Eugene Wigner

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Eugene Paul Wigner once quipped that he never expected to see his name in the newspapers "without doing something wicked" - yet in 1963, the Nobel Committee put it there for contributions that had reshaped physics over three decades. Born on the 17th of November 1902 in Budapest, Wigner spent his life moving between two worlds: the abstract kingdom of pure mathematics and the urgent, mortal business of nuclear weapons. How does a man who spent years studying the geometry of symmetry end up designing reactors to produce weapons-grade plutonium? How does the same physicist who helped persuade Franklin D. Roosevelt to authorize what became the Manhattan Project later spend his final years meditating on consciousness and the mystery of existence? Those are the questions this documentary will chase. Along the way, we will encounter the German Physical Society colloquia that changed how he saw science, a letter that changed history, a graphite pile beneath the stands of a Chicago football stadium, and a philosophical puzzle about the nature of reality that Wigner's own student would take in a direction Wigner never intended.

• 2. Budapest to Berlin

  ›

  Antal Wigner was a leather tanner in Budapest, and it was into that solidly middle-class Jewish household that young Jenő Pál arrived in 1902. An elder sister, Berta, known as Biri, and a younger sister, Margit, known as Manci, completed the family. Manci would later marry the British theoretical physicist Paul Dirac - a connection that grew directly from her brother's professional world. Wigner was home-schooled until age nine, when he entered school at the third grade, already ahead of his peers. At eleven, doctors suspected tuberculosis and sent him to a sanatorium in the Austrian mountains for six weeks before concluding the diagnosis was wrong. The illness left no permanent mark on his body, but the period of relative isolation seems to have deepened his taste for mathematical problems.

  From 1915 through 1919, Wigner attended the Fasori Evangélikus Gimnázium, the same secondary grammar school his father had attended. There he sat beside János von Neumann, a year his junior, and both were shaped by the mathematics instruction of a teacher named László Rátz. Politics interrupted the school years in 1919, when the Béla Kun communist regime prompted the family to flee briefly to Austria. On their return, and partly in reaction to the prominence of Jews in the Kun government, the Wigners converted to Lutheranism. Wigner said later that the decision "was not at heart a religious decision but an anti-communist one".

  After graduating in 1920, he enrolled at the Budapest University of Technical Sciences but found the courses unsatisfying. In 1921 he moved to the Technische Hochschule Berlin to study chemical engineering. Wednesday afternoon colloquia of the German Physical Society opened a different world entirely. The speakers included Max Planck, Werner Heisenberg, Wolfgang Pauli, Walther Nernst, and Albert Einstein. Wigner also met Leó Szilárd, who became at once his closest friend - a friendship that would have enormous consequences two decades later. At the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry he met Michael Polanyi, who supervised his doctoral thesis on the formation and decay of molecules, and whom Wigner would later rank as his greatest teacher after László Rátz.

• 3. Symmetry and the Quantum World

  ›

  In 1927, while working as an assistant at the University of Göttingen, Wigner introduced what is now called the Wigner D-matrix - a mathematical object describing how quantum states transform under rotation. He had arrived at Göttingen at Arnold Sommerfeld's invitation, assigned to assist the great mathematician David Hilbert, but found the aged Hilbert's interests had shifted to logic and his abilities were failing. Wigner worked independently, and the independence bore fruit.

  The larger project he shared with Hermann Weyl was bringing group theory into quantum mechanics. Group theory is the mathematics of symmetry: it studies the rules by which objects or equations remain unchanged under transformations such as rotation, reflection, or translation. Weyl had written a standard text, Group Theory and Quantum Mechanics, in 1928, but physicists found it dense. Wigner's own Group Theory and Its Application to the Quantum Mechanics of Atomic Spectra, published in 1931, made the material accessible to a wider audience.

  That same year, Wigner proved what is now called Wigner's theorem, a cornerstone of the mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics. The theorem specifies how physical symmetries - rotations, translations, CPT symmetry - are represented on the mathematical space of quantum states known as the Hilbert space. It establishes that any symmetry transformation must be represented by either a linear unitary or an antilinear antiunitary transformation. The theorem has since become as foundational to quantum mechanics as any experimental result. Princeton University recruited Wigner in 1930, offering a one-year lectureship at seven times his European salary. John von Neumann joined him at the same time, and the two men, who had already co-authored papers together in 1928 and 1929, anglicized their first names from Jenő and János to Eugene and John.

• 4. The Letter That Started a Race

  ›

  On the 2nd of August 1939, Wigner drove with Leó Szilárd to the tip of Long Island to find Albert Einstein at a summer rental. The visit produced the Einstein-Szilárd letter, addressed to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, warning that recent research in nuclear fission had made an atomic bomb feasible and that Germany might be pursuing one. Roosevelt authorized the creation of an Advisory Committee on Uranium, the earliest institutional precursor of the Manhattan Project. Wigner's fear was not abstract. He later recalled that "thoughts of being murdered focus your mind wonderfully" - explaining why he even refused to have his fingerprints taken, fearing they could be used to identify him if Germany won the war.

  By July 1942, Wigner had chosen a conservative 100-megawatt design for the production reactors, using a graphite neutron moderator and water cooling. At the time, reactors existed only on paper; no reactor had yet achieved a controlled chain reaction. Wigner was present on the 2nd of December 1942 beneath the stands of the University of Chicago's abandoned Stagg Field, when Chicago Pile One became the world's first atomic reactor to sustain a controlled nuclear chain reaction.

