Judge Holden

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Judge Holden may have been a living man, a borrowed name, or only a rumor that one soldier wrote down. The proof that he existed at all rests on a single memoir. More than a century after that memoir was finished, the novelist Cormac McCarthy took the thin record and built a far darker figure from it. Critics now rank the result among the great characters of American fiction. This documentary follows two Holdens. One was described by an eyewitness who despised him. The other stalks the pages of a novel, and readers still argue about what he is. Three questions run underneath the story. Who was the man behind the name? What did the witness actually claim? And is the novel's Judge a person at all?

  576

• 2. The Only Witness

  ›

  Samuel Chamberlain fought as a soldier in the Mexican-American War, and he later wrote an autobiographical book called My Confession: Recollections of a Rogue. He worked on it between 1855 and 1861, and it is the sole document known to mention Judge Holden.

  After the war, Chamberlain traveled for a short time with a roving band of mercenaries led by John Joel Glanton, who died in 1850. The band earned its living as professional scalp-hunters across northern Mexico and the American Southwest. Chamberlain placed Holden as Glanton's second in command, left in charge of the camp, and called him "Judge" Holden of Texas. Nobody in the camp knew who or what he had been before. Chamberlain judged him the most ruthless man in the whole band.

  Chamberlain disliked Holden intensely and says he hated him at first sight. He adds that Holden knew it. Yet Holden treated him with unfailing gentleness and often sought him out to talk. In one such conversation Holden spoke of Massachusetts, and Chamberlain was astonished to discover that the outlaw knew more about Boston than he did. The physical presence behind that politeness was something Chamberlain described in careful detail.

  51276

• 3. Portrait of a Polymath

  ›

  Six feet six inches in his moccasins is how Chamberlain measured Holden, calling him "a man of gigantic size". The face, in his telling, was "a dull tallow colored face destitute of hair and all expression". When a quarrel turned bloody, however, Holden's "hog-like eyes" would gleam with what Chamberlain called "sullen ferocity".

  The memoir is just as striking about the man's mind. Chamberlain called him "by far the best educated man in northern Mexico". Holden spoke to everyone in their own language, including several Indian tongues. At a fandango he might pull the harp or guitar from a musician's hands and charm the whole room with his playing. He could also waltz better than any local dancer. With a rifle or revolver he was "plum center", and he rode boldly. He knew strange plants by their botanical names and was fluent in geology and mineralogy.

  Chamberlain summed him up as "another Admirable Crichton", a reference to a sixteenth-century Scottish prodigy and polymath. Then came the sting: Holden was also, in Chamberlain's words, "an arrant coward". He had enough nerve to fight Indians, Mexicans, or anyone else when he held the advantage in strength, skill, and weapons. Where the odds were even, he steered away from the fight if he could. Brilliance and cowardice were only part of what the camp said about him.

  576

• 4. Whispers in Camp

  ›

  Fronteras is where Chamberlain places the most disturbing episode he ties to Holden. Before the band left that town, a ten-year-old girl was found murdered in the chaparral. Chamberlain says the mark of a huge hand was left on her throat. No other man in the camp had a hand that size, so everyone suspected Holden. Even so, nobody accused him of the crime.

  Chamberlain also reports that Holden's desires ran to "blood and women". Terrible stories circulated among the men about earlier crimes in the Cherokee nation and in Texas. These, he wrote, were committed when Holden was bearing another name. All of this is Chamberlain's account alone, with no second source to test it against. That remark about a different name set off a long search among later readers.

  576

• 5. Hunting for a Name

  ›

  Charles Wilkins Webber is one of the favorite answers among amateur historians who treat "Judge Holden" as a pseudonym. Webber was an educated man in the region, and he once wrote under the pseudonym "Holden".

  John Allen Veatch is another candidate. He was a geologist working in the same area, and he led a scalp-hunting party into Mexico. That record echoes the polymath Chamberlain sketched, with his scientific learning and his role in bounty work.

  Michael Hancock Chevallie offers a third possibility. He was a Virginia-educated, high-ranking associate of Glanton's, yet he is conspicuously missing from Chamberlain's memoir. The omission may imply that "Judge Holden" was simply the alias Chamberlain used for him. None of the three has been established as the man behind the name, so the figure stays unresolved.

  76

• 6. The Judge on the Page

  ›

  In 1985, Cormac McCarthy published the Western novel Blood Meridian, and a fictionalized Holden stands at its center. In the book, he and Glanton lead a pack of nomadic criminals who rob, torture, rape, and kill across the borderlands between the United States and Mexico. Holden murders dozens of people along the way, children among them.

  Brent Edwin Cusher describes McCarthy's version as "a massive, hairless, albino man" who excels at nearly everything he tries. Cusher also calls him "the chief proponent and philosopher of the Glanton gang's lawless warfare". The novel gives Holden knowledge of paleontology, archaeology, linguistics, law, drafting, chemistry, sleight of hand, and philosophy. Where Chamberlain's Holden was a cruel braggart, McCarthy's is a cold killer who explains why violence is the natural order.

  The novel also implies that he is a predator of children. He is seen tempting them with sweets, and a child often goes missing when he is nearby. Close readers noticed that this Judge's body and habits did not behave like those of an ordinary human.

  43910

• 7. Demon or Demigod

  ›

  Strength beyond any normal man, startling speed, and agility mark McCarthy's Holden, and he seems immune to both sleep and aging. These traits suggest to readers that he is something other than human. In the closing pages, McCarthy leans harder toward the supernatural. He points to Holden as Satan, as a Djinn, or as evil personified.

  Literature professor Leo Daugherty offered a precise reading in his essay "Gravers False and True: Blood Meridian as Gnostic Tragedy". He argued that Holden is, or at least embodies, a gnostic archon, a kind of demigod. Harold Bloom agreed that the Judge is immortal but refused to fit him into any such framework. Bloom pointed to a passage saying there was no "system by which to divide him back into his origins". Instead, Bloom compared Holden to Iago in Shakespeare, a methodical dispenser of strife.

  Other readers see Holden as a perverse form of the Nietzschean übermensch, or as Zarathustra. Each label captures a piece of him, and none fully contains him.

  1211151620

• 8. A Monstrous Reputation

  ›

  Book magazine ranked Holden the 43rd greatest character in fiction since 1900 in a list published in 2002. Admirers have likened him to a "Captain Ahab of the desert", placing him beside the obsessive whaler of Moby Dick.

  Harold Bloom pushed the praise further. He called Holden "short of Moby Dick, the most monstrous apparition in all of American literature". He also declared the Judge "the most frightening figure in all of American literature". Another commentator has called him "perhaps the most haunting character in all of American literature".

  Some McCarthy scholars still treat the search for further evidence of a real Holden as a hobby. So far, the only man who claims to have seen him remains Samuel Chamberlain.

  91115166