Daniel Patrick Moynihan

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Daniel Patrick Moynihan shined shoes at Pennsylvania Station as a boy during the Great Depression, in the same building he would later spend decades fighting to restore as a United States Senator. That arc, from the floors of Hell's Kitchen to the halls of the Senate, captures something essential about a man who never stopped being the Irish Catholic kid from New York even as he became one of the most intellectually restless figures in American public life.

  Moynihan was born in Tulsa, Oklahoma on the 16th of March, 1927. His father deserted the family when Pat was nine years old, leaving his mother to raise him in a working-class neighborhood. He went on to serve in the navy, earn a doctorate, advise presidents, represent New York in the Senate for nearly a quarter century, present what was at the time the largest check ever written in banking history, and author 19 books. His friend, columnist George F. Will, once remarked that Moynihan had written more books than most senators had read.

  He was, depending on who you asked, a visionary or a provocateur. He predicted the collapse of the Soviet Union before it was fashionable and warned about the fracturing of the welfare state before his own party was ready to listen. He clashed with Nixon's inner circle, broke with liberal orthodoxy repeatedly, and still managed to win four Senate elections in New York. How a man of such contradictions held together a career that long, and left behind ideas that still provoke argument today, is the story ahead.

• 2. Hell's Kitchen to Harvard

  ›

  His father, John Henry Moynihan, was a newspaper reporter who had moved to Tulsa from Indiana. His mother, Margaret Ann, was a homemaker. When Pat was six, the family relocated to New York City. Three years later, his father was gone for good.

  Raised in Hell's Kitchen, Moynihan shined shoes and moved through a patchwork of public, private, and parochial schools before graduating from Benjamin Franklin High School in East Harlem. He worshipped at St. Raphael's Church, where he also cast his first vote. Summers were spent at his grandfather's farm in Bluffton, Indiana, with his brother Michael Willard Moynihan.

  Before college, Moynihan worked briefly as a longshoreman. He enrolled at the City College of New York, which at the time offered free higher education to city residents. After a year there, he joined the United States Navy in 1944 and was assigned to the V-12 Navy College Training Program at Middlebury College. He then enrolled as a Naval Reserve Officers Training Corps student at Tufts University, completing a degree in naval science in 1946 and finishing his active service as a Gunnery officer on the USS Quirinus at the rank of lieutenant (junior grade) in 1947.

  He returned to Tufts, earned a second undergraduate degree in sociology with honors in 1948, and an MA from the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy in 1949. When he failed the Foreign Service Officer exam, he turned to doctoral studies and spent time as a Fulbright fellow at the London School of Economics from 1950 to 1953. During those years in London, he worked for two years as a civilian employee at RAF South Ruislip. He fashioned himself, by his own account, as a "dandy", cultivating a taste for Savile Row suits and what he called "Churchillian oratory" while insisting he remained at heart "a New York Democrat who had some friends who worked on the docks and drank beer after work."

  His PhD in history came from Tufts in 1961, with a dissertation on the relationship between the United States and the International Labour Organization. By then he was already a junior professor and research director at Syracuse University's Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs, where he had been working with the papers of Averell Harriman.

• 3. The Moynihan Report

  ›

  Moynihan's work as Assistant Secretary of Labor for Policy, Planning and Research, a post he held from 1963 to 1965 under Presidents Kennedy and Johnson, put him at the center of debates about poverty that would define American domestic policy for decades. His small staff at the time included Ralph Nader.

  The team drew on historian Stanley Elkins's 1959 book, Slavery: A Problem in American Institutional and Intellectual Life. Elkins had argued that slavery had made Black Americans structurally dependent on the dominant society, and that the effects persisted a century after the Civil War. Moynihan's analysis of Labor Department data turned up a troubling pattern: even as unemployment fell, more families were joining the welfare rolls. The recipients were overwhelmingly single-parent households, almost always headed by the mother.

  In 1965, Moynihan published his findings under the title The Negro Family: The Case For National Action. The report argued that government must go beyond equal rights and act affirmatively to counter the legacy of historic discrimination. It triggered a fierce controversy. Critics on the left accused it of "blaming the victim," a phrase coined by psychologist William Ryan. The charge was that Moynihan was giving cover to racist arguments by focusing on children born out of wedlock. Moynihan's actual recommendation, that the Aid to Families with Dependent Children program was structured in ways that penalized intact families, was largely drowned out. He later said that critics of the AFDC structure, himself included, believed the nation was paying poor women to push their husbands out of the house.

