Great Purge

• 1. Origins And Power Vacuum

  ›

  The assassination of Sergei Kirov by Leonid Nikolaev in 1934 marked the beginning of a political purge that would consume millions. Joseph Stalin, who had gained control of the Communist Party by 1928, used this event to eliminate rivals and consolidate power. The murder occurred on the 1st of December 1934, and led to an investigation revealing a network of party members supposedly working against Stalin. Many arrested after Kirov's death admitted plans to kill Stalin themselves under duress. Historians debate whether Stalin arranged the murder or if sufficient evidence existed for such conclusions. Kirov was a staunch Stalin loyalist but may have been viewed as a potential rival due to his popularity among moderates. At the 1934 Party Congress, Kirov received only three opposing votes compared to Stalin's 292. This stark contrast highlighted the growing tension within the party leadership. The NKVD charged former opponents with treason, terrorism, sabotage, and espionage following the assassination. By 1936, the NKVD under Genrikh Yagoda began removing central party leadership and Old Bolsheviks from office. Soviet politicians who opposed or criticized Stalin were imprisoned or executed. The purges eventually expanded to affect the Red Army high command and other segments of society including the intelligentsia and kulaks. The term "purge" in Soviet political slang meant expulsion from party ranks which often resulted in arrest and execution. In 1933, the party expelled about 400,000 people before the Great Purge officially began between 1936 and 1938.

• 2. Moscow Show Trials

  ›

  Between 1936 and 1938, three large Moscow trials eliminated senior Communist Party leaders through forced confessions obtained via torture. The first trial held in August 1936 involved sixteen members accused of conspiring with fascist powers to assassinate Stalin. Chief defendants Grigory Zinoviev and Lev Kamenev confessed after enduring repeated beatings and simulated drownings. Their teenage son was arrested and charged with terrorism as part of the psychological pressure tactics used by interrogators. All defendants in this trial were sentenced to death and executed despite earlier promises that their lives would be spared. The second trial in January 1937 included seventeen lesser figures known as the anti-Soviet Trotskyite-centre. Thirteen of these defendants were shot while others received sentences in labor camps where they soon died. A secret military tribunal tried Red Army commanders including Mikhail Tukhachevsky in June 1937. Confessions were extracted using methods described by former OGPU officer Alexander Orlov which included sleep deprivation and threats against families. The third and final trial in March 1938 called the Trial of the Twenty-One targeted Nikolai Bukharin and other high-ranking officials. Christian Rakovsky survived until 1941 when he was killed in NKVD prisoner massacres. Bukharin initially repudiated his written confession but changed his plea after special measures dislocated his left shoulder. His young wife and infant son faced threats designed to wear him down during three months of interrogation. Western observers noted that Bukharin's confession contained subtle criticisms even as he admitted being a degenerate fascist working for capitalism. Romain Rolland and others wrote to Stalin seeking clemency but all leading defendants except two were executed. The Dewey Commission established in May 1937 found no evidence supporting charges made at the trials and concluded they were frame-ups.

• 3. Mass Operations Against Society

  ›

  NKVD Order No. 00447 issued on the 30th of July 1937 directed regional party chiefs to arrest ex-kulaks and anti-Soviet elements for execution or Gulag imprisonment. These individuals included former Tsarist civil servants White Army officers clergy members and participants in peasant rebellions. Local NKVD units rounded up people in markets and train stations to meet casework minimums while interrogating and beating prisoners. Death sentences were immediately enforceable and carried out at night in prisons or secluded forest areas run by the NKVD. The Kulak Operation arrested 669,929 people and executed 376,202 making it the largest single campaign of repression between 1937 and 1938. Campaigns targeting national minorities followed Yezhov's orders with the Polish Operation resulting in 143,810 arrests and 111,091 executions. Ethnic Poles comprised 12.5 percent of those killed despite representing only 0.4 percent of the population. National minorities targeted accounted for 36 percent of victims but just 1.6 percent of Soviet citizens. Seventy-four percent of ethnic minorities arrested during the Great Purge were executed compared to a 50-percent chance for kulak operation victims. NKVD Order No. 00486 dealt with wives and children of arrested individuals sentencing women to forced labor and placing minors in orphanages. Extended families lost all possessions which sealed their fate affecting 200,000 to 250,000 people of Polish background alone. Similar operations targeted Finns Latvians Estonians Bulgarians Afghans Iranians Greeks and Chinese using quota systems called album procedures. At least 100,000 special settlers under permanent police surveillance were arrested during the Great Purge. Eighty-five percent of 35,000 Orthodox clergy members were arrested while nearly annihilated. Common criminals such as thieves made up nearly one third of the 20,765 people executed on Moscow's Butovo firing range.

