Fumimaro Konoe

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Fumimaro Konoe committed suicide on the morning of the 16th of December 1945, swallowing potassium cyanide in his room rather than face arrest for war crimes. The night before, his son Michitaka had searched that same room for weapons and poison. The two men had talked at length about the invasion of China, the failed negotiations with the United States, and the weight of responsibility Konoe felt toward the emperor and the Japanese people. When Michitaka apologized for not being a more dutiful son, his father's reply was blunt: "What does 'to be filial' mean?" They sat in silence until Michitaka told him to go to sleep. Michitaka gazed at his father. His father gazed back. Michitaka had never seen such a strange and distasteful expression on that face. For the first time, he understood what his father intended.

  Konoe had been one of the most powerful men in Japan. He served as Prime Minister twice, from 1937 to 1939 and again from 1940 to 1941. He presided over Japan's invasion of China, the signing of the Tripartite Pact with Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy, and the chain of events that pulled the Pacific into the Second World War. Yet he also made late, halting attempts to stop the slide toward catastrophe, attempts that consistently fell short. Who was Fumimaro Konoe? Was he a peacemaker who lacked the will to make peace, or a man whose convictions about Japan's destiny made war all but inevitable?

• 2. Aristocrat and Outsider

  ›

  Fumimaro Konoe was born in Tokyo on the 12th of October 1891 into what historian Eri Hotta described as "First among the go-sekke": the most prestigious noble house in Japan. The Konoe family had its origins in the ancient Fujiwara clan, which Minamoto no Yoritomo divided into the Five Regent Houses in the 12th century. As that house's 29th leader, Fumimaro carried a lineage that was almost incomprehensibly old by modern political standards. He was also unusually tall for his time: over 180 cm, at a moment when the average height of Japanese men was around 160 cm.

  His childhood was marked by private loss. His mother died shortly after his birth. His father then married her younger sister, and Fumimaro was kept in the dark about the substitution until he was 12, when his father died and the truth came out. That same death left him with an inherited title and an inherited debt. Financial support from the zaibatsu Sumitomo, and the auction of Fujiwara family heirlooms, eventually restored the family's solvency.

  Conventional aristocratic education pointed toward Gakushuin, the institution created to educate the children of Japan's nobility. Konoe instead chose the First Higher School for university preparation, inspired by its dean Inazo Nitobe. He went on to study philosophy at Tokyo Imperial University, then transferred to the law department of Kyoto Imperial University. There one of his professors was the Marxist economist Hajime Kawakami, under whose influence Konoe became interested in socialism and wrote a Japanese translation of Oscar Wilde's "The Soul of Man Under Socialism." It was in Kyoto that he also met the genro Saionji Kinmochi, who became his mentor and would shape his political career for decades.

  His younger brother Hidemaro Konoye later founded the NHK Symphony Orchestra. The family that had once traded heirlooms to pay off debts was quietly reshaping Japanese cultural life from multiple directions at once.

• 3. Versailles and Its Discontents

  ›

  In December 1918, before the Paris Peace Conference had even opened, Konoe published an essay arguing that western democracies championed democracy, peace, and self-determination only hypocritically, while enforcing colonial dominance through racially discriminatory imperialism. He attacked the proposed League of Nations as a mechanism to preserve that colonial status quo. American journalist Thomas Franklin Fairfax Millard translated the essay and published a rebuttal in his journal, Millard's Review of the Far East. Saionji considered the writing reckless. After it attracted international attention, Konoe was invited to dinner by Sun Yat-sen, who admired Japan's rapid modernization and who shared Konoe's interest in pan-Asian nationalism.

  At the peace conference itself, Konoe was among the Japanese diplomats who proposed the Racial Equality Proposal for the Covenant of the League of Nations. The clause received support from Japan, France, Yugoslavia, Greece, Italy, Brazil, Czechoslovakia, and China. U.S. President Woodrow Wilson overturned the vote, declaring that unanimous support was required. For Konoe, that outcome was not simply a diplomatic defeat. It confirmed a worldview he would carry for the rest of his life: that the Anglo-American powers were hypocrites who preached equality while enforcing racial hierarchy.

  Back in Japan, he published a booklet describing his travels to France, Britain, and the United States. He noted the anger he felt at rising anti-Japanese sentiment in America and the discrimination faced by Japanese immigrants. He described China not as a natural partner but as a rival in international relations. The intellectual framework he formed at Versailles at age 27 would prove remarkably durable. Twenty years later, in a 1935 speech, he was still arguing that the "monopolization" of resources by the Anglo-American alliance must end and be replaced by an "international new deal."

• 4. The House of Peers and Political Calculations

  ›

  In 1916, while still at university, Fumimaro took his father's seat in the House of Peers, the upper chamber of the Imperial Diet. The most powerful faction in the emerging Taisho democracy actively recruited him: the kenkyukai, a conservative, militaristic group led by Yamagata Aritomo and opposed to democratic reform. He joined them in September 1922, though his reasoning was self-interested rather than ideological. He believed the House of Peers should stay neutral in partisan politics, lest a politically compromised peerage have its privileges curtailed.