  Almost three decades later, after the 1994 Republican sweep of Congress, Moynihan acknowledged that correction was needed for a welfare system that may have encouraged women to raise children without fathers. He quoted the Republican position back: "We have a hell of a problem, and we do."

• 4. Nixon's Resident Thinker

  ›

  Connecting with president-elect Richard Nixon in 1968, Moynihan joined the Executive Office of the President in January 1969 as Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy. He was the rare figure in Nixon's circle who had done serious academic research on social policy, which made him unusually influential in the administration's early months.

  His signature proposal was the Family Assistance Plan, a guaranteed minimum income for families that met work requirements or demonstrated they were actively seeking work. Moynihan described it as a "negative income tax." He had conducted significant discussions on the concept of a Basic Income Guarantee with Russell B. Long and Louis O. Kelso. The plan stalled in the Senate Finance Committee, but it prefigured the later Supplemental Security Income program. His push for it put him in frequent conflict with Arthur F. Burns, Nixon's principal domestic policy advisor and a conservative economist who held Cabinet rank. By his own account, the clashes were real even as mutual respect remained.

  In 1969, at Nixon's initiative, NATO attempted to establish what was described as a civil research column to handle challenges beyond military affairs. Moynihan named acid rain and the greenhouse effect as problems suited to international coordination through the alliance. The German government was skeptical, viewing the initiative as a bid by the United States to recover international standing after Vietnam. The topics did gain traction in civil conferences.

  In 1970, Moynihan wrote a memo to Nixon that would follow him for the rest of his career. He suggested that "the issue of race could benefit from a period of 'benign neglect'." He argued that the subject had been taken over by, in his words, "hysterics, paranoids, and boodlers on all sides." Critics read the memo as a call for government to abandon Black Americans. Moynihan maintained to the end of his life that they had misread it.

  His demotion from operational control of the Urban Affairs Council came through a maneuver by White House Chief of Staff H. R. Haldeman, who handed oversight to former White House Counsel John Ehrlichman. Moynihan was shifted into the role of the administration's "resident thinker" on domestic affairs. He departed at the end of 1970, under a standing requirement that he return to Harvard as a condition of his leave from the university.

• 5. The World's Largest Check

  ›

  Moynihan's posting as United States Ambassador to India, which he accepted in 1973, came at a difficult moment in the relationship between the two countries. The Indo-Pakistani War of 1971 had left deep scars, and the two great democracies, as Moynihan saw them, were cast as adversaries.

  His approach to repairing the relationship was practical. The United States held a large debt claim against India. Moynihan proposed a three-part resolution: write off part of the debt, use part to cover United States embassy expenses in India, and convert the remainder into Indian rupees to fund an Indo-US cultural and educational exchange program. That exchange program ran for a quarter century.

  On the 18th of February, 1974, Moynihan presented the Government of India with a check for 16,640,000,000 rupees, then equivalent to $2,046,700,000. It was presented to India's Secretary of Economic Affairs. The transaction was logged in the Guinness Book of World Records as the world's largest check ever paid by a single instrument.

  In June 1975, Moynihan accepted his third offer to serve as United States Ambassador to the United Nations. He had declined twice before: once in November 1969 because he wanted to see the Family Assistance Plan through the Senate, and again on the 24th of November, 1970, citing family strain, financial pressures, and frustration with what he considered a tertiary role behind Henry Kissinger and Secretary of State William P. Rogers.

  His tenure at the UN lasted only until February 1976, but it produced the moment that biographer Gil Troy would later describe as the key moment of Moynihan's political career. When the United Nations passed Resolution 3379 declaring Zionism to be a form of racism, Moynihan condemned it publicly and forcefully. His argument was that the resolution was factually false and that it harmed not only Israel but every Jewish American who held Zionist beliefs, which he noted included the majority of American Jews. The American public responded strongly to his stance, and his condemnation brought him a level of celebrity that helped him win a Senate seat the following year.

• 6. East Timor

  ›

  The most contested episode of Moynihan's career at the United Nations was his response to Indonesia's invasion of East Timor in 1975. President Gerald Ford regarded Indonesia, then under military rule, as a critical ally against Communist influence in the region.

