Battle of Antietam

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Battle of Antietam, fought on the 17th of September 1862, produced more American casualties in a single day than any other engagement before or since. By the time the guns fell silent near Sharpsburg, Maryland, 22,726 soldiers were dead, wounded, or missing on both sides combined. That toll, reached in under twelve hours, still stands as the bloodiest day in American history. Yet the battle was not simply a catastrophic collision of armies. It was a political hinge point. What happened along Antietam Creek that September would give President Abraham Lincoln the confidence he needed to issue the Emancipation Proclamation, and that document would reshape the war's meaning for the entire world. How did two massive armies end up facing each other across a narrow Maryland creek? Why did a Union commander with twice the men fight Lee's army to a standstill rather than crushing it? And what did a set of battle plans wrapped around three cigars have to do with the whole affair?

• 2. The Invasion That Invited Disaster

  ›

  Robert E. Lee's Army of Northern Virginia, roughly 55,000 men, crossed into Maryland on the 3rd of September 1862, riding the momentum of their victory at Second Bull Run three days earlier. The decision to invade Union soil was partly strategic and partly a matter of survival. Northern Virginia's farms had been stripped bare by the war, and the army needed to feed itself somewhere. Confederate leaders also believed Maryland might welcome them. They pointed to the Baltimore riots of the spring of 1861 and the fact that President Lincoln had once passed through the city in disguise to reach his own inauguration. To mark the moment, Confederate troops sang "Maryland, My Maryland!" as they marched through the state's towns. The welcome they expected never arrived. Civilians hid indoors or watched from doorsteps in cold silence, while the Army of the Potomac was cheered along its own route.

  The invasion was also designed to coordinate with simultaneous Confederate drives into Kentucky led by the armies of Braxton Bragg and Edmund Kirby Smith. Some Confederate politicians, including President Jefferson Davis, believed a victory on Union soil could win formal recognition and financial support from Britain and France. Lee himself, according to the source, did not appear to share that calculation, seeing no reason to build military plans around diplomatic speculation.

  The most consequential event of the prelude to battle was not a skirmish but a piece of paper. Two Union soldiers, Corporal Barton W. Mitchell and First Sergeant John M. Bloss of the 27th Indiana Volunteer Infantry, discovered a mislaid copy of Lee's operational orders wrapped around three cigars. Special Order 191 revealed that Lee had divided his army and spread its parts across several locations, including Harpers Ferry and Hagerstown, making each portion vulnerable to isolation and defeat if McClellan moved swiftly. McClellan waited roughly eighteen hours before acting on this intelligence, squandering what many historians regard as his best chance to destroy Lee's army before it could reassemble.

• 3. Two Armies, One Creek

  ›

  By September 15, Lee had positioned his available forces behind Antietam Creek on a low ridge near Sharpsburg. The terrain favored defenders. Stone walls, limestone outcroppings, and natural hollows gave Confederate infantrymen excellent cover, while the creek itself, ranging from 60 to 100 feet wide and fordable in places, was crossed by three stone bridges spaced about a mile apart. The problem was what lay behind the Confederate line: the Potomac River, with only a single viable crossing point, Boteler's Ford at Shepherdstown, available as a retreat route.

  On September 15, Lee had no more than 18,000 men immediately at hand, roughly a third the size of the Federal force. An immediate Union attack that morning would have carried an overwhelming numerical advantage. McClellan, however, believed Lee commanded as many as 100,000 men at Sharpsburg and delayed his attack by a full day. That day allowed Longstreet's corps to arrive from Hagerstown and Jackson's corps to arrive from Harpers Ferry, minus only A.P. Hill's division.

  A 2023 study by historian D. Scott Hartwig estimates that McClellan had 72,199 men available for combat on September 17, supported by 293 cannons. The Confederates had around 37,600 men and approximately 246 cannon, many of them obsolete smoothbore weapons of shorter range than their Union counterparts. About a quarter of McClellan's army was inexperienced and poorly trained; roughly one-third to one-half of Lee's was absent due to straggling and disease. McClellan's battle plan called for a coordinated attack against Lee's left flank supported by a diversionary assault on the right and reserves ready to strike the center. What actually unfolded bore little resemblance to that plan.

• 4. The Cornfield and the Dunker Church

  ›

  At dawn, about 5:30 in the morning, Major General Joseph Hooker's I Corps advanced down the Hagerstown Turnpike toward a modest whitewashed building belonging to a congregation of German Baptist Brethren: the Dunker Church. The plateau on which it sat was Hooker's objective. His roughly 8,600 men faced about 7,700 defenders under Stonewall Jackson, a slight disparity that the Confederate defensive positions more than canceled out.

