Historical reenactment
In 1638, Lord James Dunn of Coniston brought the first known reenactment to life in London. A staged battle featuring dozens of costumed performers enacted a recent conflict during the English Civil War. The Roundheads, flush from victories, recreated a battle at Blackheath in 1645 despite ongoing fighting. King Charles II later staged a recreation of the siege of Maastricht in 1674 near Windsor Castle. An eighty yard wide fortress with twelve foot thick walls and a moat was constructed for this event. Five hundred men garrisoned the site while seven hundred serving soldiers recreated the siege over five days. Cannon fire, trench-busting mines, and prisoner captures filled the spectacle. Noted diarist Samuel Pepys attended the large crowds drawn from London and nearby towns.
The Eglinton Tournament of 1839 marked historical reenactment's coming of age as a grand public spectacle. Archibald Montgomerie, 13th Earl of Eglinton organized this medieval joust and revel held on a meadow at a loop in the Lugton Water. One hundred thousand spectators watched thirteen medieval knights on horseback perform the pageant. Lord Eglinton announced that the public would be welcome and requested medieval fancy dress if possible. Tickets were free to ensure broad attendance. The ground chosen was low and almost marshy with grassy slopes rising on all sides. Preparations and many works of art commissioned for the tournament affected public feeling and the course of 19th-century Gothic revivalism. Walter Scott's novel Ivanhoe inspired features of the tournament attempting to be a living reenactment of literary romances. The Duke of Buckingham had previously staged naval battles from the Napoleonic Wars on his estate lake in 1821.
Civil War reenacting received its major boost during the United States centennial commemorations spanning 1961 through 1965. More than six thousand reenactors participated in a 125th anniversary event near the original Manassas battlefield. This mega-event sparked interest in Civil War reenacting during the late 1980s and 1990s. Today over one hundred Civil War reenactments are held each year throughout the country. The North-South Skirmish Association formed during this period as a result of the centennial. Veterans organizations recreated camp life to show their children how they lived and reproduce camaraderie. The Great Reunion of 1913 celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg attracted more than fifty thousand Union and Confederate veterans. They included reenactments of elements like Pickett's Charge at that historic gathering.
Reenactors commonly divide themselves into categories based on the level of concern for authenticity. Farbs or polyester soldiers spend relatively little time and money achieving authenticity with regard to uniforms or accessories. Anachronistic clothing, fabrics, fasteners such as velcro, headwear, footwear, vehicles, and consumables like modern cigarettes are common among them. Mainstream reenactors make an effort to appear authentic but may come out of character when no audience is present. Visible stitches are likely sewn in a period-correct manner while hidden stitches and undergarments may not be period-appropriate. Hardcore authentics or progressives value thorough research and sometimes deride mainstream reenactors for perpetuating inaccurate reenactorisms. These hard-core participants seek an immersive experience trying to live as much as possible as someone of the period might have done. They eat seasonally and regionally appropriate food and stay in character throughout an event.
The term living history describes performance bringing history to life without following a planned script. Third-person interpreters take on dress and work in a particular period style but do not assume personas of past people. Second-person interpreters engage audiences to participate in period activities such as soap-making or churning butter. First-person interpreters feign previous folk from outward appearances to innermost beliefs pretending not to know anything of events past their epoch. Combat demonstrations are mock battles put on by reenacting organizations primarily to show what combat in the period might have been like. Scripted battles are reenactments where companies and regiments make actions taken in original battles beforehand. Tactical battle scenarios are games where both sides develop strategies and maneuvering tactics to beat opponents. The Society for Creative Anachronism hosts tournaments using practice versions of medieval and renaissance weapons.
Historians' perspectives on historical reenactment remain mixed regarding its value and fidelity. Some historians cite reenactment as a way for ordinary people to understand narratives about the past that academic history fails to provide. Others critique the anachronisms present and cite the impossibility of truly retrieving the past from the vantage point of the present. Lowenthal writes that we are not past but present people with experience, knowledge, feelings, and aims previously unknown. Further, some worry that focus on historical accuracy in details obscures broader historical themes critical for audiences to understand. By focusing on accuracy of dress, discussion of war causes like slavery ends confined to margins. Under guise of adhering to the past, true underlying purposes can be obscured when reenactors defend beliefs of prescribed side. One reenactor stated I do this because I believe in what they believed in while another warned that real pure hobby is thinking right not just looking right.
Continue Browsing
Common questions
Who organized the Eglinton Tournament of 1839?
Archibald Montgomerie, 13th Earl of Eglinton organized this medieval joust and revel held on a meadow at a loop in the Lugton Water. One hundred thousand spectators watched thirteen medieval knights on horseback perform the pageant.
When did Lord James Dunn bring the first known reenactment to life in London?
Lord James Dunn of Coniston brought the first known reenactment to life in London in 1638. A staged battle featuring dozens of costumed performers enacted a recent conflict during the English Civil War.
What is the difference between farbs and hardcore authentics in historical reenactment?
Farbs or polyester soldiers spend relatively little time and money achieving authenticity with regard to uniforms or accessories while anachronistic clothing and modern items are common among them. Hardcore authentics or progressives value thorough research and seek an immersive experience trying to live as much as possible as someone of the period might have done.
How many black reenactors participated in the 2013 Gettysburg event?
In 2013 five black reenactors at the 150th anniversary event at Gettysburg constituted largest bloc of black civilians ever seen at such an event. Astonished spectators stopped them constantly assuming they were portraying enslaved people.
Why do some historians critique the value of historical reenactment?
Some historians cite the impossibility of truly retrieving the past from the vantage point of the present and worry that focus on historical accuracy obscures broader historical themes critical for audiences to understand. By focusing on accuracy of dress, discussion of war causes like slavery ends confined to margins.