Cleveland Browns relocation controversy

• 1. Introduction

  ›

  The Cleveland Browns relocation controversy began with a single announcement on the 6th of November 1995, when owner Art Modell stood at a podium at Camden Yards and told the world that his NFL franchise was leaving Cleveland for Baltimore. Fans, elected officials, and players learned about it at the same time. The city had no warning. Modell had been negotiating in secret for months.

  What followed was not simply a team moving cities. It became a legal fight between a city and its owner, a congressional hearing, a compromise that had never been tried before in North American professional sports, and a template that leagues still reach for when a franchise shifts. The question at the heart of it all: when a team moves, who owns its name, its trophies, its history?

• 2. Art Modell's Finances

  ›

  Art Modell purchased the Browns through one of the most heavily leveraged transactions in NFL history. Most of the funds used to buy the team were borrowed, leaving him financially vulnerable from the start. His net worth had always been relatively modest compared to other principal NFL owners, even as his influence in league circles remained considerable.

  In 1975, Modell signed a 25-year lease on Municipal Stadium, agreeing to absorb more than $300,000 per year in operating costs. His company, Stadium Corporation, paid the city annual rents of $150,000 for the first five years, then $200,000 afterward. The arrangement gave him quasi-ownership of the stadium and a share of annual profits, but tied him to a venue that was aging and increasingly expensive.

  As early as 1983, Modell concluded he would never be able to pay off his debts before the city deal expired. When voters in 1990 approved the Gateway Sports and Entertainment Complex, which built a new baseball stadium and a new arena for the Indians and Cavaliers, Modell chose not to participate. He assumed his own revenues were safe. They were not. When the Indians moved to Jacobs Field in 1994, Stadium Corporation's suite revenues fell sharply. Modell claimed to have lost $21 million between 1993 and 1994.

• 3. Secret Negotiations

  ›

  While the Browns were entering the 1995 season with high expectations, Sports Illustrated had predicted they would represent the AFC in Super Bowl XXX. The team had finished 11-5 the previous year under head coach Bill Belichick and advanced to the second round of the playoffs. But behind the scenes, minority owner Al Lerner was quietly urging Modell to consider Baltimore.

  Lerner connected Modell to John Moag, the newly installed Maryland Stadium Authority chairman. Moag had been told earlier in the year by the league that Baltimore would receive a team if a stadium were already in place. He made several calls to Modell throughout 1995 that went unanswered. In late July, Modell allowed Lerner to meet with Moag, but only on the condition that Lerner stress that Modell was not serious about moving.

  At that meeting, Moag presented an offer: the Browns would receive rights to a new $220 million stadium if they relocated. Negotiations continued in secret through September. When Moag pressed that the Browns needed to act immediately, Lerner, Modell, and Moag gathered at Lerner's Midtown Manhattan office. Moag presented a memorandum of understanding that was nearly identical to one offered to the Cincinnati Bengals months earlier. Some paragraphs still referred to Cincinnati rather than Cleveland.

  Modell signed the document with tears in his eyes. He told Moag it was "the hardest thing I've ever done" and meant "the end of our life in Cleveland." Years later, Browns general counsel Jim Bailey described Modell as "an emotional wreck" at the moment of signing. The very next day after Modell's public announcement on November 6, Cleveland voters overwhelmingly approved a tax measure to remodel Cleveland Stadium.

• 4. The City Fights Back

  ›

  Cleveland filed suit in Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, Case No. CV-95-297833, naming Modell, the Browns, Stadium Corp, the Maryland Stadium Authority, and its director John A. Moag Jr. as defendants. The city argued that the Browns' lease required the team to play home games at Cleveland Stadium for several years past 1995. Season ticket holders filed separate lawsuits. The United States Congress held hearings on the relocation.

  Comedy and sport converged on the 26th of November 1995, when comedian Drew Carey returned to his hometown to host "Fan Jam" in protest of the move. A protest was also held in Pittsburgh during a Browns game against the Steelers, though ABC, which was broadcasting the game, declined to cover it. Steelers fans joined Browns fans that day in opposing the move, not wanting to lose their long-standing rivalry.

  The team's final weeks in Cleveland unraveled on the field as well. After the announcement, the Browns stumbled to a 5-11 finish, losing twice to the first-year Jacksonville Jaguars. They became the first team in the NFL's modern era to lose twice to a first-year expansion team. Virtually all sponsors pulled their advertising, leaving the stadium devoid of signage. The final home game, a 26-10 win over the Cincinnati Bengals, was blacked out locally on WKYC. NBC host Bob Costas noted the "final sad irony" of Brooklyn native Modell moving a beloved franchise, much as Walter O'Malley had moved the Dodgers to Los Angeles.

