October Revolution

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The October Revolution did not happen in October. At least, not by the calendar the rest of the world was using. Russia still kept the Julian calendar in 1917, which ran thirteen days behind the Gregorian standard, so what Russians called the 25th of October was the 7th of November everywhere else. That accident of timekeeping gave the world one of history's most famous misnomers, and it points to something deeper: the revolution that ended the Russian Empire and ignited the first communist government in world history was always a story of contested versions, rival dates, and disputed meanings.

  At the center of it stood a fragile provisional government clinging to power in Petrograd, a population ground down by three years of war, and a disciplined Bolshevik party whose membership had surged from 24,000 in February 1917 to 200,000 by September. How did a small urban insurrection, largely free of casualties in its opening hours, become the founding act of the Soviet Union? How was the nearly bloodless seizure of the Winter Palace transformed, within years, into a heroic storming that never happened? And why do historians still disagree about whether it was a popular revolution or a coup by a determined minority?

• 2. A Country Coming Apart

  ›

  Gross industrial production in 1917 fell by over 36 percent compared to what it had been in 1914. That single figure tells the story of Russia's collapse more plainly than any speech. By the autumn, as much as half of all enterprises in the Urals, the Donbas, and other industrial centers had closed entirely, driving mass unemployment at the precise moment the cost of living was climbing sharply. Real wages had dropped to roughly 50 percent of what they had been in 1913, and Russia's national debt had reached 50 billion roubles, of which more than 11 billion were owed to foreign governments.

  Workers in factories across Russia responded by organizing into committees that could negotiate wages and hours. In September and October 1917, more than a million workers participated in strikes across Moscow, Petrograd, the Donbas mines, the Urals metalworks, the Baku oil fields, the Central Industrial Region's textile mills, and 44 railway lines simultaneously. These were not spontaneous eruptions; factory committees channeled the anger, even as overall living conditions refused to improve.

  The countryside was fracturing along different lines. By autumn, peasant uprisings had spread to 482 of Russia's 624 counties, roughly 77 percent of the country. Over 42 percent of all recorded acts of destruction, mostly the burning and seizing of landlord estates, occurred in October alone. When the Provisional Government dispatched punitive detachments to restore order, they only deepened the resentment.

  Soldiers' wives formed one of the most volatile forces in the villages. From 1914 to 1917, almost 50 percent of healthy men had been sent to the front, leaving women as heads of households. When government allowances arrived late and fell short, these women organized what contemporaries called subsistence riots, seizing food from shopkeepers they accused of price gouging. When police intervened, protesters responded, in one account, with rakes, sticks, rocks, and fists. By September, the garrisons of Petrograd, Moscow, and several other cities, along with the Baltic Fleet through its elected body Tsentrobalt, had formally announced that they no longer recognized the authority of the Provisional Government.

• 3. The Road to October

  ›

  Vladimir Lenin had been living in exile in Switzerland when he negotiated a remarkable arrangement: the German government, recognizing that Russian dissidents could destabilize their wartime enemy, agreed to allow 32 Russian citizens, including Lenin and his wife, to travel in a sealed train carriage through German territory. Upon his arrival in Petrograd on the 3rd of April 1917, Lenin immediately issued his April Theses, calling on the Bolsheviks to overthrow the Provisional Government and end the war.

  The Provisional Government had already survived one near-death experience that summer. On the 17th of July 1917, over 500,000 people joined what was meant to be a peaceful demonstration in Petrograd during the so-called July Days, demanding that power pass to the soviets. The government, backed by the Socialist-Revolutionary and Menshevik leaders of the All-Russian Executive Committee, ordered an armed attack on the demonstrators, killing hundreds. A period of arrests followed; the editorial offices and printing presses of the Bolshevik newspaper Pravda were attacked on the 5th and the 6th of July, and on the 7th the government ordered Lenin's arrest, forcing him underground.

  The Provisional Government's authority suffered a further blow through the Kornilov affair. General Lavr Kornilov, who had been Commander-in-Chief since the 18th of July, directed an army under Aleksandr Krymov toward Petrograd, ostensibly to restore order. Kerensky, reportedly alarmed by the prospect of a military coup, reversed the order. Kornilov pushed on regardless. With few troops available, Kerensky was forced to turn to the Petrograd Soviet for help. Bolsheviks, Mensheviks, and Socialist Revolutionaries jointly stopped the advance, and the Bolsheviks' influence over railroad and telegraph workers proved decisive in blocking troop movements. The immediate political consequence was the formal abolition of the monarchy and the proclamation of the Russian Republic on the 1st of September.

