Monasticism

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Monasticism is a way of life that asks one question above all others: what would you give up to devote yourself entirely to the sacred? The answer, across thousands of years and dozens of traditions, has ranged from marriage and money to food, footwear, and even the right to own a bowl. From Buddhist bhikkhus receiving daily food from strangers in ancient India, to Martin Luther spending six years as a monk in Erfurt, Germany, to the Essenes copying scripture near the Dead Sea before the Common Era, the monastic impulse has surfaced in nearly every corner of the religious world. Some faiths built entire institutions around it. Others, like Islam and Sikhism, pushed back hard, arguing that holiness belongs inside ordinary life, not outside it. What makes monasticism so persistent? And what does each tradition's version of it reveal about what that tradition values most?

• 2. The Buddhist Blueprint

  ›

  The Buddha founded the Sangha, the community of ordained monastics, more than 2,500 years ago, and it grew out of something older still. Earlier wandering ascetics had already charted a path of radical renunciation, and the Buddha had studied under some of them before charting his own course. The earliest Buddhist monastics were expected to own almost nothing; the lay community provided food and shelter on a voluntary basis, and monks and nuns carried that arrangement into daily life.

  After the Buddha's death, referred to in the tradition as the parinibbana or Final Passing, the monastic order shifted from scattered wandering toward settled communal life. A key catalyst was the practice of gathering together during the rainy vassa season, which the Buddha himself had prescribed. That seasonal rhythm gradually became year-round residence in a monastery.

  The resulting rulebook, the Patimokkha, encoded this communal life in extraordinary detail. Theravada bhikkhus follow around 227 rules. Bhikkhunis, the female monastics, follow a larger number. The path into full ordination moves in stages: a novice, called a samanera, may ordain as young as eight years old, though full bhikkhu status requires being at least twenty.

  The order was male-only at first. It opened to women after the Buddha's own stepmother, Mahaprajapati, asked directly for permission to live as an ordained practitioner and received it. That opening carried conditions: bhikkhunis were required to live as novices for typically five years before higher ordination, longer than the period required of men. Bhikkhus and bhikkhunis were expected to serve the laity as a "field of merit", giving lay followers the opportunity to earn spiritual credit through their generosity.

• 3. Christian Roots and Rules

  ›

  Egypt and Syria stand out as the likely early centers of Christian monasticism, though the movement's precise origins remain obscure. What is clear is that by the fourth century, Christians in Egypt were drawn to eremitic life, retreating from society in the spirit of what the source calls "Desert Theology", a return to God through solitude. Athanasius named Saint Anthony the Great as one of the earliest hermit monks.

  Around 318, Saint Pachomius began organizing his followers into what became the first Christian cenobitic, or communal, monastery. From there the model spread rapidly across the Egyptian desert and throughout the eastern Roman Empire. Mar Awgin founded a monastery on Mount Izla above Nisibis in Mesopotamia around 350, and from that single foundation the communal tradition branched into Persia, Armenia, Georgia, and even India and China. Saint Sabbas the Sanctified organized the monks of the Judean Desert in a monastery near Bethlehem in 483, now called Mar Saba, regarded as the mother of all Eastern Orthodox monasteries. Emperor Justinian I ordered the founding of Saint Catherine's Monastery in the Sinai Peninsula between 527 and 565.

  Monasticism also gave women in the fourth and fifth centuries an escape route from the expected path of marriage and childbearing. It offered what the source describes as "great spiritual autonomy." Shenoute of Atripe, an influential figure in Egyptian monastic development, commanded a federation that included both male and female congregations, though his writings were sometimes cast in the masculine gender as if they applied only to men. In 379, Saint Melania the Elder founded the first dedicated monastery for women in Jerusalem; before that moment, female monasteries existed only as adjuncts to male ones.

  In the West, the Rule of Saint Benedict, created by Benedict of Nursia for his monastery at Monte Cassino in Italy around 529, became the dominant framework for monastic life throughout the Middle Ages and remains in use today. Around the 12th century, the Franciscan, Carmelite, Dominican, Servite, and Augustinian orders took a different approach, choosing to live in city convents among ordinary people rather than in secluded monasteries. St. Augustine's Monastery in Erfurt, Germany, founded in 1277, holds a particular place in Western history: Martin Luther lived there as a monk from 1505 to 1511.

• 4. Islam's Firm Refusal

  ›

  Muhammad's own example is the core of Islam's rejection of monasticism. The story of Uthman ibn Maz'un, one of the earliest converts to Islam, makes the point directly. Out of religious devotion, Uthman decided to devote himself to night prayers and take a vow of chastity from his wife, Khawlah bint Hakim. She went to Muhammad to complain. Muhammad's response was to remind Uthman that the Prophet himself lived a full family life, and that Uthman owed responsibilities to his household that he could not simply abandon.

