Hanukkah

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Hanukkah begins on the 25th of Kislev each year, the night when a single jar of oil became the center of one of history's most enduring stories. The jar was small. It held enough oil to keep a lamp burning for one day. According to the Talmud, it burned for eight. That gap between what was possible and what happened is the heartbeat of this holiday.

  The Hebrew word Hanukkah means "to dedicate." The holiday commemorates a revolt in the 2nd century BCE, when a family of Jewish priests named the Maccabees drove the Seleucid Empire from Jerusalem and took back the Second Temple. But the story of what happened after the revolt, inside the Temple, in that moment with the oil, is what Hanukkah has carried across two thousand years.

  What makes Hanukkah unusual is the distance between its religious rank and its cultural weight. In strictly religious terms, it is a relatively minor holiday. It was instituted after the Hebrew Bible was completed, which means it carries no biblical authority. Yet it has become one of the most recognized Jewish observances in the world, especially in the West. How a modest feast of rededication became a signature of Jewish identity is a story about migration, memory, and the stubborn persistence of light in dark seasons.

• 2. The Revolt and Its World

  ›

  After the death of Alexander the Great in 323 BCE, Judea passed between empires. The Ptolemies of Egypt held it until 200 BCE, when Antiochus III of Syria defeated Ptolemy V at the Battle of Panium. Antiochus III was conciliatory: he guaranteed the Jews the right to live according to their ancestral customs and practice their religion at the Temple in Jerusalem.

  His son reversed all of that. Antiochus IV Epiphanes came to the throne in 175 BCE and within a few years had set off one of the ancient world's most consequential rebellions. In 168 BCE the Second Temple was looted. Jewish religious practices were suppressed. The following year, Antiochus ordered an altar to Zeus erected in the Temple itself, banned circumcision, and commanded that pigs be sacrificed on the altar.

  Modern scholars note that what began as an internal civil war complicated the picture. Two factions of Jews competed violently for the office of High Priest: traditionalists with Hebrew names like Onias on one side, and Hellenizing figures with Greek names like Jason and Menelaus on the other. When Antiochus sided with the Hellenizers, the conflict became an imperial suppression of traditional Judaism rather than a dispute between Jewish factions alone.

  The response came from Mattathias, a Jewish priest, and his five sons: Jochanan, Simeon, Eleazar, Jonathan, and Judah. Mattathias began the revolt by killing a Jew who moved to comply with the order to sacrifice to Zeus, and then killing the Greek official sent to enforce the decree. By 166 BCE, Mattathias was dead and Judah had taken command. Two years later, in 164 BCE, the revolt succeeded. Jerusalem was recovered, and the Temple was liberated and rededicated. Judah's epithet, Yehuda HaMakabi, translates as "Judah the Hammer."

• 3. The Oil and Its Sources

  ›

  The eight-day rededication of the Temple is described in 1 Maccabees, but that account says nothing about a miracle of oil. The miracle appears elsewhere, and later. The Talmud, committed to writing roughly 600 years after the events it describes, tells the story in Shabbat 21b: when the Maccabees reclaimed the Temple, they found that nearly all the ritual olive oil had been profaned. Only one sealed container remained, bearing the mark of the High Priest and holding enough oil for a single day's lighting. They used it. It burned for eight days, the time needed to press, prepare, and deliver fresh oil.

  The Talmud itself is explicit about what this meant: the following year, the sages appointed those eight days as a festival with the recital of Hallel and thanksgiving.

  An older account appears in Megillat Antiochus, probably composed in the 2nd century, which describes a bowl of oil sealed with the signet ring of the High Priest "from the days of Samuel the prophet." The text of Megillat Antiochus was read in Italian synagogues on Hanukkah during the Middle Ages, much as the Book of Esther is read on Purim, and it still forms part of the liturgy of the Yemenite Jews.

  The Jewish historian Josephus, writing in Jewish Antiquities, knew the festival but called it not Hanukkah but the "Festival of Lights." He attributed the name to the unexpected restoration of freedom of worship, writing that the name was given "because this liberty beyond our hopes appeared to us." That same usage carried forward: the first Hebrew translation of his Antiquities, published in 1864, used "Festival of Lamps," but the phrase "Festival of Lights" became standard in English by the end of the 19th century.

  The miracle of the oil first appears in the Babylonian Talmud and is widely regarded by modern scholars as a legend. Yet the medieval jurist Joseph Karo, writing in the 16th century, treated it as historical fact, posing a now-famous question: if there was already enough oil for one day, then the true miracle lasted only seven days, not eight. His willingness to argue the arithmetic meant he believed the story was real. His Shulchan Aruch became a primary code of Jewish law, and with it his acceptance of the miracle as fact passed into Orthodox practice.

• 4. How the Lights Are Lit

  ›

  The central ritual of Hanukkah is the lighting of the Hanukkah menorah, a nine-branched candelabrum with spaces for eight ceremonial lights and one additional candle called the shammash, meaning "attendant." The shammash serves a specific legal purpose: Jewish law, as specified in the Talmud, prohibits using the Hanukkah lights for ordinary illumination. The shammash is lit as a practical light so that no one accidentally benefits from the sacred flames. Rashi, writing a note to Shabbat 21b, put the reason plainly: the lights exist to publicize the miracle.

  One candle is added each night, building from one on the first night to eight on the last. The disagreement over this order goes back to two rabbinical schools of thought. The House of Shammai argued that eight candles should be lit on the first night and the number reduced by one each night, because the miracle was greatest at the start. The House of Hillel argued for the reverse: begin with one and add a candle each night, because the miracle grew in greatness each day. Jewish law adopted the position of Hillel. The Hanukkah acronym embedded in the holiday's Hebrew name records this decision: "Eight candles, and the halakha is according to the House of Hillel."

