H. P. Lovecraft

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  H. P. Lovecraft died on the 15th of March 1937 in Providence, Rhode Island, virtually unknown to the reading public. He was 46 years old, hospitalized with terminal cancer of the small intestine, and had spent his final weeks keeping a diary of his own physical decline until he could no longer hold a pen. Nearly all of his fiction had appeared only in pulp magazines. No major publisher had issued a collection of his work during his lifetime. He left behind no wealth, a failed marriage that he had never legally dissolved, and a body of strange, unsettling fiction that almost nobody had read.

  Within a generation, that assessment would be reversed completely. Stephen King would call him the twentieth century's greatest practitioner of the classic horror tale. Philosophers would cite him as an inspiration for new schools of metaphysical thought. His invented monsters would become global cultural touchstones. And scholars would spend decades arguing about whether his unmistakable genius could be separated from his unmistakable bigotry.

  How did a sickly, reclusive man from Providence, who never learned to support himself as a writer and spent his adult life in genteel poverty, come to reshape the entire tradition of supernatural horror? That question takes us back to a house on Angell Street, a grandfather's bedtime stories, and a childhood haunted by nightmares that refused to stay in the dark.

• 2. A Childhood of Nightmares

  ›

  Whipple Van Buren Phillips told his young grandson stories of "winged horrors" and "deep, low, moaning sounds", tales he invented himself for the child's entertainment. Lovecraft later guessed that these creations drew on Gothic novelists like Ann Radcliffe, Matthew Lewis, and Charles Maturin, though the original sources were never identified. Whatever their origin, those bedtime stories lodged deep. By the time the boy was roughly five and a half, following his grandmother Robie's death in 1896, he began having recurring nightmares about beings he called "night-gaunts". He credited their appearance to Gustave Doré's illustrations, which he said would "whirl me through space at a sickening rate of speed, the while fretting and impelling me with their detestable tridents." Thirty years later, night-gaunts appeared in his published fiction.

  The family home on Angell Street held a large library that gave the young Lovecraft access to classical literature, scientific works, and early weird fiction. He was reading One Thousand and One Nights at five, Nathaniel Hawthorne at six, and by seven had produced his earliest known literary works: poems restyling the Odyssey and other Greco-Roman myths. He briefly accepted the Greek and Roman pantheon as genuine expressions of divinity, setting aside his Protestant upbringing. He later recalled being told at five that Santa Claus did not exist and retorting by asking why God was not equally a myth.

  When Lovecraft was three, his father Winfield suffered a psychotic episode in a Chicago hotel and was committed to Butler Hospital in Providence. The family's version of events obscured the truth: Winfield's death certificate listed the cause as general paresis, a term synonymous with late-stage syphilis. Lovecraft maintained throughout his life that his father had simply fallen into a paralytic state from insomnia and overwork. Whether he was kept ignorant or chose to mislead others has never been established.

  With Winfield institutionalized, Lovecraft grew up in the care of his mother Susie, his aunts Lillian and Annie, and above all Whipple, who became, in the boy's own words, "the centre of my entire universe". Whipple encouraged him toward literature and science, maintained correspondence with him by letter even while traveling on business, and educated him in the classics. When Whipple died in the spring of 1904 at the age of 70 from a stroke, following the catastrophic failure of his largest business venture, Lovecraft described the aftermath as one of the darkest periods of his life. He wrote in a 1934 letter that he had seen no point in living anymore and had considered suicide. His scientific curiosity, he said, prevented him from going through with it.

• 3. The Lost Years and the Pulp World

  ›

  In 1908, shortly before what would have been his high school graduation, Lovecraft suffered a severe health crisis. He described it in letters as a "nervous collapse" and "a sort of breakdown", blaming it variously on high school stress and on persistent "intense headaches, insomnia, and general nervous weakness". A high school classmate recalled that he exhibited "terrible tics" and would suddenly leap from his seat. A psychology professor named Harry K. Brobst later examined that account and identified chorea minor as the probable cause, while noting that Brobst also attributed the 1908 event specifically to what he called a "hysteroid seizure", a term now associated with atypical depression. Whatever the cause, Lovecraft never graduated and never attended school again.

