Hadda, Afghanistan

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Hadda, Afghanistan sits ten kilometers south of Jalalabad, in Nangarhar Province, and it holds a secret that puzzled scholars for over a century. When archaeologists dug into the earth here in the 1930s and again in the 1970s, they pulled out roughly 23,000 sculptures made of clay and plaster. The faces on those sculptures looked Greek. The figures they depicted were Buddhist. And nobody could quite explain how those two worlds fused so completely in a remote corner of eastern Afghanistan. How did Greek artistic traditions travel this far east? What community of artists produced work so faithful to Hellenistic models that scholars compared it to sculptures from the Temple of Apollo in Bassae, Greece? And why did those ancient monasteries eventually vanish, leaving only coins and bones behind?

• 2. Greek Faces, Buddhist Souls

  ›

  A sculptural group excavated at the Hadda site of Tapa-i-Shotor places Buddha at the center, flanked by two figures that are unmistakably Greek: Herakles and Tyche, with Tyche holding a cornucopia. The only concession to Buddhist iconography is that Herakles carries not his usual club but the thunderbolt of Vajrapani. Everything else reads as late Hellenistic in style. The style of the Hadda sculptures sits in an interesting chronological tension. The artistic vocabulary belongs to the 2nd or 1st century BCE, the tail end of the Hellenistic world. Yet the sculptures themselves are usually dated, with some uncertainty, to the 1st century CE or later, meaning one or two centuries after the style they display had already passed out of fashion elsewhere. One explanation is that Greek aesthetic traditions were simply preserved in this region for a few extra centuries, maintained perhaps by communities with direct Greek heritage. Given how technically refined the work is, scholars have suggested that Greek communities were directly involved in making these sculptures. That suggestion led to the claim that Hadda might be "the cradle of incipient Buddhist sculpture in Indo-Greek style." The earliest structures at the Tapa Shotor monastery complex date even further back, to the reign of the Indo-Scythian king Azes II, who ruled roughly 35-12 BCE.

• 3. The Monasteries of Hadda

  ›

  Jules Barthoux, working as part of the French Archaeological Delegation in Afghanistan, excavated several of the Hadda monasteries in the 1920s. He led the expedition to the Tapa-i Kafariha Monastery in 1926-27. He also dug the Tapa Kalan monastery, dated to the 4th-5th century CE, which yielded one of the site's most celebrated pieces: a Hellenistic-style attendant to the Buddha known as the "Genie au Fleur," now held in Paris at the Guimet Museum. Barthoux's other focus was the Chakhil-i-Ghoundi monastery, built around a small limestone stupa. Most of its remains were gathered in 1928, and a collaboration with the Tokyo National Museum made possible the reconstruction of the stupa's base, canopy, and decorative elements. That reconstitution is also now on display at the Musée Guimet. Archaeologist Raymond Allchin, studying the Tapa Shotor site, argued that the Greco-Buddhist art of Gandhara descended directly from the art of Hellenistic Bactria, as visible at the site of Ai-Khanoum. Scholar Tarzi went further, calling Tapa Shotor, with its clay sculptures dated to the 2nd century CE, the "missing link" between Hellenistic Bactrian art and the later stucco sculptures at Hadda, which are typically dated to the 3rd-4th century CE.

• 4. Coins at Tope Kalan

  ›

  The large stupa known as Tapa Tope Kalan stands roughly 200 meters to the northeast of the modern city of Hadda. It carried several names over time: the 19th-century explorer Masson called it "Tope Kalan" and labelled it Hadda 10; Barthoux knew it as "Borj-i Kafarihā." What the stupa held inside was remarkable. Deposits of over 200 mainly silver coins were found there, and the mix of those coins tells a precise story about when the stupa was in use. Sasanian coins issued under Varhran IV, who ruled 388-399 CE, Yazdagird II, who ruled 438-457 CE, and Peroz I, who ruled 457/9-484 CE, were all present. Five Roman gold solidi were also recovered, representing the reigns of Theodosius II, Marcianus, and Leo I, covering the years 408-474 CE. Then there were Hunnic imitations of Sasanian coins stamped with the Alkhon tamgha, and 14 coins of Alkhon rulers identifiable by the elongated skulls depicted on them. Taken together, the numismatic evidence points to a mid-to-late 5th century date for the stupa's construction or use.

• 5. The Oldest Manuscripts

  ›

  Around Hadda, hunters or diggers at some point unearthed a clay pot bearing an inscription in Gandhari using the Kharoshthi script. Inside the pot were manuscripts written on bark in the same language and script. Those manuscripts are believed to be the oldest surviving Buddhist manuscripts, and the oldest surviving Indian manuscripts of any kind. They probably date from around the 1st century CE. The texts belong to the long-lost canon of the Sarvastivadin sect, a Buddhist school that dominated Gandhara and played a central role in spreading Buddhism into central and east Asia via the Silk Road. The Tapa Shotor monastery was itself a Sarvastivadin institution, suggesting that the Sarvastivadin presence at Hadda was deep and sustained. The bark manuscripts are now in the possession of the British Library.

• 6. Destruction and Loss

  ›

  The name Hadda derives from Sanskrit haḍḍa, meaning "a bone," or possibly from an unrecorded adjective meaning "place of bones." That etymology likely reflects the belief that Hadda housed a bone-relic of the Buddha. The word passed into Pashto as haḍḍ, which scholars read as evidence of the linguistic influence of the area's original pre-Islamic population. The civil war in Afghanistan ended the site's physical survival as an active archaeological resource. Hadda was reported to have been almost entirely destroyed in the fighting. In early 1980, three independent sources confirmed that a 2nd century BCE Buddha statue and other antiquities held in a museum at Hadda had been destroyed. The 23,000 sculptures excavated in the earlier decades, now scattered between Paris, Tokyo, London, and other institutions, became the primary surviving record of what Hadda once contained.