagius. He took the position of Regius Professor of Divinity at Cambridge while his wife Wibrandis joined him in September followed by her stepdaughter Agnes Capito. The following year Wibrandis arranged for her children and elderly mother to come to England. In June 1550 another conflict arose when John Hooper refused traditional vestments for consecration creating division between Cranmer and reformers like Martyr and Laski. Bucer tried staying out arguing more important issues existed such as lack of pastors and pastoral care though Hooper remained imprisoned until accepting demands. On the 21st of October 1550 Bucer worked on a major treatise called De Regno Christi giving it as draft to friend John Cheke. It urged Edward VI to control the English Reformation proposing fourteen laws covering ecclesiastical and civil matters including deacons caring for the poor. He described marriage as a social contract permitting divorce an idea considered too advanced then advocating restructuring economic systems improving industry agriculture and education. His ideal society was authoritarian emphasizing Christian discipline though never printed in England appearing instead in Basel in 1557. His last contribution involved revising the original 1549 Book of Common Prayer submitting responses on the 5th of January 1551 calling for simplification removing non-essential elements like genuflections and private masses.

• 6. Death And Posthumous Trials

  ›

  Bucer's time in England suffered from illnesses including rheumatism coughs and intestinal ailments suggesting severe tuberculosis. Symptoms included vomiting shivering and sweating causing his health to break down in February 1551. On the 22nd he dictated additions to his will naming Walter Haddon and Matthew Parker executors commending loved ones to Cranmer thanking stepdaughter Agnes Capito. He died on the 28th of February after encouraging those near him to realize his vision expressed in De Regno Christi at age 59. Buried in Great St Mary's church before university professors and students his wife Wibrandis received significant inheritance including household and large book collection returning to Basel where she died on the 1st of November 1564. When Mary I came to throne she had Bucer and Fagius tried posthumously for heresy restoring Catholicism by disintering caskets burning remains along with copies of books. On the 22nd of July 1560 Elizabeth I formally rehabilitated both reformers marking original grave location with brass plaque. No Buceran denomination emerged though Anglicans Puritans Lutherans and Calvinists claimed him as their own due to adaptable theology criticized as too accommodating. His theology proved practical and pastoral rather than theoretical focusing on winning opponents over through discussion instead of staking doctrinal claims per se.