  Muhammad was quoted on the question more than once. To companions who wanted to end their sexual lives, pray through every night, or fast without interruption, he said: "Do not do that! Fast on some days and eat on others. Sleep part of the night, and stand in prayer another part. For your body has rights upon you, your eyes have a right upon you, your wife has a right upon you, your guest has a right upon you." On other occasions, he repeated three times, "Woe to those who exaggerate!" and separately urged, "Moderation, moderation! For only with moderation will you succeed."

  The Quran itself addresses monasticism in Surah Al-Hadid, chapter 57, verse 27, stating that monasticism was invented by those who followed Jesus, not ordained by God, and that even those who adopted it did not observe it properly. Islam does endorse zuhd, an abstaining from excessive worldly pursuit, but stops well short of demanding withdrawal from ordinary life. A Hadith recorded by Imam Ahmad offers the tradition's own substitute for monasticism: "Every Prophet has Rahbaniyyah (monasticism); Jihad in the cause of Allah, the Exalted and Most Honored, is the Rahbaniyyah of this Ummah."

  Yet in a 1995 conference of the DIMMID, Christian de Chergé identified three genuine structural parallels between monastic and Muslim spirituality: the centrality of obedience in monasticism mirrors the Islamic concept of submission; both traditions gather for communal prayer multiple times daily; and the monastic practice of Lectio Divina, meditative reading of scripture as God's word addressed to the individual, echoes the Muslim understanding that God speaks directly through the Quran.

• 5. Hinduism, Jainism, and Renunciation

  ›

  A Hindu monk, called a sanyasi, sadhu, or swami, typically wears ochre-colored clothing that marks the choice of renunciation from a distance. The material constraints on a sadhu's life are spelled out in detail: personal property is restricted to a bowl, a cup, two sets of clothing, and necessary medical aids such as eyeglasses. Money may not be touched in any form. No personal relationships are maintained, and contact with women is forbidden under the vow. The sadhu is expected to treat every person equally, whether poor or rich, good or wicked, and to remain unmoved by praise, blame, pleasure, or pain.

  Some sadhus live in monasteries while others wander, trusting entirely in the donations of lay devotees for food and other necessities. Providing a sadhu with food is considered a highly meritorious act. Vaishnava monks shave their heads except for a small patch at the back; Shaivite monks let both hair and beard grow uncut, making the two groups immediately distinguishable.

  In Jainism the demands are even more radical. A Jain ascetic carries no permanent home and no possessions at all, walking barefoot from place to place except during the months of Chaturmas. They use no vehicle of any kind regardless of distance, own nothing, carry no phone, use no electricity, and eat only what people freely offer them, since they do not prepare their own food.

  Sikhism takes the opposing view. According to Sikh teaching, being God-centered while living as a householder is spiritually superior to the path of the ascetic. When Guru Nanak visited Gorakhmata and debated the true meaning of asceticism with yogis, he articulated a vision where inward purity matters more than outward marks: "Asceticism lies in remaining pure amidst impurities" and "He is an ascetic who treats everyone alike."

• 6. Judaism's Complicated Path

  ›

  The mainstream Jewish tradition does not encourage monastic ideals of celibacy or poverty. The Torah's commandments are understood as tools for sanctifying ordinary physical life, not escaping it. The teachings of the Baal Shem Tov went further, actively encouraging the pursuit of permitted pleasures as a way to "serve God with joy", citing Deuteronomy 28:47.

  Before the destruction of the Second Temple roughly two thousand years ago, however, Nazirite vows were common. A Nazirite refrained from grape products, haircuts, and contact with the dead, but did not withdraw from society, could marry and own property, and in most cases took the vow for a limited time only.

  The Essenes, a sect that flourished from the second century BC to AD 100, went considerably further. Josephus recorded that they existed in large numbers, with thousands living throughout Roman Judaea. They congregated in communal life devoted to asceticism, voluntary poverty, daily immersion in a mikvah, and abstinence from worldly pleasures, including marriage for some groups. Modern interest in the Essenes exploded after the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls, an extensive collection of religious documents including multiple copies of the Hebrew Bible untouched from as early as 300 years before Christ until their discovery in 1946. The documents are commonly believed to be the Essenes' library, though no definitive proof exists that the Essenes wrote them. The Israeli scholar Rachel Elior has questioned whether the Essenes existed at all.

  Two other distinct Jewish monastic traditions round out the picture. The Beta Israel of Ethiopia practice a form of monasticism believed to date to the 15th century, unique among Jewish communities worldwide. In pre-World War II European Ashkenazi communities, a practice called prishut saw married Talmud students enter voluntary exile from their families to study at a kollel in a different city, a practice associated with the Perushim.