History of the Marranos in England

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Hidden in plain sight, the Marranos of England maintained prayer-meetings at Creechurch Lane while passing outwardly as Spaniards and Catholics. They were Sephardic Jews, Spanish and Portuguese by origin, who had converted or been forced to convert to Christianity during the Middle Ages, yet continued to practice Judaism in secret. How did a community of secret Jews come to settle in England, trade with the known world, and eventually change the course of English religious policy? Those are the questions this documentary will follow.

• 2. Arrivals and Concealment

  ›

  Spanish and Portuguese diplomatic sources contain some of the earliest evidence that Sephardic Jews had reached London by the late 16th century. Catholic ambassadors sent repeated complaints to their governments about members of this small community gathering in London to celebrate Passover and Yom Kippur. The community was modest in size at first, but it was real, and it was operating beneath the surface of English society.

  By the middle of the 17th century, a more substantial wave of Sephardic merchants had settled in London. They formed a secret congregation led by Antonio Fernandez Carvajal. Their commercial reach was striking: trade with the Levant, the East and West Indies, the Canary Islands, Brazil, and above all with the Netherlands, Spain, and Portugal. These merchants served as a vital link in a trading network that stretched across the Spanish and Portuguese world, and that network depended on Sephardi or secret Jews embedded in port cities across Europe.

  Their dual identity was not merely a matter of survival. It was also a source of political leverage. Their knowledge of Spanish Catholic plans and of Charles Stuart's activities in Holland made them invaluable to Oliver Cromwell and his secretary, John Thurloe. Lucien Wolf later documented this relationship under the title "Cromwell's Secret Intelligencers". Prayer-meetings at Creechurch Lane eventually made the congregation known to the English government as Jews by faith, even while they dressed and spoke as Spaniards in public life.

• 3. Synagogues and Memory

  ›

  Creechurch Lane, the site of those clandestine gatherings, became one of the first Jewish religious places in England since the Edict of Expulsion of 1290. The Bevis Marks Synagogue, built in 1701, followed it as the next landmark in that same unbroken tradition. Together they mark the physical and institutional footprint of a community that had survived centuries of exclusion.

  In the three centuries after those earliest arrivals, Sephardic Jewish communities concentrated near the major European sea ports, including Amsterdam and London. That positioning was not accidental. These port cities provided the commercial connections and the relative anonymity that allowed expelled Marranos from the Spanish Inquisition to rebuild merchant activities and sustain communal life.

• 4. Puritans and the Push for Return

  ›

  Johanna Cartwright and her son Ebenezer presented a petition to the army in 1649 arguing for the formal readmission of Jews into England. The two Baptists from Amsterdam titled their appeal "The Petition of the Jews for the Repealing of the Act of Parliament for Their Banishment out of England". They were not alone. Roger Williams, Hugh Peters, and Independents broadly added their voices to the campaign.

  The Puritan movement had already prepared English public opinion to treat Jewish readmission with sympathy. Among the Parliamentary extremists, the Judaizing sects were particularly energetic advocates, and their calls resonated with a wider strand of mystical Messianic thinking that swept through mid-17th century England.

  Menasseh Ben Israel gave that mystical argument its most systematic form. In 1650 he published Hope of Israel, in which he argued that the return of the Jews to England was a necessary step before the Messiah could appear. His reasoning rested on the idea that the Messiah could not come until Jews were present in every land on earth. Antonio de Montezinos had claimed to have discovered the Ten Lost Tribes among the indigenous people of Ecuador, which meant England, the one country still barring Jews, was the remaining obstacle. If England opened its doors, the Messianic age, according to this logic, might finally begin.

• 5. A Story in Fiction

  ›

  Philippa Gregory's historical novel The Queen's Fool approaches the Marrano experience from a different angle. The story is told from the perspective of a fictional Marrano girl living in England during the reign of Queen Mary I. The novel places an invented character inside the documented historical setting, bringing the secrecy and double life of the community into narrative form. Gregory draws on the same period that produced the Catholic ambassadors' complaints and the Creechurch Lane gatherings, imagining what daily life inside that concealment might have felt like for an individual caught between identities.