Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny reached theaters in 2023, decades after Paramount Pictures signed a deal in 1979 for five Indiana Jones films. James Mangold directed this fifth entry, working from a screenplay he wrote with David Koepp, Jez Butterworth and John-Henry Butterworth. Harrison Ford returned once more as the archaeologist Henry "Indiana" Jones Jr., now retiring from his professorship at Hunter College in New York City. Set in 1969, the story follows Jones and his estranged goddaughter Helena Shaw. Together they search for Archimedes' Dial, an ancient device said to reveal fissures in time. Pursuing them is Dr. Jürgen Voller, a former Nazi scientist working undercover at NASA, who wants the Dial for a purpose of his own. How did a franchise built around a deal signed decades earlier finally reach the screen? Who ended up playing the villain testing an aging hero one last time? And why would a film with this much history behind it become defined by its financial losses instead?

• 2. Decades In The Making

  ›

  In April 2008, Harrison Ford said he would return as Indiana Jones for a fifth film. He set one condition: the process could not take another twenty years. That same year, George Lucas began researching plot devices for the story, insisting on a MacGuffin that felt supernatural but stayed grounded in reality. Lucas explained his approach bluntly, saying "you can't just make something up, like a time machine." Steven Spielberg remained attached as director through much of the next decade, and David Koepp was brought on to write the screenplay in 2016. Koepp delivered two versions of the script, but disagreements between Spielberg, Ford, and the studio kept neither one moving forward. Jonathan Kasdan replaced Koepp in mid-2018, then left the project by May of 2019, and Koepp returned that September. In February 2020, Spielberg stepped down as director, wanting a different filmmaker to bring a fresh eye to the story. James Mangold signed on in May 2020, becoming the first person besides Spielberg to direct an Indiana Jones film. He asked for extra time to rework the script, and delays caused by the COVID-19 pandemic gave him that room. Mangold wrote the new screenplay with Jez and John-Henry Butterworth over six to eight months. He told one interviewer, "I wanted to really retool the existing script pretty aggressively, almost entirely." Principal photography began in England on the 4th of June 2021. Filming later moved through Scotland, Sicily, and Morocco before wrapping at Pinewood Studios on the 26th of February 2022. Ford injured his shoulder that June while rehearsing a fight scene against Mads Mikkelsen's character, and production shot around his recovery.

• 3. Building The Villain

  ›

  Working for NASA under the alias "Dr. Schmidt," Jürgen Voller is secretly a former Nazi scientist chasing the Dial for his own ends. Mads Mikkelsen based the character partly on real scientists brought to America through Operation Paperclip, particularly Wernher von Braun. He avoided the exaggerated menace of earlier Indiana Jones villains. As Mikkelsen put it, the team "tried to avoid the cliché of the German or the Nazi with the extreme accent and the extreme madness." Instead, he wanted Voller to appear as someone who blended into America because he is, in his words, "predominantly a scientist." Mikkelsen called Voller a "misunderstood person," a description he has applied to many villains he has played. Voller's dressing style drew on Major Arnold Toht, the antagonist of Raiders of the Lost Ark. Mikkelsen was careful, though, not to copy Ronald Lacey's performance. He drew a distinction between the two: "Toht was more of a henchman," while Voller functions as "the brain behind a lot of things." Boyd Holbrook, cast as Voller's enforcer Klaber, described the character as Voller's lapdog, "and a very crazy one at that." Holbrook had already played a similar second-in-command villain, Donald Pierce, in Mangold's 2017 film Logan, which initially left him hesitant to take the role.

• 4. Fighting For Marion's Return

  ›

  Karen Allen first raised the subject of a return in 2011. She noted that her character had married Jones in Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. As Allen put it, "it would be difficult, I think, to move forward without her." Her comeback was kept secret for years afterward. When fans asked if she was in the film, she deflected, saying "I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you." Mangold's initial script, written after he took over the project, did not include Marion at all. After learning of the decision, Allen wrote a letter to Mangold, Spielberg, and Kennedy, arguing that cutting her character would be a "terrible mistake." Kennedy replied the following day, agreeing that Allen was right, a decision that led to the film's closing scene of Marion and Jones reconciling. Allen's scene was shot in a day and a half, with the actress wearing a gray wig for the part. John Rhys-Davies reprised his role as Sallah for the first time since Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade in 1989. Jim Broadbent expressed willingness to return as Charles Stanforth from Crystal Skull but ultimately did not appear. Shia LaBeouf's character Mutt Williams, Jones' son, is instead represented only by a photograph. Mangold said he simply didn't think Mutt's arc had worked in the previous film. The film's opening sequence, set in 1944, would call for a very different kind of transformation, one applied to Ford himself.

