Jim Irsay

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Jim Irsay was 24 years old when he became general manager of the Indianapolis Colts, the youngest person ever to hold that title in the NFL. He stayed with the franchise for the rest of his life, rising from front-office apprentice to its principal owner. He was also an unusual collector, a philanthropist, and a man whose private struggles became public. How does the son of a Chicago contractor come to run a football team? What did he do with that power and money? And why did questions follow his death?

  67497981

• 2. Chicago Roots

  ›

  Jim Irsay was born on the 13th of June 1959 in Lincolnwood, Illinois, to Harriet and the Chicago businessman Robert Irsay. His mother was the daughter of Polish Catholic immigrants. His father came from a Hungarian Jewish family. Jim was raised Catholic and did not learn of his father's Jewish heritage until he was fourteen.

  Robert Irsay built a fortune estimated at more than 150 million dollars as a heating and air-conditioning contractor. The family also knew loss. Jim's sister, Roberta, died in a car accident in 1971. His brother, Thomas, who was born with a mental disability, died in 1999.

  In 1972, when Jim was 12, his father paid 12 million dollars for the Los Angeles Rams. He then immediately traded franchises with Carroll Rosenbloom, the owner of the Baltimore Colts. The boy grew up around the team. He worked as an on-field ball boy and helped answer phones in the ticket office.

  Irsay attended Loyola Academy in Wilmette, Illinois, and then Mercersburg Academy in Pennsylvania, graduating in 1978. At Southern Methodist University he earned a degree in broadcast journalism in 1982. He also played linebacker for the SMU Mustangs as a walk-on. An ankle injury ended that career, and he had boxed, golfed and lifted weights in his younger years. With his playing days over, the only road left to football ran through the Colts' offices.

  23459

• 3. Running the Colts

  ›

  In 1982, straight out of SMU, Irsay joined the Colts' professional staff and received an orientation in every part of the business. He then moved into the personnel department ahead of the 1983 season. His early duties covered college scouting, film analysis and administrative chores. By early 1984 the team had left Baltimore for Indianapolis, and he held the title of vice president and general manager.

  A stroke in 1995 changed everything for his father. Jim took over the daily running of the club under the long title of senior executive vice president, general manager and chief operating officer. When Robert Irsay died in 1997, Jim fought a legal battle with his stepmother over who owned the team. He emerged as the youngest team owner in the NFL, at 37.

  The results were strong by the numbers. According to Pro Football Reference, the Colts' 258 wins across his ownership ranked fourth-most in the league. The team won 10 division titles, reached the playoffs 18 times and played in 2 Super Bowls. It won Super Bowl XLI. From 2000 to 2009 Indianapolis won 115 regular-season games, the second-most by any team in a single decade.

  Still, Irsay was reportedly frustrated that only one championship came with quarterbacks like Peyton Manning and Andrew Luck. He released Manning, who went on to a strong late stretch with the Denver Broncos. When Luck abruptly retired after a successful comeback, Irsay declined to claw back 25 million dollars from the injury-plagued quarterback.

  Over the years he worked alongside many future Pro Football Hall of Famers. They included Eric Dickerson, Marshall Faulk, Bill Polian, Tony Dungy, Marvin Harrison, Edgerrin James and Peyton Manning. Manning's enshrinement in the class of 2021 was the most recent.

  81011614

• 4. Voice Among Owners

  ›

  At an NFL owners meeting in 2009, Irsay spoke against a bid to buy the St. Louis Rams. The group included the talk-show host Rush Limbaugh. Irsay said he could not even consider voting for him. He pointed to comments Limbaugh made in 2003 about Donovan McNabb, which were condemned as racist. "When there are comments that have been made that are inappropriate, incendiary and insensitive... our words do damage, and it's something we don't need," he said.

  In October 2022, another owners meeting produced a more striking moment. Irsay said he believed "that there's merit to remove Dan Snyder as the owner of the Washington Commanders." He was the first NFL owner to say so publicly. Snyder's lawyers had reportedly dug up dirt to keep other owners quiet, but Irsay did not fear being embarrassed.

  His own decisions drew scrutiny the following month. In November 2022 the Colts started the season 3-5-1, and Irsay fired head coach Frank Reich. He named former Colts player Jeff Saturday interim coach. Saturday was then working as an ESPN analyst and had no coaching experience beyond the high school level. The hire became one of the most debated moves of Irsay's ownership.

  2018212255

• 5. The Collector

  ›

  In 2001, Irsay paid 2.43 million dollars for the original manuscript of Jack Kerouac's On the Road. It is known as "the scroll," a continuous 120-foot roll of tracing paper sheets that Kerouac cut to size and taped together. It became the first major piece of The Jim Irsay Collection, which grew far beyond books.

  On the 5th of May 2018, he bought an original printing of the 1939 book Alcoholics Anonymous for 2.4 million dollars at auction. It carried handwritten notes by Bill Wilson, a cofounder of the movement.

  Guitars became the heart of the collection. In 2021, Guitar Magazine called him the owner of "the greatest guitar collection on Earth." He bought instruments once owned by Elvis Presley, George Harrison, John Lennon, Paul McCartney, Jerry Garcia, Prince and Les Paul. In 2014 he paid just under a million dollars for the electric guitar Bob Dylan played at Newport. In 2017 he paid 2.2 million dollars for a Ludwig drum set that belonged to Ringo Starr.