  Moynihan later acknowledged in his memoir exactly what he had done. He wrote that the United States had wished for things to turn out as they did and had worked to bring that outcome about. He described the State Department's desire that the United Nations "prove utterly ineffective" in whatever measures it undertook against Indonesia's annexation of East Timor. "This task was given to me," he wrote, "and I carried it forward with no inconsiderable success." The Indonesian invasion caused the deaths of between 100,000 and 200,000 Timorese through violence, illness, and hunger.

  In later years, he characterized the policy he had defended as "shameless." The candor of his own admission became, for many critics, the most damning part of the record: that he had known what he was doing and did it anyway.

  The East Timor episode sat alongside a different kind of evolution that was already underway in his thinking. His UN tenure had begun to shift his view of the Soviet Union. By the time he wrote his 1993 book Pandaemonium, he had concluded that the Soviet Union was not an expansionist ideological empire but a weak, self-preserving state in decline. That view had made him, during the Reagan years, a consistent critic of what he called the administration's "consuming obsession with the expansion of Communism." In a December 1986 editorial in The New York Times, he predicted that ethnic conflict, not Communist expansion, would define the struggles ahead on the world stage.

• 7. Senator from New York

  ›

  In November 1976, Moynihan won election to the United States Senate from New York, defeating Bella Abzug, former Attorney General Ramsey Clark, New York City Council President Paul O'Dwyer, and businessman Abraham Hirschfeld in the Democratic primary, then defeating Conservative Party incumbent James L. Buckley in the general election. He was also nominated by the Liberal Party of New York.

  One of his first acts after election was to analyze whether New York State was paying more in federal taxes than it received in federal spending. Finding that it was, he began producing an annual report he called the Fisc, from the French word for treasury. The reports became a tool for arguing New York's case in budget negotiations for the next two decades.

  His tenure was marked by a pattern of principled defection from his own party's positions. He voted against the Defense of Marriage Act, the North American Free Trade Agreement, the authorization of the Gulf War, the balanced budget amendment, the flat tax, the death penalty, the flag desecration amendment, the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, and the Communications Decency Act. Despite earlier writing about the structural dangers of the welfare state, he also voted against the welfare reform bill of 1996, which set time limits on benefits and imposed work requirements.

  He chaired the Senate Finance Committee from 1993 to 1995 and during that period opposed President Clinton's health care expansion, famously declaring that "there is no health care crisis in this country." He chaired the Senate Environment Committee from 1992 to 1993. He also led a bipartisan commission to study what he called the 80-year "culture of secrecy" in the American government, tracing it back to the Espionage Act of 1917. The commission's findings were presented to the President in 1997. As part of that work, Moynihan secured release of the FBI's classified Venona file, which documented the joint FBI and United States Signals Intelligence Service investigation into Soviet espionage inside the United States. The file had been classified for more than 50 years.

  In 1981, alongside Senator Ted Kennedy and Speaker of the House Tip O'Neill, Moynihan co-founded the Friends of Ireland, a bipartisan organization of members of Congress who opposed sectarian violence and supported peace in Northern Ireland. He served in the Senate until 2001, a tenure that left him tied with Jacob K. Javits as the longest-serving senator from New York until both were surpassed by Chuck Schumer in 2023.

• 8. Legacy in Brick and Text

  ›

  Moynihan's scholarly output ran alongside his political career for his entire life. He coined the phrase "professionalization of reform" to describe a tendency in government bureaucracy: the habit of generating problems for government to solve rather than simply responding to needs identified from outside. He published articles on urban ethnic politics and poverty in outlets including Commentary and The Public Interest.

  In 1983, the American Political Science Association gave him the Hubert H. Humphrey Award for notable public service by a political scientist. On the 9th of August, 2000, President Clinton presented him with the Presidential Medal of Freedom. In 1992, the University of Notre Dame awarded him the Laetare Medal, considered the most prestigious honor for American Catholics. After retiring from the Senate, he returned to the Maxwell School at Syracuse University, where he had first built his academic career in 1959.

  He died at Washington Hospital Center on the 26th of March, 2003, from complications of a ruptured appendix, ten days after his 76th birthday.

  His efforts to restore and expand Penn Station eventually produced the Moynihan Train Hall, which opened in January 2021. The new concourse occupies the renovated James Farley Post Office building adjacent to the original station and serves Long Island Rail Road and Amtrak passengers. Moynihan had shined shoes in the original Pennsylvania Station as a boy. The building where he once worked for tips now carries his name.