Franco Modigliani

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Franco Modigliani was born on the 18th of June 1918 in Rome, into a Jewish family headed by a pediatrician father. He died in Cambridge, Massachusetts, in 2003, still teaching at MIT in the final months of his life, aged 85. Between those two dates runs one of the stranger intellectual journeys in the history of economics: from a prize handed to him by Benito Mussolini, to a Nobel Medal awarded by the Swedish Academy, to a model that guided monetary policy in Washington for many decades.

  What forces shaped a man who began as a contributor to a fascist magazine and ended as a trustee of an organization devoted to peace and economic security? How did a law student in 1930s Rome become the architect of ideas that still sit at the center of corporate finance and macroeconomic policy? And why, decades after his Nobel Prize, did critics from the left find him a complicated figure to praise?

  1944

• 2. Rome, Fascism, and Flight

  ›

  Modigliani entered the Sapienza University of Rome at seventeen, studying law rather than economics. During his second year, he submitted an entry to a nationwide economics contest run by the official student organization of the Italian state, and won first prize. The award was placed in his hands personally by Benito Mussolini.

  That moment did not sit in isolation. Modigliani wrote essays for the fascist magazine Lo Stato, showing what the record describes as an inclination for fascist ideological currents critical of liberalism. He also produced an article, written in Italian, arguing the case for socialism in production management, drawing on the work of earlier market socialists including Abba Lerner and Oskar Lange. The intellectual currents pulling at him were not yet settled.

  The passage of racial laws in Italy in 1938 ended that chapter decisively. Modigliani left the country with his then-girlfriend Serena Calabi, joining her parents in Paris. He returned briefly to Rome to defend his laurea thesis, received his diploma on the 22nd of July 1939, then went back to Paris. That same year, together with Serena's family, they all emigrated to the United States. The man who had accepted a prize from Mussolini was now a refugee.

  356739

• 3. The New School and a Groundbreaking Thesis

  ›

  At the Graduate Faculty of the New School for Social Research, Modigliani enrolled and found two supervisors who would prove decisive: Jacob Marschak and Abba Lerner, the same Lerner whose market-socialist arguments he had cited in fascist Italy. His doctoral dissertation, completed in 1944, took the IS-LM model developed by John Hicks and extended it into new territory. The work is described in the record as groundbreaking.

  From 1942 to 1944, while still completing that doctorate, Modigliani taught at Columbia University and Bard College as an instructor in economics and statistics. In 1946 he became a naturalized American citizen. Two years later, in 1948, he joined the faculty at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. The man who had studied law in Rome was now shaping a generation of American economists.

  846944

• 4. Life-Cycle Savings and Corporate Finance

  ›

  Beginning in the 1950s, Modigliani helped originate the life-cycle hypothesis, a framework for understanding why people save. The core idea is that consumers aim for a stable level of consumption across an entire lifetime, saving during working years and drawing down those savings in retirement. It was an attempt to explain aggregate saving behavior at the level of the whole economy.

  While a member of the Carnegie Mellon University faculty, where he served from 1952 to 1962, Modigliani collaborated with Merton Miller on a theorem that would define corporate finance for generations. The Modigliani-Miller theorem, formulated in 1958, argues that under certain assumptions the value of a firm is unaffected by whether it is financed through equity or debt. The debt-to-equity ratio, the theorem concludes, is unimportant for private firms. The simplicity of the claim was as striking as its implications, and it anchored decades of academic finance.

  In 1962, Modigliani joined MIT as an Institute Professor. The rational expectations hypothesis, now a central pillar of macroeconomics, is traced by economists to a 1954 paper Modigliani co-wrote with Emile Grunberg.

  1110161412

• 5. Policy Debates and the NIRU

  ›

  In the early 1960s, Modigliani co-authored a response with Albert Ando to a 1963 paper by Milton Friedman and David I. Meiselman. That exchange ignited what became known among economists as the monetary and fiscal policy debate, a dispute that continued for more than sixty years.

  In 1975, Modigliani introduced a new concept alongside his former student Lucas Papademos: the non-inflationary rate of unemployment, abbreviated NIRU. The term was framed as an improvement over the established concept of the natural rate of unemployment. Both terms describe a threshold level of unemployment below which inflation begins to rise. The NIRU framing drew criticism from Post-Keynesian economists, who disputed the degree to which Modigliani's thinking could be called Keynesian at all.

  Late in his career, Modigliani and his granddaughter Leah Modigliani developed what is now called the Modigliani Risk-Adjusted Performance measure, published in 1997. It derives from the Sharpe ratio and adjusts the risk-adjusted returns of an investment portfolio relative to a benchmark such as the overall market.

  1920232126

• 6. The Nobel and the Federal Reserve Model

  ›

  In October 1985, the Nobel Prize in Economics was awarded to Modigliani for what the citation called his pioneering analyses of saving and of financial markets. The same year, MIT gave him its James R. Killian Faculty Achievement Award. In 1997, the University of Naples Federico II conferred an honorary degree in Management Engineering.

  Less celebrated but perhaps more consequential in practical terms was the model Modigliani designed in the late 1960s on a contract with the Federal Reserve. Called the MIT-Pennsylvania-Social Science Research Council model, it guided monetary policy in Washington for many decades. His papers are now held at Duke University's Rubenstein Library.

  Despite his critics on the left, Modigliani also held positions that broke with mainstream consensus. He agreed early with heterodox economists that the widespread unemployment in Europe during the late twentieth century was driven by austerity-induced demand shortfalls rather than structural factors. That dissenting view kept him from being entirely claimed by any single school. He became a trustee of Economists for Peace and Security, the organization formerly known as Economists Allied for Arms Reduction, where he was regarded as an influential adviser.

  274302135

• 7. The End of a Long Career

  ›

  Modigliani died in Cambridge, Massachusetts, in 2003, still an active member of the MIT faculty. He had kept teaching until the last months of his life. Serena Modigliani-Calabi, whom he had married in Paris in 1939 and with whom he had two children, Andre and Sergio, outlived him. She remained active in progressive politics, most notably with the League of Women Voters, until her own death in 2008, described as an outspoken believer in participatory democracy.

  The Modigliani-Miller theorem and the life-cycle hypothesis continue to appear in economics curricula worldwide. The MIT-Pennsylvania-Social Science Research Council model, built quietly on a Federal Reserve contract, shaped the monetary decisions of Washington policymakers long after the man who designed it had turned his attention elsewhere.

  19383940