Keith Raniere

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Keith Raniere was addressed by his followers as Vanguard, and for twenty years he led a company in Albany, New York, called NXIVM. The company sold personal development seminars. From 1998 to 2018 it drew 700 members at its height, among them celebrities and wealthy people. Scholars in religious studies, law and sociology describe NXIVM as a cult. Raniere is now a convicted felon. How did a seminar business grow into something a federal court would treat as a criminal enterprise? What did a man with a record of failed ventures offer that persuaded powerful people to follow him? And why did so many of the people harmed around him go unheard for so long? This documentary follows those questions through his youth, his company, his secret inner society and the courtroom.

  168911

• 2. Early Years and Failed Ventures

  ›

  Keith Allen Raniere was born on the 26th of August 1960 in Brooklyn, the only child of James Raniere, an advertising executive, and Vera Oschypko, a ballroom-dancing instructor. The family moved to Suffern, New York, when he was five, and his parents separated when he was eight. He began high school at Suffern High School, then transferred to Rockland Country Day School and graduated in June 1978.

  As an adult, Raniere said he read Isaac Asimov's novel Second Foundation at age 12. The book is about mind control, and he credited it with inspiring his later work in NXIVM. In 1982 he graduated from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute with a 2.26 grade point average, barely passing and failing many classes. He then worked as a computer programmer for the New York State Division of Parole.

  Barbara Bouchey, a former partner, later described a conversation with Raniere's father. According to her, James said the family had told Keith how gifted he was, and that it was like a switch went off overnight. She said the father believed his son began to see himself as superior to everyone else, almost a deity. She also relayed that Vera heard from dozens of young girls calling the house. Raniere, Vera felt, told each one the same thing: "I love you. You're the special one."

  In June 1988 the Albany Times Union profiled Raniere because of his membership in the Mega Society. He had earned entry with a high score on the MEGA test, an unsupervised, 48-question quiz published in the April 1985 issue of Omni magazine. The test has been widely criticized as never properly validated. Even so, the 1989 edition of the Guinness Book of World Records called the society the most exclusive ultrahigh IQ society. A 1989 Australian edition named Raniere, Marilyn vos Savant and Eric Hart as its highest scorers.

  Throughout the 1980s Raniere was involved with the multi-level marketing company Amway. In 1990 he founded a similar business, Consumers' Buyline Inc., known as CBI, a buying club that offered discounts in exchange for recruiting new members. At a CBI pitch meeting he met Toni Natalie, who became a top seller with her then-husband. Natalie and Raniere dated for the next eight years.

  By 1993 CBI was declining, and regulators in twenty states had opened investigations. New York State sued, alleging that CBI was a pyramid scheme. In 1994 Raniere started National Health Network, a multi-level seller of vitamins, and it failed three years later. In 1996 he signed a consent order and agreed, without admitting wrongdoing, to a $40,000 fine. He paid only $9,000, saying he could not afford more, despite having claimed a multimillion-dollar net worth. The order also permanently barred him from promoting a chain distribution scheme. Decades later, a civil lawsuit and a federal prosecutor would use similar language about his next venture.

  2528333436

• 3. Building NXIVM

  ›

  Toni Natalie met a nurse named Nancy Salzman in 1998. Salzman practiced hypnotism and neuro-linguistic programming, and Natalie asked her for help with a boyfriend whose hours and ideas had grown erratic. Natalie recalled that Salzman called him a sociopath. Four days after meeting Raniere, Natalie said, Salzman returned with glazed eyes and told her she did not know who he really was.

  Raniere and Salzman then founded Executive Success Programs, a personal-development company offering techniques for self-improvement. A few years later it was rebranded as NXIVM. Raniere took the title Vanguard from a favorite arcade game, one in which destroying enemies increased the player's own power.

  The teachings of NXIVM were a patchwork. The group borrowed from Ayn Rand, one of Raniere's favorite authors, including her idea of "parasites." It took the word "suppressives" from L. Ron Hubbard. Other threads came from Milton Erickson's hypnosis, Isaac Asimov's science fiction, Rudolf Steiner, Tony Robbins and neuro-linguistic programming. NXIVM also folded in elements of multi-level marketing and practices from judo, including colored cloth to mark rank and ritual bowing.

  In 2002 Raniere and Salzman recruited members of the Bronfman family, heirs to the multibillion-dollar Seagram fortune. Sara Bronfman joined first, followed by her sister Clare. Their father, Edgar Bronfman Sr., took a NXIVM course the following year.

  From January 2005 until late 2007, Raniere lost nearly $70 million trading commodities. Bouchey spent $1.6 million covering losses on trades he had made in her name. Raniere suggested to Clare Bronfman that market manipulation by her father explained the losses. Beginning in August 2005 the Bronfman sisters covered the shortfalls, and they ultimately put in $150 million of their own funds. The group would next chase something money alone could not buy, the public blessing of a famous spiritual leader.