  The fighting that erupted around Miller's Cornfield, an area approximately 250 yards deep and 400 yards wide, was among the most ferocious of the war. Colonel Stephen D. Lee later described the artillery exchange as "artillery Hell." Confederate fire poured from horse artillery batteries under Jeb Stuart and four batteries on the high ground near the Dunker Church. Union return fire came from nine batteries and twenty 20-pounder Parrott rifles positioned two miles east of the creek. Soldiers fought at such close range in the corn that rifles became fouled from continuous firing, and officers on horseback shouted orders no one could hear.

  The Cornfield changed hands an estimated fifteen times during the morning. Hood's Confederate division, 2,300 men strong, launched a furious counterattack that drove Union forces back through the field. Hood's men paid a price of 60% casualties for holding the line. When asked where his division was, Hood reportedly replied, "Dead on the field." The 12th Massachusetts Infantry suffered the highest casualty rate of any unit that day, losing 67% of its men. The Louisiana "Tiger" Brigade lost 323 of 500 men to point-blank artillery fire before being beaten back.

  Brigadier General Joseph K. F. Mansfield's XII Corps, 7,200 infantrymen, reinforced the battered I Corps. Mansfield had taken command only two days before the battle and had never led large numbers of troops in combat, despite forty years of prior service. Concerned his raw recruits would bolt under fire, he marched them in a formation called "column of companies, closed in mass," bunched ten ranks deep rather than the standard two. It made them, in one description, "almost as good a target as a barn." Mansfield was shot in the chest during the advance and died the following day. After two hours of fighting and 2,500 casualties, Hooker's corps had been driven back nearly to its starting positions. Hooker himself was shot through the foot by a Confederate sharpshooter who spotted the general and his white horse.

• 5. Bloody Lane

  ›

  By midday, the center of Lee's line had become the focus. A division under Major General William French, separated from the rest of Sumner's II Corps in the chaos of the morning, drifted south and stumbled into combat with D.H. Hill's division dug into a sunken road worn down by years of wagon traffic. Hill had roughly 2,500 men, less than half of French's strength, and three of his five brigades had already been torn up in the morning fighting. But the sunken road formed a natural trench, and Hill's men used it expertly.

  French launched three consecutive brigade-sized assaults beginning around 9:30 in the morning. The first, mostly inexperienced troops under Brigadier General Max Weber, was cut down by rifle fire. The second, raw recruits under Colonel Dwight Morris, managed to beat back a counterattack by the Alabama Brigade of Robert Rodes before falling to the same rifle fire. The third, under Brigadier General Nathan Kimball, included veteran regiments but also went down under fire from the road. French's division suffered 1,750 casualties from his 5,700 men in under an hour.

  The fourth assault was led by the Irish Brigade under Brigadier General Thomas F. Meagher. As the mostly Irish immigrants advanced under emerald green flags, a regimental chaplain, Father William Corby, rode back and forth across the front of the formation shouting words of conditional absolution prescribed by the Roman Catholic Church. The brigade lost 540 men before being ordered to withdraw.

  The Confederate line eventually collapsed through a combination of flanking fire and miscommunication. Colonel Francis C. Barlow led the 61st and 64th New York into a position that allowed enfilade fire down the length of the sunken road. A misunderstood order from Rodes, passed through Lieutenant Colonel James N. Lightfoot who had just taken command of the 6th Alabama, sent five Confederate regiments marching away from the line instead of wheeling to meet the threat. The road that had been a defensive stronghold became a killing ground open from both ends.

  The fighting along the 800-yard road from 9:30 in the morning to 1 in the afternoon produced around 5,600 casualties, roughly 3,000 Union and 2,600 Confederate. The road earned the name Bloody Lane. With the Confederate center broken, Lee's army could have been split in half. Porter's V Corps and Franklin's VI Corps, totaling more than 22,000 men, were waiting nearby. But senior corps commander Sumner refused to authorize an advance, and McClellan, after hearing both arguments at the front, backed Sumner's decision. General Richardson, who had driven the breakthrough, was mortally wounded. Colonel Barlow was severely wounded. Command of the division passed to Winfield S. Hancock, and the momentum of the Federal advance evaporated.