  His approach to universal male suffrage followed the same logic. During the premiership of Kato Komei, Konoe supported extending the vote to all men not out of democratic conviction but as a way to channel popular discontent and reduce the risk of violent revolution. He left the kenkyukai in November 1927, once the house of peers had allied itself too closely with lower-house factions. Stability, not ideology, was the operating principle.

  Through the Japan Youth Hall, where he became managing director in 1921, Konoe built relationships with home ministry officials who shared his concern about local political bosses using pork-barrel politics to manipulate the rural vote. In 1925, he and these officials formed the Alliance for a New Japan, which advocated running candidates outside the established parties. An associated organization, the Association for Election Purification, aimed to support candidates not beholden to local bosses. The alliance formed a political party, the meiseikai, but failed to secure popular support and dissolved by 1928.

  Konoe ascended to the presidency of the House of Peers in 1933. For the next several years he mediated between elite political factions, the military, and what remained of civilian government. In 1932, political parties had lost control of the cabinet entirely. Cabinets were now assembled from alliances of political elites and military factions, and the space for civilian authority was narrowing fast.

• 5. War With China

  ›

  At a costume party before Saionji's daughter's wedding in 1937, Konoe arrived dressed as Adolf Hitler. The ageing genro had grown alarmed by what he took to be Konoe's attraction to fascism, despite his protege's liberal education and his earlier support for universal suffrage. Despite those misgivings, Saionji nominated Konoe to Emperor Hirohito, and in June 1937 Konoe became Prime Minister.

  One month after taking office, Japanese and Chinese troops clashed near Beijing in the Marco Polo Bridge Incident. A consensus had emerged among Japanese military leaders that the country was not ready for full-scale war, and a truce was reached on the 11th of July. The ceasefire broke by the 20th of July after Konoe's government sent additional divisions to China, triggering full-scale war. In November 1937, he created a joint conference system between the civil government and the military, called liaison conferences, but the arrangement gave equal weight to military and civilian members, tilting policy toward the generals.

  Before Nanjing fell, Chiang Kai-shek attempted to negotiate through the German ambassador. Konoe rejected the overture. After Nanjing was captured, the Imperial Japanese Army favoured accepting a German offer of mediation. Konoe instead chose to escalate, proposing deliberately humiliating terms that he knew Chiang would never accept, in pursuit of what he called total victory. Historian Gerhard Weinberg wrote of this moment that "the one time in the decade between 1931 and 1941 that the civilian authorities in Tokyo mustered the energy, courage and ingenuity to overrule the military on a major peace issue they did so with fatal results - fatal for Japan, fatal for China, and for Konoe himself."

  In January 1938, Konoe issued a statement blaming Chinese aggression for the ongoing conflict. When pressed for clarification, he said he had meant not merely non-recognition of Chiang's regime but that Japan would "reject it" and "eradicate it." In April 1938, he pushed the State General Mobilization Law through the Diet, which declared a state of emergency, gave the central government control over all manpower and material, and rationed raw materials into the Japanese market. Konoe resigned in January 1939, leaving the war he had done much to create unfinished, and was appointed chairman of the Privy Council. A public that had been told the war was a string of victories was bewildered.

• 6. The Tripartite Pact and Second Premiership

  ›

  The Japanese Army forced Konoe's return in July 1940, after Prime Minister Mitsumasa Yonai refused to align Japan with Nazi Germany. Army minister Shunroku Hata resigned, the army declined to nominate a replacement, and the Yonai Cabinet collapsed. Saionji, making what would be his final political intervention before his death later that year, endorsed Konoe once more.

  In 1940 Konoe founded the Imperial Rule Assistance Association, a wartime mobilization organization that pressured political parties to dissolve themselves into a single structure under his leadership. He resisted calls to model it on the Nazi party, partly because he believed party politics would revive the factional strife of the 1920s and partly because he felt heading a party would be beneath the dignity of a nobleman. The IRAA was built, with some irony, in alliance with the local political bosses Konoe had spent years trying to weaken, since their cooperation was necessary to mobilize the rural population.

  Foreign minister Yosuke Matsuoka signed the Tripartite Pact on the 27th of September 1940, over the objections of some of Konoe's own advisors, including former Japanese ambassador to the United States Kikujiro Ishii. At a press conference on the 4th of October, Konoe warned that if the United States continued what he called provocative actions and chose to misunderstand the intentions of the tripartite powers, there would be no option left but war.

  In November 1940, Japan signed a treaty recognizing Wang Jingwei's government in Nanjing, though Konoe's government declined to hand over all occupied territory, undercutting the new regime's authority. Wang had been a disciple of Sun Yat-sen, whom Konoe had dined with decades earlier; the puppet government they built in his memory was largely seen as illegitimate. In December 1940, Britain reopened the Burma Road and lent ten million pounds to Chiang's Kuomintang. Konoe resumed negotiations with the Dutch in January 1941 in an attempt to secure an alternate supply of oil.