  145485551

• 4. Reputation Under Pressure

  ›

  In October 2003 Raniere appeared on the cover of Forbes magazine, his face cloaked in shadow, under the label "The World's Strangest Executive Coach." The story, titled "Cult of Personality," was written by Michael Freedman. It examined his self-chosen title and the collapse of CBI. It also quoted Edgar Bronfman accusing the organization of being a cult. One later description called it "a gold mine of previously unpublished information."

  Vanity Fair reported that NXIVM's leaders were stunned. Raniere, Salzman and Sara Bronfman had all spoken to Forbes expecting a flattering profile. What upset them most were Edgar Bronfman's remarks. One anonymous source told Vanity Fair that this was when Edgar became NXIVM's enemy. A witness at Raniere's trial later testified that group members compromised Edgar's computer and monitored his emails for years.

  Eager to shake off the negative attention, NXIVM members spent $2 million seeking the endorsement of the 14th Dalai Lama. On the 6th of May 2009 he traveled to Albany to give a talk, and onstage he presented Raniere with a white scarf. He also wrote the foreword to The Sphinx and Thelxiepeia, a book Raniere co-authored in 2009 after publishing Odin and The Sphinx the year before. Eight years later it emerged that Sara Bronfman had a sexual relationship in 2009 with Lama Tenzin Dhonden, the Dalai Lama's gatekeeper, who arranged the visit and had taken a vow of celibacy as a monk. Amid accusations of corruption, Dhonden was replaced.

  Also in 2009, a group of associates known as the NXIVM Nine, including Bouchey, broke with the organization. They cited unethical practices and the alleged abuse of his leadership status to sexually manipulate women. In November 2010 Vanity Fair published "The Heiresses and the Cult," in which Toni Natalie said Raniere had made her keep her dead puppy in the garage freezer and look at it daily. A 2010 Times Union article quoted former coaches describing students as "prey" for Raniere.

  Kristin Keeffe, a longtime partner of Raniere and the mother of his first child, left in February 2014. Reports in 2010 had said the boy was kept from other children and cared for by nannies who spoke five languages. After she fled the Albany area with her son, an email under her name said Raniere had been experimenting on him. In 2015 she alleged that Raniere had directed a Canadian investigative firm, Canaprobe, to gather financial information on six federal judges, a United States senator, and a reporter, an editor and the publisher of the Times Union. She also alleged a plan to lure critics to Mexico with an anti-cult conference invitation, where a bribed local judge would have them arrested on false charges. At his sentencing she said he had never paid child support.

  In 2015 Raniere also sued AT&T and Microsoft, claiming they had infringed his patents. The case was dismissed with prejudice the next year. The trial court cited a "pattern of obfuscation and bad faith," pointing to his untruthful testimony, and ordered him to pay $450,000 in attorneys' fees. Meanwhile, accusations about his treatment of women, some reaching back decades, were reaching the press.

  4276566966

• 5. Allegations of Abuse

  ›

  Toni Natalie's relationship with Raniere ended in 1999, and she later said she was harassed afterward. In January 2003 federal judge Robert Littlefield wrote that one lawsuit "smacks of a jilted fellow's attempt at revenge or retaliation against his former girlfriend, with many attempts at tripping her up along the way." In 2011 Natalie filed documents in federal court alleging that Raniere had repeatedly raped her.

  A 2012 Times Union investigation reported that Raniere had three sexual relationships with girls under the age of consent in the 1980s and 1990s. Reporters spoke to the girls and their families. One woman said she met him in 1990, when she was 12 and he was 30. He offered to tutor her, her mother worked for CBI, and his live-in partner Pamela Cafritz hired her to walk their dog. She said the tutoring was a pretext for more than sixty sexual encounters over several months, ending around 1991. In 1993 she received counseling and filed a report with the New York State Police. It was never forwarded to prosecutors because she declined to wear a wire to get a confession.

  In the 2019 criminal case, prosecutors described a different pattern. Starting in 2002, they said, Raniere gained a Svengali-like hold over a Mexican family that moved from Monterrey to the NXIVM community in Albany. Three sisters from the family eventually became his sexual partners. Marianna, the eldest, is the mother of his second biological child. Daniela, the middle sister, testified that she was groomed as a minor and that a sexual relationship began days after her 18th birthday. Camila, the youngest, said the abuse began in 2005, when she was 15. Prosecutors established that he impregnated each sister at various times and compelled them to have abortions. Daniela testified that Cafritz coached them to avoid answering paternity questions, so no nurse who was a mandated reporter would learn of it.