  With Kornilov defeated, Bolshevik resolutions on the question of power swept through the Petrograd Soviet on the 31st of August and the Moscow Soviet on the 5th of September. On the 10th of October, the Bolsheviks' Central Committee voted 10-2 for a resolution declaring that an armed uprising was inevitable and fully ripe. Party membership had grown nearly tenfold since February.

• 4. The Insurrection Itself

  ›

  In the early morning of the 24th of October, soldiers loyal to Kerensky marched on the printing house of the Bolshevik newspaper Rabochiy put, seizing equipment and thousands of copies. The government simultaneously ordered the closure of Rabochiy put, the left-wing Soldat, and two far-right newspapers, Zhivoe slovo and Novaia Rus. By 9 a.m., the Bolshevik Military Revolutionary Committee had issued a formal denunciation; by 10 a.m., Bolshevik-aligned soldiers had retaken the printing house. Around 3 p.m., Kerensky ordered the raising of all but one of Petrograd's bridges. By 5 p.m., the Military-Revolutionary Committee had seized the Central Telegraph of Petrograd, handing the Bolsheviks control over communications across the city.

  On the morning of the 25th of October, a pro-Bolshevik flotilla, consisting primarily of five destroyers and their crews along with marines, entered Petrograd harbor. At Kronstadt, sailors declared their allegiance to the insurrection. Red Guards, operating from Smolny Palace, systematically captured government facilities and communication installations with little resistance. The Petrograd Garrison and most of the city's military units joined the uprising. Kerensky, finding no serviceable vehicles and the railways controlled by Soviet workers, ultimately borrowed a Renault from the American embassy, left the Winter Palace alongside a Pierce Arrow, slipped through the pickets, and drove out to seek reinforcements.

  The final act, the assault on the Winter Palace, was almost anticlimactic. A defending force of roughly 3,000 cadets, officers, Cossacks, and female soldiers offered little vigorous resistance. The Bolsheviks themselves delayed the assault because they could not locate functioning artillery. At 6:15 p.m., a large group of artillery cadets abandoned the palace, taking their guns with them. At 8 p.m., 200 Cossacks left and returned to barracks. At 9:45 p.m., the cruiser Aurora fired a blank shot from the harbor. Some revolutionaries entered the palace at 10:25 p.m., and a mass entry followed roughly three hours later. By 2:10 a.m. on the 26th of October, it was over. The 140 volunteers of the Women's Battalion and the remaining cadets surrendered to a force of some 40,000. The cabinet of the Provisional Government was arrested and imprisoned in Peter and Paul Fortress.

• 5. Myth Versus Reality

  ›

  The seizure of the Winter Palace happened nearly without resistance, and Soviet historians knew it. What they published was something else entirely. The historical reenactment titled The Storming of the Winter Palace was staged in 1920 and watched by 100,000 spectators. That spectacle provided the template for official films depicting fierce fighting that never occurred. Grandiose paintings of the Women's Battalion and photo stills taken from Sergei Eisenstein's staged film came to be treated as documentary evidence.

  Historical falsification became a formal instrument of Stalin's rule. The 1938 publication History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks) systematically altered the record, depicting Lenin's primary associates, among them Zinoviev, Trotsky, Radek, and Bukharin, as vacillators, opportunists, and foreign spies. Stalin, who had in reality been a figure of secondary importance during the revolution, was recast as its chief disciplinarian.

  Leon Trotsky pushed back in his book The Stalin School of Falsification, drawing on private letters, telegrams, party speeches, meeting minutes, and suppressed texts including Lenin's Testament. Even early Soviet interpreters of the revolution, figures such as Anatoly Lunacharsky and Moisei Uritsky, had acknowledged that the October insurrection was carried out according to Trotsky's plan, not Lenin's. That admission was eventually buried.

  The disputed role of Pavlo Dybenko offers one example of how contested even the basic facts remained. Some sources identified Dybenko, as leader of Tsentrobalt, as the force that actually took power in Petrograd, with ten warships and ten thousand Baltic Fleet mariners arriving at the city. In his memoirs, Dybenko described a violent incident involving those same mariners as nothing more than several shots in the air. American journalist Louise Bryant, who was present in Russia at the time, countered that Western news outlets reported the worst violence occurred in Moscow, not Petrograd, and at a much smaller scale than claimed.

• 6. A Government Assembled

  ›

  Lenin initially declined the leading position when the Bolsheviks formed their new government after the revolution. He suggested Leon Trotsky for the role of Chairman of the Council of People's Commissars. Trotsky refused, other Bolsheviks pressed Lenin to take responsibility, and Lenin eventually accepted. He reportedly approved of the new council's name on the grounds that it smelled of revolution.