• 7. The Failed Summit and the Road to Pearl Harbor

  ›

  On the 18th of April 1941, word arrived from Konoe's chosen ambassador to Washington, Admiral Kichisaburo Nomura, of a potential diplomatic breakthrough: a draft understanding between the United States and Japan. The proposal had been drafted by two American Maryknoll priests, James Edward Walsh and James M. Drought, who had reached Roosevelt through Postmaster General Frank C. Walker. In consultation with banker Tadao Ikawa, Colonel Hideo Iwakura, and Nomura, the outline offered American recognition of Manchukuo, a merging of Chinese governments, normalization of trade, and a Japanese troop withdrawal from China in exchange for Japanese immigration to the United States proceeding on equal terms with other nationals.

  When foreign minister Matsuoka returned to Tokyo, he denounced the draft as a betrayal of Japan's Nazi allies, left a liaison conference claiming exhaustion, and began to openly criticize Konoe. Konoe retreated to his villa claiming a fever, rather than forcing the issue. Matsuoka rewrote the proposal into a counteroffer that stripped most of the Japanese concessions on China and Pacific expansion. When he then sent the revised draft to Berlin for approval without cabinet permission, Konoe and his cabinet resigned en masse on the 16th of July 1941 and reformed the government without Matsuoka.

  The third cabinet took office on the 18th of July 1941, but the diplomatic window was closing. The United States froze Japanese assets on the 24th of July, after Japan occupied all of French Indochina. The U.S. supplied 93% of Japan's oil in 1940; on the 1st of August the oil embargo began. Navy chief of staff Osami Nagano told Emperor Hirohito that Japan's oil stockpiles would be fully depleted in two years.

  Konoe requested a face-to-face summit with Roosevelt on the 8th of August, encouraged by Kinkazu Saionji, the grandson of his deceased mentor. Roosevelt, after condemning Japanese aggression in Indochina, said he was open to the idea and suggested Juneau, Alaska, as a venue. But at a liaison conference on the 3rd of September, the military imposed a deadline: Konoe would have until mid-October to secure a diplomatic agreement, or Japan would commit to war. Konoe met the emperor on the 5th of September with chiefs of staff General Hajime Sugiyama and Admiral Osami Nagano to explain this decision. The emperor asked Sugiyama directly about the odds of success in an open war with the West. After a positive answer, Hirohito scolded him, noting that the army had once promised the invasion of China would be finished in three months.

  On the 7th of October, Konoe met Tojo and told him that "military men take wars too lightly." Tojo replied that "occasionally one must gather up enough courage, close one's eyes and jump off the platform of the Kiyomizu." Konoe answered that while such a leap might be acceptable for an individual, it was not a policy he could adopt as the man responsible for a nation of a hundred million people and a polity that had lasted twenty-six hundred years. On the 12th of October, at the meeting that became known as the Tekigaiso conference, Konoe told his military ministers he had no confidence in the war they were about to wage and would not lead it. He resigned on the 16th of October 1941. Two days later, Hirohito appointed Hideki Tojo as his successor. Six weeks after that, Japan attacked Pearl Harbor.

• 8. The Konoe Memorial and Final Reckoning

  ›

  On the 29th of November 1941, at a luncheon with the emperor attended by all living former prime ministers, Konoe voiced his objection to war. When news of the Pearl Harbor attack reached him, his response was: "What on earth? I really feel a miserable defeat coming; this will only last 2 or 3 months."

  Konoe played a role in the fall of the Tojo Cabinet in 1944 following the defeat in the Battle of Saipan. In February 1945, at his first private audience with the emperor in three years, he advised Hirohito to begin negotiations to end the war. Grand Chamberlain Hisanori Fujita recorded that the emperor, still hoping for a decisive victory he called a tennozan, firmly refused.

  On the 14th of February 1945, Konoe submitted a formal report to Hirohito titled "The Konoe Memorial." In it he called for surrender to the Allies, arguing that continued resistance risked a communist revolution in Japan. He named the threat specifically: "communist agitators" such as Okano, the alias of Japanese Communist Party leader Sanzo Nosaka, as well as Soviet expansionism and pro-Soviet elements within the Japanese government itself.

  After Japan's surrender, Konoe briefly served in the cabinet of Prince Naruhiko Higashikuni, the first post-war government. He came under suspicion of war crimes after refusing to cooperate with U.S. Army officer Bonner Fellers in an operation aimed at shielding Emperor Hirohito and the imperial family from criminal responsibility. Konoe chose death over the public humiliation of a trial. He was buried at the Konoe clan cemetery at the temple of Daitoku-ji in Kyoto. His grandson, Morihiro Hosokawa, became Prime Minister of Japan on the 9th of August 1993, fifty years after the country Fumimaro had helped drag into catastrophe had rebuilt itself into something his grandfather never imagined.