Lucretia

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Lucretia died around 510 BC, and Rome was never the same. A noblewoman of the late Roman monarchy, her rape by Sextus Tarquinius and her subsequent suicide triggered a chain of events that ended centuries of royal rule and gave birth to the Roman Republic. What makes her story remarkable is not just its consequence but its persistence. The only records we have come from the Roman historian Livy and the Greco-Roman historian Dionysius of Halicarnassus, writing roughly 500 years after the fact. Modern scholars place her narrative within the category of Roman mythohistory, alongside tales like the rape of the Sabine women. These are stories that use violence against women to explain the turning points of Roman civilization. How did one woman's fate become the origin story of a republic that would shape Western governance for millennia? And who were the men who used her death to seize power?

• 2. The Ideal Wife

  ›

  Spurius Lucretius, a magistrate of Rome, had a daughter whose virtue would become legendary. Lucretia married Lucius Tarquinius Collatinus, and Roman writers presented that union as the ideal marriage. Both Livy and Dionysius describe her as an exemplar of beauty and purity by Roman standards. The story of how she came to the attention of the king's son begins with a bet. While the men were on furlough from the siege of Ardea, the sons of Tarquinius and their kinsmen Brutus and Collatinus argued over which of their wives best exemplified sophrosyne, a Greek concept of superb moral and intellectual character. They rode home to check. The wives of the others were found socializing and in conversation. Lucretia was found alone, working with wool in silence. She was awarded the victory. Collatinus invited the men to stay, but they returned to camp. The bet had been won, but it had also placed Lucretia in view of a man who would not forget her.

• 3. The Crime at Collatia

  ›

  Dionysius of Halicarnassus places the year of the rape at the beginning of the sixty-eighth Olympiad, when Isagoras was the annual archon at Athens, which corresponds to 508/507 BC. While Lucius Tarquinius Superbus, the last king of Rome, was engaged in the siege of Ardea, he sent his son Tarquin on a military errand to Collatia. Lucretia's own father, Spurius Lucretius, served as prefect of Rome and ensured the king's son was received as an honored guest at the governor's mansion. That hospitality became a weapon. In one version of the story, Tarquin entered Lucretia's bedroom in the night, avoiding the slaves sleeping at her door. He gave her a choice: become his wife and future queen willingly, or be killed alongside a slave so it would appear she had committed adultery. In an alternate telling preserved in the sources, Tarquin had returned from camp a few days later, slipped into her room, and began washing her belly with water to wake her, then tried to persuade her using, in the source's words, "every argument likely to influence a female heart." She refused. He raped her.

• 4. Three Versions of a Death

  ›

  The accounts of Dionysius, Livy, and Dio each preserve the suicide of Lucretia, but with different emphases that reveal how ancient writers interpreted her act. In Dionysius's version, Lucretia dressed in black the following day and traveled to her father's house in Rome, casting herself down in the supplicant's position and weeping before her father and husband. She insisted on summoning witnesses before she would speak. After disclosing the rape, she asked for vengeance from the chief magistrate of Rome himself. While the men debated what to do, she drew a concealed dagger and stabbed herself in the heart. She died in her father's arms. In Livy's version, she acts with greater deliberation, staying in her room and sending for her father and husband with instructions to each bring one friend as witness. Those chosen were Publius Valerius Publicola and Lucius Junius Brutus. The men told her that where there was no consent there was no guilt. She extracted an oath of vengeance from them with the words, "Pledge me your solemn word that the adulterer shall not go unpunished," then drew a poignard and stabbed herself. Dio's version gives Lucretia a direct and politically charged last speech: she calls herself a woman and says she will act as one, then demands that the men, if they truly are men who care for their wives and children, exact vengeance and show what kind of woman had been wronged.

• 5. Brutus and the Oath

  ›

  Lucius Junius Brutus had spent years performing the role of a fool to survive under a dangerous king. His mother was Tarquinia, daughter of Lucius Tarquinius Priscus, making him a Tarquin on her side and therefore a candidate for the throne if Superbus died. But because his father was a Junius, he was legally not a Tarquin, and so could propose the exile of the entire royal family without implicating himself. Superbus had taken Brutus's inheritance and kept him at court as entertainment. Standing over Lucretia's body, Brutus dropped the pretense. He grasped the bloody dagger and swore by Mars and all the gods to drive out Lucius Tarquinius Superbus, his wife, and his entire blood, by fire and sword and every means available, and to prevent any man from ever reigning in Rome again. Each mourner swore the same oath by the same blade. Livy preserves the oath almost word for word: "By this blood, most pure before the outrage wrought by the king's son, I swear... that I will drive hence Lucius Tarquinius Superbus, together with his cursed wife and his whole blood."