• 6. Burnside's Bridge

  ›

  Three miles to the south, the afternoon phase of the battle turned on a stone bridge. Rohrbach's Bridge, a three-span structure 125 feet long, was the southernmost crossing of the Antietam and the scene of one of the most costly delays of the day. Defending it were roughly 400 men, the 2nd and 20th Georgia regiments under Brigadier General Robert Toombs, backed by two artillery batteries positioned on a steep bluff above the west bank. Major General Ambrose Burnside's IX Corps had 12,500 troops and 50 guns on the east side of the creek. Burnside did not receive his orders to attack until 10 in the morning, three hours after the fighting had begun elsewhere.

  The bridge itself was not the only available crossing. Historians have noted that the creek could have been forded at multiple points out of enemy range. Burnside concentrated his plan on the bridge anyway. Three separate assaults failed before the fourth attempt at 12:30 in the afternoon, led by the 51st New York and the 51st Pennsylvania under Brigadier General Edward Ferrero. The soldiers had recently had a whiskey ration canceled; an officer promised to restore it if they took the bridge. With a captured light howitzer firing double canister down the span, the attackers reached within 25 yards of the defenders. By 1 in the afternoon, Confederate ammunition was nearly exhausted and Toombs ordered his men to withdraw. His Georgians had inflicted more than 500 Union casualties while suffering fewer than 160 themselves, and had stalled Burnside's assault for over three hours.

  The Federal advance then stalled again on its own. Burnside's officers had failed to transport ammunition across the bridge, which became a bottleneck for soldiers, artillery, and supply wagons, causing another two-hour delay. By 3 in the afternoon, Burnside moved west with more than 8,000 troops, pushing Jones's badly outnumbered Confederate division back past Cemetery Hill and to within 200 yards of Sharpsburg. Panic spread through the town's streets.

  A.P. Hill's division arrived at 3:30 in the afternoon, completing a grueling 17-mile march from Harpers Ferry. Hill divided his force; about 2,000 men struck Burnside's exposed left flank. Brigadier General Maxcy Gregg's South Carolinians hit the 16th Connecticut, a regiment that had been in service for only three weeks. The Connecticut line collapsed with 185 casualties. Confusion compounded the disaster when soldiers of the 4th Rhode Island could not distinguish Confederate attackers wearing Union uniforms captured at Harpers Ferry. Burnside, unnerved by the collapse, ordered his entire force back to the east bank and sent word to McClellan that he needed more men and artillery. McClellan replied, "I can do nothing more. I have no infantry." He had two fresh corps in reserve.

• 7. Proclamation and Consequence

  ›

  Lee's army withdrew across the Potomac the evening of September 18, ending his first invasion of the North. The Union had 12,410 casualties with 2,108 dead; the Confederates had 10,316 casualties with 1,547 dead. Lee lost 31% of his force, McClellan 25%. Five days later, on September 22, Lincoln issued the preliminary Emancipation Proclamation, giving Confederate states until the 1st of January 1863, to end their rebellion or lose their enslaved people. Lincoln had drafted the proclamation earlier but held it back on the advice of Secretary of State William H. Seward, who warned that issuing it after a string of Union defeats would look like an act of desperation rather than strength.

  The battle's consequences reached far beyond American borders. Britain and France had been considering formal recognition of the Confederacy, a step that might have brought financial support and possibly military intervention. The Emancipation Proclamation removed any realistic path to that outcome. Both countries had already abolished slavery, and as historian James M. McPherson observed in his book Crossroads of Freedom, neither government could afford to be seen supporting a foreign state actively fighting to preserve it. McPherson described Antietam as having more "momentous, multiple consequences" than any other single campaign of the war, arguing that without the defeat of Lee's Maryland invasion in 1862, the later Union triumphs at Gettysburg, Vicksburg, and Atlanta would never have occurred.

  Lincoln relieved McClellan of command on November 5, citing what he characterized as a pattern of overcaution and McClellan's refusal to pursue Lee across the Potomac between September 17 and October 26 despite repeated orders from the War Department. McClellan was replaced by General Burnside on November 9, effectively ending his military career. General-in-Chief Henry W. Halleck's official report captured the frustration plainly: "The long inactivity of so large an army in the face of a defeated foe, and during the most favorable season for rapid movements and a vigorous campaign, was a matter of great disappointment and regret."

  Photographers Alexander Gardner and James F. Gibson arrived at the battlefield on September 17 or 18 and documented the carnage over the following days. When their photographs were displayed publicly, they became the first images of an American battlefield taken before the bodies had been removed. Among those who tended the wounded in the aftermath was Clara Barton, who brought a wagonload of medical supplies to the field. She later founded the American Red Cross disaster relief organization, a consequence that traces its origins directly to that single September day along Antietam Creek.