• 4. Military Purge Consequences

  ›

  The purge of the Red Army removed three of five marshals thirteen of fifteen army commanders eight of nine admirals and fifty of fifty-seven corps commanders. Only Semyon Budyonny and Kliment Voroshilov survived among the original five marshals from November 1935. The true figure of purged officers was between 3.7 and 7.7 percent though initially thought to be 25 to 50 percent due to systematic underestimation of officer corps size. Thirty percent of officers purged from 1937 to 1939 were allowed to return to service after being expelled from the party. German-forged documents alleging correspondence between Marshal Tukhachevsky and German high command supported claims but lacked factual basis since two group members were already imprisoned when documents supposedly reached Stalin. Field Marshal Keitel testified at Nuremberg that many German generals warned Hitler not to attack Russia arguing the Red Army remained formidable. Hitler rejected this opposition citing the elimination of first-class high-ranking officers in 1937 as his main reason for invading in 1941. Many German generals opposed an invasion believing the Red Army's intellectual leadership had been destroyed by Stalin's actions. Despite combined firepower exceeding German forces the purge effectively crippled the Red Army by destroying its officer corps. This destruction became the decisive element persuading Hitler to launch Operation Barbarossa in June 1941. The disruption caused by the purge contributed significantly to the Red Army's disastrous military performance during the initial stages of World War II.

• 5. Stalin's Direct Involvement

  ›

  Archival evidence confirms Joseph Stalin was intimately involved in authorizing execution lists throughout the Great Purge period. Russian historian Oleg V. Khlevniuk states theories about spontaneous terror or loss of central control are unsupported by historical records. Stalin signed 357 lists in 1937 and 1938 authorizing executions of approximately 40,000 people with around 90 percent confirmed shot. He issued specific instructions about individuals telling Nikolai Yezhov questions like Isn't it time to squeeze this gentleman? Where is he: in a prison or a hotel? Reviewing one list Stalin added beat beat! next to M.I. Baranov's name. While reviewing another list he reportedly muttered Who's going to remember all this riff-raff in ten or twenty years time? No one. He ordered 100,000 Buddhist lamas in Mongolia to be liquidated though political leader Peljidiin Genden resisted the order. Contemporary commentators surmised that Stalin may have failed to anticipate NKVD excesses under Yezhov and objected to large numbers being purged. When Yezhov announced 200,000 party members were expelled Stalin interrupted saying they were very many suggesting expulsion of 30,000 former Trotskyists would be a bigger victory. Stephen Wheatcroft wrote that while Hitler constituted murder causing purposive deaths those under Stalin fell into execution category yet caused death by criminal neglect exceeding Hitler's ruthlessness. Stalin undoubtedly executed innocent people but likely thought many guilty of crimes against state while feeling executions would deter others.

• 6. Western Awareness And Silence

  ›

  Although trials of Soviet leaders received wide publicity hundreds of thousands of arrests and executions remained hidden from Western eyes until Gulag inmates reached the West with stories. Jean-Paul Sartre said evidence of camps should be ignored so French proletariat would not be discouraged according to Robert Conquest. Walter Duranty of The New York Times noted proof beyond reasonable doubt justifying treason verdicts despite fraudulent charges. American ambassador Joseph E. Davies claimed justification for verdicts while Beatrice and Sidney Webb authored Soviet Communism: A New Civilization supporting the regime. Communist parties everywhere transmitted Soviet lines though some critical reporting came from left-wing outlets like The Manchester Guardian. H.R. Knickerbocker reported executions calling them great purges in 1941 describing how over four years affected top fourth or fifth of Party Army Navy Air Force leaders plus new Bolshevik intelligentsia. He estimated five million kulaks died at once or within few years during dekulakization. Khrushchev's revelations in 1956 profoundly impacted Western communist parties when Daily Worker published Secret Speech following The New York Times lead. Attempts were made to silence witnesses in many Western nations especially France where legal actions ensued presenting definitive evidence validating labor-camp testimonies. These efforts failed as historians later confirmed widespread fraudulence underlying charges presented at Moscow show trials.

• 7. Post-Stalin Rehabilitation Efforts

  ›

  Nikita Khrushchev delivered his secret speech On the Cult of Personality and Its Consequences on the 25th of February 1956 to a closed session of the 20th Party Congress acknowledging Stalin acted through imposing concepts rather than persuasion. He stated ninety-eight out of 139 Central Committee members elected at 17th Congress were arrested and shot mostly between 1937-1938 attributing this to abuse of power by Stalin. Confessions gained with cruel tortures were admitted as invalid while many victims declared innocent during rehabilitation processes beginning in 1954. Mikhail Tukhachevsky and other generals convicted in Red Army trial were rehabilitated in 1957 though Bukharin waited until 1988 for similar treatment. Leon Trotsky never received official rehabilitation from USSR despite being considered major contributor to Marxist theory. Two Soviet commissions investigated show trials after Stalin's death: first led by Molotov 1956-1957 second Shvernik Commission working 1961-1963. Final reports admitted accusations unproven during trials evidence obtained by lies blackmail physical influence. Mass graves discovered late 1980s during glasnost period included Kurapaty Belarus site where demonstrators clashed with police in 1988. Butovo firing range near Moscow became shrine to victims between August 1937 and October 1938 when over 20,000 people shot buried there. Joffe Foundation launched Map of Memory website in 2016 recording locations current use 411 burial grounds across Russia linked forced resettlement deportation Gulag secret execution sites. Wall of Grief opened the 30th of October 2017 by Vladimir Putin recognized Soviet crimes officially though controversially.