• 5. The Unprecedented Compromise

  ›

  On the 9th of February 1996, the NFL announced a settlement that had no precedent in North American professional sports. The Browns franchise would be deactivated for at least three years. A new stadium would be built. A revived Browns team, either an expansion club or a relocated franchise, would begin play by 1999. In exchange, Modell would receive the 31st NFL franchise for Baltimore.

  Modell retained the existing player contracts and football personnel, effectively transferring the football organization to what would become the Ravens. He replaced head coach Belichick with Ted Marchibroda, who had previously coached the Colts in Baltimore in the 1970s. Modell changed his holding company's name from Cleveland Browns, Inc. to Baltimore Ravens, Inc.

  The settlement was approved by league owners in a 25-2 vote with three abstentions. Ralph Wilson of Buffalo and Dan Rooney of Pittsburgh cast the two "no" votes. The three who abstained were owners whose teams had most recently moved: the Cardinals, Raiders, and Rams. Raiders owner Al Davis, who had publicly clashed with Modell over franchise moves, was among the abstentions.

  The reactivated Browns would retain the name, colors, history, records, awards, and archives. By 1998, the NFL had sold the franchise to Al Lerner, a former minority owner under Modell, for $530 million. Lerner had been among those who helped push Modell toward Baltimore in the first place. The revived team began play in 1999 in a new stadium built on the footprint of the demolished Cleveland Stadium.

• 6. Baltimore Becomes Ravens

  ›

  The arrival of the NFL in Baltimore forced out the city's existing professional football team. The Baltimore Stallions of the Canadian Football League had won the Grey Cup in their two seasons in Baltimore, drawing respectable fan support. But owner Jim Speros knew his team could not survive against an NFL franchise and would likely be evicted from Memorial Stadium. Speros chose to re-establish the Montreal Alouettes, effectively ending the CFL's experiment with American markets.

  Naming the new Baltimore team required a substantial process. Team officials narrowed a list of more than 100 suggested names down to 17. Focus groups of 200 Baltimore area residents reduced that to six. A phone survey of 1,000 people trimmed the list to three finalists: Marauders, Americans, and Ravens. A fan contest drawing 33,288 voters settled on Ravens, a reference to the poem by Edgar Allan Poe, who spent the latter part of his life in Baltimore and is buried there.

  The team adopted purple and black, a sharp departure from the Browns' brown and orange. The former Colts Marching Band, which had stayed in Baltimore after the Indianapolis move, was renamed Baltimore's Marching Ravens. The Ravens proved far more successful than the franchise they effectively replaced: they reached the playoffs 15 times between 2000 and the late 2010s, winning Super Bowl XXXV and Super Bowl XLVII.

• 7. A Template for Other Leagues

  ›

  The Browns-Ravens compromise has since been applied, in various forms, across professional sports. In Major League Soccer, the Browns case shaped the 2005 move of the San Jose Earthquakes to Houston. The Earthquakes left behind their name, colors, logo, and two championship trophies. An expansion team later revived the Earthquakes in San Jose under new ownership.

  Ohio passed the Modell Law in 1996, requiring teams that benefited from public facilities or financial assistance to give six months notice and attempt to sell to a local group before relocating. When the Columbus Crew faced a potential move to Austin, Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine and the city of Columbus filed suit. Cleveland Browns owner Jimmy Haslam stepped in with other investors to purchase the Crew and keep it in Columbus. The deal was announced on the 28th of December 2018.

  In the NHL, the Arizona Coyotes replicated the Browns structure almost exactly in 2024, suspending operations while their organization transferred to what became the Utah Mammoth. The NBA applied a version of the agreement when the Seattle SuperSonics moved to Oklahoma City in 2008, requiring the Thunder to hold the SuperSonics' name, banners, trophies, and history in trust for a future Seattle team. The Seattle artifacts were stored at the Museum of History and Industry pending a new franchise.

  Modell continued to struggle financially after the move to Baltimore. On the 27th of March 2000, NFL owners approved the sale of 49 percent of the Ravens to Steve Bisciotti. On the 8th of April 2004, Bisciotti exercised his option to buy the remaining 51 percent for $325 million. Modell died in 2012 having never returned to Cleveland.