  In the United States, public Hanukkah observance expanded significantly in the 1970s when Rabbi Menachem M. Schneerson called for public awareness of the festival and encouraged the lighting of public menorahs. Since then, the Chabad movement within Hasidic Judaism has organized community-wide lightings of public menorahs in locations around the world.

  Among Ashkenazi Orthodox Jews, every male member of a household lights a full set of lights each night; among Sephardim, the common custom is one set for the entire household. On the Friday night of Hanukkah, the menorah must be lit before sunset, because candles cannot be lit on the Sabbath itself. Larger candles than usual are required that night so they remain burning through the lighting of the Shabbat candles.

• 5. Food, Games, and Gifts

  ›

  Fried food is the defining culinary fact of Hanukkah: everything cooked in oil connects back to the miracle. Among Ashkenazi families, potato pancakes called latkes are the central dish. Sephardic families eat sufganiyot, jam-filled doughnuts deep-fried in oil, as well as bimuelos, a fried fritter. Italian Jews and Hungarian Jews traditionally eat cheese pancakes called cassola. Romanian Jews eat pasta latkes. Syrian Jews consume Kibbet Yatkeen, a dish made with pumpkin and bulgur wheat, and their own version of keftes de prasa spiced with allspice and cinnamon. Indian Jews eat gulab jamun, fried dough balls soaked in sweet syrup.

  In Israel, sufganiyot have largely displaced latkes due to local economic factors and the influence of trade unions. Bakeries have expanded well beyond the traditional strawberry jelly filling into chocolate cream, vanilla cream, caramel, cappuccino, and others. A miniaturized version containing roughly half the calories of the standard 400-to-600-calorie sufganiyah has become popular in recent years.

  Dairy foods are a separate tradition tied to a different story. The deuterocanonical Book of Judith describes a widow named Judith who entered the camp of the Assyrian general Holofernes, fed him cheese until he was thirsty, then gave him wine until he fell into a drunken sleep, and beheaded him. The Assyrian army panicked and fled; the town was saved. Eating dairy on Hanukkah commemorates her heroism.

  The dreidel is a four-sided spinning top imprinted with Hebrew letters abbreviating the phrase "A great miracle happened there." Dreidels sold in Israel substitute one letter so the phrase reads "A great miracle happened here," marking the miracle's location as the land of Israel rather than a distant past. Hanukkah gelt, the gift of money to children, began as an East European custom of children giving their teachers a small sum at this time of year as a token of gratitude. One tradition favors the fifth night for giving gelt specifically because the fifth night, unlike all others, can never fall on the Sabbath and therefore never conflicts with the prohibition against handling money on that day.

• 6. Hanukkah in America

  ›

  Penina Moise's Hannukah Hymn, published in the 1842 Hymns Written for the Use of Hebrew Congregations, was an early marker of the holiday's transformation in American hands. By the 1800s, Jewish leaders including Max Lilienthal and Isaac Mayer Wise had begun rebranding Hanukkah as a children's celebration at their synagogues, complete with candy and songs. By the 1900s, gifts and decorations had appeared in stores, and Jewish women's magazines were publishing articles on holiday celebrations and gift-giving.

  Diane Ashton, who studied this transformation, attributed it to a conscious effort by American Jewish immigrants to adapt to American life by framing Hanukkah in terms of individualism and personal conscience drawn from Protestantism and the Enlightenment. On one hand, the mirroring of Christmas gave Jewish families and children a sense of belonging to American culture. On the other, it maintained a Jewish identity distinct from mainline Christian practice.

  The timing of Hanukkah on the Hebrew calendar means it frequently overlaps with Christmas. Sociologists have observed that Jewish families with children are more likely to celebrate Hanukkah than childless families, suggesting that parents use it to keep children from feeling excluded from the gift-giving season of their non-Jewish peers.

  In 2013, Thanksgiving and Hanukkah coincided for only the third time since Abraham Lincoln declared Thanksgiving a national holiday. The last overlap had been in 1899. The nature of the Gregorian and Jewish calendars being slightly out of sync means the convergence will not recur in the foreseeable future. The event generated a neologism: Thanksgivukkah.

  The earliest Hanukkah link to the White House was in 1951, when Israeli Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion presented President Harry Truman with a menorah. In 2008, President George W. Bush held an official Hanukkah reception using that same 1951 menorah, with a grandson of Ben-Gurion and a grandson of Truman lighting the candles together.

• 7. Zionism and Renewed Meaning

  ›

  Rabbi Shmuel Mohilever, an early religious Zionist, proposed in 1881 making Hanukkah the official holiday of the proto-Zionist organization Hovevei Zion in Russia. The proposal captured something real: Hanukkah offered a rare point where both religious and secular Zionists could find shared meaning. For secular nationalists, it was a story of military resistance and national sovereignty. For the religiously observant, the same story had always been there in the Al HaNissim prayer, which has been part of Jewish liturgy since at least 700 CE.

  In Mandate Palestine, schools took an early role in promoting public Hanukkah celebrations. Parades and public events became common in the early 20th century. With the establishment of the state of Israel, the national and military dimensions of the holiday came forward again, becoming once more the dominant frame.

  In North America, Hanukkah in the 21st century has taken a place alongside Passover as a primary symbol of Jewish identity. Both holidays, in their North American form, emphasize resistance and combine themes of national liberation with religious freedom. The holiday that Josephus first described as eight days of "very rich and splendid sacrifices" and hymns now carries a range of meanings that its ancient celebrants could not have anticipated, grounded still in the image of a single cruse of oil burning far longer than any reasonable expectation.