Dutch and Flemish Renaissance painting

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Dutch and Flemish Renaissance painting has a peculiar way of hiding its heroes. Consider a painting long associated with Pieter Brueghel the Elder. A peasant ploughs a field in the foreground. Near the water's edge, a pair of pale legs disappears beneath the surface. Those legs belong to Icarus, the figure from ancient legend who flew too close to the sun. The peasant does not look up. That painting, The Fall of Icarus, is now considered a copy of a Brueghel work. It is described as atypical in many ways. Yet the impulse it carries runs through much of what 16th-century painters in the Low Countries were doing. Dutch and Flemish Renaissance painting spans the entire 16th century. At its opening stands Hieronymus Bosch. At its close are the late Northern Mannerists Hendrik Goltzius and Joachim Wtewael. Through Antwerp, the most important artistic center in the region, its painters absorbed the precision of older Netherlandish masters. They also drew on formal innovations arriving from Italy. But again and again, they turned toward the world as it actually was. This documentary asks why that happened, what made Bosch so singular, and how painters here built entirely new subjects. The answers involve landscapes, kitchen tables, and the faces of strangers.

  1

• 2. Bosch and the Gothic Dream

  ›

  Hieronymus Bosch arrived at the start of the 16th century and promptly ignored almost everything his era valued most. His work is full of seemingly irrational imagery. Scholars find it genuinely difficult to interpret. More than anything else, Bosch seems strangely modern. The world he painted belongs more to Gothic art than to the Italian Renaissance. It is a world of dreams. Some Venetian prints from the same period show a comparable degree of fantasy, which suggests Bosch was not entirely without company in his impulses. But no other painter built an entire body of work on that kind of strangeness.

  Bosch worked for European courts. The images he produced on canvas left a long legacy. Other painters in the Low Countries were busy absorbing lessons from Italy. Bosch was building something that seemed to have come from an older, darker century. Jan Mabuse, Maarten van Heemskerck, and Frans Floris would each make very different choices, embracing Italian models in ways Bosch never chose to consider.

  1

• 3. Antwerp and the Italian Turn

  ›

  Jan Mabuse, Maarten van Heemskerck, and Frans Floris each represent a decisive phase in the turn toward Italian models. Italian Renaissance influences had begun appearing in painting from the Low Countries around 1500. Even then, the older Netherlandish style proved remarkably persistent. The first phase of Italian-inflected work in the region is called Antwerp Mannerism. Painters in this phase showed some Italian influence but maintained the subjects and approach of their Netherlandish predecessors.

  The Romanists came next. They adopted Italian forms far more thoroughly. Mabuse, van Heemskerck, and Floris each absorbed those models and worked them into their own artistic language. After 1550, something further shifted. Flemish and Dutch painters began showing greater interest in nature and beauty as subjects worth pursuing in their own right. The resulting work incorporated Renaissance elements but stayed far from the polished lightness of Italian Renaissance painting. Joachim Patinir was already demonstrating what that northern approach could achieve, building an entire compositional method around the expanse of the natural world.

  1

• 4. The World Landscape

  ›

  Joachim Patinir is credited with inventing the compositional type known as the world landscape. In his paintings, the viewpoint rises high above the scene. The land stretches back toward a distant horizon. Human figures appear within the scene but are made small by the natural world around them.

  Pieter Brueghel the Elder took Patinir's invention and perfected it. Pieter Aertsen followed Brueghel in helping to popularize genre painting. Genre scenes depicted the ordinary activities of daily life. Brueghel chose to depict the peasant rather than the prince. Pieter Aertsen brought a similar preference for lower subjects into a very different setting, one built around the kitchen and the market table.

  1

• 5. The Monumental Still Life

  ›

  Pieter Aertsen, from the mid-century onward, established a form of painting unlike anything that had come before. Large compositions placed kitchen tables and market goods at the center. Generous spreads of food filled the foreground. Genre figures moved through the scene. Tucked into the background were small religious or moral scenes, visible but deliberately secondary.

  Aertsen's nephew Joachim Beuckelaer followed him in developing this approach. Scholars call the result the monumental still life. The structure was deliberate. Religious subjects occupied the highest rank in the traditional hierarchy of pictorial genres. A kitchen table occupied the lowest. By placing the kitchen table at the center of large compositions, Aertsen enacted what critics of this period describe as a Mannerist inversion. Lower subject matter was given more visual space than higher. Anthonis Mor was extending the tradition's reach in a different direction, carrying Netherlandish precision into the portrait galleries of European courts.

  1

• 6. Portraits Across Europe

  ›

  Anthonis Mor was the leading portraitist of the mid-16th century, and European courts sought him out across the continent. His approach drew on two distinct traditions. One was the Netherlandish habit of meticulous precision in rendering surface and detail. The other was what he absorbed from Titian and other Italian painters. That combination satisfied clients who wanted both dignity and likeness. Mor's portraits were valued for their reliability, a quality that clients across Europe required.

  Lucas van Leyden, Quentin Matsys, Caterina van Hemessen, and Levina Teerlinc all appear in the historical record of this tradition. They are part of a roster that includes more than thirty documented painters from the 16th-century Low Countries. Antwerp's position at the center of European trade and culture made it a natural point of departure for painters building international careers. Landscape, still life, and genre painting were all established in the Low Countries before the great Baroque painters made them their own.

  1