Portrait of Thomas Cromwell

• 1. The Political Commission

  ›

  In 1532, Hans Holbein the Younger arrived in England as a court painter under the patronage of Thomas Cromwell and Anne Boleyn. This German-Swiss artist would soon become King's Painter to Henry VIII by 1535. Cromwell, an English lawyer who rose from being a blacksmith's son in Putney, commissioned this specific portrait during his peak power years between 1532 and 1540. He was around 48 years old when he sat for the work. The political climate demanded propaganda images that positioned him as both a reformist and loyal royalist. Cromwell understood the effect of such imagery and used it to counterbalance the influence of Cardinal Wolsey before Wolsey's fall. He produced anti-clerical woodcuts and designed title pages for Myles Coverdale's English translation of the bible. His efforts aligned with Henry VIII's grandiose programme of artistic patronage which culminated in building Nonsuch Palace starting in 1538.

• 2. Visual Composition And Symbolism

  ›

  Cromwell sits on a bench before a table holding a legal document while wearing sober colours including a black fur lined overcoat and a black hat. His left hand displays a patterned gold ring with a large green gemstone. The table is covered with a green cloth serving as a symbolic reference to the Board of Green Cloth. Items placed upon the cloth include a quill, scissors, a leather bag, and a devotional book known as Cromwell's Book of Hours. The inscription on the border reads To our trusty and right well beloved Councillor Thomas Cromwell Master of our Jewel House. Holbein presents Cromwell as somewhat sour cold and grim yet described by some as softened compared to other Tudor portraits. The sitter appears reduced in scale placing him low in the frame deep within pictorial space. This positioning creates distance between the viewer and subject. A historian named R. B. Merriman described Cromwell as short stoutly built with a large face smooth shaven close cropped hair heavy double chin small cruel mouth extraordinary long upper lip gray eyes set closely together moving restlessly under light eyebrows. The same source compares Cromwell to Niccolò Machiavelli mentioning criminal intentions and supposed contempt for ordinary morality.

• 3. The Disappearing Original

  ›

  Only hours after Cromwell was taken to Traitors Gate on the 1st of June 1540 soldiers arrived at his house to take belongings to the treasury. There is no record of this painting in any later royal inventory. Historians assume the original oil on oak panel was destroyed shortly after Cromwell's execution by beheading on the 28th of July 1540 in the Tower of London. Beckingsale published research in 1978 confirming the likely destruction timeline. Holbein's portrait most likely vanished soon after Cromwell's fall leaving only copies behind. The artist had survived the downfalls of Thomas More and Anne Boleyn through guile but Cromwell's sudden death badly damaged his own reputation. Although he retained his position as King's painter his standing never fully recovered. The original panel probably showed a painted scroll above his head containing text now removed during an early twentieth century restoration improvement. A 1915 photograph preserves the Frick version wording which reads To our trusty and right well beloved Councillor Thomas Cromwell Master of our Jewel House.

• 4. Three Surviving Versions

  ›

  Today three versions survive held by the Frick Collection New York the National Portrait Gallery in London and the Chichester Constable collection in Yorkshire England. The Frick panel measures specific dimensions though exact numbers vary across sources. It dates to circa 1532, 33 when Cromwell served as Master of the Jewel House. An undated inventory from Cromwell's London home mentions two tables of my master his visnamy painted. The first mention of these copies appears in records of the Countess of Caledon from 1866 when she lent it to the National Portrait Exhibition. That version is now housed in the Frick Collection where it hangs opposite Holbein's Portrait of Thomas More. Art historian Roy Strong believed all three extant portraits were mere copies while others argued differently. The London copy was likely commissioned by Cromwell's descendants either when the original portrait was sold or for display in a different family property. The Frick version underwent extensive technical analysis in 1952 and was cleaned in 1966 work that did not substantiate an attribution to Holbein but rather indicated the hand of a less skilled workshop member. Historian John Rowlands deduced from pentimenti revealed by X-ray photographs that the Frick version shows the hand of Holbein and may be the original.

• 5. Shifting Critical Opinions

  ›

  Cromwell's reputation remained poor until revision efforts began in the 1960s. Today he is seen as a reformer and highly capable supreme political operator. Earlier opinion noted that among all portraits Holbein did at the English court this one always seemed least flattering to its subject most viciously mocking. Henry Clay Frick romantically asked viewers to imagine Thomas More the beautiful saint and Cromwell the monster united in art and history facing each other through Holbein time and chance. The historian R. B. Merriman compared Cromwell to Niccolò Machiavelli mentioning criminal intentions and supposed contempt for ordinary morality. This portrait has been described as a softened version of the subject despite appearing sour cold and grim. Cromwell engineered King Henry VIII's divorce from Catherine of Aragon while playing key roles in both Anne Boleyn's rise and her downfall. He advised Henry to marry Anne of Cleves hoping to strengthen political alliances with Protestant Germany but erred causing his enemies to bring treason charges leading to arrest and execution.

• 6. The Prayer Book Discovery

  ›

  Researchers discovered Cromwell's actual Book of Hours in the Wren Library at Trinity College Cambridge in 2023. The book was donated to Trinity College by Anne Sadleir who lived between 1585 and circa 1671 widow of Ralph Sadleir born 1579 died 1661 descendant of Cromwell's protégé Sir Ralph Sadleir born 1507 died 1587. Original silver gilt mounts on its cover were made by Pierre Mangot. It was printed in Paris by Gilles and Germain Hardouyn in 1527 the year when Henry VIII first sought a divorce. Two other significant copies belonged to Henry VIII's first wife Catherine of Aragon and second wife Anne Boleyn. Tudor historian Tracy Borman called it the most exciting Cromwell discovery in a generation if not more. Cromwell was a devout man keen to display this devotional book within his portrait. The painting dates from Holbein's second visit to England when Cromwell acted on behalf of Henry VIII commissioning propagandistic images during peak reputation years. He emerged as Protestant counterweight to Thomas More in Privy Council sealing Boleyn's position in bitter circumstance becoming one of most influential powerful men in England.