• 5. De-Aging Indiana Jones

  ›

  Steven Spielberg used motion capture to animate his film The Adventures of Tintin in 2011, but he rejected that method for de-aging Harrison Ford. In 2012 he said he wanted the actor's real age to be acknowledged onscreen. By mid-2019, Spielberg and David Koepp had devised a five-minute World War II opening sequence featuring a de-aged Ford. When Mangold took over the project, he expanded that sequence to roughly 25 minutes. More than 100 artists at Industrial Light & Magic worked on it over a three-year period. Techniques included new artificial intelligence software that searched archived footage of a younger Ford. This included his earlier work in the original Star Wars films, from 1977-1983. Ford's head was also scanned to build a younger CGI version of his face. The production used a lighting capture system called Flux, previously used to de-age performers in the 2019 film The Irishman. Visual effects supervisor Robert Weaver pointed to a persistent problem with the actor's eyes. "Many times, we weren't quite getting the right balance of the eye-opening and the shape of the overall eyes," he said. Ford said the process left him a little "spooked," though he was ultimately impressed by the results. Mikkelsen underwent the same de-aging treatment for the same sequence. This level of technical ambition was just one piece of a production that would prove enormously expensive.

• 6. The Cost Of A Farewell

  ›

  Reports pegged the film's production cost at around $419 million. A $66.7 million tax reimbursement from the United Kingdom brought the net budget down to $352.3 million. Other reports listed a gross budget of $294.7 million, with a $55.8 million tax credit lowering net costs to $238.9 million. Still other figures circulated, including "$300 million+" and "$387.2 million." Whatever the true number, Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny became the most expensive film in the franchise's history. Forbes calculated that Disney needed a worldwide theatrical gross of $477.8 million to break even, while Collider put the figure closer to $600 million. The film ultimately grossed $384 million worldwide, made up of $174.5 million in the United States and Canada and $209.5 million elsewhere. Its opening weekend brought in $60.4 million over three days. That was the second-highest debut in the franchise unadjusted for inflation, trailing only 2008's Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. Over the five-day Fourth of July holiday, it took in $83.9 million. Deadline Hollywood noted that 58% of the opening weekend audience was over the age of 35. Ticket sales then fell sharply. The film made $26.5 million in its second weekend, a 56.1% drop that was the largest in franchise history. It earned $12 million in its third weekend and $6.7 million in its fourth. Overseas, the film opened to $69.6 million across 52 countries. The United Kingdom led with $8.9 million, ahead of France at $5.9 million and Japan at $4.7 million. Some publications called it a box-office bomb, a verdict its reception among critics would soon complicate.

• 7. A Divided Reception

  ›

  Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of B+ on an A+ to F scale. PostTrak separately recorded a 79% positive score, with 59% saying they would definitely recommend it. John Nugent of Empire gave the film four out of five stars, praising Ford's performance and Mangold's confident handling of its action sequences. Bilge Ebiri of Vulture called it "fun," admitting the comparisons to earlier films were "warranted," though he found it "too entertaining to dismiss." Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian said it had "quite a bit of zip and fun and narrative ingenuity." Germain Lussier of io9 praised its "great premise, exciting action, wonderful banter, and some fantastic twists and turns." Mike Ryan of Uproxx called it "a very fun movie," while noting that "Indy's arc is poignant and also sad." Not every critic agreed. Owen Gleiberman of Variety called it a "dutifully eager but ultimately rather joyless piece of nostalgic hokum." David Rooney of The Hollywood Reporter called it "bombastic," writing that it never found "much joy in the process." Robbie Collin of The Telegraph praised Ford's performance but found the action "painfully short on spark and bravado." Richard Lawson of Vanity Fair wrote that the four credited screenwriters seemed to be "grasping at inspiration and coming up short." Members of the cast and crew would later offer their own verdicts on the film once the dust had settled.

• 8. What Came After

  ›

  The film premiered out of competition at the 76th Cannes Film Festival on the 18th of May 2023. That date fell exactly fifteen years after the Cannes premiere of Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. It received a "lukewarm" five-minute standing ovation. John Williams' score earned a nomination for Best Original Score at the 96th Academy Awards, his fourth nomination in the series. At 91, the nomination extended his own record to 54 Oscar nominations, the most for any living person. The same score also earned a nomination at the 66th Grammy Awards, where Williams won Best Instrumental Composition for "Helena's Theme," his 26th Grammy. At the 44th Golden Raspberry Awards, the film picked up two nominations under joke titles. It lost in the Worst Remake, Rip-Off or Sequel category, nominated as "Indiana Jones and the Dial of...Still Beating a Dead Horse." It also lost Worst Screenplay, nominated as "...Can I go home now?" Both categories went to Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey. In October 2024, Rhys-Davies said he liked the film as a franchise finale. He felt it hadn't used Banderas' talent well, and suggested his own character Sallah should have filled Renaldo's role instead. That December, Mangold told Deadline Hollywood he felt disappointment at the film's reception. He said he wanted audiences "to love him as he was" and to accept that "things come to an end, that's part of life." In February 2025, Ford told The Wall Street Journal that the film's financial disappointment came down to "shit happens." He said he was still happy he had made it. Producer Kathleen Kennedy said she had "no regrets." She noted that Ford "wanted a chance at another" film and "did not want Indy to end with the fourth movie." In 2016, Disney chief Bob Iger had said the fifth film would not be the series' final chapter. By March 2023, Lucasfilm was reported to have shelved further Indiana Jones films or a Disney+ series to focus on Star Wars. Disney confirmed the following month that Dial of Destiny would, after all, mark the end of the franchise.