  Daniela told the court that Raniere claimed mystical powers and said sex could help people grow spiritually and fix "disintegrations." Beginning in 2010 she was confined to a bedroom in her family home for two years, on the pretext that she had stolen money. She maintained it began after she told Raniere she had feelings for another man. He accused her of an "ethical breach" and assigned Salzman to help her learn from her mistakes. The room had blacked-out windows, a mattress on the floor, a pen and paper. Only Salzman was allowed to speak to her, and relatives were told to shun her.

  The confinement ended in 2012, after Daniela nearly attempted suicide and instead decided to leave. She went to a volleyball game to confront Raniere, who tried to hide. She was later escorted out of the community and left at the border between the United States and Mexico with less than $80 and no personal documents. At the trial Salzman corroborated the account, admitting that she and others had been "incredibly abusive." Salzman added that Raniere told her to ignore Daniela's letter begging to be let out, calling it a tantrum.

  Camila did not testify, but prosecutors built their case about her from Daniela's testimony, hospital records, explicit photographs found in his home and WhatsApp messages. The messages showed Raniere calling her his "slave" and asking her to find more women he called "successors." In her victim impact statement at sentencing, Camila said she met Raniere at 13 and that a sexual relationship began when she was 15, lasting twelve years. She described an eating disorder, self-harm and a suicide attempt. Not every woman in his circle lived to tell such a story.

  7113848983

• 6. Deaths and Illness

  ›

  In 1984 Raniere, then 24, began a relationship with 15-year-old Gina Melita, whom he met in a theater group. When it ended, Melita introduced him to her friend Gina Hutchinson, who was 14. Hutchinson's sister Heidi found him climbing into Gina's bedroom window, and he told her that Gina was a "Buddhist goddess meant to be with him." Gina left school and later worked at CBI. On the 11th of October 2002, at age 33, she was found dead of a gunshot wound at the Karma Triyana Dharmachakra Buddhist monastery in Woodstock, New York, in an apparent suicide.

  Frank Parlato, a former NXIVM publicist, relayed an account from a source close to Raniere. The source said Raniere discussed methods of suicide with Gina, sent her images of it, and asked whether suicide could ever be right. Allegedly, once he learned she had another boyfriend, he said she must ascend to the level of the goddess by leaving her body.

  Kristin Snyder was a 35-year-old environmental consultant who paid $7,000 in November 2002 to enroll in a sixteen-day ESP course in Anchorage, Alaska, hosted by Salzman. The following January she traveled to Albany to meet Raniere and other leaders. Her mother recalled that she "thought Keith was incredible." On the 6th of February 2003, the tenth day of a second Anchorage seminar, she reportedly began saying she was pregnant with Raniere's child. Clifford recalled being told by a NXIVM instructor not to take her to the hospital. Snyder was last seen leaving that session.

  Her vehicle turned up two days later in Seward, Alaska, 120 miles from Anchorage. Police found a note saying she had been brainwashed and that her internal organs were rotting. A separate page read, "No need to search for my body." A witness at Raniere's trial testified that after her disappearance he paid $24,000 for the password to her email account.

  Barbara Jeske, a Michigan State University business graduate, was one of the earliest ESP recruiters in 1999 and became Raniere's top lieutenant. In 2014 she was diagnosed with a brain tumor, but Raniere told her she had carpal tunnel syndrome and instructed her not to seek medical attention. She died of brain cancer on the 3rd of September 2014, at age 63.

  Pamela Cafritz died of renal cancer on the 7th of November 2016, at age 57. She and Jeske were both diagnosed while living with Raniere in his condominium in Halfmoon, New York. Two other women in that residence were also diagnosed with cancer, though both survived. Hair from one of them, who survived bladder cancer, showed "significantly higher" levels of heavy metals such as bismuth and barium. After Cafritz died, Raniere and co-conspirators used her identity and credit card to charge over $300,000. In a 2009 recording he said, "I've had people killed because of my beliefs." The year after Jeske died, Raniere created a secret society of his own.

  9939617263

• 7. The Secret Society

  ›

  In 2015 Raniere created a hidden subgroup inside NXIVM called DOS, short for "Dominus Obsequious Sororium." It was organized as a pyramid of women called slaves, each led by a master. Slaves were expected to recruit slaves of their own, who would owe service to their direct master and every master above. An estimated 150 women joined. Raniere was the only man, seated at the top as grandmaster.

  He first recruited eight women, among them Allison Mack, Nicki Clyne and Lauren Salzman, who became his inner circle and first-line masters. New members were told they were joining a women-only group that would empower them, and his role as leader was hidden. To keep control, Raniere collected "collateral," meaning damaging personal information, sexually explicit photographs or videos, and rights to personal assets. Women had to supply collateral before joining and new collateral every month. They were told it could be released if they left, spoke publicly or repeatedly failed their assignments.

