Jaw
The jaw is one of the oldest and most consequential structures in animal life, a pair of opposable articulated parts at the entrance of the mouth that gave rise to nearly every creature capable of actively pursuing a meal. Before jaws existed, the ancestors of today's vertebrates had none. They were filter feeders and passive grazers, locked out of the predatory arms race that would come to define life in the seas. The story of how jaws appeared, what they were first used for, and how they reshaped animal bodies across hundreds of millions of years is one of the most surprising chapters in the history of evolution. What were jaws actually for, before they were used for eating? Why do snakes have skulls so different from ours? And what connects the tiny bones inside your ear to an ancient jawbone that disappeared long ago?
The vertebrate jaw probably originally evolved in the Silurian period. It appeared first in the Placoderms, an early class of armored fish that diversified dramatically during the Devonian period. What makes the jaw's origin particularly striking is the leading hypothesis about why it arose at all. The original selective advantage offered by the jaw may not have been related to feeding. Instead, researchers believe it served respiration. The jaw was used in what is called the buccal pump, a mechanism still visible in modern fish and amphibians. In fish, this pump pushes water across the gills; in amphibians, it forces air into the lungs. Feeding came later. Over evolutionary time, the more familiar use of jaws to capture and process food was selected for, and it became a central function in vertebrates. The key anatomical building blocks were the two most anterior pharyngeal arches, the gill-supporting structures present in primitive jawless vertebrates. These are thought to have become the jaw itself and the hyoid arch. The hyoid system suspends the jaw from the braincase of the skull, allowing the jaws a striking degree of mobility. Fossils cannot directly confirm this transformation, but the arithmetic of living animals supports it. Jawed vertebrates, called Gnathostomes, have seven pharyngeal arches; jawless vertebrates, the Agnatha, have nine. The missing two arches are the ones that, the theory holds, became the jaw and the hyoid.
Insects, crabs, spiders, and their relatives took a different path entirely. In arthropods, the jaws are made of chitin, the tough polymer that also forms their exoskeletons. Rather than opposing vertically as in vertebrates, these jaws oppose laterally, moving from side to side. They may take the form of mandibles or chelicerae, depending on the lineage, and they are often composed of numerous distinct mouthparts working in concert. Their function centers on food acquisition, moving food toward the mouth, and initial mechanical processing. Many of these mouthparts are thought to be modified legs, structures that were repurposed by evolution for the tasks of eating. Associated appendages such as pedipalps can serve sensory or manipulative roles alongside the jaws themselves.
When vertebrates moved onto land and became tetrapods, the jaw underwent a dramatic simplification compared to the elaborate multi-boned arrangement in fish. Many of the upper jaw bones, including the premaxilla, maxilla, jugal, quadratojugal, and quadrate, fused to the braincase. The lower jaw bones, including the dentary, splenial, angular, surangular, and articular, fused together into a single unit called the mandible. The jaw articulates through a hinge joint between the quadrate and articular bones. Even within tetrapods, though, degrees of mobility vary. Some species have jaw bones completely fused, while others retain joints that permit independent movement of the dentary, quadrate, or maxilla. The most extreme case is the snake skull, which shows the greatest degree of cranial kinesis of any tetrapod group. This flexibility allows snakes to swallow prey items that are larger than their own heads.
The mammalian jaw tells one of the more counterintuitive stories in anatomy. In mammals, the jaw is composed of just two bones: the mandible forming the lower jaw and the maxilla forming the upper. That is a far smaller number than in earlier vertebrates. Two bones that were once part of the jaw structure in reptilian ancestors, the articular bone of the lower jaw and the quadrate, were reduced in size over evolutionary time and incorporated into the ear. This repurposing transformed jaw bones into ear bones, contributing to the hearing apparatus that gives mammals their acute sense of sound. As a result of this consolidation, mammals show little or no cranial kinesis. The mandible connects to the skull at the temporomandibular joints, where it meets the temporal bone. Temporomandibular joint dysfunction is a recognized disorder of these joints, marked by pain, clicking, and limited jaw movement. In therian mammals specifically, the premaxilla that formed the anterior tip of the upper jaw in reptiles has been reduced in size. Most of the tissue at the ancestral upper jaw tip became a protruded mammalian nose instead.
Sea urchins offer an entirely separate evolutionary solution to the problem of eating. Their jaws display five-part symmetry, a configuration that reflects the broader body plan of echinoderms. This structure is called Aristotle's lantern, named for an early observer who described it in detail. Each unit of the jaw holds a single tooth. Those teeth are composed of crystalline calcium carbonate, the same mineral that forms shells and coral, and they grow continuously throughout the urchin's life. The perpetual renewal of the teeth is an adaptation to a diet of hard materials including algae and encrusted surfaces. The five-part jaw represents an entirely independent invention of biting and scraping, arising in a lineage with no shared ancestor with vertebrate or arthropod jaw-bearers.
Common questions
What did jaws originally evolve for in vertebrates?
The original selective advantage offered by the vertebrate jaw may not have been related to feeding at all. Jaws are thought to have first functioned in the buccal pump, a mechanism that pushes water across the gills in fish or air into the lungs in amphibians. Feeding became a dominant function only later in evolutionary history.
When did the vertebrate jaw first appear?
The vertebrate jaw probably originally evolved in the Silurian period. It appeared in the Placoderm fish, which then diversified extensively during the Devonian period.
What are the two main types of jaw in arthropods?
Arthropod jaws take the form of mandibles or chelicerae, depending on the group. Unlike vertebrate jaws, they are made of chitin and oppose laterally rather than vertically. Many mouthparts associated with arthropod jaws are thought to be modified legs.
What is Aristotle's lantern in sea urchins?
Aristotle's lantern is the name for the jaw structure of sea urchins. It displays five-part symmetry, with each unit of the jaw holding a single continuously growing tooth composed of crystalline calcium carbonate.
What happened to reptile jaw bones during mammal evolution?
Two bones that formed part of the jaw in reptilian ancestors, the articular bone of the lower jaw and the quadrate, were reduced in size and incorporated into the ear in mammals. This transition contributed to the hearing apparatus characteristic of the mammalian lineage.
Which animal has the most mobile skull and jaw bones?
The snake skull shows the greatest degree of cranial kinesis among tetrapods. This extreme flexibility of the jaw bones allows snakes to swallow prey items larger than their own heads.
All sources
5 references cited across the entry
- 1bookDevelopment, function and evolution of teethM.M. Smith et al. — Cambridge University Press — 2000
- 2webFeeding mechanics and bite force modelling of the skull of Dunkleosteus terrelli, an ancient apex predatorPhilip S.L Anderson et al. — 28 November 2006
- 3journalEvolution of the mammalian middle earAllin EF — December 1975
- 4bookManual of temporomandibular disordersEdward F. Wright — Wiley-Blackwell — 2010
- 5journalMammalian face as an evolutionary noveltyHiroki Higashiyama et al. — November 2, 2021