  The Second Congress of Soviets, which ratified the transfer of power, comprised 670 elected delegates; 300 were Bolsheviks and nearly 100 were Left Socialist-Revolutionaries who supported the overthrow of Kerensky's government. When the center and right wings of the Socialist Revolutionaries and the Mensheviks walked out in protest over what they considered an illegal seizure of power, Trotsky dismissed them with a phrase that became one of history's most quoted political taunts: "You are pitiful isolated individuals; you are bankrupts; your role is played out. Go where you belong from now on, into the dustbin of history!"

  The new government moved quickly. The Decree on Peace and the Decree on Land were passed on the 26th of October. The Decree on Land formally ratified what peasants across 77 percent of the country had already begun doing on their own: seizing and redistributing private estates. On the 10th of November, the government declared all Russians citizens of equal standing, nullifying the legal designations of estates, titles, and ranks. On the 16th of December, all titles and ranks were eliminated from the army, along with uniform decorations and the tradition of saluting. On the 20th of December, Lenin's decree created the Cheka, the secret police body that would anchor Bolshevik control over political opponents. The Red Terror began in September 1918, triggered by a failed assassination attempt on Lenin.

• 7. How Historians Have Fought Over It

  ›

  Few events have generated as much politically charged historical disagreement as the October Revolution. Three broad schools have dominated the debate: Soviet-Marxist, Western-totalitarian, and revisionist, each shaped as much by geopolitics as by archival evidence.

  Soviet historians, working within guidelines set by the state, interpreted the revolution as the inevitable product of class struggle guided by Lenin's mastery of scientific Marxist theory. After Stalin's death, a group of historians including E. N. Burdzhalov and P. V. Volobuev, sometimes called the New Directions Group, challenged the mono-causal explanation of monopoly capitalism and argued that only multi-causal analysis could account for the revolution's complexity. Their work represented a significant deviation from party orthodoxy, though the Bolshevik party remained central to their account.

  Western Cold War historians, sometimes labeled traditionalists or totalitarians, described the revolution as the result of contingent accidents, including the timing of World War I and the poor leadership of Nicholas II. They argued it was not popular support but party discipline and ruthlessness that brought the Bolsheviks to power. Two of the most prominent figures in this school, Richard Pipes and Zbigniew Brzezinski, moved between academic positions and direct policy roles: Pipes headed the CIA's Team B, and Brzezinski served as National Security Advisor to President Jimmy Carter.

  The revisionist historians who rose in the 1960s and 1970s challenged this picture from below, emphasizing social history over high politics and arguing that the revolution had genuine popular roots. According to Evan Mawdsley, the revisionist school was dominant in academic circles from the 1970s onward. After 1991, the opening of Soviet archives prompted a further shift: post-Soviet Russian historians largely repudiated their predecessors' state-approved narrative, while Stephen Kotkin argued that the archival opening prompted a return to political history and what he called the apparent resurrection of totalitarianism as an interpretive lens.

• 8. The Revolution's Long Shadow

  ›

  The October Revolution marked the creation of the world's first large-scale, constitutionally ordained socialist state, and its global consequences extended far beyond Russia's borders. Communist parties began forming in many countries after 1917. The revolution was also perceived as a rupture with imperialism by civil rights and decolonization movements around the world, and the Soviet Union subsequently provided financial support to anti-colonial movements against European colonial powers.

  The revolution generated a substantial cultural record. John Reed, an American journalist who witnessed the events directly, published Ten Days That Shook the World in 1919; he died in 1920, shortly after completing it. Sergei Eisenstein and Grigori Aleksandrov's film October: Ten Days That Shook the World, commissioned to commemorate the revolution, was first released on the 20th of January 1928 in the USSR and on the 2nd of November 1928 in New York City. Dmitri Shostakovich composed his Symphony No. 2 in B major, Op. 14, subtitled To October, for the revolution's tenth anniversary; its choral finale sets a text by Alexander Bezymensky praising Lenin, and the work received its premiere on the 5th of November 1927 under conductor Nikolai Malko. The 1981 Hollywood film Reds, based on Reed's account, incorporated interviews with people who had lived through the period.

  The term Red October spread well beyond politics. It was applied to a steel factory made notable by the Battle of Stalingrad, to a Moscow confectionery still known in Russia, and to the fictional Soviet submarine at the center of Tom Clancy's 1984 novel The Hunt for Red October and its 1990 film adaptation. The date of the 7th of November, the Gregorian anniversary, was the official national day of the Soviet Union from 1918 onward and remains a public holiday in Belarus and the breakaway territory of Transnistria.