Zionism

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  Zionism is a nationalist movement born in late 19th-century Europe with one declared purpose: establishing a Jewish homeland in Palestine. But the story of how that idea moved from scattered pamphlets to a declared state is tangled with competing beliefs about identity, land, and who belongs where. At its heart, the movement asked a question that Jewish communities across Europe had wrestled with for generations: was assimilation into European society a path forward, or a slow erasure? The answer that Zionism gave was neither accommodation nor resignation. It was a state of one's own.

  The movement's founders disagreed about almost everything except that fundamental goal. Some wanted a religious revival; others wanted a purely secular nation. Some considered land in Africa or the Americas; others insisted that only Palestine carried enough historical weight to animate mass migration. What united them was the conviction that Jews living as minorities in Europe faced a problem that liberal emancipation could not solve. What the documentary will trace is how that conviction, first articulated in pamphlets and congress halls, collided with the reality of a populated land and the people already living in it.

• 2. The Word and the Idea

  ›

  Mount Zion, a hill in Jerusalem, gave the movement its name long before the movement existed. The word "Zion" had functioned as a poetic shorthand for the Land of Israel since the period of the Babylonian Exile, with particular significance in Jewish messianic belief. It even appeared on coins issued during the Great Jewish Revolt against Roman rule in 66-73 CE, when rebels used the term to rally popular support.

  The term "Zionism" as a political category was coined by the Austrian writer Nathan Birnbaum in an 1890 article published in his periodical Selbst-Emancipation. Birnbaum used the word to describe the activities of the Hovevei Zion, or "Lovers of Zion," a network of groups that had coalesced at the 1884 Katowice Conference, inspired by Leon Pinsker's pamphlet Auto-Emancipation. In 1893, Birnbaum published a pamphlet titled The National Rebirth of The Jewish People in Their Own Land, advocating for European Jews to migrate to Palestine, and in the same year founded Zion: Union of Austrian Societies for the Colonization of Palestine and Syria.

  Theodor Herzl, the figure who would become the movement's defining leader, was unaware of Birnbaum's original coinage when he began popularizing the term himself. In diary entries from 1895 and early 1896, Herzl used the word "Zionist" to describe emigration advocates like the Lovers of Zion, whom he saw as fellow Jewish nationalists without a concrete plan. When he published his 1896 manifesto Der Judenstaat, he sometimes used the term critically, to describe those who called for emigration without systematic organization. Birnbaum quickly wrote a review of the pamphlet and struck up a correspondence with Herzl, delivering him a copy of his own earlier work as a kind of Zionist education. Herzl did not begin calling himself a Zionist until months after Der Judenstaat appeared.

• 3. Herzl and the First Congress

  ›

  A courtroom spectacle in France in 1894 changed the trajectory of European Jewish politics. The Dreyfus affair, in which a Jewish French army officer was falsely convicted of treason, had a profound impact on Central and Western European Jews who had believed in the promise of assimilation. Among those who witnessed the events unfold was Theodor Herzl.

  Herzl's project was purely secular. He recognized from early on that Zionism could not succeed without the backing of a great power, and he hoped that a future Jewish state would serve European imperial interests, describing it as "part of a defensive wall for Europe in Asia, an outpost of civilization against barbarism." His selection of Palestine, after considering locations including Cyprus, Mesopotamia, Mozambique, Argentina, and parts of British East Africa, was motivated by the credibility the name would lend the movement, given the historic connections Jews held with that land.

  In 1897, Herzl convened the First Zionist Congress in Basel, which created the Zionist Organization and adopted the Basel Program, codifying the official objective of establishing a legally recognized home for the Jewish people in Palestine. The Zionist Organization subsequently established the Jewish Colonial Trust, designed to encourage European Jewish emigration to Palestine and support economic development there through its subsidiary the Anglo-Palestine Bank, now Bank Leumi. Ahad Ha'am, founder of cultural Zionism, criticized Herzl's vision as offering a European-style state where Jews would merely transmit imperialist culture rather than create a distinctly Jewish one. That early disagreement over what kind of Jewish society should take shape in Palestine would persist across every subsequent generation of Zionist politics.

• 4. Land, Labor, and Exclusion

  ›

  By 1901, the World Zionist Organization had established the Jewish National Fund with the stated goal "to redeem the land of Palestine as the inalienable possession of the Jewish people." The fund's founding principle held that purchased land could not be sold, could not be leased to a non-Jew, and should not be worked by Arabs. Land was purchased primarily from absentee landlords, and tenant farmers who had traditionally held rights of usufruct were often expelled upon purchase.

  Herzl publicly opposed such dispossession, but wrote privately in his diary: "We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it any employment in our country... Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discreetly and circumspectly."

  With the Second Aliyah beginning in 1904, a more ideologically driven wave of settlers arrived and made the "conquest of labor" a core Zionist tenet. The goal was a "pure Jewish settlement" built on "100 per cent Jewish labor" and an exclusively Jewish, highly productive economy. According to Benny Morris, one motivation for excluding Arab workers was the worry that their employment would lead to "Arab values" being passed on to Zionist youth and encourage exploitation of workers. The Zionist leadership also believed that excluding Arab workers would limit class conflict to within Arab society and prevent the Jewish-Arab national conflict from gaining a class dimension.

  At the 1903 assembly organized by Menachem Ussishkin, the Zionist movement formalized its approach to land acquisition. Ussishkin laid out three methods: by force and conquest, by expropriation through governmental authority, and by purchase. He viewed purchase as the only option available at that moment, "until at some point we become rulers."