  His team at the Metallurgical Laboratory included J. Ernest Wilkins Jr., Alvin M. Weinberg, Katharine Way, Gale Young, and Edward Creutz. The team's task was to design reactors that would convert uranium into weapons-grade plutonium. When DuPont was given responsibility for the detailed reactor design rather than just construction, Wigner threatened to resign in February 1943. The head of the Metallurgical Laboratory, Arthur Compton, sent him on vacation instead. DuPont's decision to build in additional load tubes for more uranium turned out to save the project when neutron poisoning became a problem, a vindication of the more robust design that Wigner had not anticipated. Wigner would later say his only regret about building the bomb was that it had not been done sooner.

• 5. The Wigner Effect

  ›

  Beneath the engineering triumph of the Manhattan Project lay a discovery Wigner made that would haunt nuclear programs for decades. Neutron radiation, he found, could displace atoms in a graphite moderator, causing the material to swell. This became known as the Wigner effect, and it proved a serious problem for the reactors at the Hanford Site in the years immediately after the war, forcing production cutbacks and eventually shutting down at least one reactor entirely. Scientists eventually found they could overcome it through controlled heating and annealing - carefully warming the graphite to allow the displaced atoms to migrate back toward equilibrium.

  In that same period, Wigner and Leonard Eisenbud developed the Wigner-Eisenbud R-matrix theory, a general mathematical approach to nuclear reactions published in 1947. The theory gave physicists a framework for analyzing how particles interact at the boundary of a nuclear reaction, and it has remained a standard tool in nuclear physics.

  After the war, Wigner accepted the directorship of research and development at the Clinton Laboratory, which is now the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, in early 1946. He did not want administrative work, so he arranged for James Lum to handle executive duties while he focused on research. The arrangement fell apart when the newly created Atomic Energy Commission took over operations at the start of 1947. Wigner saw the Commission's Washington-based decision-making as interference with science. A specific confrontation came in March 1947, when the AEC discovered his scientists conducting experiments with a critical mass of uranium-235, in apparent violation of an order issued by Major General Leslie R. Groves after the death of Louis Slotin at Los Alamos in August 1946. Wigner argued the order had been superseded; he was forced to stop the experiments. He left Oak Ridge later that year and returned to Princeton.

• 6. Consciousness and the Quantum

  ›

  In 1960, Wigner published the article that became his most widely read work outside the technical literature: "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in the Natural Sciences". He pointed out that mathematics, developed often with no practical aim, repeatedly turns out to describe physical reality with uncanny precision - a coincidence he called "unreasonable" and difficult to explain. He suggested that biology and cognition might be the deeper origin of physical concepts as humans perceive them. The article prompted responses from researchers across disciplines, including Richard Hamming in computer science, Arthur Lesk in molecular biology, Peter Norvig in data mining, Max Tegmark in physics, Ivor Grattan-Guinness in mathematics, and Vela Velupillai in economics.

  A related puzzle occupied Wigner for much of his later career. He developed a thought experiment, now called the Wigner's Friend paradox, to explore what happens when one quantum observer is observed by another. A friend inside a sealed laboratory performs a quantum measurement; from outside, Wigner treats the friend and the experiment as a combined quantum system. The two descriptions seem incompatible. For Wigner, this pointed to consciousness as foundational to the measurement process. He wrote: "All that quantum mechanics purports to provide are probability connections between subsequent impressions (also called 'apperceptions') of the consciousness". The interpretation - sometimes called the 'consciousness causes collapse' view - held that measurement is the interaction that creates impressions in a conscious observer, and that this collapse of the wave function is a real physical event tied to awareness.

  Hugh Everett III, who studied under Wigner, addressed the friend scenario in the introduction to his 1957 dissertation, calling it an "amusing, but extremely hypothetical drama". An early draft of Everett's work includes a drawing of the thought experiment, which is the earliest paper evidence that the scenario existed before Wigner published it. The two men had clearly discussed it. Everett's own response - the many-worlds interpretation - took a direction opposite to Wigner's: instead of consciousness collapsing the wave function, all outcomes occur in branching worlds, with no special role for the observer at all.

• 7. Nobel, Late Honors, and Last Words

  ›

  Wigner received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1963 for his contributions to the theory of the atomic nucleus and elementary particles, particularly through the discovery and application of fundamental symmetry principles. The other half of that year's prize went to Maria Goeppert-Mayer and J. Hans D. Jensen. When told of the award, Wigner said he never expected to see his name in the newspapers without having done something wicked. He had already received the Franklin Medal in 1950, the Enrico Fermi Award in 1958, the Atoms for Peace Award in 1959, the Max Planck Medal in 1961, and the National Medal of Science in 1969. Later came the Albert Einstein Award in 1972, the Golden Plate Award of the American Academy of Achievement in 1974, the Wigner Medal in 1978, and the Herzl Prize in 1982.

  After retiring from Princeton in 1971, Wigner compiled Symmetries and Reflections, a collection of philosophical essays, and became active in international scientific and political meetings. In 1979 he married his third wife, Eileen Clare-Patton Hamilton, the widow of physicist Donald Ross Hamilton, who had served as the dean of the graduate school at Princeton University. In 1992, at ninety years old, Wigner published his memoirs, The Recollections of Eugene P. Wigner, in collaboration with Andrew Szanton. In those pages he wrote: "The full meaning of life, the collective meaning of all human desires, is fundamentally a mystery beyond our grasp. As a young man, I chafed at this state of affairs. But by now I have made peace with it. I even feel a certain honor to be associated with such a mystery."

  His collection Philosophical Reflections and Syntheses, published in 1995, returned to the question he had never been able to resolve: "It was not possible to formulate the laws of quantum mechanics in a fully consistent way without reference to consciousness." Wigner died of pneumonia at the University Medical Center in Princeton, New Jersey, on the 1st of January 1995 - the same date, across the decades, as his own birthday month had begun.