  Almost nothing was recorded of Lovecraft's and Susie's activities between late 1908 and 1913. A neighbor named Clara Hess recalled Susie describing her son as so hideous that he hid from everyone and refused to walk on streets where people might see him. In fact, what neighbors assumed were loud nocturnal quarrels between mother and son turned out to be recitations of Shakespeare that apparently delighted them both.

  The turn came in 1913 from an unlikely source: a critical letter Lovecraft wrote to a pulp magazine called Argosy. He attacked a writer named Fred Jackson, describing Jackson's characters as exhibiting "the delicate passions and emotions proper to negroes and anthropoid apes." The letter triggered a nearly year-long feud in the magazine's letters section. His most prominent opponent was a writer named John Russell, who often replied in verse. Lovecraft felt compelled to keep answering because he genuinely respected Russell's craft. Edward F. Daas, then head editor of the United Amateur Press Association, noticed both men and invited them to join. Lovecraft accepted in April 1914.

  Within the UAPA, Lovecraft found something that had been largely absent from his isolated life: community. He was appointed chairman of the Department of Public Criticism in late 1914, elected vice-president in mid-1915, and president two years after that. He used these positions to champion what he considered superior English usage, which in practice meant criticizing contributors for their "Americanisms" and "slang" in terms laced with xenophobia. W. Paul Cook, a fellow UAPA member who became a lifelong friend, encouraged Lovecraft to write and publish prose fiction. The result was "The Alchemist" in 1916, followed by "The Tomb" and "Dagon". Lovecraft acknowledged that "The Tomb" drew heavily on Edgar Allan Poe's style. "Dagon" was the first story that scholars later identified as carrying the themes his work became known for.

• 4. New York, Failure, and "The Call of Cthulhu"

  ›

  Sonia Greene thought Lovecraft needed to leave Providence to flourish and was willing to support him financially. They married on the 3rd of March 1924 and relocated to her Brooklyn apartment at 259 Parkside Avenue. Greene later said Lovecraft performed satisfactorily as a lover but that she had to take the initiative in all aspects of the relationship. She attributed his passivity to his upbringing. His weight climbed to 200 lb on her home cooking, and he was genuinely captivated by the city.

  Through the informal group of literary friends known as the Kalem Club, Lovecraft was introduced to Weird Tales, the publication that would become his most prominent outlet. Its editor Edwin Baird accepted many of his stories, including "Under the Pyramids", which Lovecraft ghostwrote for the escape artist Harry Houdini. But the New York years unraveled quickly. On the 1st of January 1925, Sonia moved to Cleveland for a job opportunity. Lovecraft took a small first-floor apartment on 169 Clinton Street "at the edge of Red Hook", a location that came to discomfort him greatly. Greene then lost her business in a bank failure. Lovecraft was offered the editorship of Weird Tales, a job that would have given him stable income, but declined on the grounds that he refused to relocate to Chicago. His apartment was later burgled, leaving him with only the clothes he was wearing.

  His despair found its way directly onto the page. In a story written in August 1925, the narrator declares: "My coming to New York had been a mistake; for whereas I had looked for poignant wonder and inspiration … I had found instead only a sense of horror and oppression which threatened to master, paralyze, and annihilate me." It was also during this period that Lovecraft wrote the outline for "The Call of Cthulhu", with its theme of the insignificance of all humanity. By 1926, having lost roughly 40 lb, he returned to Providence.

  Back in Providence, living with his aunts at 10 Barnes Street, Lovecraft produced what scholars now regard as his most significant works. The Call of Cthulhu, At the Mountains of Madness, The Shadow over Innsmouth, The Shadow Out of Time, and The Case of Charles Dexter Ward all came from this final decade. He also corresponded prolifically with other writers, weaving a loose network called the Lovecraft Circle. In August of one year, Robert E. Howard wrote a letter to Weird Tales praising a reprint of "The Rats in the Walls". The editor Farnsworth Wright forwarded it to Lovecraft, who responded warmly. The two writers exchanged letters for the rest of Howard's life.

• 5. Cosmicism and Forbidden Knowledge

  ›

  "That is not dead which can eternal lie; And with strange aeons even death may die." That couplet, recited by a character named Abdul Alhazred in the 1921 story "The Nameless City", is one of Lovecraft's most quoted passages. It also captures the engine driving almost everything he wrote: the idea that the universe is vast, indifferent, and harbors things that the human mind cannot safely encounter.