• 5. Britain, the Balfour Declaration, and the Mandate

  ›

  While 85,000 Jews lived in Palestine in 1914, that number had fallen to 56,000 by 1917 as the Ottoman Empire's entry into the war on Germany's side turned tens of thousands of Russian Jews into enemy citizens, prompting many to leave. The war gave Zionist leaders an opening with Britain. Their main initial success was building a lobbying effort centered around the Rothschild family, largely driven by Chaim Weizmann.

  In 1917, the Balfour Declaration announced Britain's support for "the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people." The declaration was motivated partly by wartime calculations and by antisemitic preconceptions about Jewish influence over Tsarist Russia and American policy. Notably, Arthur Balfour himself had earlier passed the Aliens Act 1905, which aimed to restrict Eastern European Jewish immigration to Britain. More decisive for British policy were colonial and imperial goals, specifically retaining control over the Suez Canal by establishing a pro-British presence in the region.

  Weizmann's role in securing the declaration made him the movement's recognized leader, a position he held until 1948, when he was elected the first President of Israel. He envisioned a Jewish state stretching east of the Jordan River and extending to the Litani River in what is now Lebanon. His strategy was incremental: settlement and land acquisition over time, while maintaining that negotiations over Palestine's future should be conducted solely between Britain and the Jews.

  The British Mandate established in 1922 explicitly privileged the Jewish minority over the Arab majority. Jewish immigration grew sharply in the mandate period, rising from 9,149 immigrants in 1921 to 33,801 in 1925. By the mandate's end, the Jewish population in Palestine had nearly tripled, reaching roughly one third of the country's total. Arab wages were one third of their Jewish counterparts, including when paid by the same employer, and unlike the Jewish population, Arabs received no government protections such as social security, trade union protection, or employment benefits.

• 6. Partition, Transfer, and the 1936 Revolt

  ›

  Ze'ev Jabotinsky founded the Revisionist Party in 1925, rejecting Weizmann's strategy of incremental state-building in favor of immediately declaring sovereignty over both banks of the Jordan River. From early on, Jabotinsky openly ruled out any voluntary agreement with Palestinian Arabs, arguing instead for building an "iron wall" of Jewish military force to break Arab resistance before any negotiated arrangement could follow.

  With the rise of the Nazis in 1933, Jewish immigration to Palestine accelerated sharply. In 1935 alone, more than 60,000 Jews arrived, a figure exceeding the total Jewish population of Palestine at the time of the Balfour Declaration in 1917. Ben-Gurion declared that immigration at this rate would make the maximalist Zionist goal of a Jewish state in all of Palestine achievable.

  The 1936 Arab Revolt became a turning point in Jewish-Arab relations. It unified previously divided Zionist factions around the necessity of force. During the revolt, the Irgun carried out terror attacks against Palestinian Arabs. According to historian Anita Shapira, beginning in this period, Labor Zionism's use of violence against Palestinians was essentially the same as that of radical conservative Zionist groups.

  In 1937, the Peel Commission proposed partitioning Palestine, allocating to a Jewish state occupying 17 percent of Mandatory Palestine's territory, and recommending the population transfer of Palestinian Arabs from those areas, citing the 1923 Greek-Turkish population exchange as a precedent. At the time Jews owned 5.6% of the land in Palestine, while the proposed Jewish state would contain 40% of the country's fertile land. Ben-Gurion's acceptance of partition was, according to the record, contingent on the removal of the Palestinian population. The Zionist congress ultimately adopted the position that the land allocated was inadequate, and the partition plan collapsed in the face of opposition from both sides.

• 7. The Holocaust, the State, and the Nakba

  ›

  In the Biltmore Program of 1942, the Zionist movement openly declared for the first time its goal of establishing a Jewish state in all of Palestine. American President Truman supported the program, motivated largely by humanitarian concerns and the growing influence of the Zionist lobby. The Holocaust united much of world Jewry behind the Zionist project; once news of the full scale of the destruction reached Palestine in 1942, the movement abandoned its previously selective approach to immigration.

  Strict American immigration policies and Zionist efforts resulted in 10% of the 3 million Jews leaving Europe settling in Palestine. The British, facing Zionist armed attacks on their presence beginning in 1944, including the King David Hotel bombing and strikes on British immigration offices and police stations, eventually referred the question of Palestine's future to the United Nations in 1947.

  The UN General Assembly voted in favor of partition on the 29th of November 1947. Violence between Arab and Zionist militias grew into a wider civil war. In March 1948, Zionist forces began implementing Plan D, described by historians as an ethnic cleansing operation aimed at expelling civilians and destroying Arab towns and villages. According to Benny Morris, Zionist forces committed 24 massacres of Palestinians during the ensuing war; the most notorious was the Deir Yassin massacre. The United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine estimated that between 1948 and 1949, 710,000 Palestinians were driven out of the country and another 40,000 were internally displaced.

  Of the 870,000 Palestinians in the territory at the time, an estimated 160,000 remained, forming a Palestinian minority within Israel. Israel expanded its territory to control over 78% of former Mandatory Palestine. On the 14th of May 1948, Ben-Gurion declared the establishment of the State of Israel. The Declaration of Independence described a democracy with equality of social and political rights for all citizens, while a Transfer Committee had already been established by the Israeli Cabinet during the war.