  Raniere devised assignments for the slaves, including seduction tasks in which masters directed their slaves toward sexual activity with him. Those assignments later formed the basis of his sex trafficking charges. FBI agent Michael Lever reported that slaves were put on extreme diets to fit Raniere's taste for "exceptionally thin" women, causing some to stop menstruating and lose hair. Slaves were also deprived of sleep by "readiness drills" requiring instant response to a master at any hour. Punishments included holding painful poses, standing barefoot in the snow, taking cold showers and whipping one another with a strap.

  DOS members were branded near the pelvis with a symbol that secretly incorporated Raniere's initials. Some were told it stood for the elements. Only inner-circle members knew the truth. At trial, prosecutors played a recording of a 2016 meeting in which Raniere said the monogram was "very directly related to my initials," and the group discussed how to obscure that. Raniere scripted the ceremony, which required nakedness and was filmed to create more collateral. In a recording with Mack, he advised that the person should ask to be branded beforehand, so it would not look like coercion. Danielle Roberts performed the branding with a cauterizing pen, and New York State's Department of Health later revoked her medical license.

  Lauren Salzman testified that DOS had four levels of slaves, all accountable to Raniere, and that its overriding emphasis was veneration of him, obedience and secrecy. Members used encrypted apps such as Telegram and Signal. She also testified that she helped Raniere edit a DOS manifesto, which declared that the best slave takes the highest pleasure in being her master's ultimate tool.

  On the 5th of June 2017 Frank Parlato reported the existence of DOS and the practice of human branding. On the 17th of October 2017 The New York Times detailed the abuses, including the collateral requirement. Raniere answered with a draft statement calling the branding story a "misogynistic strike." He described DOS as autonomous and separate from NXIVM, and in a letter to members wrote that he was not associated with the group. Prosecutors would later show otherwise.

  471716929

• 8. Arrest and Trial

  ›

  After the Times story, Raniere and members of his inner circle fled to Mexico. A search warrant for his email account was issued on the 18th of January 2018, and the FBI obtained an arrest warrant on the 14th of February. On the 26th of March, Mexican Federal Police found him in a luxury villa outside Puerto Vallarta, arrested him and deported him. Salzman later testified that he tried to hide in a walk-in closet as police arrived. He was presented in federal court in Fort Worth, Texas, then held at the Metropolitan Detention Center in New York City. United States Attorney Richard Donoghue said he had created a secret society of women he had sex with and branded, coercing them with threats to release personal information and take their assets.

  The federal racketeering trial opened on the 7th of May 2019. The charges included sexual exploitation of Camila as a minor, sex trafficking and forced labor, attempted sex trafficking, and identity theft against Edgar Bronfman and Pamela Cafritz among others. Prosecutors called him a "predator" who targeted people trying to improve their lives. The defense compared him to a strict sports coach and argued that "this was something these people signed up for." Witnesses included Lauren Salzman, filmmaker Mark Vicente, cult educator Rick Alan Ross and several victims. The defense called no witnesses.

  In closing, prosecutor Moira Penza described Raniere as a con man and a crime boss with no limits on his power. Defense attorney Marc Agnifilo said every interaction was consensual and that those who left were never punished. On the 19th of June 2019 the jury convicted Raniere on all counts after five hours of deliberation. The verdict covered racketeering, sexual exploitation of a child, sex trafficking of women and conspiracy to commit forced labor. The court received more than 100 victim impact statements.

  Before sentencing, Raniere filed two motions for a new trial, claiming perjury in March 2020 and witness intimidation in October 2020. Judge Nicholas Garaufis denied both. The pandemic delayed sentencing for more than a year. In the summer of 2020, followers including Clyne danced near the jail, calling themselves "The Forgotten Ones." A July 2020 Bureau of Prisons memorandum said Raniere had instructed a supporter, Suneel Chakravorty, to recruit more women to dance outside. Guards moved him to a different unit to keep them out of his line of sight.

  On the 27th of October 2020, Garaufis sentenced Raniere to 120 years in prison and a $1.75 million fine. He went first to Lewisburg in Pennsylvania, then to the penitentiary in Tucson, Arizona, the only federal facility that is both maximum security and designated for sex offenders. On the 20th of July 2021 the judge awarded $3.46 million in restitution to twenty-one victims, and ordered Raniere to return collateral to lower-ranking DOS members. That order was stayed until sixty days after the appeals ruling. On the 9th of December 2022 the Second Circuit upheld the conviction, with Judge José A. Cabranes writing that Raniere had not shown the evidence was insufficient.

  The story reached screens as well. HBO released the docuseries The Vow on the 23rd of August 2020, and its second season in October 2022 covered the trial. As of 2026 Raniere is held at FCI Butner I, while a civil suit brought in January 2020 by eighty former members remains ongoing.

  1621201417