• 6. A Republic Is Born

  ›

  Lucretia's body was carried to the Roman Forum and placed on display. The sight of it functioned as evidence and argument simultaneously. Brutus, in his capacity as Tribune of the Celeres, used a minor magistracy to summon the curiae, the organization of patrician families that ratified royal decrees. By doing so, he transformed the gathered crowd into a legal legislative assembly. He then delivered what the sources describe as one of the more noted speeches of ancient Rome. He revealed that his act of foolishness had been a calculated deception. He charged the king with tyranny, with forcing plebeians into labor in the ditches and sewers of Rome, and with reaching the throne through the murder of Servius Tullius, Tarquin's own father-in-law. The king's wife Tullia, reportedly watching from her palace near the forum, fled toward the camp at Ardea in fear. A debate followed on the proper form of government. The assembly voted for a republic with two consuls in place of a king. Spurius Lucretius, Lucretia's father, was elected the first interrex. He proposed Brutus and Collatinus as the first two consuls. A second speech to the plebeians ratified the choice. The monarchy was ended while Lucretia's body remained in the forum.

• 7. Two Thousand Years of Retelling

  ›

  Livy's account in Ab Urbe Condita, composed around 25-8 BC, is the earliest surviving full historical treatment of Lucretia's story. Within a few decades, Ovid returned to the material in Book II of his Fasti, published in 8 AD, focusing on what he saw as the reckless ambition of Tarquin. By 426 AD, St. Augustine was citing Lucretia in The City of God to defend the honor of Christian women raped during the sack of Rome who had not killed themselves. Dante placed her in Canto IV of the Inferno, in the section of Limbo reserved for virtuous pagans. Geoffrey Chaucer told her story in The Legend of Good Women. Christine de Pizan used her, as Augustine had, to defend the sanctity of women in her City of Ladies. William Shakespeare wrote a long poem, The Rape of Lucrece, in 1594, drawing on Livy and Ovid, and he referenced her in Titus Andronicus, As You Like It, Macbeth, Cymbeline, and Twelfth Night. In 1931, Andre Obey wrote a stage adaptation that became the basis for Benjamin Britten's 1946 opera The Rape of Lucretia, which premiered at Glyndebourne, and also for Thornton Wilder's Broadway play Lucrece in 1932, with incidental music by Deems Taylor. In 1769, a doctor named Juan Ramis wrote a neoclassical tragedy in Catalan on the subject, a work considered significant in the history of that language. Each retelling shifts something: the emphasis on consent, the politics, the theology, the gender. But the core of the story, a woman who refused to survive dishonor without speaking it aloud, has remained.

• 8. Lucretia in Paint and Stone

  ›

  Since the Renaissance, the death of Lucretia has drawn artists across centuries, among them Titian, Rembrandt, Dürer, Raphael, Botticelli, Artemisia Gentileschi, Lucas Cranach the Elder, and many others. Two moments dominate the visual record: the rape itself, and Lucretia alone at the moment of her death. In both situations, her clothing is loosened or absent; Tarquin is normally fully clothed. The pattern placed her within a broader iconographic tradition grouping women from legend and scripture who were either powerless, like Susanna and Verginia, or who could only escape their circumstances through death, like Dido of Carthage. These subjects formed a counterpoint to the Power of Women theme, which depicted women dominating or acting violently against men. The same artists often painted both groups, particularly in Northern Renaissance art. Botticelli's treatment depicts three scenes in sequence: the rape, Brutus rousing the Roman people, and the suicide. Hendrick Goltzius produced a series of four engravings following the full arc of the story, including a scene of Lucretia spinning with her ladies. A work attributed to either Titian or Palma Vecchio shows Lucretia holding a knife with a shadowy male figure just behind her, identified in the source as either Tarquin or her husband. The ambiguity was apparently intentional, or at least unresolved. Artemisia Gentileschi, who had her own experience of sexual assault and its legal aftermath, brought a perspective to the subject no male artist could replicate, making her treatment one of the most studied in the tradition.