  Several purchases set records. On the 20th of June 2019 he paid 3.975 million dollars for The Black Strat, formerly owned by Pink Floyd guitarist David Gilmour. On the 23rd of May 2022 he paid 4.6 million dollars for the 1969 Fender Mustang Kurt Cobain played in the "Smells Like Teen Spirit" video.

  Sports and film pieces followed. In 2023 he acquired the saddle Secretariat wore in winning the American Triple Crown in 1973. He also bought the boots Muhammad Ali wore in the "Thrilla in Manila" against Joe Frazier, and the volleyball Wilson from Cast Away. He added letters from Abraham Lincoln, George Washington and Thomas Jefferson.

  Irsay did not just display the music. He played it with The Jim Irsay Band, which hosted free concerts in Nashville, Washington, Austin, Los Angeles, New York City, Chicago, Indianapolis, San Francisco and Las Vegas. Guests included John Mellencamp, Buddy Guy, John Hiatt, Kenny Wayne Shepherd and Ann Wilson. Pieces from the collection traveled with the band and went on display at the shows.

  6263646970

• 6. Giving Back

  ›

  In late 2020, the Irsay family launched Kicking The Stigma, a foundation meant to raise awareness of mental health disorders and remove the shame attached to them. Partners include Mental Health America of Indiana, the National Alliance on Mental Illness of Greater Indianapolis, Project Healthy Minds and Bring Change to Mind. By late 2022 it had committed more than 17 million dollars. Grants in 2021 totaled 2.7 million dollars to 16 groups, and in 2022 they reached 1.4 million dollars across 23 nonprofits.

  In December 2021, the family gave 3 million dollars to Indiana University for the Irsay Family Research Institute. It sits in Morrison Hall on the Bloomington campus and studies mental health and its stigma. Other family gifts went to the Irsay Family YMCA, the Colts Canal Playspace, Riley Hospital for Children and the Wheeler Mission Center for Women and Children.

  Irsay also stood behind Chuck Pagano, the Colts head coach from 2012 to 2017, who beat acute promyelocytic leukemia after a diagnosis in September 2012. Pagano's annual Chuckstrong Tailgate Gala has raised more than 12 million dollars for cancer research at Indiana University. In 2021 Irsay hosted it at his home. He pledged 2 million dollars after Pagano sank a free throw worth 1 million and 10 layups worth 100,000 dollars apiece on Irsay's basketball court.

  On the 20th of November 2022, Irsay gave 1 million dollars to the Indianapolis Zoo for a renovation and a new Colts Welcome Center Plaza, finished on Memorial Day of 2023.

  His most unexpected cause arrived on the 30th of March 2023. The Miami Seaquarium announced that Lolita, its sole captive orca, would return to her home waters in the Pacific Northwest. Irsay helped fund the move of Lolita and her dolphin companions, Li'i and Loke. The effort was expected to take 18 to 24 months and cost an estimated 15 to 20 million dollars, mostly from him. Lolita died on the 18th of August 2023, before it could happen.

  4042454831

• 7. Private Struggles

  ›

  Irsay married Meg Coyle in 1980, and the couple had three daughters: Carlie, Casey and Kalen. They also had ten grandchildren. The couple had been separated since 2003 when Meg filed for divorce on the 21st of November 2013.

  On the 16th of March 2014, police in Carmel, Indiana, arrested Irsay on suspicion of driving under the influence and drug possession. His car held multiple bottles of prescription medication and more than 29,000 dollars in cash. Prosecutors said he tested positive for oxycodone and hydrocodone. Multiple felony charges were pleaded down to two misdemeanors.

  While Irsay was in rehab, his daughter Carlie took over the day-to-day operations of the Colts. On the 2nd of September 2014, shortly after he pleaded guilty to operating while intoxicated and received a year of probation, the NFL suspended him for six games and fined him 500,000 dollars. In a 2023 Real Sports interview, Irsay claimed he had been arrested because "I am prejudiced against because I'm a rich, white billionaire."

  Another crisis surfaced publicly in January 2024. A TMZ report, repeated and partly verified by other outlets, said Irsay was found unresponsive and struggling to breathe at home on the 8th of December 2023. He was taken to a hospital and given a dose of Narcan, which reverses an opioid overdose.

  5253575859

• 8. Final Season

  ›

  On the 21st of May 2025, Irsay died in his sleep at The Beverly Hills Hotel in Los Angeles. The cause was cardiac arrest complicated by pneumonia, and he was 65. Forbes estimated his net worth at 4.8 billion dollars at the time.

  Six days later, on the 27th of May, the Colts announced that every uniform would carry a Jim Irsay patch for the entire 2025 season. On the 13th of June, the date that would have been his 66th birthday, the team announced a posthumous induction into the Colts Ring of Honor. It would take place during the season opener against the Miami Dolphins.

  His funeral was held on the 2nd of June 2025. He was buried soon afterward in Crown Hill Cemetery in Indianapolis.

  On the 23rd of January 2026, it was announced that the FBI and the DEA were investigating his death. Reports said he had been treated with opioids and ketamine beforehand. The findings of that inquiry will shape how the end of his story is remembered.

  74971009698