  Lovecraft first articulated this philosophy, which he called cosmicism, in 1921, though he did not fully incorporate it into his fiction until five years later. Cosmicism holds that humanity is an insignificant force in the cosmos. Crucially, Lovecraft did not picture the universe as hostile. The entities in his fiction are not malevolent toward human beings; they simply have no awareness of human beings at all. His protagonists do not discover their insignificance through revelation. They arrive already knowing it, and events confirm what they feared.

  Knowledge itself, in Lovecraft's fiction, is the central danger. His stories operate on the premise that happiness is only achievable through ignorance. To seek out what is not meant to be known invites psychological destruction. The protagonist of The Case of Charles Dexter Ward pursues genealogical and historical research so deeply that it leads to both madness and self-destruction. In The Shadow over Innsmouth and The Shadow Out of Time, characters experience horror not through external violence but through the internal weight of self-knowledge they cannot sustain.

  Lovecraft traced his cosmicism to a specific moment in 1902, when, as a youth, he was introduced to the scale of space. He later described that encounter with astronomy as the most poignant event of his life. It convinced him of humanity's impermanence and foreclosed any remaining religious belief. He had already, before his fifth birthday, questioned whether God was equally a myth to Santa Claus. By his early teens he was convinced. By seventeen he had read works that confirmed the worldview he had built independently. The philosopher Graham Harman, one of the four founders of the speculative realist movement, wrote a monograph titled Weird Realism: Lovecraft and Philosophy, arguing that Lovecraft was uniquely obsessed with gaps in human knowledge and comparing him to Georges Braque, Pablo Picasso, and Edmund Husserl in his treatment of objects as containing meanings that can never be exhausted.

• 6. The Contested Legacy

  ›

  In 1944, a mystery columnist for the New York Herald Tribune recommended a volume of Lovecraft's stories to readers. In 1945, the critic Edmund Wilson offered a sharper assessment: "the only real horror in most of these fictions is the horror of bad taste and bad art." Wilson did add that Lovecraft had written about supernatural horror "with much intelligence". According to L. Sprague de Camp, Wilson later softened his view, and a writer named David Chavchavadze reported that Wilson was found reading Lovecraft's correspondence.

  The scholarly recovery of Lovecraft's reputation gathered speed in the 1970s, after August Derleth, who had co-founded Arkham House with Donald Wandrei specifically to keep Lovecraft's work in print, died in 1971. L. Sprague de Camp published the first major biography in 1975. A dedicated field called Lovecraft studies emerged, tracing his influence through the American literary canon and grappling with the full contradictions of his life and thought.

  Those contradictions are not minor. Lovecraft was a white supremacist who published racist poetry during his lifetime and embedded racial fears allegorically in stories like The Shadow over Innsmouth, where the interbreeding of humans and the Deep Ones is explicitly framed as miscegenation that corrupts a town. He married a Jewish woman he described as "well assimilated". He held antisemitic views even as Samuel Loveman, who was Jewish, became one of his closest friends in the Kalem Club. His political views shifted dramatically over his life: from conservative Tory and Anglophile to a form of socialism during the Great Depression, though he described his ideal system using the word "fascism" even as scholars like S. T. Joshi noted it bore little resemblance to that ideology. In 2015, the World Fantasy Award dropped its trophy, which had been a bust of Lovecraft designed by cartoonist Gahan Wilson, in response to his racial views.

  In 2005, the Library of America published a volume of Lovecraft's works that sold 25,000 copies within a month of release. Stephen King stated in his book Danse Macabre that Lovecraft was responsible for King's own fascination with horror and was the largest influence on his writing. Film directors John Carpenter and Guillermo del Toro have both cited Lovecraft directly. The first World Fantasy Awards were held in Providence in 1975 under the theme "The Lovecraft Circle". In 2019, Lovecraft and the other Cthulhu Mythos authors were posthumously awarded the 1945 Retro-Hugo Award for Best Series. And on the headstone erected in Swan Point Cemetery in 1977 by his fans, the inscription his admirers chose was a line from one of his personal letters: "I AM PROVIDENCE."